-
Re: Classic Book Critique
Saw this in my bi-monthly-or-so exploration of the site and felt I had something to say regarding th subject. I was speaking with a classmate (an avid reader, by the ...
Mar 10, 2012 -
Re: Expanding My Horizons
Hi. It is a bit cliched, but I wouldn't call it dumb. I hate judging stories harshly with such a narrow window as a prologue, because there is so much ...
Jan 24, 2012 -
Re: Glory On the Court
Huh. Well. Flash-fic sport stories, in my experience, invariably end in the same way. I am for this reason inclined to dismiss this as hackneyed and only review it as ...
Jan 20, 2012 -
Re: Succubus [Rated 16+ for gore and nudity]
Well, that made sense! Not really. This is to help familiarize yourself with your novel, then? My tip would be to actually get started on your novel. Preliminaries like these ...
Jan 14, 2012 -
Re: Don't be dismayed at goodbyes
So, did the narrators change? I agree with the previous reviewer in that that is somewhat nebulous. Narrator changes aren't bad things, and they can be quite powerful in specific ...
Jan 10, 2012 -
Re: Tainted Love Rewrite
Mmkay. This was interesting. I'm not going to go into the scientific issues with this, because they're so manifold and blaring that it's clear that you weren't really writing this ...
Jan 5, 2012 -
Re: Organ Donor
As requested. Firstly, I would like to offer a humble rebuttal of Lavender's first point. Verbosity in itself is not a crime. Some of the best writers are terribly verbose ...
Jan 4, 2012 -
Re: Rose
Right. This was kind of a good story. A little. Not really. Truth is, it ended the same way it started. No one learned anything. Narrator ends up with the ...
Dec 31, 2011 -
Re: Memories in the Sand
Um. Wow. I guess it was good. I'm assuming that its purpose was allegorical, if anything. If this reflects your opinion (which I hope it doesn't), then your views on ...
Dec 28, 2011 -
Re: Of Memories and Tea
Dusk dawned in a winter haze and lay sleeping across the westerly horizon. It was cold, tooth-numbing cold—curling my jacket around the summits of my shoulders, I quickened, or tried ...
Dec 13, 2011 -
Re: Dark Dance Chapter One
Welcome to YWS! Actually, I rather enjoyed this. You're writing was crisp and easy to follow, delving into pieces of imagery here and there, but not overdoing it. It was ...
Dec 10, 2011 -
Re: somewhere, nowhere
Ear! I had a dream last night where true love and true homes were nonexistent. Fairly strong first lines, but not amazing first lines. While this is a nice lead ...
Dec 10, 2011 -
Re: Inferno Prologue
Zup. I guess this wasn't too bad. Personally, I'd move it up to the chapter one position, considering that its contents are more immediately relevant to the story than they ...
Dec 9, 2011 -
Re: Audy's Star Fund! - Donate your Poetry
A review on this would be awesome.
Dec 9, 2011 -
Re: Heat-Smothered
Morning driving on a sun-stung Mexican highway, concrete wisps around like Sahara sand, flickers on and off through the eons. Sweat pulses like the tide, men sprouting from behind tattered ...
Dec 9, 2011
