12+

Slate and Earth Chapter 4.2

Despite the delicate herbs left drying from the ceiling and the smudge of incense she left burning, Esther’s cottage smelled sick. When she returned from the forest, Ana remained curled beneath the goose down duvet from Esther’s bed and two or three other blankets Esther had crocheted over the years. The fire in the hearth burnt to coals, but still the room felt hot.

“If you’re alive in there, girl, you’re going to drown in this heat,” Esther said by way of announcing her return.

Ana didn’t stir, and Esther sighed.

First, she went to the girl and pressed the backs of her fingertips to her forehead. Then, to the curve of her neck, just beneath her chin. Ana was hot, slick with sweat and sick, but her pulse tapped out a message. I’m here.

Esther held her breath and listened. Beneath the weight of the blankets, Ana’s ragged pulse only served to amplify the narrowband frequency of the girl that grew inside her. I’m here, I’m here, I’m here.

She removed her hand from Ana’s neck and reached across her to force the window open. “I hope you’re giving thanks to all the gods you know the names of,” she murmured under the awful creak of the window sticking in it’s frame. “You made a bargain with that little one inside you, and that may be all that’s keeping you alive.”

The window released and slid easily to the top of the frame. Esther stepped back and brushed dust and bits of displaced wood from her hands, considering the other end of that sort of bargain. The forest was known to be true, but never fair. One day, perhaps soon, Ana would give birth and present the human the forest had welcomed. There was no saying what the forest would, then, want to do with Ana.

The notion of it pricked at her heart, and Esther steeled herself. It wouldn’t do to let the girl give birth in the forest. She would simple have to ensure she was well enough to leave well before that became an issue.

“I’m going to put on a kettle of tea,” she announced, though Ana would not - as she had not for many days now - respond. “Perhaps this time you’ll actually drink some.”

Esther’s cottage had a little gas range, which she preferred for all her cooking, fed by an unsettlingly large propane tank set out by Jane’s stable that never seemed to run dry. She filled a kettle from the sink and set it on the range, relishing the moment the pilot click-click-clicked as the burner ignited. Then, she took down a small glass and poured herself a glass of bourbon.

It burned her gums, but she relished the feeling. When she swallowed, it singed the lining of her throat. Many people drank to drown a thing inside their own heads but Esther-- Esther drank to drown the taste of glass and ash that lingered on her tongue.

The kettle whistled, and Esther set the bourbon on the edge of the sink. She moved the kettle to an empty burner and took a fresh tea bag from the basket she kept on the counter. Healing things were not hard to come by. What she could not find with Jane and a little directional magic in the forest, she grew herself in her garden. All of it she dried in the rafters overhead and decanted into mismatched glass jars she’d collected from antique malls and roadside garage sales. Occasionally, she would walk the lane from her cottage to the highway, where she kept her pickup truck parked in a drive marked private and find little offerings of used spice jars from the nice grocery store wrapped with paper notes filled with wishes.

Less occasionally, she would walk the lane from her cottage to the highway and find one of the windows smashed in on her truck, or a substance suspiciously like blood used to scrawl the word witch across her windshield. Esther preferred it when she returned to her truck and there was nothing.

She surveyed her overstuffed cabinet of healing things, sorting through bottles and bags and scented sachets she’d picked up from a woman pretending to be a witch in the city the singular time she had visited since coming to live in the forest. She far preferred the town that bordered the forest to the city where she’d grown up. It had been so long since anything was the way it was when she was a girl. Going there only served to make her sad. Esther did all she could to avoid dwelling on things that made her sad.

The cabinet was full, but Esther found it lacked inspiration. She turned to the overstuffed jar of chamomile next to the range and filled two tea bags that she dropped into two teacups with cracks on their brims. Chamomile to calm a troubled mind, she recited to herself.

A cool dusk breeze hung in the window over Ana’s down cocoon when Esther returned with two cups of tea. She set them both on the sill and settled into a wooden chair positioned by the head of the couch. The inherited grimoire sat open on the coffee table, which she closed and shifted aside to take the battered mystery novel underneath. She cracked it open, flipping the pages to find her place, when Ana shifted beside her.

“I,” she started, her voice dry and catching in her throat. She moved to sit, to stand, but the duvet and several days spent in bed kept her back. “I’m sorry,” she said. “I’m not supposed to be here.”

