z

Young Writers Society


Beauty's Beast



User avatar
20 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 1398
Reviews: 20
Mon Sep 13, 2010 3:51 pm
View Likes
GirlInTheMirror says...



This is the first couple of sections of a short story I'm writing that is a twist on Beauty and the Beast.
Prologue.
Once upon a time there was a story that did not end in a "happily ever after". It was a story of a beauty with a monster hidden inside of her, and a story of a monster with a hidden beauty inside of him. It was a story about struggle interrupted by precious moments of tranquility. It was a story about fighting; against others and with one's self. It was a story about hate. But most importantly, it was a story about love.

Chapter 1: Belle
Once upon a time in a land far far away, there was a young girl named Belle. The only child of a widower, Belle grew up nearly alone. She stayed pent up in her little cottage, books her only companion.
It had been this way ever since she was seven. That was when her mother died and her father locked himself away in his tool shed, burying himself so deep in his inventing that he could never dig his way back to the real world, even if he wanted to. Belle strove to pull him back to her by relentlessly trying to improve herself. She would spend her days teaching herself to sing, play the piano, dance, and of course read. Every once and a while she would manage to capture her father’s attention and show him her new talents. But his only reaction would be a vague hint of a smile swiftly followed by a cold shoulder. He could not bear to face his neglected child, no matter how amazing she may be.
…………………….
One early fall morning, Belle journeyed through the small village that she inhabited in order to find another book. The air was cold and a vague fog hovered around the city. Belle hurried across the cobblestone streets of the town looking down at her feet so that she could hide her face that she thought looked hideous. She hadn’t eaten anything before she left, and her stomach was growling. But she ignored it, as she always did.
Unfortunately for Belle, staring at the ground prohibited her from seeing anyone who may be approaching. So, Belle collided with a man who had his nose so far up in the air that he could not see anything except for the blinding beauty of the morning’s sunrise.
Belle’s eyes cautiously looked up towards his as his eyes lowered to hers. They stared at each other for a long moment. All that Belle saw in this stranger’s eyes was a shallow, foggy brown.
“You are the most beautiful girl I have ever laid my eyes upon, what is your name?” Gestaund asked in a gentle voice with a slightly growling undertone. Belle stood bewildered for a moment. She never thought of herself as pretty. Not once.
“Belle,” she responded in a trance.
“Hmm... I don’t recall ever noticing you in this small village. Are you new to the town?” Gestaund inquired.
“No,” was the only thing Belle managed to say.
“No, huh… Oh you must be the crazy inventor’s daughter.”
“Yes."
“Well, regardless of your family you are a wonderful creature,” he said. “May I do you the honor of escorting you?”
“Yes,” Belle responded.
“Then where are we headed?”
“Library,” Belle said, still mistified by how a man as attractive as Gestaund could want her company.
Gestaund talked about his wealthy upbringing and many accomplishments throughout nearly the entire walk. He only stopped once to tell Belle to hurry up because his time was precious. Belle obeyed promptly, even though she felt a bit woozy and quite tired. This brought a slight smile to Gestaund’s face. She was definitely a woman that would be seen and not heard.
They arrived at a tiny building that was not much larger than the carriage parked in front of it. Belle opened the door and walked inside heading directly for a bookshelf in the far corner. She knelt down to look at the bottom shelf as she carefully picked up several fairy-tales. She searched through the books gently opening them to the first page, reading the first line, and then the back page, reading the last line. After a couple of tries she found one that began with “Once upon a time” and ended with “Happily ever after”. She loved books that began and ended in such a way because in those lines was an understood promise that the story would be about a beautiful young girl and a handsome prince that would fall in love and live happily together forever. Belle lived for putting herself in those lovely girls' shoes. She wished adamantly that she could be like them; pretty, thin, and never alone. But, she knew that she was much too imperfect, much too ugly, and much too fat to ever be like those characters in fairy-tales.
As Belle stood up, book in hand, Gestaund towered over her. “Wait, you went to the library to get a book for yourself?” Gestaund asked forcefully.
“ummm… yes,” Belle meekly answered. Gestaund stared at her. He could not deny how beautifully her long brown hair glistened, how unblemished her pale skin looked, and how thin her frail body was. He knew that he must have her, but he also knew that he could not be seen with a woman that actually enjoyed such a terribly unladylike thing as thinking.
“Belle.” Gestaund finally broke the silence. “I would very much like to do you the honor of taking you to the upcoming ball, but you must stop reading. It will poison your mind.”
“I ca-can’t,” Belle stuttered, thinking of how she absolutely needed to hold on to her only porthole into a perfect life. Before Belle could further be swayed, she mustered up all of her strength and she ran away. She wished for some reason that she could not quite grasp, that she could keep on running forever.

