I Could Write a Poem for You

12 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 60568
Reviews 537
I don't know where this goes: Lryric or Dramatic? So, 'Other' is it. My first posted piece!

EDIT: Thank you to everyone who reviewed! I'm going to keep editing.

I could write a poem for you,
say how my heart was torn in two.
Use words like ‘scars’ and ‘pain’ and ‘tears’,
but in the end, I’d still be here.
You’d still be gone, your mind still made.
My wrath would only spark and fade.
While I could cry, and shout, and scream,
and write with rage ‘bout broken dreams,
I’d rather know that I stayed calm.
Since I’m composed, and you were wrong.
Last edited by Evi on Sun Mar 01, 2009 4:32 pm, edited 2 times in total.
"Let's eat, Grandma!" as opposed to "Let's eat Grandma!": punctuation saves lives.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 51
Alright then, it sounds as if you forced some of the rhymes, justa reminder that all poems don't have to rhyme, but it is nice when they do. Some of the lines sound a bit cliched, but as long as you add some of your own, it will be okay. *shrugs* The poem was fine, nothing fantasic, but that can be fixed up with a little bit more imagery, of maybe adding some metaphors. I also think that one the my wwraoth sparks... I sugest that you put sparks AND fades. Easier to read that way. It is a bit teen love angst, but its strong.
Well, keep it up, practice makes perfect!
~Alyss
Last edited by *DaughteroftheMoon* on Tue Feb 03, 2009 10:45 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Amor Vincit Omnia




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1361
Reviews 106
Hi, Evi. I like this poem. I'm so glad you paid attention to RHYTHM. The rhythm is perfect. I like the premise pf the poem. I especially like how, when you're reading it, you slow down on the last line. It's like the poem itself is on the verge of flipping out and then calms itself down at the end. Does that make sense? The quality of the writing itself matches the subject of the poem.

"My wrath would only spark and fade."

I don't like the word "spark" here. I understand what you're trying to say, but is there a way to say it that seems more natural?

The calm/wrong rhyme seems a little off to me. And just personally, the phrase "Since I'm composed" just seems a bit too prose-y for a poem. I'd change it, but there's nothing wrong with it.

This is good stuff. I'd like to read more!

rachel
"He found his voice tended either to disappear or to come out too loud." -William Golding




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1564
Reviews 16
I liked it for the most part, but I agree with the other "reviewers" that some rhymes sound forced. But I really liked the part:

Use words like ‘scars’ and ‘pain’ and ‘tears’,

but in the end, I’d still be here
We're living in a den of theives, and it's contageous.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1290
Reviews 7
I really, really loved it. I think the rythem is good, the thought behind it is awesome and I really don't have a huge problem with the rhyming, either. Maybe it's just me, idk. Regardless, keep up the good work! :D




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1802
Reviews 261
I don't think the rhyme sounds forced. Well, except here:

I could write a poem for you,
say how my heart was torn in two.


Anyway, I love this poem. It's a change from the common teen angst poems. It comes off really strong as well.:) Great job.

Oh and another thing, the line with spark and fade. And is usually a conjuction used for continuity or other things like that but I think you're looking for something that signifies an effect here. Sorry, that sounded messed up. Anyway, I think 'then' would be better. Anyway, it's a small thing.

Your ending was fantastic. 8)
All that I'm after is a life full of laughter, as long as I'm laughing with you.:)




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 26101
Reviews 1335
Hallo, Evi! Since you so kindly took the time to look at some of my pieces, I thought I'd critique a few of yours as well. ^_^ First of all, let me say that I really loved this piece. As I read it, I thought the rhythm was perfect and I didn't find any of the rhymes very forced~

There were only a few comments I had about your word choices! ^_^
I have to agree with KnightlyAngel09 about using 'then' instead of 'and', since it seems logical that after rage sparks, it would burn for just a bit before fading rather than doing both at the same time. C:

I’d rather know that I stayed calm.

Since I’m composed, and you were wrong.


I like the essence of the ending, but the way it's delivered seems a bit off to me. Taking a look at the punctuation we see that you mean for the last line to stand as a sentence by itself, which it can't really do as it's written. The only suggestion that jumps to my mind as a replacement would be 'As I'm composed, so you were wrong', which would kind of compare the amount of composed-ness {? hahaha...} to wrong-ness. <_< I like making up words, apparently. Anyways, do you get what I'm saying though. In fewer words, that new sentence would say 'As composed as I am, that's how wrong you were' and since the poem is obviously very controlled {expressed through the rhythm and meter as well}, you'll drive the point home!

Well, those are my two cents. C: Hope I helped! <3

-Hannah-




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1190
Reviews 200
Hey Evi! Congradulations on your first posted piece, and since you reviewed my work (and I thank you for that) I feel entitled to review yours.
First of all:
nixonblixen wrote: I especially like how, when you're reading it, you slow down on the last line. It's like the poem itself is on the verge of flipping out and then calms itself down at the end. Does that make sense? The quality of the writing itself matches the subject of the poem.