Esther closed the book over her thumb, pressed to the page to save her place. “No, you’re certainly not,” she said. “But you are.”

“Who are you?”

She studied the girl a moment, the way her hair frayed around her face and the way her eyes were not as afraid as they were curious. “I’m Esther.”

Ana settled back against the couch. “Are we in the forest?” she asked.

“Yes,” she answered. “I live here.”

This seemed to tickle her, whether from exhaustion or the fever that still clung to her brow. “When I was in high school, the boys always said there was a witch in this forest.”

“Yes,” Esther repeated.

Ana rested her head against the overstuffed cushion on the back of the couch. She looked up out the window, through the steam that rose from the cups of tea. “Has my husband been looking for me?” she asked, her voice quiet and far away.

Esther uncrossed and crossed her legs again, paperback still balanced on her knee. “No man’s been through here,” she said.

Ana nodded. She sunk down in her duvet and Esther could see her hands shift to cradle the child in her womb. “My grandmother used to dry wildflowers,” she said, her gaze drifting to the herbs hung in Esther’s rafters. “She would press them between pages in old books and give them to me as presents.”

“These aren’t flowers,” Esther said, opening her book. She curled half of it behind itself so as to hold the book in one hand. “They’re magic.”

The girl laughed, soft and sweet, and turned to curl into the back of the couch. “Flowers are the only magic I ever believed in.”

Comments & reviews · 4
Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.

User avatar
elysian
Review
elysian wrote a review · Tue Sep 25, 2018 4:15 pm

it's been a while, but I am back! Excited to read on and immerse myself into this intriguing world.

**disclaimer: I will most likely focus on negative aspects more so than positive aspects when reviewing, and this is just to help you grow as a writer! It is totally okay not to agree with something I say! Also, If I repeat anything already said, it's probably because it needs to be changed!**

Occasionally, she would walk the lane from her cottage to the highway, where she kept her pickup truck parked in a drive marked private and find little offerings of used spice jars from the nice grocery store wrapped with paper notes filled with wishes.


this sentence is very wordy, I would either split it up or cut back on words.

okay, so again, another lovelyyy chapter. the descriptions are like poetry and I can really see what's happening. My only complaint is that everything??? is???? vague???? like, I'm just waiting for the info dump even though you've had plenty of opportunities to add in some information and spread it out so it's not overwhelming. I think by the fourth chapter I should have a better idea of what this world is but I don't. I just know this woman is a witch that lives in some kind of enchanted forest. so vague, i'm ready for specifics!

Other than that, I don't think there's really any other complaints. lovelyyyy <3

hope this helped.

- del

User avatar
ExOmelas
Review

Hey Lauren, what better time to start my week 4 reviews than the first day of week 5 :P

Before I say anything, for some unknowable reason I thought Esther had taken Ana with her when she went to the barrier in the last chapter. I went back and checked and you didn't tell me that she did, so my best guess is that I just assumed that because she was so insistent to the reader that she had to take Ana home. Anyway, hopefully that'll clear up anything in my last review that didn't make sense xD

Nit-picks:

She would simpley have to ensure she was well enough to leave well before that became an issue.

Just a typo.

“I’m going to put on a kettle of tea,” she announced

That is a very very strange way to phrase that. You put the kettle on, or you make a cup of tea :P *britishness intensifies*

Less occasionally, she would walk the lane from her cottage to the highway and find one of the windows smashed in on her truck, or a substance suspiciously like blood used to scrawl the word witch across her windshield. Esther preferred it when she returned to her truck and there was nothing.

Wait wait wait, this is happening in the magical forest? Or can she leave the forest? For the former - that seems an odd thing to target someone for in a forest that seems to be approaching sentient. For the latter, I did not get the feeling that was possible, what with how formidable a barrier we came across in the last chapter.

pretending to be a witch in the city the singular time she had visited since coming to live in the forest

Why say singular rather than just "one"?

Overall:

I would like to get the thing I have an issue with out of the way before I fangirl. I think it would be more enjoyable if the parameters of the setup were clear at this point. I don't need to know who the king of the forest is or anything, but I would like to know what options are open to the characters in this world so I know how to view new information and how it affects their chances. For example, can Ana be returned, or is something to do with her baby stopping her. Again, I don't need to know what will happen if Ana gives birth and the forest decides she can no longer stay, just that it is bad enough that this is not an option. Similarly, can Esther leave whenever she likes, like that one time she did leave to go to the city. This changes what resources they have access to in order to get out of situations, and therefore I would like to know.