Chapter 2: Betrayed by a Kiss
Belle continued to run, powered by sheer will. She was very tired. Her breath was heavy. She developed a nauseous feeling that started at the pit of her empty stomach and climbed up to her throat. Her body was calling out to her to stop, to stop everything. Yet she continued to run.
Belle finally reached the comfort of the inside of her cottage. Her weight pulled her to the ground, and she lay there sprawled out on the cold wood floor. Her head swam. Her breath gasped. Her chest heaved. Her stomach ached. Her heart raced. Her body was screaming, but she refused to listen.
Belle mustered all of her remaining energy and curled onto her side while unfolding the book from the library. She entered willingly into its world.
The hours flew by.
Thunder roared outside, forcing her back to reality. Her stomach responded with a growl of it’s own. It was so hungry. It wanted food horribly. A voice inside of her would certainly protest. Belle braced herself for the upcoming battle that inevitably would occur. It always did. It was an internal battle; perfection verses beastly instinct, (which side is which, however, is uncertain). In this fight reason and delusion were ammunition, her body was the scorched battle field, and her soul was collateral damage.
The battle begun with the words "You're fat" shooting through her mind.
"I'm hungry," was the slightly wounded response.
"You don't need food. You had some yesterday, too much yesterday," the first side retaliated.
"But I'm weak without food," was the other side's poorly aimed response.
"You're right," the voice teasingly declared, a fake white flag waving. "You are weak," the voice continued. "I can defeat you."
The other side knew that those words were true. "Please, I'm hungry," it begged. It would receive no mercy.
The words, "No one cares," jabbed through her heart. The battle was lost.
Belle mechanically sat up. Her eyes fully glazed over. She felt completely empty. The clock ticked the seconds away.
All of a sudden a heavy knock burst through the silence. Belle stood up and walked to the door. She opened it. Standing in the middle of the darkening night sky was none other than the gorgeous, "valiant", Gestaund. "How could you reject me you stupid girl?" Gestaund asked. Without waiting for a response, Gestaund intruded into Belle's house, her only private place, knocking into belle as he passed through the barriers. Belle was startled and even afraid of his sudden change in character, but nonetheless she followed him into the sitting room. She knew that she should remark upon his rudeness and impropriety however she couldn't muster up the courage.
Gestaund turned around to face Belle. "Can you imagine the embarrassment I felt when I had to admit to the townsmen that you, Crazy Maurice's daughter, rejected me?" he continued. "I am the most handsome, envied man in the entire town. You ruined my reputation." Belle looked at him blankly, she was afraid. "Don't you hear me?" Gestaund interjected. "You ruined me!" Belle could vividly smell the strong alcohol in his breath. She wanted to leave the tension filled room but just as the thought crossed her mind, Gestaund abruptly grabbed her shoulders and pushed her up against the wall. He smacked Belle across the face and then forced a kiss upon her. Belle was trapped.



Thanks for reading! Please give me harsh critiques, either nit picky or more general. Oh, and if you could, let me know whether you caught any metaphors because I'm developing some and want to know at this point how much the reader can pickup.
Last edited by GirlInTheMirror on Fri Sep 24, 2010 2:06 am, edited 6 times in total.
  





