Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
BLINKEEEEHH!!
Thought your piece here looked a little lonely so I came along to keep it company.
Hi there
I don't think I've read much if your writing before but I really quite enjoyed it. You seem to be capable of doing that thing where you put nice imagery in your description that I don't get tired of or frustrated with. So that's good. Plus I can't do that to save my life in my own writing so it impresses me.
One thing I am very glad for is that you didn't just make this about the war in Syria. I read your author's note and I was like 'Oh no...this is going to be political and a bit boring and just shove a message about Syria in my face.' It's too often that writers take a topical subject and just end up shoving it down your throat. But happily, you did not do this. You managed to make this very human, to still speak about the conflict in general but then narrow it down to these two people. I liked that very much. There was a lot of emotion in it.
Dems has picked up on all the nitpicks (I say that but I probably didn't notice most of what she put anyway) I think maybe the only criticism is that this story kind of relies on my knowledge of Syria to carry it a little. I think that the story would still work well even if you had no knowledge of Syria. You could grasp that there are protests and an uprising and these two people are in it, however, I think because I've read up on Syria, it makes this story much more powerful than it would be if I didn't have that knowledge. It's a fairly small point I suppose since Dems seemed to grasp it fine. Perhaps it is a story that can work on more than one level. A basic level of someone not knowing about the conflict and a more hard hitting level for someone that does.
I don't know, it kind of just made it more tense for me because not only do you have this (I assume some sort of foreign aid worker/reporter) guy sneaking in to see a woman who has a husband but also that they're doing all this in the middle of a pretty terrifying conflict.
I hope you'll post the second part some time soon! I'd love to see how this progresses, even if I think this first part works somewhat as a standalone piece.
I'll stop rambling because it's not actually helpful! lol
Hope to see you around sooooooon! Don't let uni swallow you up!
Bex x
Hey, Blinky! It’s been a while, hasn’t it.
So, I'll try to review this even though I know nothing about the Syrian civil war! I have some nitpicks (really nitpicky, might I add), and then a few general comments.
This is really a very minor point, but semi-colons shouldn’t be used like commas. I’ve been taught that you may only use a semi-colon when you could use a period as well – so both sentences on each side of the semi-colon should be individual, so that they could also be made two separate sentences only by replacing the semi-colon with a period. Semi-colon means that the writer has found the two sentences so closely related that s/he thought they’d be better linked together like that. If you don’t want to make the quoted bit two separate ones, I’d suggest you use a comma instead.
Here, I think a colon would be better, since what comes after it explains the bit before it.
Sorry. xD I will get past punctuation in this review, I promise.
This sentence has too many subordinate clauses to be perfectly comprehensible, I’m afraid… and you can see it’s quite a long sentence anyway, so it might be better to divide it into parts.
Not quite sure who says this?
This is really beautiful.
Proofread?
I’m not sure why you say “fist” but “slapped”. Slapping happens with the palm of the hand, while fist punches. (It sounds like I have experience, but I really don’t.)
“Whining” makes me think of saying words in a whiny tone like “Aaaaare we theeere yeeet?”, but I think this is meant to express just sounds, so I’m not sure is “whine” is the best word choice.
Maybe I'm suffering from a memory loss, but I didn't remember that your style was so pleasant to read! I don't mean that your earlier stories were terrible or something (I'm afraid I can't really remember much of them...) but I think your writing has really improved/somehow "ripened"? I don't want to say "matured", because it would sound like it was immature before, which it certainly wasn't. But something has changed, I think. In a good way!
It was easy for me to imagine the setting and the atmosphere of the place, and your descriptions were somehow soft and really pretty. It's like you've grown or something.
I liked the italicised "yells" in between the paragraphs; they did their own good things for the atmosphere. (<-- correct usage of semi-colon
I hope you tell me when you post the next part! I'm interested to see more. I'm not sure if I'm hooked plot-wise (yet at least), but I'd really like to see more.
Hope this helped!
Thank you Dems!
That was really helpful - I've abused semicolons for far too long and I have a feeling that you might have contributed a great deal towards my university essays too... I shall get round to writing the next/final part at some point which is hopefully when the plot will make sense. I really appreciate your thoughts on my style! I was being a bit experimental but I'm glad that you liked it. It's the first time I've written anything substantial for a long time! Thanks again. 