-
Re: your kisses
lexy: I don't see any redeemable material here. You have some cliches (fading into his arms). You have an event that leads to name-calling. The one-word lines are sure-fire signs ...
Nov 18, 2006 -
Re: fade away
Krystalstars-- The narrator is self-obsessed and boring. I doubt if a revision that does not include starting over will be worthwhile. Take some time. Step away from writing and read. ...
Nov 18, 2006 -
Re: To a dear friend
ilubdraco-- When I got to the end of this piece and read, "...I hope your last few months are magical", the only thought that came to mind was, "Is she ...
Nov 18, 2006 -
Re: Popular
Hi Fantasyfreak14, What is this stuff? S1L2 is the end of this poem--the rest is filler. There's no doubt you have potential, but it is not enough to save this. ...
Nov 18, 2006 -
Re: What is Normal?
Fantasyfreak14-- Welcome to the YWS Poetry forums. This curious construction serves no purpose that I can see. Best, Brad
Nov 18, 2006 -
Re: The Pathologies of Poetry
Face it. We’ve all walked (clicked) away from a poem worrying that we might catch cancer if we kept reading it—so much that even our commenting runs the risk of ...
Nov 16, 2006 -
Re: Wanting More
All-- Thanks for taking your time to read and respond to this. Crysi, The first is a call, the second an answer. The third: resolution. Poetry articulates the gaps in-between. ...
Nov 15, 2006 -
Re: My Friend John
Fantasy of You-- I appreciate the honesty. As it were, being published in a magazine doesn't mean anything, since three-fourths of the users on the site could be published in ...
Nov 14, 2006 -
Re: My Friend John
Fantasy of You-- This is instantly forgettable fluff with a pastoral and conversational tone sprinkled throughout. It wanders randomly towards an end-goal only the writer must find satisfying. The sec
Nov 14, 2006 -
Re: Through the Mirror /P
avidreader10-- Thanks for taking the time to read and respond. It is a short story. Jack, I am surprised this received any positive feedback. Besides being written in a slightly ...
Nov 14, 2006 -
Re: walks after rain
watergirlwriter3-- Please refrain from posting any more poetry until you have reviewed three or four pieces by other users. Thanks, Brad
Nov 14, 2006 -
Re: If only a picture could freeze the past.
watergirlwriter3-- Welcome to the YWS; there seem to be a lot of other "girlwriter"s or "writergirl"s about the site. Maybe you can all start a family! That would be neat. ...
Nov 14, 2006 -
Re: the abandoned
Jack, There's some good writing here. A few suggestions: Consider dropping L11. The point has been made with L10 and L11 adds little. I think the poem gathers force by ...
Nov 14, 2006 -
Re: Through the Mirror /P
Removed.
Nov 14, 2006 -
Re: Corrupt a Wish
Granted, but you'll be tired all the time and burn-out in the next five years. I wish more people knew how to write poetry...
Nov 13, 2006