User avatar
61 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 1903
Reviews: 61
Mon Sep 13, 2010 4:14 pm
View Likes
Sierra says...



wow, this was really amazing. Tell me if you post any more.


GirlInTheMirror wrote:Prologue.
Once upon a time there was a story that did not end in a "happily ever after". It was a story of a beauty with a monster hidden inside of her, and a story of a monster with a hidden beauty inside of him. It was a story about struggle interrupted by precious moments of tranquility. It was a story about fighting; against others and with one's self. It was a story about hate. But most importantly, it was a story about love. I like your prologue, however, it is a bit short. Can you make it a little longer?

Chapter 1: Belle
Once upon a time in a land far far away, there was a young girl named Belle. The only child of a widower, Belle grew up nearly alone. She stayed pent up in her little cottage, books her only companion.
It had been this way ever since she was seven. That was when her mother died and her father locked himself away in his tool shed, burying himself so deep in his inventing that he could never dig his way back to the real world, even if he wanted to. Belle strived to pull him back to her by relentlessly trying to improve herself. She would spend her days teaching herself to sing, play the piano, dance, and of course read. Every once and a while she would manage to capture her father’s attention and show him her new talents. But his only reaction would be a vague hint of a smile swiftly followed by a cold shoulder. He could not bear to face his neglected child, no matter how amazing she may be.
…………………….
One early fall morning, Belle journeyed through the small village that she inhabited in order to find another book. The air was cold and a vague fog hovered around the city. Belle hurried across the cobblestone streets of the town looking down at her feet so that no one could see her hideous face. She hadn’t eaten anything before she left, and her stomach was growling. But she ignored it, as she always did.
Unfortunately for Belle, staring at the ground prohibited her from seeing anyone who may be approaching. So, Belle collided with a man who had his nose so far up in the air that he could not see anything except for the blinding beauty of the morning’s sunrise.
Belle’s eyes cautiously looked up towards his as his eyes lowered to hers. They stared at each other for a long moment. All that Belle saw in this stranger’s eyes was a shallow, foggy brown.
“You are the most beautiful girl I have ever laid my eyes upon, what is your name?” Gestaund asked in a gentle voice with a slightly growling undertone. Belle stood bewildered for a moment. She never thought of herself as pretty. Not once. “Belle.”, she responded in a trance. “hmm.. I don’t recall ever noticing you in this small village. Are you new in town?” Gestaund inquired. “No” was the only thing Belle managed to say. “No, huh… Oh you must be the crazy inventor’s daughter”. “Yes”. “Well, regardless of your family you are a wonderful creature” he said, “May I do you the honor of escorting you?”. “Yes” Belle responded. “Then where are we headed?”. “Library” was all that Belle could manage to utter.
Gestaund talked about his wealthy upbringing and many accomplishments throughout nearly the entire walk. He only stopped once to tell Belle to hurry up because his time was precious. Belle obeyed promptly, even though she felt a bit woozy and quite tired. This brought a slight smile to Gestaund’s face. She was definitely a woman that would be seen and not heard.Make a new paragraph every time someone says something. Also, put a comma or a period or something at the end of every sentence of dialogue. It's "Belle," not "Belle"
They arrived at a tiny building that was not much larger than the carriage parked in front of it. Belle opened the door and walked inside heading directly for a bookshelf in the far corner. She knelt down to look at the bottom shelf as she carefully picked up several fairy-tales. She searched through the books gently opening them to the first page, reading the first line, and then the back page, reading the last line. After a couple of tries she found one that began with “Once upon a time” and ended with “Happily ever after”. She loved books that began and ended in such a way because in those lines was an understood promise that the story would be about a beautiful young girl and a handsome prince that would fall in love and live happily together forever. Belle lived for putting herself in those lovely girl’s shoes. She wished adamantly that she could be like her; pretty, thin, and never alone. But, she knew that she was much too imperfect, much too ugly, and much too fat to ever be like those characters in fairy-tales.
As Belle stood up, book in hand, Gestaund towered over her. “Wait, you went to the library to get a book for YOURSELF?” Gestaund asked forcefully. “ummm… yes.” Belle meekly answered. Gestaund stared at her. He could not deny how beautifully her long brown hair glistened, how unblemished her pale skin looked, and how thin her frail body was. He knew that he must have her, but he also knew that he could not be seen with a woman that actually enjoyed such a terribly unladylike thing as thinking. “Belle” Gestaund finally broke the silence, “I would very much like to do you the honor of taking you to the upcoming ball, but you must stop reading. It will poison your mind”. “I can’t” Belle stuttered, thinking of how she absolutely needed to hold on to her only porthole into a perfect life.
Before Belle could further be swayed, she mustered up all of her strength and she ran away. She wished for some reason that she could not quite grasp, that she could keep on running forever.

