You Can't Erase ch. 3

5 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6915
Reviews 115
Three days. Three days my only daughter had gone with out talking to me, it was tearing me apart. It was amazing how we could be living in the same house and she could be acting like I wasn’t there.

She would wake up, eat breakfast in silence and leave for school. She would come home, do her homework and ignore me. During dinner she would look past me, as if I wasn’t there. I didn’t even know how to apologize.
I wasn’t fit to be a mother.

On the third day, Sam was watching T.V. and pretending that I didn’t exist. I was watching from the kitchen, thinking of a way to get her to talk to me. It’s not like with little kids. With little kids you can put your foot down, send them to their room for attitude, demand they never treat you like that again. But teenagers can think for themselves, they think like adults, and they know when they have a reason to be mad. You can’t talk down to teenagers because they will pick up on it and resent you for it.

A commercial blared onto the screen, “Coming to a store near you...” What I needed was forgiveness, a fresh start so maybe I wouldn’t mess up so bad this time. “And don’t miss Brent ’s new CD, A Roll of the Dice, which he is promoting on tour with his band...” The voice faded as I walked into the other room, my mind shifting from my daughter to Brent; actor and musician. Typical.

I grabbed the mail from the box and was pleased to find a postcard from Brandon. On the front was a snow-covered mountain surrounding a lake.

To my girls - I’m writing you from Colorado where I landed this morning. I’m reporting at the Colorado Neurological Institute tomorrow. They have a groundbreaking new study on music and endorphins. It’s rather interesting - i’ll send the story once it’s done. Montana was great, there’s nothing more exciting than wildfires, let me tell you. I ended up singeing my sneaker by getting too close. Lesson learned - I guess. Well, that’s all I have to report (get it?). I hope to here from you soon.
- Brandon
p.s. Sam, how did you do on your French presentation, you never got back to me. Je suis inquiet
Katie, I have some news, I’ll talk to you sometime next week
.

I always liked getting postcards from Brandon, it reminded me that we were a family, however skewed and atypical a family we were. We had been roommates the last two years of college and when I found out I was pregnant we had tried dating a little.

Sixteen Years Earlier

“Our child should have a family, don’t you think?” Brandon and I strolled across the campus after lunch one afternoon. He looked at my stomach affectionately. My body was a swollen, rounded orb that I hated. I was supposed to be enjoying my senior year in college not pregnant. I wasn’t ready to be a mom. Sometimes I felt like I couldn’t even take care of myself.

“Well, of course, I think so, too,” I said. Brandon put his arm around me awkwardly. It felt heavy around my shoulders, uncomfortable. He must have felt it too because he put his arm back by his side. We’d been trying to date for months but I know neither of us felt it. I looked down at my stomach again, this baby was destroying our friendship.

“Well,” he muttered and then paused. He stopped and kneeled down like he was tying his shoe. I waited but he didn’t tie his shoe, instead he pulled something out of his pocket and looked at me.

“Katie,” Brandon began slowly, holding out in front of him a little blue, velvet box. My stomach clenched together as I realized what he was doing. He said it, “will you marry me?”

I just stared at him in disbelief. Why was he doing this? He was ruining it. I didn’t want to marry him.
“Brandon,” I said shakily, I wrapped my hands around his and the little box but I did not open it. “Brandon, I don’t love you.” His face broke so I added hurriedly, “you don’t love me, either!”

He was still on the ground, looking defeated, “I- I do.”

“No, you don’t,” I pulled him up off the ground. “You don’t have to do this just because- because you think you have to.” We both looked at my stomach and I added, “I’ll be fine.”

“You shouldn’t have to do this alone. You always try to be so independent but this time...” he trailed off.

“I won’t be alone,” I grinned at him and wrapped my hands around my swollen belly. “I’ll have my best friend.” The word swam through my head, I’d never really thought of Brandon that way, it fit him perfectly but I’d never thought of having another best friend.

He beamed and hugged me. It was the first time in months he’d hugged me and it hadn’t been forced. Maybe this will work out, I thought. Maybe something in my life will work out how I want it to.
Last edited by LittlePrincess on Thu Jun 02, 2011 9:22 pm, edited 2 times in total.
"One sees clearly only with the heart. Anything essential is invisible to the eyes."
The Little Prince




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1040
Reviews 3
This was really well written, i really enjoyed how you put the flashback into it. Maybe you could elaborate more about why Sam is mad at her mom and explain who each character is because i kind of understand but not really... Keep writing (:




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 368
Reviews 456
Hey,
Thanks for the request, and letting me know this was up. Since you know the drill, I'll just dive right on in to your review.

Three days. Three days my only daughter had gone with out talking to me, it was tearing me apart.

Three days is not a full sentence, so replace the period after it with a comma and lower case the t in three after the comma.

It was amazing how we could be living in the same house and she could be acting like I wasn’t there.

You are combining two complete sentences with the conjunction and, so add a comma after house. In your previous chapters I spent quite a bit of time explaining conjunctions and so forth, so it would be helpful if in other chapters you re-read them and the commas in where they need to be. This helps your reviewer focus more on the plot and characters, instead of your grammar mistakes. :) (If you still need help though, feel free to ask)

She would wake up, eat breakfast in silence and leave for school.

