Dear God

8 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6817
Reviews 74
WHAT YOU SHOULD KNOW BEFORE YOU READ: This story is rated PG-13 for swearing. I didn't rate it 16+ because they're words you've obviously heard before if you speak English.
ALSO...I'm not trying to write this to diss Christianity or religion or whatever else you may think is offending in this story. I'm just wrote it because I wanted to write something convicting and emotional.
That is all. :D -Jane


The little analog clock on Stephanie’s bedside table ticked solemnly as she wept, mucus covered Kleenexes piled in her lap. She leaned her head down as she choked on the curses she tried to release from her dried-out mouth. Right below her pudgy left knee was the picture of her father, Reverend Jack Miller, standing in front of a church that looked more like a cement sports arena than a chapel. He had his hands held out; his wrinkly palms faced the baby blue sky. Printed in large, bold lettering was, “Skyline Ministries: A Path to (After)Life.”

Jack Miller had once again tried to send his daughter a plea to turn to God. Ministry reminders, Bible passages, and inspiring messages arrived in the mail every other day, and Stephanie, with all her conflictions, could just not stand it any longer.

She tried to understand why he kept on sending her all these things about Jesus and church, having enough faith to believe she would turn to Christ one day. But as life churned on, becoming a Christian became an even bigger impossibility.

Stephanie balled the picture into a crinkly sphere; her thick fingers grasped around it. Weeping even harder, she tried throwing the ball in the white waste-basket at the far side of the bedroom, but the paper pitifully landed four feet away from her on the plush carpet.

The trash can was empty. Stephanie felt empty. And in an act of frustration, she clambered over to her work desk. The crying had let up but salt water still soaked her pale cheeks. She delicately unfolded the picture and turned the paper over. Picking up a Papermate and staring at blankness, she finally sighed and began her letter.


Dear God,

I used to believe in you. If you were any part human, I think that would make you feel better, but of course you’re not. I don’t even believe you exist. Some sad person made you up thousands of years ago so he or she could feel better. They imagined creation because no one wants to believe we came from dust and they imagined the second coming because no one, no matter how young or old, loves the idea of dying. Nature’s unfair though. We’re most likely related to apes and one day none of us will be alive. Worms will be sucking up our nutrients, and the last pieces of us will be fertilizer.

But God, and I’m just going to get right to it right now, why should I believe you live? Because you’re the one and only? Because my radical, televangelist father thinks you are? I have a theory that if you were, you would have helped me by now, I’m sure of it. I’m buried in a heap load of shit, to be frank. My situation has me literally begging down on my hands and knees and I want things to get better, I mean who wouldn’t? But they never do. They never fucking do. Here I am God, thirty-six years old, drowning in a pool of my own blood like some kiddy who decided to venture off into the kiddy pool without his mommy and didn’t know how to swim! Wouldn’t you give me one fucking good thing? Once? After all these years of my hypocrite father spitting out things at me like, “God will provide,” or “He works in mysterious ways.” Well, you know what Jesus Christ? You haven’t helped! And you haven’t provided!


Stephanie tried to add some extra exclamation marks to her last sentence, but her hands were already shaking. A line of sweat clustered on her brows. A cry was imminent in her throat, and in the next second she bubbling like a baby. She leaned over the paper, head tucked in her folded arms, tears staining those newly formed words.
Apple of my soul,
Eats me whole,
Take one bite,
No delight,
Rotting hole.




Random avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1040
Reviews 1
Definitely a dark piece! I really enjoyed it. The tone came through wonderfully and your diction was for the most part spot on. But as it stands right now it feels incomplete. I could see this as being a fabulous exposition to a longer piece, but I don't think it can stand on its own right now. The characterization of Stephanie is really full, but I did get a slight impression that she was younger than 36 before revealing her age (I'm not sure why that is). Overall, well-worded, had me intrigued, I just want to see more!

But these are just suggestions!
"How vain it is to sit down and write when you have not stood up to live
H.D. Thoreau




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 7650
Reviews 147
Hi, I'm gonna review this today.

I loved your description of her crying. Your main character felt strong and I felt like I knew her well. I already performed a test once, but I'll do a full blown one day. I asked my brother the colour of one of my characters' hair. He knew the character well, in fact he was his favourite. He knew Jason's hair was brown. That might have been an isolated incident, but I really try nowadays to describe a character's physical features by their abstract ones, play the reader's stereotypes. You did this perfectly. Rather than force something into my imagination, you let me imagine what a crying person might look like. We could learn a lot from this piece.

But that's the good side.

I'm not exactly sure what you were getting at. Yes, she dislikes God now more than ever but why? What is this tough time? How has God not provided? Of course, we could argue that her middle-class living is blessing enough. Did someone die? Was she kicked out of work? What? How has God 'not provided'?

Also, I must disagree with the swearing. To me the F-word feels like an exaggeration, not that people don't talk like that... just that the fact that she began swearing before we could feel sorry for her made her seem a little 'childish'. Swearing might build up pity, but only when we have something to pity her for or feel sorry about. Don't buy the paint and ask how pretty it is unless you've painted a building.