Chapter 2: Betrayed by a Kiss
Belle continued to run, powered by sheer will. She was very tired. Her breath was heavy. She developed a nauseous feeling that started at the pit of her empty stomach and climbed up to her throat. Her body was calling out to her to stop, to stop everything. Yet she continued to run.
Belle finally reached the comfort of the inside of her cottage. Her weight pulled her to the ground, and she lay there sprawled out on the cold wood floor. Her head swam. Her breath gasped. Her chest heaved. Her stomach ached. Her heart raced. Her body was screaming, but she refused to listen.
Belle mustered all of her remaining energy and curled onto her side while unfolding the book from the library. She entered willingly into it’s world.
The hours flew by.
Thunder roared outside, forcing her back to reality. Her stomach responded with a growl of it’s own. It was so hungry. It wanted food horribly. A voice inside of her would certainly protest. Belle braced herself for the upcoming battle that inevitably would occur. It always did. It was an internal battle; perfection verses beastly instinct, (which side is which, however, is uncertain). In this fight reason and delusion were ammunition, her body was the scorched battle field, and her soul was collateral damage.
The battle begun with the words "Your fat" shooting through her mind. "I'm hungry" was the slightly wounded response. "You don't need food. You had some yesterday, too much yesterday" the first side retaliated. "But I'm weak without food" was the other side's poorly aimed response. "You're right" the voice teasingly declared, a fake white flag waving. "You are weak" the voice continued, "I can defeat you". The other side knew that those words were true. "Please, I'm hungry" it begged. It would receive no mercy. The words "No one cares" jabbed through her heart. This paragraph is confusing. Can you clarify exactly what it is about and the outcome?
Belle mechanically sat up. Her eyes fully glazed over. She felt completely empty. The clock ticked the seconds away.
All of a sudden a heavy knock burst through the silence. Belle stood up and walked to the door. She opened it. Standing in the middle of the darkening night sky was none other than the gorgeous, "valiant", Gestaund. "How could you reject me you stupid girl?" Gestaund slurred. Without waiting for a response, Gestaund intruded into Belle's house, her only private place, knocking into belle as he passed through the barriers. Belle was startled and even afraid of his sudden change in character, but nonetheless she followed him into the house. She knew that she should remark upon his rudeness and impropriety however she couldn't muster up the courage.
Gestaund turned around to face Belle. "Can you imagine the embarrassment I felt when I had to admit to the townsmen that you, Crazy Maurice's daughter, rejected me?" he continued, "I am the most handsome, envied man in the entire town. You ruined my reputation". Belle looked at him blankly, she was afraid. "Don't you hear me?" Gestaund interjected "YOU RUINED ME!". Belle could vividly smell the strong alcohol in his breath. She wanted to leave the tension filled room but just as the thought crossed her mind, Gestaund abruptly grabbed her shoulders and pushed her up against the wall. He smacked Belle across the face and then forced a kiss upon her. Belle was trapped.