However, I so so so love the mood of this, the sympathy Esther shows even as her rigidity that Ana cannot be there stays firm. I like that she seems to intuitively get that Ana is frightened of her husband, because that is so realistic as something people sometimes just get. I like that Ana doesn't particularly seem to be bothered about the fact that she is in a house with a witch, because that is nowhere near as frightening as where she came from - she has nothing to lose - and I think that really is very clever.

Hope this helps,
Biscuits :)

Oh man, all the excellent questions. You've stumbled upon my biggest first draft issue which is WHERE IS ALL THE INFORMATION, LAUREN. And basically you can count on an unholy infodump in the next chapter to answer some of these questions. xD But essentially, Esther can come and go through the veil as she wishes as she (more or less) belongs to the forest. Mortal humans, like Ana, can't typically enter the Veil.

You make an EXCELLENT point about needing this info for the reader to understand the resources available to them. Thank you so so much for pointing it out!

yaaaay go infodumps! I have a whole chapter of one lined up for some readers at some point and I cannot wait to dump it right on their heads :P

User avatar
PrincessInk
Review

Hello hello again! I'm here, following along with your novel! As a little note, would you mind letting me know when you've posted a new installment (whether by PM/tagging/posting a link on my wall)? I'd like to keep up :D

Anyway, on with the review.

She moved to sit, to stand, but the duvet and several days spent in bed kept her back.


This confused me a bit, because I was unaware that several days had passed already! Maybe it would be nice for some sign that tells us time is passing. Because to me, it looked as though Esther had gone to investigate and came back in the same day. But that's pretty minor.

I am really concerned about Ana's bargain she made with her unborn child. I'm afraid something bad might happen, especially since I know about the result of the silver spoons bargain Esther made. Also, I am so curious what bargain Ana made. Maybe I missed something in the 1st chapter? I'll have to go back and check that. My favorite thing about this magic system is how you have to bargain to get what you want from the magic. It makes it feel more dangerous than the wand-waving kind, and not a trifle to play with.

I'm enjoying the way Ana and Esther are being developed. One is knowledgeable about magic, the other is not. Yet I think both of them are very plucky, resourceful women who can handle a tough situation without cracking easily. I also like the way you give little tidbits of information about them to make them seem real--like how Esther likes to read mystery novels, how Ana's grandmother used to give her pressed wildflowers, etc. etc. It makes them feel more like real people with backstories and life.

Anyway, I'm really liking this is all shaping up! I'll see you in the next installment :)

-Ink

Ooooh, if I'm perfectly honest I hadn't really thought about Ana's "bargain" with the forest/her child as the same kind of magic as Esther's magic. But, like, of course it's the same and I'm really excited to dig into that. So thank you so much for connecting the pieces there <3

I'm definitely looking forward to where you're going with the magic!!

User avatar
Cadi
Review
Cadi wrote a review · Wed Jul 25, 2018 8:51 pm

Hi Lauren! It's me, your thoroughly intermittent reviewer, here to continue enthusing about this story and how I'm super into it and looking forward to next week already!

You're continuing to unwind this story in what feels like a wonderfully careful manner, painting detailed pictures of the place that we are and the moments we're watching, and bringing out little bits about the characters and the plot as you go. I'm intrigued by the bit about Ana making a bargain with her little human, and the forest welcoming the little human in particular, rather than Ana - remembering Esther's call to the magic with the silver spoons in an earlier chapter, the idea of Ana's bargain feels not a little ominous.

Just one thing that made me think twice while reading - the fire burning down to coals. Possibly a lost-in-cultural-translation thing, but that made me think of a fire burnt to the point of glowing embers, which is one of the hottest points of a fire (i.e. the kind of fire you cook on), rather than a fire that's burnt past heat and basically run out. So it then seemed weird for the room to be hot "despite" that? Idk.

But yeah! Still loving it! Keep it up! :D

Omg thank you about the coals. TBH I wrote that thinking "gonna come back and confirm that means what I want to mean" and forgot xD thanks so much for your thoughts! I'm glad you're enjoying it <3



I would be a terrible novel protagonist.
— mellifera