Crux - Edited

12 posts
User avatar
Gender Male
Points 13307
Reviews 350
The light from the moving torches –their high flames undaunted by the stinging rain– threw long and hideous shadows over the men. The colour of the skins, the rippled muscles of the legs as they ran, the sheen of armour slicked in the rain: all reflected orange in the firelight, a single hue that burned the eyes of observers for miles about.
High up on the cliff, the shadows receded into the black oncoming of stormy night. Here and there, pairs of eyes, glowing white in the dark, peeped out of shadowy lairs, but quickly receded as the convoy of light and noise drew near.
Shouts rang out across the mountain range, the reverberations rising up the cliff and then falling down below to black depths ringed with tooth-edged rocks. The words were harsh; without meaning, solely for the purpose of exciting the shouter and his companions.
The sound fell on the ears of many that night, but none more so importantly than those of Crux: that thief, that scoundrel! As he ran, his sharp breaths matched beat with his feet; his teeth ground like a millstone as fearful thoughts churned above like the gears of a clock.
His wet body, inadequately clothed with a simple tunic and light cloak, glistened whenever a far-flung finger of light touched him. His right hand he held close to his chest, guarding the coffer of stolen goods. Every fibre in his body was bent towards escaping. His heaving legs ate up the ground greedily, heedless to pain and slippery rock.
Only that morning, Crux had walked peacefully among those who now chased him. Of course, once he’d stolen some of their most prized possessions, it was only a matter of time before they rose as one and sought out his sorry hide. True, they’d reacted faster than he’d predicted, but it was still enough time.
You couldn’t blame him, though, he had to steal the darn stuff, the peasants’ security was so lax they deserved to have it stolen from them. In the future, they would constrict any other valuables: he was really doing them a favour.
However, the mob behind him hardly saw it in the same light: anyone could tell that.
Crux’s ears were fully tuned to the sounds of night, which was why it was no wonder he heard one of the hunters yell to the other: “Cut him off before he reaches the Stream or we’ll never see our gold again!”
Hearing this, Crux grinned widely and put on a final burst of speed; this Stream couldn’t be far. Already he was deciding what to do with the loot. The silver and gold he could sell, but the jewels were far too valuable to just give up. He would definitely have to buy food. The last time he’d eaten was that morning, and even then it was just a sour melon. It would have been better if he’d skipped a meal completely, since he’d been spitting seeds all evening after that. Maybe–
His train of thought suddenly cut itself off as his feet struck on nothing. For a moment he seemed to be hanging in midair –arms flailing, mind racing– as the rain fell below him. Too late he realized that he had not heard the Stream, had not felt the ground slope down, had not stopped to think about the dangers in the shadows.
“I shouldn’t have counted my eggs before they hatched…”
The lid of the broken coffer flapped open and a single penny flew out, spinning in the cold air. When the face was turned towards Crux, moonlight flashed like a beacon; flash, flash, flash. He reached out towards it in sluggish motion, touching its edge with the furthest tip of his fingers.
“Damn eggs…”*
But nothing lasts forever, and Crux felt air rushing around his ears, the sickening drop in his heart, the final protest of his stomach. The night was black, and the water black, and the very air was heavy with darkness, so he never saw how far he dropped. Bone-chilling waters closing over his head. The turmoil of the waters kept him underwater and current seemed to flow down, keeping him from any hope of ever resurfacing. The coffer was wrenched from his grasp. Gold, silver and jewels were swept away in a glittering cascade.
“One, two three…eggs.”
High above, the mob, now silent, stood at the edge of the Stream. They could see nothing and the roar of the river was muted by a similar roar of rain on the mountainside.
“He never heard it,” one of the Russian peasants quietly confirmed the thoughts of the others. “In he went and the treasure with him.”
Slowly they turned away, shedding bitter tears over their loss.

Spoiler
This is my submission to Trident's Three-pronged Contest. I chose the following columns: Russian peasants, spitting watermelon seeds and a silver penny. 809 words, a 107-increase.
*Normally, I do not resort to profanity. In fact, I feel rather guilty about using that single word (I know, I’m a wimp, right? ;) ). However, it seemed to fit Crux’s personality perfectly, so I couldn’t resist. :P

Back story: Crux is a professional thief. He’d escaped from the big cities where his name was well-known, and the pursuers were hot. Upon entering this peaceful Russian village, Crux realizes that they keep gold, silver and costly jewels in their monastery. He waits until night-time to steal them, swiping a melon while waiting. After dark, Crux breaks into the monastery, grabs the loot and high-tails it out. The peasants were warned early on, however, by witness who had been near the monastery. Gathering up their pitchforks and torches, they head out into the growing storm to chase him. The story starts there.
The idea of Crux dying not at the hands of his captors and haters, but at the hands of Nature, was unique to me. Normally for me, evil is bad, and good is good, and both are rewarded accordingly. In this story, however, Crux actually gets a light sentence (in my view). He does die, and probably painfully, but in my eyes it was better for him to go that way than to be hung, humiliated, in the village.
Also, he managed the biggest heist of his life, that should account for something.
My point is, I wanted Crux to win. He was a likeable guy. ;) I couldn’t let him win, though, since it goes against my morals, but I could give him a softer landing into the afterlife.
Does that make sense? Didn’t think so. :|
Last edited by Jenthura on Thu Dec 16, 2010 4:46 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-ж-Ж-ж-




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 4343
Reviews 51
Wow, this is really good. I never even caught on that it was for the contest. You embedded the three elements that well. I couldn't find any mistakes. This is a very well rounded story. Good description in the beginning. You portray Crux well; just a thgief that can't help himself. It has a definite beginning, middle and end. i don't know what else to say, i wouldn't be surprised if this won. Good job!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 30301
Reviews 770
Jent, this was brilliant!

