Saving Lilly-Beginning redone

7 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1052
Reviews 28
I've posted this before, but I'm going to repost it with everything corrected :)

A lonesome balloon floated down steadily in the dark of night. Its bright yellow exterior glowing brightly against the dreary town. The owner of the balloon was high above, watching it from the roof of a tower that disappeared in the clouds high above the tops of the other buildings around. She prayed with all her heart someone would find it. Her tears were swept away in the wind, and her sobs were lost in the clouds. She watched the balloon until it was no longer visible, before ducking back into the top room of the tower.

“What is that?” Jasper whispered under his breath. He instantly regretted it, and glanced around to make sure no Sarakas were lurking around. Ever since the Sarakas took over his town, the color and life had been sucked from everything. Children, much like himself, were forced to live on their own because their parents had been taken away. The streets no longer smelled of the bakeries that used to line them. The buildings had been stripped of their brightness and were painted black or gray. No one spoke unless absolutely necessary, and if they did, it was no louder than a whisper. Everyone lived in fear of being taken away by the Sarakas. Kidnapping was not below the Sarakas. They had taken the princess of his town, Princess Lilly-Lynne, and then took over the town. A yellow balloon sat on the ground, wet with mildew, stuck in a bush. Seeing something so bright in such a dark town was shocking.
Jasper glanced around once again before hurriedly sneaking over to the bright yellow balloon, setting down the groceries, and snatching it up. He looked all around, making sure there was nothing important on it. He saw nothing, but noticed a scrap of paper lying inside. Writing could be seen scrawled on. Carefully, so as not to make a loud noise by popping it, he bit a tiny whole by the knot. The air began to flow out, and soon he had a piece of latex that fit under his shirt. After picking his bags up again, he set off to his house.
The wind was blowing hard, and it nipped at Jasper’s ears and nose. He tried to pull his coat tighter around himself, but the glass milk jug slipped out from a bag and fell to the floor. The sound of glass hitting pavement rang loud and clear throughout the silent town. His heart skipped a beat. He silently cursed under his breath, and then waited for a Saraka to show up. It wasn’t long before one appeared in the distance. He strolled up to Jasper, clearly irritated he had to go check on some kid. He looked at the groceries in Jasper’s hands, the broken milk bottle on the ground, then at Jasper. “What’d you do?” He asked. Jasper avoided his cold stare, and explained that it fell from his bag. The Saraka nodded.
“Clean it up,” He spat. Jasper almost protested, but realized that he could be arrested, or worse, and got on his knees and began to pluck up the glass. Glass is very sharp, and Jasper’s hands were bleeding badly by the time he was done. The Saraka pursed his lips at Jasper. Worried, he looked around, wondering if he missed a piece. He saw nothing.
“What’s that?” He demanded. Jasper hesitated.
“Glass,” He replied. The guard spit on his shoe.
“Don’t you get smart with me. That,” He motioned to his shirt.
One day your prince will come... Mine? He took a wrong left turn, got lost, and is too stubburn to ask for directions.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2804
Reviews 22
Hello funkyreg101! I'm aspiringyoungwriter and I'm gonna be critiquing your story today(tonight?)!
I liked the plot of this story a lot. How you began it made me want to know more instantly. I want to know what happened before Lilly-Lynne got kidnapped. And, speaking of the princess, I love the name you gave her. I thought it was interesting. Now let's get to the nit picky stuff...

funkyreg101 wrote:The owner of the balloon was high above, watching it from the roof of a tower that disappeared in the clouds high above the tops of the other buildings around.

How is it possible to be above a balloon? Especially one you just let loose.

She watched the balloon until it was no longer visible, before ducking back into the top room of the tower.

You don't need the comma there.

Jasper glanced around once again before hurriedly sneaking over to the bright yellow balloon, setting down the groceries, and snatching it up.

How about you do something like this: Jasper glanced around once again before hurriedly sneaking over to the bright yellow balloon and, setting his groceries down, he snatched it up.

Jasper avoided his cold stare, and explained that it fell from his bag.

Again, no need for the comma. It makes it an unnatural pause.

The Saraka pursed his lips at Jasper.

Can you purse your lips at someone? I think you should maybe rewrite this sentence.

“Don’t you get smart with me. That,” He motioned to his shirt.

WHAT HAPPENS NEXT?!?!?

I hope I helped! Keep writing and don't forget to enjoy it! :D
“If I had to choose between betraying my country and betraying my friend, I hope I should have the guts to betray my country.” -E.M. Forster




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 28467
Reviews 675
Eeek, I have to review this. It has my name on it…well…plus an ‘l’ but still.

Its bright yellow exterior glowing brightly against the dreary town.


You have ‘bright’ and ‘brightly’ in the same sentence which is a bit repetitive. In fact, you don’t even really need the second one. If you change ‘glowing’ to ‘glowed’ and cut ‘brightly’ I think it would be a total improvement. Also, in the next sentence, you use ‘high again’ twice which can be repetitive, just like this.

Writing could be seen scrawled on it.


I think you should add ‘it’ to the end of this, mostly because without the word ‘it,’ the sentence lacks a necessary part.


Dialogue

I noticed you had some punctuation issues with your dialogue, so I figured I would bring it in one little spot.