Nice ending, I like the tension and suspense. I think you should break up your paragraphs a bit. Big blocks are writing are hard to read.
What a shame,
We used to be such fragile broken things.
  





User avatar
262 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 1193
Reviews: 262
Tue Sep 14, 2010 4:17 pm
View Likes
ultraviolet says...



'Ello, ultraviolet here!

I have several points to make, so I shall number them (I like numbering things. XD ).

1. The Prologue.

Amazing. It hooked me right away. In fact, I had decided I wasn't really in the mood to read and review something when I glanced at the first line and knew I had to continue. It was that good. I like the comparisons, and how you state this is a different kind of fairy tale. Normally being so abrupt with stating this wouldn't work, but it's worded much like I imagine a fairy tale like this would be, so it works.

2. Dialogue.

a. Some of your paragraphs have a lot of dialogue in them, and at times it was hard to tell who was speaking. A general rule is to start another paragraph with every new person speaking a line of dialogue. This isn't always the case, but in here I think you should follow that rule.

b. Your dialogue punctuation isn't that great. It's kind of really bad. Not to worry! Almost everyone fails in this area, at least at first, and I have seen worse. Here's a writing tutorial that covers all the dialogue punctuation basics. Master these, and you're set for life.

3. Belle's Anorexia.

I like this, how she views herself. It's so unlike typical fairy tales, and more modern, something that a lot of people can relate to (I mean, who really likes how they look these days?). I think you portrayed it well with the voices in her head.

4. Gestaund.

I wouldn't start off your encounter with him by him telling Belle just how beautiful she is. Maybe have him think it, but I doubt even he is so blunt. I like how he thought Belle would be a seen-not-heard kind of person. It goes well with his character. It also gives us insight on him. I do think, however, that he was a little overreacting about the whole book thing. I'd tone it down a bit.

Another thing, when he came to her house drunk. So soon, really? Maybe later, but by running she barely had time to get there herself. I'd pace this a little better, and make sure that the timelines match up.

5. Description.

You need more of it. Yes, those of us who have heard the story and seen the movie dozens of times know that there are cobblestone streets, bakers and shoe cobblers, girl in long dresses, and all that jazz, but imagine you're writing this to someone who's never heard of Beauty and The Beast.

Just because this is a spin off of the fairy tale doesn't mean you have to treat it like such. Make this your own book, with your own characters. Make sure we see this just like you imagine it, not like we assume it must be like. So far we get a good idea of the characters, but we need setting. We need to use all of our senses, and it's your job to make sure we do. So give us description, and the quality of this will skyrocket.

Overall, this is really good. I like the unusual twist you don't even see in parodies of fairy tales. Sorry if what I say sounds harsh, and I hope you don't think I'm beating down on this and you. I truly am trying to help you improve this. Keep writing.

loveness, ultraviolet <3
"Blah blah blah. You feel trapped in your life. Here is what I am hearing: happiness isn't worth any inconvenience."

~asofterworld.com
  





User avatar
565 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 1395
Reviews: 565
Tue Sep 14, 2010 4:23 pm
Stori says...



Hi Mirror, I just thought I'd point out a couple small errors.

those lovely girl’s shoes.


If it's more than one girl, the ' goes after the s: girls' shoes.

Belle strived to pull him back


The past tense of "strive" is "strove". Simple mistake.

[She entered willingly into it’s world.
[/quote]

Its world; it's means "it is." There you have it; keep writing, my friend.
  





User avatar
20 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 1398
Reviews: 20
Wed Sep 15, 2010 2:01 am
GirlInTheMirror says...



Thank you people for the reviews. I did a couple of quick corrections but I will try to get on the more lengthy ones ASAP. Why am I always busy when I have stuff to do, and not when I don't. That came out wrong. Please just ignore my babbling...
  





User avatar
377 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 22732
Reviews: 377
Wed Sep 15, 2010 3:07 pm
seeminglymeaningless says...



Hi Girl :) I'm Jai, one of the Four Musketeers, here upon your request at our WRFF thread.