You are making a list of three things, so there should be a comma after silence.

She would come home, do her homework and ignore me.

There should be a comma after homework because you are making a list of three things.

But teenagers can think for themselves, they think like adults, and they know when they have a reason to be mad.

Never start a sentence with a conjunction. In this case take out the word but and add a comma after teenagers and put on the other hand and add a comma after that. Also, don't forget to capitalize teenagers.

I hope to here from you soon.

Here should be hear. silly typo, but if you self edit first you can get rid of silly typos like that :)

We’d been trying to date for months but I know neither of us felt it.

Know should be knew because this is in past tense.

Overall: I really liked this chapter because of the flashback it was so cute! Just be careful on your dialogue and thoughts because sometimes the thoughts of the mother make me feel like she's the teenager. She's a parentso she is the one in control. Sooner or later her daughter will come around because if they had any relationship at all she'll start to feel guilty. Bravo, can't wait till the next chapter!
If you have any questions or need another review feel free to ask,
Have a great day,
Tiffany
There is nothing to writing; all you do is sit down at a typewriter and open a vein~ Red Smith

Who needs a review? :) http://www.youngwriterssociety.com/topic38078.html




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2383
Reviews 67
Hi,

I thought his name was Bernie?! Not Brandon. I could've sworn I saw Bernie in Chapter One. Anyways, I really like this. While there were many errors, it was really well written. There were mostly gammatical errors. This grabbed my attentiion and I can't wait to see Chapter 4.1. This really caught my attention, but you could elaborate just a tad on why Sam was mad. I really like how you showed the mother, and what you did with the postcard and commercial. You did a very nice job. The transition was less rocky this time, it went so smooth. I wasn't confused, except on her age. I'm thinking she was 23 or something, but I don't know. Anyways, time to read onward on my noble steed, Walrus the penguin.!

Farewell,
A.
You think you are any different from me,or yourfriends?Or this tree?If you listenhard enough,you canhear every living thingbreathing together.You canfeel everything growing.We are all living togethereven if most folksdon't act like it.We all havethe same roots,and we are allbranches of the sametree.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6235
Reviews 2631
Hi again, getting closer to that fourth chapter ;)

Line-By-Line

Three days. Three days my only daughter had gone with out [Without is one word.] talking to me, it was tearing me apart. It was amazing how we could be living in the same house and she could be acting like I wasn’t there.

On the third day, Sam was watching T.V. and pretending that I didn’t exist. I was watching from the kitchen, thinking of a way to get her to talk to me. It’s not like with little kids. With little kids you can put your foot down, send them to their room for attitude, demand they never treat you like that again. But teenagers can think for themselves, they think like adults, and they know when they have a reason to be mad. You can’t talk down to teenagers because they will pick up on it and resent you for it. [I'm finding the mother's character hard to get to drips with. She says that teenagers think like adults? What?! That's a very un-motherly thing. It's a very un-adult thing. I'm only just into adulthood myself but already I can feel the gap widening. It's true that teenagers think in a similar way to adults but not the same. Once all the thoughts of marriage, houses, bills and jobs starts crowding in, a lot of the essence of that teenage life drifts away.]

I always liked getting postcards from Brandon, it reminded me that we were a family, however skewed and atypical a family we were. We had been roommates the last two years of college and when I found out I was pregnant we had tried dating a little. [This is getting a little too info-dumpy. Do we really need to be told this stuff? It just seems to be really forced.]

Tension

So the most important thing in this scene is that the mother and daughter aren't talking. But you need to build the tension more! Show us her attemptes to draw her daughter out of this silence, show us that awkward dinner table moment in all its glorious detail. At the moment this feels like just a splurge of self pity and I don't like the mother. She's coming across in this chapter as being such a whiny, woe is me teenager! That would be alright if you took it further and made it a consistent trait but in the previous two sections she was motherly and mature so she can't just descend to this. All she's doing is moaning to herself and blaming herself. Mothers are used to this. For the first few days at least she shouldn't be too worried, she should just work on coaxing her daughter out. After four days maybe the worrying starts as mothers always expect that their children will get bored after half a week so then it starts getting serious. But the silent treatment is such a common offence of teenagers so she shouldn't jump straight away to thinking she's a terrible mother.

Overall

Not a bad chapter. I think it's written quite well, though less telling and more showing would be nice. And it's pretty interesting. I wish you had a little more going on though. These chapters are so short that there's not a lot of action to them or general 'pull' factor - not enough to keep drawing your reader in. You've mentioned this old love of hers plenty but nothing has happened with him yet. Surely you should be more into the novel by now? You're three chapters in! By this stage I'd have thought the daughter would be sneaking out to one of his concerts or something.

Well I hope this helps, will be reviewing the next chapter soon,

Heather xxx
Writing Gooder

~Previously KittyKatSparklesExplosion15~

The light shines brightest in the darkest places.



cron
Stupid risks make life worth living.
— Homer Simpson