Silverstar

Oh, I loved that book! Unfortunately, the library only had the first two of the trilogy... which is murder. Very funny. Stars are cool. Marark didn't vlaim to be king.. ...

*thunderous applause* Reichieru, that was very aptly put, exactly how I feel. However, it is an insult to geniuses when this book is compared with the greatest works of fanatsy ...

See. Amatuerish writing, really amatuerish plotting. He shouldn't have been published. He should have had more time to develop his writing, not publishing the first finish piece of writing he ...

The Lord of the Rings by JRR Tolkien is not a book written for children or young adult. Its original audience was intended for adults, unlike the Hobbit. It was ...

but the lord of the rings isn't i think people are only reading them because of the movies. Excuse me? Anyone who truly likes the series likes them for the ...

*twitches* I'm going to retire to my cave with classic literature now. If you need me, ring the bell marked 'Large Stompy Things.' WHat is the world coming to? Yes. ...

Which is sad. A book should be written to be a book, not a movie. An insult to the genre, I say! *waves fist* Not to be rude, or anything, ...

*raises eyebrows* Really? As in... what? I saw nothign immediately wrong with it.

Looky what I found! On accident! Linky! Heehee.

Y'know, if we judge the quality of writing by how many people like it, we're in trouble. I really couldn't care how many people liked it, all the people who's ...

Actually, I have yet to find someone who thought it was well-written. You'd be about the first. (I take that back, second. there was that other guy... yeah) I cannot ...

... I read the first one. Have no desire to read the second one, cause as far as I can see, writing quality aside, the plot ain't much. There are ...

Not to start any fights or such like, but that was totally uncalled for. I do not go around insulting people who do not like the Sillmarillion.

*coughcoughahem* I really, shouldn't, but I will. Against my better judgement. My Two Bits I was not impressed at all by the first one. The plot was seriously cliched, and ...

No contest. LotR all the way. Actually, the Silmarillion is better, *high fives Erethror* As for too much description? Its a matter of taste. And for me, what mood I'm ...