My Sister

12 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 317
My Sister

I have a sister
I have known her since birth
When I look in her eyes
I see mine looking back

Her hair is blonde and long
As is mine
Her eyes are sky blue
I share those too

Sometimes we fight
I almost always win
She is a peace maker
I don’t back down.

She sets goals
And attains them
I float anywhere
Just happy to be me

When she is sad
I share her pain
When she is mad
I run

I have been blessed
Beyond any measure
I have never been alone
I share my life with her

We don’t always get along
And sometimes I tolerate her
But there is one thing I have never done
And that is to stop loving her

She is my twin
My identical me
Our souls were formed together
And together they will always be
Last edited by Kim on Sun Nov 11, 2007 9:00 pm, edited 1 time in total.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 34
I think while reading this I thought this was a good conceptual idea, some of the lines seemed a little forced, but I thought your ending was really strong, so at the point those shakey lines became obsolete. Well done.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 441
That was grate!
You really let your emotions get wined into those words. I could feel it. I know how you feel because I have a sister as well!
Keep on writing! Never judge yourself!
:D

~ Gwen




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 7740
Reviews 713
Kim, this was really good. I knew that it would be. There are only two things I noticed:

"Her eyes are sky blue
I share those to."

To should be too.

"I have been blessed
Beyond measure"

This seems a teeny forced so if you added "Beyond ANY measure, it would flow better.


Kim, that's all. Great job!

BBB
Just write -- the rest of life will follow.

Would love help on this.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 43
Wow, I loved this poem, I too have a sister and I could not have put it any better. She is blessed to have you.

Hummingbird
I hate mean people




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 17580
Reviews 798
Hi Kim!

As the second of four girls, I have to say: Awww!

As a mean, evil critiquer, I have to say: EDIT!

Some of the things you put in here are really great, about how you look alike, the differences in your personality, and how even though you don't always get along, you'll never stop loving her. I find that unless the poetry is really, really well done, these sorts of things often work out better prosacially. I challenge you to write this as a story, rather than as a poem, so that you can show, and not tell, your audience how you feel about your sister. I think it could be really good!
Got YWS?

"Most of us have far more courage than we ever dreamed we possessed."
- Dale Carnegie




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 196
Aww, that was really sweet. My favorite stanza was:

When she is sad
I share her pain
When she is mad
I run


Haha! Cute. ^_^ Agreeing with Arieda, though, it would have been a lot better had you shown and not told. You have some wonderful reasons as to why you treasure your sister, but perhaps you should work on sharing that emotion with us. We want to feel what you feel, so show us.

I didn't know how to word that, so I hope it at least SOMEWHAT helped. lol Beautiful work!

~*Syd*~
Formerly known as Silly Sydstix... as well as Aquarius Angel.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 516
That was really sweet.

She sets goals
And attains them
I float anywhere
Just happy to be me


This bit didn't work for me. The sound was different from the previous two.

When she is sad
I share her pain
When she is mad
I run


I think it should be, I run away. Just I run is too short and doesn't fit.

Overall I really loved it.
*Don't expect to see me around much in the next couple of weeks. School has started again, and it'll be a couple of weeks before I've settled in. If you've asked me for a critique, you will get it, but not for a little while. Sorry*




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 709
Reviews 83
THAT was strong adn emotional, it makes me think of my sister...and wish she were here with me.....very good job....the reader can understand what the author is going through......i can relate to your poem in one of my own....i think its called my true friend....i haven't finished it yet but heres the beginning....

You were there for me,
when i needed a shoulder.
You guided me,
when I was lost.
You led me to safety,
helping me stand strong
You, with your gentle,
guiding hand.
Are the hope within me,
I know I can find not another true friend.

well anywayz....thats just one im working on for my sister...i only get to see her once a month...yeah sad i know....well the poem was really great!!!

good job.keep writing!
"Hello, is this thing on?"




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 4790
Reviews 42
this was great written in prose, your feelings for your sister are genuine. I like how you chose to write this. I do agree if you were to go back and add more to it, it would even be better. I also liked the humour you added. Very well done.

Carl




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1382
Reviews 237
Edits and comments in bold

Kim wrote:My Sister

I have a sister
I have known her I think that it would flow better if you got rid of the her since birth
When I look in her eyes
I see mine looking back

Her hair is blonde and long
As is mine This line seems too short...maybe put "Mine are as well" or something here.
Her eyes are sky blue
I share those too

Sometimes we fight
I almost always win
She is a peace maker
I don’t back down. I don't really think that "Win" and "Down" go very well together here (and yes, I know it's not supposed to rhyme).

She sets goals
And attains them
I float anywhere
Just happy to be me I liked this stanza, but in line two I thought "attains" seemed a little awkward with the rhythm.

When she is sad
I share her pain
When she is mad
I run Hahaha, this seriously made me laugh

I have been blessed
Beyond any measure
I have never been alone
I share my life with her This was a great line and a great stanza (it flows...).

We don’t always get along
And sometimes I tolerate her On this line, change the "And" to "But"
But there is one thing I have never done
And that is to stop loving her

She is my twin
My identical me
Our souls were formed together
And together they will always be I loved your ending!!



I thought that this was a really good poem. Your rhythm needs a little bit of work around the middle, but overall I think that it was a good poem, showed your feelings for your sisters, and had a really good ending. A little work and this would be a really, really good poem. (It's very good already!)

Keep writing!!!!!!!!!!

Teh Wozzinator
Go K-State for North Division!!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2168
Reviews 183
I have a sister
I have known her since birth
When I look in her eyes
I see mine looking back

Her hair is blonde and long - Couldn't you describe that a bit better?
As is mine
Her eyes are sky blue - Again, pretty bland. Use more colorful adjetives.
I share those too

Sometimes we fight
I almost always win
She is a peace maker
I don’t back down.

She sets goals
And attains them
I float anywhere
Just happy to be me

When she is sad
I share her pain
When she is mad
I run - Haha.

I have been blessed
Beyond any measure
I have never been alone
I share my life with her

We don’t always get along
And sometimes I tolerate her
But there is one thing I have never done
And that is to stop loving her

She is my twin
My identical me
Our souls were formed together
And together they will always be - reword that "together they always will be."

I liked this poem. A bit straight-forward. I see you didn't spend time to dwell on the little, pretty words. You could probably do better. And also, you just repeated the same message in every stanza. "She's my sister and I love her." you gave out a lot of cliches like "we fight. but I love her." "im so glad shes my sister." "I feel what she feels." Where's the originality?

Keep writing!
Got YWS?



I know history. There are many names in history, but none of them are ours.
— Richard Siken