In the beginning I thought her father had died and
Jack Miller had once again tried to send his daughter a plea to turn to God.

meant that even after death he was still somehow trying to get his daughter to join him in Heaven, as he might have put it. That made my mouth go 'O'. But meh... I'm probably missing the hidden words. Remember though, Show don't Tell doesn't mean obscurity.

I agree with the above reviewer, you could extend it but you really don't have to. Perhaps tweak the ending. In my opinion, by ending on her in that POV, you broke a possibly heartbreaking moment. I would really recommend that you isntead end on the letter. If you think that ending on her crying is a good scene (It is, as you wrote it - very well done - but it can also be horribly cliche and the eyes can simply scan over it) then you can tell God that she's crying her letter. The reason I would like you to end on that is because the ending of your story should really make people think. And you know all we Christians are gonna be reading your poem right? You want to... no you NEED to leave us seriously questioning how we view God. In other words, how would God respond to this? And in my opinion, the best way you could do this is by ending it as a proper letter.
From Dissapointed Potential Follower,
Goodbye

Also, the subject of your poem is your letter, so it should leave the resounding note.

I agree with the above reviewer - this could be extended. But rather than put another scene, try and exaggerate and emphasize on things. Perhaps explain what had happened, then give an emotional thought. Describe her father and give an emotional recount. Describe her emotions, and give an emotional recount of how simpler days were gone - for example. I don't want to drive your piece, I was just giving you an example.

---

And don't worry, people ought not be offended. I would personally say, after reading this piece, right on! A problem I believe Christians have to face is the 'no' factor. That and we have to stop thinking of provide in a financial sense. We have to realize God doesn't have to serve us, but the other way around. What usually happens is that we expect God to do SOMETHING and in that expectancy either overlook what we have or what we could get if we just got off our lazy bums. God gave us hands, we don't need Him to lift a wall - we can break it. And what about hopeless situations where you can't do a thing. I truly believe in my heart that that is where God will intervene in a very audible way - you'll see it. Now if you were a tad crueller and really wanted to make us re-question our faith and re-question how we treat God, then strike at that. And by the way, there are tons of Bible verses that - in my opinion - say exactly what I said up there. I'll find one when I can, but now I must off to school!

Thanks for the read,
TheNewHero




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6817
Reviews 74
Uhhh...I didn't really want religion to come into play in the comments. :/
Apple of my soul,
Eats me whole,
Take one bite,
No delight,
Rotting hole.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 3181
Reviews 131
As someone had said before, I think you should expand on this idea, because this was beautifully written.
However, there was one part of the story that caught my eye.
The trash can was empty. Stephanie felt empty.

For some reason, that didn't feel right. Maybe you could write that differently so it flows better with the rest of the story. Also, as someone had said before, I get the impression early on that Stephanie is a teenager. Maybe you should add some more detail to the beginning of the story to make it seem like Stephanie is the age that you say she is.
Need reviews?
I'd be happy to give them.
http://www.youngwriterssociety.com/topic76104.html




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1930
Reviews 17
I enjoyed this. I think the idea has a lot of potential, and you did a good job of helping it reach that potential. I think that you could possibly give the the story more depth if we knew why the woman was so upset with her life and why she was so against God. I thought the first part of the story was better than the actual letter. The letter sounds as if it's written by a younger person, rather than a 36-year-old. It gives off a bit of a teenage-y, angst-y vibe. The letter made a lot of good points, but I feel like the complaining tone kind of voided them. I think it could be improved if Stephanie pulled herself together a bit and then wrote the letter.
I thought the irony was perfect - how she was taking the time to write a letter to a god she supposedly didn't believe in. Maybe she still does a bit? Very good!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6553
Reviews 122
This was a dark piece. I'm just saying this, I'm a Christian and all, and even at 14, I do question the things Stephanie was writing on her letter. I do everyday.
I am totally in love with this piece, though. You really captured the thought of someone turning away, and the way you described her crying like that, it really out the emotion out there that you were talking about. And i like how you were giving your kind of "opinion" I guess, through this piece. Honestly, I am not offended by it, I think this is a very convicting piece, though. it makes you question yourself and makes you think "What would you do in her place?"
I like how you wrote it, and in the way you wrote it, it kept me wanting to read it.
Definately an A+ piece in my eyes, but there were spots, like 322sivart mentioned that didn't flow well in that kind of sentence.

i really want to see more, but you don't have to. Overall, just captivating.

--Ash
And just when the caterpillar thought her life was over, she turned into a beautiful butterfly.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6817
Reviews 74
I haven't been on in forever. :(
Apple of my soul,
Eats me whole,
Take one bite,
No delight,
Rotting hole.



That's how we should measure our lives. Not in distance traveled, or time passed, or worlds conquered, but in moments... and the rush of joy—of grace—that exists within them.
— Megatron (Lost Light, by Roberts, Lawrence, Lafuente)