Hi Em! I noticed your poem has been sitting around in the Green Room for a while, so I thought I'd drop by with a quick review for you c:
Gosh, you've got some really lovely language and imagery in this poem! Everything from comets to rainbows to marble to butterflies to seashores. (I'm personally a fan of the stardust/galaxies/astronomy thread of imagery that you use throughout the poem - I think it reflects the hugeness of the narrator's feelings and also the distance they feel from the person they're addressing. Like, "you rain stardust on my cheeks"??? So beautiful and poetic!) The variety definitely keeps things interesting and unrepetitive in that regard, which is great! And the language throughout the poem is very emotionally charged which helps to hit the reader in the feels.
My main critique is that as a reader, this poem is long. I'm not going to lie, that makes it feel very intimidating to read and harder to stay focused while reading. Of course, sometimes length is necessitated based on what a poem is trying to cover, but I feel like it's not entirely necessary here? To demonstrate what I kind of mean, let me condense each stanza into one sentence:
Stanza one - you are overwhelmingly beautiful and I cannot resist you
Stanza two - I long for you and I can't stop imagining us together
Stanza three & four - I'm sad because I know I'll never have you
Stanza five - I'm going to try my best to forget about you
Of course your poem is far more nuanced than that, and sounds way more beautiful and emotional and poetic, but those are the four sentiments you convey over the course of the entire thing. I'd encourage you to see how you could make it more concise and really just say enough to get your point across. If you're having trouble figuring out how to do that, you could even try to convey each of those points in just a single image (or very approximately, ~ 2 to 6 lines) and then go back and add a bit more as you see fit. You can keep something concise and still include some punchy, really evocative imagery (which you're a pro at!).
Another thing I did enjoy was how you utilized sentence structure/length in the poem! You have some long, winding, imagery rich sentences, and then alternate with short, gut-punchers. All these decisions you make help to contribute to and emphasize the narrator's tones in the different parts of the poem. For example in the final stanza:
You no longer exist to me. You are an abstraction.
You are a distraction. You are gone from my sight.
^These short, snappy sentences drive home the more aggressive tone of the narrator in this section.
And then your use of all the rhetorical questions in the second stanza, on the other hand, demonstrate how lost and helpless the narrator feels. Since they don't know what to do, they direct their questions at the reader and/ or love interest, showing an outward expression of their inner conflict. Very effective!
Overall, I enjoyed the roller coaster ride of feelings that this poem took me on. I hope this review proves useful for you, and if you have any questions about stuff I brought up/ want me to elaborate, just let me know! ^-^
Keep writing!
Seirre
Points: 22098
Reviews: 455
Donate