(Oh-so-short) Preface of my untitled novel.

7 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 14
((Okay, so this is stellar-short, I know, but more is coming very soon. If you feel like this is too short to critique, I won't be mad if you wait until I submit some more to take it apart. :) Also, in the beginning, this won't sound fantasy at all, so all of you hard-core-fantasy readers, I'm not sure how into it you'll be. Thanks guys, love you!))



On my fifth birthday, my brand new bunk bed collapsed. On my lungs.

Of course, I was immediately rushed away in an ambulance. And despite the EMTs pinging machines and pumping valves and flashing lights, they lost me for only the briefest amount of time.

But still. I was clinically dead for three minutes and fifty-nine seconds.

When I awoke to those anxious hospital strangers in their masks like villains, I told them I’d seen heaven. And they tapped their watches and shot each other looks and somehow convinced me that it was all a dream.

And so I believed them. I believed them for eleven years and I forgot and forgot and forgot. But closing my eyes now, I can still see that blinding, consuming light that shone out of everywhere, even my own pores. I see that white and white and endless white. I see those final marble steps that I wasn’t allowed to climb because no, no, it wasn’t my time yet.

And so sometimes, after everything that’s happen, I picture that heavenly dream and I wonder if I really did make up all of those angels on my own.
If all the world is but a dream---fantastic posing greed---then we should feed our jewelry to the sea. For diamonds do appear to be just like broken glass to me.

---
Roo loves yoo. <3




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 59
Hey! Basket here to critique your work today, I hope you don't mind. Okay, well, my corrections/what I will be correcting is going to be in bold within the quotation boxes that we can do.
If i feel it needs an explanation or something, I'll mention it below it.
Sound good? Great. Lets get started. :D


And despite the EMTs pinging machines and pumping valves and flashing lights, they lost me for only the briefest amount of time.

I would change that "and" to a comma.

And they tapped their watches and shot each other looks and somehow convinced me that it was all a dream.

Hmm... I'd personally change this to:
"They tapped their watches and shot each other looks; yet somehow managed to convince me that it was all a dream."

years and I forgot and forgot and forgot.

I see that white and white and endless white.

I realize that you're more than likely repeating everything on purpose, but, really, its uneeded.


Okay, this was really short, so I have nothing major to point out, except that you started two paragraphs and many different sentences with the word "and". Whether or not you did this on purpose, writing like that can rather tire the reader out.

However! I liked this. I really did. I'm interested to see where this is going. Its written well enough to interest me.
So, pray tell, when's the first chapter coming up? :D
-Basket-
Phantom's Contest Basket <--Make me happy and join my contest! Due date: August 15th!
Phantom's Reviewing Basket <--Need a review? Go here and ask!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 790
Reviews 2
Great job! Your first line is a great hook. Can't wait to read what happens next. Wish I could say more but Basket really said it all for me.

And so sometimes, after everything that’s happen, I picture that heavenly dream and I wonder if I really did make up all of those angels on my own.


Doesn't that's mean "that is"? If it does, this wouldn't make sense in your sentence.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 3121
Reviews 108
Great job on this! I can't wait to see where this goes.

Basket and Retrogradatory basically said it all for me, except for one thing....

Roo 2 wrote:And so I believed them. I believed them for eleven years and I forgot and forgot and forgot.


I personally thought "I forgot and forgot and forgot" was a bit redundant. I'm not sure how I would change it, but it doesn't flow as nicely as it might.

Once again, great job!

zOe
Help! I can't remember if I'm the evil twin or the good one!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1633
Reviews 53
Personally, I don't like to go far in to spelling nitpicks and stuff, so i think the other guys got the majority of that. This really grabbed my attention. As I was reading this, it took me to a place (ignore the weird wording) but despite all the white, it was very grey, very dark. But that's just me.

I am very curious to where this is going. I can see it making some very interesting turns already. Just wondering, will this take on any religious "personalities" or themes?

You've got me pulled in. If you need to collaborate or anything really, just give me a little PM, OK?

Awake
I shall but love thee better after death.
- Elizabeth Barrett Browning




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2082
Reviews 71
Hi there! Frag reporting for a review!

This was really good! There's only a couple of things I picked up.

On my fifth birthday, my brand new bunk bed collapsed. On my lungs.

I think that you should take out the period and make it all one sentence. Like "On my fifth birthday, my brand new bunk bed collapsed on my lungs." I just think it would sound better.

But still. I was clinically dead for three minutes and fifty-nine seconds.

xD I just had this random thing pop in my head. "But still. I was clinically dead for three minutes and fifty-nine seconds. Does that make me a zombie? Not really. Five-year olds tend to enjoy animal crackers better than human flesh."

That was so random. I don't even know where that came from xD

When I awoke to those anxious hospital strangers in their masks like villains, I told them I’d seen heaven. And they tapped their watches and shot each other looks and somehow convinced me that it was all a dream.

Why are they tapping their watches? That kind of confused me...

I forgot and forgot and forgot.

I see that white and white and endless white.

no, no, it wasn’t my time yet.

You repeat these words a bit too much. Like, the third one is okay, but the first two can be cut down. The first one can even be cut down to 2 forgots, if you'd like to keep that.

And so sometimes, after everything that’s happen, I picture that heavenly dream and I wonder if I really did make up all of those angels on my own.


This was good. It has me hooked! PM me with the next part, pretty please? :)


Over and out!
- Fragg




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 28467
Reviews 675
Hey there Roo, the names lily and I <3 reviewing short pieces. ^^

First off, this sets a really good stage for what is to come. It doesn't give away too much detail nor does it just state this and this, therefore having no effect on the reader.

But still. I was clinically dead for three minutes and fifty-nine seconds.


This sounds clumsy to me. A suggestion I would make would be something like: “But still, I had been clinically dead for…”

Overall, I found this rather cute and I would definitely be interested in seeing more. The only advice I can give you now is that you don’t want to force your readers into sympathizing with your character. They’ll sympathize if they want to, but don’t make her story seem sad just cause people don’t believe her. Forcing people to believe will irritate your reader.

Any questions or if you want any advice, just PM me.

~lilymoore
Never forget who you are, for surely the world will not. Make it your strength. Then it can never be your weakness. Armor yourself in it, and it will never be used to hurt you.



Everything has to be taken on trust; truth is only that which is taken to be true. It's the currency of living. There may be nothing behind it, but it doesn't make any difference so long as it is honoured. One acts on assumptions. What do you assume?
— Player (Rosencrantz & Guildenstern Are Dead by Tom Stoppard)