On to the review.


Prologue.
Once upon a time there was a story that did not end in a "happily ever after". It was a story of a beauty with a monster hidden inside of her, and a story of a monster with a hidden beauty inside of him. It was a story about struggle interrupted by precious moments of tranquility. It was a story about fighting; against others and with one's self. It was a story about hate. But most importantly, it was a story about love.

I don't think this prologue is much of a prologue and I don't think it should be here at all. If anything it sounds like a blurb, and even then, do you want to give away the story to the readers straight away? In my opinion, delete this and the story will be better off without it.

He could not bear to face his neglected child, no matter how amazing she may be.

Why? Because she reminded him so much of his deceased wife?

Belle hurried across the cobblestone streets of the town looking down at her feet so that no one could see her hideous face.

Wait, what? Hideous face?

“You are the most beautiful girl I have ever laid my eyes upon, what is your name?” Gestaund asked in a gentle voice with a slightly growling undertone.

This is absolutely confusing. Why would you say her face was hideous, and then immediately introduce someone who thought she was beautiful?

“Hmm... I don’t recall ever noticing you in this small village. Are you new in town?” Gestaund inquired.

If this is set in the medieval ages or earlier, "are you new in town" is not something that would have been said during that period. Be careful of period language.

“No,” was the only thing Belle managed to say.
“No, huh… Oh you must be the crazy inventor’s daughter.”
“Yes."
“Well, regardless of your family you are a wonderful creature,” he said. “May I do you the honor of escorting you?”
“Yes,” Belle responded.
“Then where are we headed?”
“Library,” was all that Belle could manage to utter.

Be careful of repetition. Also, for someone so talented, Belle isn't acting very intelligent...

She wished adamantly that she could be like her; pretty, thin, and never alone. But, she knew that she was much too imperfect, much too ugly, and much too fat to ever be like those characters in fairy-tales.

Wished she could be liked who? Why does she think these things about herself?

As Belle stood up, book in hand, Gestaund towered over her. “Wait, you went to the library to get a book for YOURSELF?” Gestaund asked forcefully.

Please avoid capitalizing words. Placing them in italics means exactly the same thing and shows far more sophistication. And why would he be so outraged?

ummm… yes,” Belle meekly answered.


“Belle.” Gestaund finally broke the silence. “I would very much like to do you the honor of taking you to the upcoming ball, but you must stop reading. It will poison your mind”.


Belle finally reached the comfort of the inside of her cottage. Her weight pulled her to the ground, and she lay there sprawled out on the cold wood floor. Her head swam. Her breath gasped. Her chest heaved. Her stomach ached. Her heart raced. Her body was screaming, but she refused to listen.

I think you went a little bit overboard here with the descriptions of her bodily functions.

It was an internal battle; perfection verses beastly instinct, (which side is which, however, is uncertain). In this fight reason and delusion were ammunition, her body was the scorched battle field, and her soul was collateral damage.

Wow, that is really good :) I wished more of your story was like this.

The battle begun with the words "Your You're fat" shooting through her mind.


She opened it. Standing in the middle of the darkening night sky was none other than the gorgeous, "valiant", Gestaund.

I'm not quite sure why you've placed quotation marks around "valiant".

"How could you reject me you stupid girl?" Gestaund slurred.

I don't think you can slurr a sentence. Like, his speech could be slurred, but "Gestaund slurred" isn't right. For example, you can say, "Gestaund lowered his voice", but you can't say, "Gestaund lowered."

Without waiting for a response, Gestaund intruded into Belle's house, her only private place, knocking into belle as he passed through the barriers. Belle was startled and even afraid of his sudden change in character, but nonetheless she followed him into the house.

Wasn't Belle already inside the house?

Gestaund turned around to face Belle. "Can you imagine the embarrassment I felt when I had to admit to the townsmen that you, Crazy Maurice's daughter, rejected me?" he continued. "I am the most handsome, envied man in the entire town. You ruined my reputation." Belle looked at him blankly, she was afraid. "Don't you hear me?" Gestaund interjected. "YOU RUINED ME!"

