Puzzle piece

5 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1055
Reviews 14
Just something I did out of boredom 

Come to me my puzzle piece and be forever mine.
For you fit so perfectly when we're intertwined.
Hold me close and sing to me sweet.
As I think about the day that  we'd meet.
At the altar where we say our I dos.
Then you will whisk me off , to where? We have no clue.
We'll live out our lives happy.
The ending will be sappy.
And when you die,  
And so do I ,
I'll see you up in heaven.<3

Review !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 
Having friend is like peeing your pants, every one can see it but only you get the warm feeling it brings.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1028
Reviews 89
Reserving a spot! Review on its way.
Do not go gentle into that good night.
Rage, rage against the dying of the light.

K's Killa Kritiques

#TNT

All Hail the undisputed king of the YWS helicopter game.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 7522
Reviews 229
Hi! This was, well, interesting. For me, it startrd off fab and then slowly went downhill. I didn't like the last line...it didn't seem to fit with the rest of the piece and didn't rhyme...a little abstract, really. As for the first few liines, your rhyming is great. I would suggest, though, some line-breaks and punctuation. Normally, I don't care whether or not a poem has the latter - I think its up to the author and what he want to create- but think piece does need some punctuation. i'm not sure why, but the lack of punctuation seems to disrupt the flow. Hope this review helped!
- Alia




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1028
Reviews 89
I'm sorry to say, but I did not like this at all. It's a nice idea, but the execution was all over the place. I'll take it line by line.

Come to me, my puzzle piece, and be forever mine.

A good start. This line has a strong pulse. The only change I could suggest is some editions to punctuation, as seen. The red comma is vital. The blue comma is not strictly necessary, but I think it would help.

For you fit so perfectly when we're intertwined.

This line is also alright. However, you've started the sentence with a constituent. Either change the full stop in line one to a semi colon or comma, or dispose of the "for" at the start of this line. Also, I would recommend changing "we're" to "we are". It would fit the meter better I think.

Hold me close and sing to me sweet.

This is where things start to unravel. The first two lines are both in iambic heptamater, but this line trashes that. There are six less syllables in this line, and "to" and "me" are juxtaposing unstressed syllables. These two things completely kill the flow. Also, I think the full stop should be a comma, as the following sentence is otherwise incomplete.

As I think about the day that we'd meet.

Again, inconsistent rhythm, and an incomplete sentence. The latter is easily solved; just remove the comma. Also, perhaps "we'd" should be "we'll", as this fits second-person better.

At the altar where we say our I dos.

Apart from the rhythm, this line is just about fine. I would, however, recommend using inverted commas like so: "...where we say our 'I do's." This is because "I do" is dialogue, and needs to be indicated as such.

Then you will whisk me off , to where? We have no clue.

This line almost recalls the original rhythm. With a bit of reshuffling I think it could be done. I would also recommend a slightly altered set of punctuation: "Then you will whisk me off. To where, we have no clue." Finally, perhaps 'we' should be 'I'. It doesn't make much sense to me to have the person doing the whisking not knowing where they themself are going.

We'll live out our lives happy.

'Happy' is the incorrect form to use in this instance. To describe the manner in which the characters' lives will be lived, you must use an adverb, such as 'happily'. If you're trying to describe the state in which the characters live, you must separate it from the clause: "We'll live out our lives, happy.

The ending will be sappy.

The edition I'd make to this line is change 'sappy'. Your characters are supposed to be happy; 'sappy' has a certain negative connotation.

And when you die,
And so do I,

These lines are not bad. A couplet at the end that does not quite fit the meter is sometimes permissible. However, I would rephrase the second line. Perhaps "As must I,"?

I'll see you up in heaven.<3

This line is a total anticlimax. As Amelia said, it obviously does not rhyme. This is very jarring, and finishes the piece on a poor note. It's akin to playing a musical scale and not ending on the tonic. It just doesn't sit right. Also, the '<3' is totally unnecessary, please remove it.

In recap, the major defecit of this poem is the seemingly random meter. When coupled with a Heroic Couplet rhyme scheme like this one, it makes it read rather poorly.

I hope this is helpful,
K
Do not go gentle into that good night.
Rage, rage against the dying of the light.

K's Killa Kritiques

#TNT

All Hail the undisputed king of the YWS helicopter game.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 14289
Reviews 232
Hello!

I think that you have a pretty good idea with where this poem is going. But some of the lines sounds a bit... off, I suppose. Some of the rhythm isn't quite right. I think that Karzkin mentioned something about metering. So, I won't go into that, not to mention that I'm as good at metering as a pre-schooler. Also, I can see that you've tried to rhyme. Which was pretty good. But, some lines seems to drag on a bit just so that it could end on a word that'll make it rhyme. Like this line:

jedigeek wrote:Then you will whisk me off , to where? We have no clue.


It's not only visually longer than the rest, but it reads longer than the rest. I think that it's really jarring and really quite obvious that the reason the line is so long is so that it can rhyme.

Other than rhyme and metering, I really liked your wording, I think that it made the flow a lot better. Especially in the third line where you wrote 'sing to me sweet' instead of just plain old, 'sing sweetly to me'. That really put a new and interesting twist on the line, so well done on that. :)

Overall, my main suggestion would be to watch your rhyming carefully.



“I'm so glad I live in a world where there are Octobers.”
— L.M. Montgomery, Anne of Green Gables