User avatar

seeminglymeaningless

seeminglymeaningless

  • Fantasy Short Stories Re: Currently untitled- please review!

    Wait wait wait wait. You're thirteen years old?! Are you kidding me?! Kid, the quality of this story is beyond that of someone five years older than you! I was ...

    Aug 2, 2009
  • Fantasy Short Stories Re: The Gem

    Firstly, this post is WAY too long. Cut it down to at most a third. People don't want to be bogged down in a person's story for longer than 10 ...

    Aug 2, 2009
  • Fantasy Novels Re: Black and White (prologue) {slightly revised}

    Hi :) You critiqued my work, so here I am returning the favour. I tend to critique while reading, so I don't forget anything and tell you my on going ...

    Aug 2, 2009
  • Fantasy Short Stories Re: The Kingdom of Whym

    Miniauthor, I didn't actually realize how many times I used the word smell, and you're right, I can simply reduce it thus: "From the kitchen behind the bar came some ...

    Aug 1, 2009
  • Fantasy Short Stories Re: The Kingdom of Whym

    Roon. It's American spelling - travelling vs traveling, harbour vs harbor, colour vs color. But that's okay, I don't expect you to realize that (realize vs realise). As orc is ...

    Aug 1, 2009
  • Fantasy Short Stories Re: The Kingdom of Whym

    [Edited as per Roon's suggestions] Festival time. The time of the year that everyone from nearby villages come to the city of Quay to celebrate and take advantage of the ...

    Aug 1, 2009
  • Science-Fiction Novels Re: Dimension Shift -- Chapter One

    Hi :) Awesome idea. It reminded me of the Golden Compass, Narnia and the Secret Garden, mixed with a sort of Harry Potter-kids-being-sorted kind of thing, what with the portal, ...

    Jul 8, 2009
  • Science-Fiction Novels Re: Mourning Doves

    I'm so sorry. It's just so long! I tried to read the majority of it - but only got up to the part where you are describing the bookshelf in ...

    Jul 8, 2009
  • Science-Fiction Short Stories Re: Are You Ready?

    Hi I looked at this once before, and couldn't make myself read it. Perhaps it is just not something I would normally read. However, as no one else has critiqued ...

    Jul 8, 2009
  • Science-Fiction Short Stories Re: The Chronograph

    Hey, Firstly. . . Loved the idea! But hell! I was disappointed by the ending! So many threads left untied, so many questions left unanswered! What was the note?! Who ...

    Jul 7, 2009
  • Science-Fiction Short Stories Re: Starting Back

    Hey :) Kylan was a bit cruel. While I do agree with him that the story is confusing and upon reaching the end I felt as if I hadn't actually ...

    Jul 7, 2009
  • Fantasy Short Stories Re: Maiko of Gion

    Hi again! Firstly - I scanned the story, and to my absolute astonishment, it's absolutely improved 100% from the first post. Well done, FireFox! Second, I see Master Yoda gave ...

    Jul 7, 2009
  • Other Re: Old Story

    If you don't want people to see this story, simply " hide" it to other viewers.

    Jun 29, 2009
  • Romantic Short Stories Re: Letters from Prison

    Epic ending.

    Jun 29, 2009
  • General Fiction Short Stories Re: How far i've come

    Blink pretty much covered everything, but here are the corrections if you had bothered to take his advice, showing you what would have been fixed, and how it'd look. I ...

    Jun 29, 2009


I would be a terrible novel protagonist.
— mellifera