Why would he admit the rejection in the first place. Also, Belle's subordinate character is starting to annoy me. She's so weak.

He smacked Belle across the face and then forced a kiss upon her. Belle was trapped.

Ow. Didn't she cry out in pain from the slap? Did she feel pain? Did she feel revulsion? Where's the emotion?

Overall, I didn't mind the story. I think you should steer this away from it being a fairy tale. You could completely remove the mentions of this being based on Beauty and the Beast. People will draw the parallels and think you are far more clever by leaving it to be subtly explored than forced down the reader's throats. I would consider deleting the beginning entirely and explain Belle's talents and her hermit father in a different way. You also need to add a fair bit more descriptions to your story, as hardly anything is described.

I don't know how you're going to advance this plot, but I would continue reading it to find out. So yeah. As I said before, strongly consider removing everything that shouts that this is a remake of an old fairy tale and make it your own story. You don't have to follow the story of the Beauty and the Beast absolutely - I mean, you've already deviated here, so you know this. Belle doesn't have to have a reclusive father - it could be her mother that went mad when her father died. Belle could have been raised in an orphanage.

I do hope you expand upon your story a bit and fill in all the descriptive gaps.

Hope this review helped, don't hesitate to reply directly to this thread with any comments or replies :)

- Jai, one of the Four Musketeers.

One for all, and all for one! YE-ah!
I have an approximate knowledge of many things.
  





User avatar
922 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 42011
Reviews: 922
Wed Sep 15, 2010 4:40 pm
GryphonFledgling says...



Ooh, Beauty and the Beast retelling! Yayz!

First off: You've got chapters here, why not try out the spiffy novel feature? 'Tis cool stuff and it keeps you from having to cram all your chapters into one thread, making it a bit easier for people trying to review.

Second: You're obviously drawing inspiration from the Disney movie, but have you thought about making this your own? I mean, you've got enough differences already that with a few changes of names and such, this could be your own original retelling of the classic fairy tale. Try reading some other people's versions and the original, make this your own rather than a fanfic of the movie. You've got some different takes on characters (Belle and her father especially), so why not make them original characters in an original retelling?

Third: Prologue! *froths* Seriously, I loved that bit at the beginning. Very fairy-tale-ish.

Fourth: The second chapter confused me. I mean, we get this strange conversation in her head (I think? Something ominous or just confused internal monologuing? Coupled with the prologue, this almost sounds like it is some sort of strange split-personality coming through. Is this true? If so, I'd give it a little more prominence. Explore it and the emotions around it a bit more. It doesn't have to be long, just give it a bit more 'oomf'.) and then Gestaund shows up. Did it really take him several hours to get there? I mean, you mention her initial panic when she gets home, then she sits down and reads for several hours, then he shows up and is angry with her. What was he doing this whole time? It seems like if he's going to be angry with her like that, he would be immediately after her, not dawdling around brooding on it.

seeminglymeaningless did some great pointing out of grammatical errors. I would recommend that you slow down a little, letting character relationships develop a bit more. I mean, we go straight from Gestaund and Belle's first meeting to him forcing himself on her. I know I said to try and make this your own, but just for an example, if you look at Disney's movie, Gaston and Belle have obviously known each other for a while. Take some time to show him becoming more and more persistant and her rejecting him, so that over time, he can get more and more angry and finally won't take it anymore.

All in all, I found this interesting. Beauty and the Beast is one of my favorite fairy-tales and the Disney movie one of my favorites as well, so I'd like to see where you're going to go with this.

~GryphonFledgling
I am reminded of the babe by you.
  





User avatar
135 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 6280
Reviews: 135
Sun Sep 19, 2010 9:36 pm
ballerina13 says...



Hello! This is very good. It so different from classic fairytales and Disney's interpretation. I really enjoyed the prologue. I do think that you could lengthen it a bit more though.