“What’s that?” He demanded. Jasper hesitated.
“Glass,” He replied. The guard spit on his shoe.
“Don’t you get smart with me. That,” He motioned to his shirt.


The first thing to remember is that, when you have dialogue, like with the first line, and it’s followed by something like ‘he said’ or ‘he demanded’ the he needs to be lower cased. This also goes with line two.

As far as line three, the opposite can be used. ‘He motioned to his shirt.’ doesn’t describe the dialogue. That means that ‘he’ can be uppercased and that the comma after ‘that’ should be a period.
Because punctuation in dialogue is important and something that any budding writing should learn, you should definitely click there blue words right here.


Also, be careful with the repetition thing. I only noticed it twice but it can be an awful habit to pick up. I can speak from experience. :D


But I do like the idea you have here and I’d be happy to read more if you would like. More than anything, I want to know what’s on that note.

PM me if you have any questions.

~lilymoore
Never forget who you are, for surely the world will not. Make it your strength. Then it can never be your weakness. Armor yourself in it, and it will never be used to hurt you.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 12987
Reviews 162
'Its bright yellow exterior glowing brightly against the dreary town'. First, this is not a sentence. It can't stand on its own. It needs to be fused with the sentence before it. ^^ Second, you used bright AND brightly, which is repetitive. XD

'The owner of the balloon was high above, watching it from the roof of a tower that disappeared in the clouds high above the tops of the other buildings around.' You used 'high above' twice in one sentence, which, again, is repetitive.

'Children, much like himself,' Um, if he's a child, they're not 'much' like him, they are like him. So you can just say, 'Children, like himself...'

'They had taken the princess of his town, Princess Lilly-Lynne, and then took over the town' Had taken... then took... This doesn't sound right. :\

'wet with mildew' Mildew is a kind of mold... Were you thinking of mildew? Or actual dew, which is the little water droplets you find in the grass in the morning?

'he bit a tiny whole by the knot' Hole.

'Glass is very sharp.' You know what? I had actually heard that before. ^^ As has everyone else. ;) Everyone knows shattered glass is sharp. Maybe change it to something like... "The tiny shards were hard to pick up, and Jasper's hands were bleeding badly by the time he was done."

Intriguing cliffhanger. ^^ My guess is, the guy's pointing to a stain on his shirt from lunch or something. :)

This is intriguing, and your description of the world is interesting. I'd like to know a little more about the Sarakas. How are they different from humans, and why'd they kidnap the adults? Wouldn't they abduct the kids in order to motivate the adults to do... Whatevere it is they're supposed to do? Why did they take over the world in the first place?

Also, this just came to me now, but if he's popped the balloon already, couldn't he have gotten the note out right away and read it?

I'm liking this so far. :) PM me if you add more.
"Pay Attention. Pay Close Attention to everything, everything you see. Notice what no one else notices, and you'll know what no one else knows. What you get is what you get. What you do with what you get is more the point. -- Loris Harrow, City of Ember (Movie)




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1052
Reviews 28
Hi everyone! Thanks for all the comments, the next "chapter" will explain everything from Lilly-Lynne's point of veiw. My chapters will switch between Lilly and Jasper. As far as Silentpages, the next chapter will explain that too. I will revise AGAIN then repost. I wont move on until I have a first chapter I like!
One day your prince will come... Mine? He took a wrong left turn, got lost, and is too stubburn to ask for directions.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2267
Reviews 17
I liked this beginning. You grabbed my attention immediately, and I think Jasper is an interesting character. He's certainly curious, and I like how he seems to be having a little 'rebellion' against these Saraka. Also, you had a very good cliffhanger. I really want to read more, and find out more about that note!

But I noticed some punctuation and grammar errors. I think the other reviewers already covered those. And also, I think you should tell us more about the princess, and about the Saraka. I'm guessing that some more of that will come in the next chapter.

You've got me hooked. I hope you continue this story! :)
"There's a big difference between shooting a target and shooting a charging Wargal. A target isn't usually trying to kill you."
~Halt, Ranger's Apprentice Book Two: The Burning Bridge




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 3342
Reviews 108
Great story! There are a few suggestions I would like to make. For example the second sentence in the first paragraph would be better if you combined the second sentence with the first. Try it like this: A lonesome balloon floated down steadily in the dark of the night, its bright yellow exterior glowing brightly against the dreary town. This makes it a complete sentence. You could also do it like this: Its bright yellow exterior glowed brightly against the dreary town. Also I think the last sentence in the first paragraph would be better if the second clause(all the words behind the comma)were before the first clause (the words before the comma.) Try it like this: Before ducking back into the top of the tower,she watched the balloon until it was no longer visible. Also, in the forth to last paragraph in the first sentence, the the h in He needs to be lower cased since the that word is part of the sentence. You could also correct this by changing the comma to a period so the quote and'He spat' are separate sentences. Lastly, in the second sentence in this same paragraph, you wrote 'Glass is very sharp.' Hopefully, most readers know that glass is sharp. You can get around this by describing the pain Jasper felt when he cut his hands on the glass. Besides this, great story. I can`t wait to read more. Happy writing(:
"A poet is, before anything else, a person who is passionately in love with language." - W.H. Auden



Stupid risks make life worth living.
— Homer Simpson