I agree with this. It really does. Kudos.


Evi wrote:Use words like ‘scars’ and ‘pain’ and ‘tears’,
but in the end, I’d still be here.

I like this line a lot. Annoyingly, sometimes it rhymes and sometimes it doesn't. I know. You're probably staring at the computer thinking I'm a complete idiot and thin.king 'but if it rhymes, it has to rhyme the entire time'. Which is true.But not. Its like ahalf rhyme, the 's' at the end is what throws it off (but don't take off the s off of tears because its better that way). You get what I'm saying?? But its one of my favorite lines

There's really nothing else to say (except for I also adored lines seven and eight). That, and I agreed with Hannah. Why couldn't my work be so wonderful when I first posted?

~MV
I realized that I said I'd be gone for only two weeks...but I was gone for much longer.I hope to stay on this time. :)




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 7273
Reviews 45




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 15394
Reviews 1464
Hello Evi! June here!

I hope we've spoken before? Because it feels like we have, and it feels like I owed you reviews? Either way, I haven't reviewed this, so I do :D. Let's get to work.


People commonly tell me I need to stop obsessing over the grammar and structure of a poem, but sometimes I can't help it. When a poem rhymes, it's all about rhythm, meter, and form. You can't have a dragging line in the middle of short ones, right?

So, to speak! Forgive my obsessiveness on those areas; I'll try to be moderate.

There isn't much to change about your poem. The way it's written implies that the narrator, in this case I'm imagining is a female, is posing herself as the innocent one. Basically, she's removing all the blame from herself and dumping it on the person she could write a poem for. Ironically, she says she won't do it, but she basically has, haha.

A few nitpicks: Or suggestions (You don't have to heed these, they're fine if you don't change them!)


say [s]how[/s] my heart was torn in two.


In this line, I killed the "how". I don't think it's necessary, but that's my opinion. It flows shorter, and smoother without the how, but the how is giving us slightly more. On another note, too much isn't leaving us when it vanishes, you know? :D

It's up to you to decide on that, dear.


My wrath would only spark then fade.


Often, I read rhyming poems aloud to sound out the syllables and make sure that it all flows like it's supposed to. My tongue tripped on this line, so I think it could use a comma after spark or replace "then" with "and". It's up to you :).


On the whole, it was a nice poem to read, dear! It was short, simple, and wasn't too mushy (haha). I really enjoyed it. Keep it up! And write more soon!

Best--

June
"I'd steal somebody's purse if I could google it and then download it." -- Firestarter




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 4362
Reviews 263
Evi wrote:I don't know where this goes: Lryric or Dramatic? So, 'Other' is it. My first posted piece!

EDIT: Thank you to everyone who reviewed! I'm going to keep editing.

I could write a poem for you,
say how my heart was torn in two.
Use words like ‘scars’ and ‘pain’ and ‘tears’,
but in the end, I’d still be here.
You’d still be gone, your mind still made.
My wrath would only spark then fade.
While I could cry, and shout, and scream,
and write with rage ‘bout broken dreams,
I’d rather know that I stayed calm.
Since I’m composed, and you were wrong.

Shina here again Evi ;) This is not my final stop though. Sorry you have to be my first victim xD I chose someone closest to. my age and you're on my friends list so you were just asking to be reviewed!

For a first poem, pretty good. The second line should add "to" in the beginning because the flow breaks at the beginning of that line. Fourth line doesn't need a comma. I think you should change "since" in the last line to "now" because at the beginning of the poem you want to write a poem for this person and you should signify that you've grown since the beginning. When you say "since", it sounds like you knew all along you were composed. If you put "now" it'll seem like a change was made.

Once again an awesome poem from Evi! You do not disappoint ;)

~Shina
You cannot dream yourself into a character; you must hammer and forge yourself into one.

The writer, when he is also an artist, is someone who admits what others don't dare reveal.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 7
Evi wrote:I don't know where this goes: Lryric or Dramatic? So, 'Other' is it. My first posted piece!

EDIT: Thank you to everyone who reviewed! I'm going to keep editing.

I could write a poem for you, Nah, you couldn't =)
say how my heart was torn in two.
Use words like ‘scars’ and ‘pain’ and ‘tears’,
but in the end, I’d still be here.
You’d still be gone, your mind still made.
My wrath would only spark and fade.
While I could cry, and shout, and scream,
and write with rage ‘bout broken dreams, I like the way you changed about to 'bout to balance the syllabes =)
I’d rather know that I stayed calm. Me too!
Since I’m composed, and you were wrong. That kind of fades out at the end (actually I read it that way... =) I like it.
Let mercy come and wash away what I've done.



Revision is one of the exquisite pleasures of writing.
— Bernard Malamud