Character development:
I think that you could add a bit more about Belle's father. Give a description of him or of him and his deceased wife. Also elaborate on the reason why he cannot look at Belle. That part was a bit confusing. Maybe describe what each character looks like, just to set a picture.

Belle:
I love how she is not the typical beauty.It adds more of a feeling her being a real person. The battle of anorexia nervosa is interesting and adds more depth to Belle. It allows people to feel as if they have something to relate to for in today's society, people go to a lot of trouble to be beautiful.

In general, I really like this. It has potential. I feel that the character GEstaund is a bit overwhelming. The whole scene with him talking about books and telling Belle that she had to give them up to go to the ball was to much. I say just tone his character down. Make it more life like.

I can't wait to read more. Keep writing!
~Ballerina
Got YWS?
"No one can arrive from being talented alone,work transform talent into genius" - Anna Pavlova
  





User avatar
73 Reviews



Gender: None specified
Points: 10566
Reviews: 73
Thu Sep 23, 2010 9:59 am
Light_Devil! says...



Why hello thar! It's Azrael at your service, part of the regiment known as the Four Musketeers. Anyway, onto the reviewing1 :D

GirlInTheMirror wrote:This is the first couple of sections of a short story I'm writing that is a twist on Beauty and the Beast. Please give me harsh critiques, either nit picky or more general. Thank you!! Oh, and if you could, let me know whether you caught any metaphors because I'm developing some and want to know at this point how much the reader can pickup.


Please put the explanation afterwards. Usually reading something like that deters many readers from continuing.

Once upon a time there was a story that did not end in a "happily ever after". It was a story of a beauty with a monster hidden inside of her, and a story of a monster with a hidden beauty inside of him.


Is it bad this instantly reminds me of Shrek?

All that Belle saw in this stranger’s eyes was a shallow, foggy brown.


Were. :D

“No, huh… Oh you must be the crazy inventor’s daughter.”


Wow. What a leap of logic. I think you need a little bit more of a conversation here.

He knew that he must have her, but he also knew that he could not be seen with a woman that actually enjoyed such a terribly unladylike thing as thinking.


Was this line meant to be funny? Because I giggled a little there. :D

Her body was calling out to her to stop, to stop everything.


The same word here is used closely in succession. Please use something else... like "halt" or something. :D

In this fight reason and delusion were ammunition, her body was the scorched battle field, and her soul was collateral damage.


Delicious. :D

He smacked Belle across the face and then forced a kiss upon her. Belle was trapped.


Wholey moley. You weren't joking when you said you were changing this popular story. :D


Overall:
I love this. I like you started off in a story-telling like writing and how you slowly eased into the usual writing. I love the internal conflict inside of Belle. I feel like this is a more real story than any other I have read. You have a wonderful way of writing and I adore it. :D You don't have any grammar or typos. Please PM if you ever post anymore chapters. I would love to see exactly how this ended up :D

Have A Nice Day,
Azrael.
Dynamic Duo AWAY!!!

A computer once beat me at chess. It was no match for me at kick boxing.

"I wish Homer was my father," - Ned's son.
"And I wish you didn't have Satan's curly red hair," - Ned Flanders.
  





User avatar
106 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 1626
Reviews: 106
Mon Oct 11, 2010 11:31 pm
Funkymomo says...



You spelled Gaston wrong
Light one candle instead of cursing the darkness.
  





Random avatar


Gender: None specified
Points: 940
Reviews: 6
Sun Mar 06, 2011 8:00 am
SuicideCrusader says...



Hey Hey hey You cannot leave us hanging like this! I wanna read more. I was caught by how you state that a beauty had a beast in her. Later I was impressed at the type of beast you chose. Gestand or however you spell it is twice as much a shovanestic pig. I would like to see where this story goes and how it will end. Please update I am really interest in reading this.
  








Alexa, are there European frat boys
— Carina