If I hadn't know it was for a contest, I wouldn't have guessed.

If I had to nitpick about anything at all, it is that I found the ending just a little anticlimatic after such beautiful descriptions. I'm okay with him dying, I just wished it was done with a little more . . flair? Oomph? Do you know what I mean. It's just that I was literally at the edge of my feet, he flies for a second or two, then bam! He dies. It's just...Lacking a bit, I find.

But maybe that's just me. I loved Crux' thoughts, about how he was doing them a favour. It is unclear how he was 'walking among them' at first. Is he also a warrior? Other than that, complete and utter love.

Tanya :D




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1060
Reviews 3
Jenthura wrote:His right hand he held close to his chest, guarding the chest of stolen goods, and his left swung to and fro as every fiber in his body bent towards escaping.


I don't like the repetition of "chest" in that sentence ...

... but that's truly all I can nitpick here. The beginning caught me in a very subtile way, the mid part introduces an ordinary but also very adorable protagonist and the final is just brilliant! I don't agree with borntobeawriter's opinion on that but I guess that's ok. I love the short and cold description of his fall, the mention of the moonlight's refraction on the penny and how the whole story ends.

Absolutely awesome work! Good job here!

LOVE
There are only a few things more interesting than my blog. Go check it out: http://www.lettersfromtroy.com/ - Read and comment my texts. Would love to meet you there!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 44887
Reviews 816
Hey Jenth! Here to review. ^^

So I have a few nitpicks...

The light from the moving torches –their high flames undaunted by the stinging rain– threw long and hideous shadows over the bodies of men. The color of the skins, the rippled muscles of the legs as they ran, the sheen of armor slicked in the rain: all reflected orange in the firelight, a single hue that burned the eyes of observers for miles about.

I could have gone for a stronger opener. I know you mentioned that your piece might be too wordy and I'll have to agree with you on that part right here. It seems like you were trying to explain the little details and I had to read it twice to build an image of it in my head. Either that or it's because me+reading in the morning= fail.
Anyway, casting that wordiness aside, I still think you had room to make this slightly better to really capture the interest of the audience.
High up on the rock wall cliff, the shadows receded into the black oncoming of night, but down below the fiery demons danced with a fervor unmatched.

Rock wall cliff? What do you mean? As far as I know, cliff = rocks, no?
Am I missing something? :O

Here and there, pairs of eyes, glowing white in the dark, peeped out of dens, nests and lairs, but quickly receded as the convoy of light and noise drew near.

The abundance of commas here is slightly annoying. Change if you want but don't if it's really necessary.
the reverberations rising up, up the cliff side and then echoing, falling down below to black depths ringed with tooth-edged rocks.

Again, you seem to be over-explaining little things and there are parts in which I have to go back and read over twice.
His right hand he held close to his chest, guarding the chest of stolen goods, and his left swung to and fro as every fiber in his body bent towards escaping.

Maybe you want to use another word besides 'chest?'
I've noticed there are few other instances where you have some repetition of the same word. I didn't point them out but if you go back, you'll see them. Try not to do this too much or it'll stick out and people will notice it.
Same goes for the colons.
Hearing this, Crux grinned widely and put on a final burst of speed: this Stream couldn’t be far.

It stands out when you use more than one, sadly.
For a moment he seemed to be hanging in midair –arms flailing, mind racing– as the rain fell below him.

Hah, for a second there I almost forgot it was raining. X3

Overall


I've read the contest and it seemed like quite the tough one to pull off so I'm not sure if I plan on doing a story for it. My life seems to be full of things that need my attention as of late. However, this isn't about me. As far as your story goes, I thought you did a great job putting all three elements into play. I was afraid you weren't going to give the watermelon seed that much attention but it seemed to fit in right at the perfect time and accelerated your story. The thing about these contest are, it's harder to come up with something you're given the material and have to play around with it. With that said, you were able to pull of a meaningful piece with action and wonderful imagery - when it wasn't too wordy.

My favorite part was the ending. I liked the imagery there (I'm all for imagery) with the coin spinning in front of him as he plummeted into the waters. Ah, just beautiful in a sad way. It reminded me of a scene out of a movie. ^^

I've already mentioned my little nitpicks so I won't go further in that but I will say that I enjoyed reading your character's thoughts. I'm a bit disappointed he died but it was for the story, unfortunately. I hate killing cool characters. =(
Anyway, for only 702 words you did an amazing job. It was short, it was realistic and it gave it's definition. Good work, Jenth! I wish you all the best in the competition!

Hope I helped,
-Pink
There are three rules for writing a novel. Unfortunately, no one knows what they are.
-W. Somerset Maugham




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 7241
Reviews 721
Hullo! It turns out I could review this sooner than I thought, so here goes. ^.^

Alright, so I had a few nit-picky comments, but I think Pinky pointed most of them out, so I'm going to skip that part of the review. Though I will say this: I suggest you do something about the first sentence. It is lovely and eloquent, but I think it needs to be more punchy. I was not drawn in by it because it didn't catch my attention. I think it really just needs to be shorter -- so maybe break it up into two or more sentences? Maybe try something like this: "The flames of the moving torches blazed high, undaunted by the stinging rain. Their bright light threw long and hideous shadows over the bodies of men." Also, you might want to change that last bit since "bodies of men" sounds sort of like they're dead. I love the bit about the shadows though!

Okay, so overall I liked this a lot. I love wordy descriptive pieces (I hope Trident does too!) and your style worked beautifully to create a clear picture as well as an moving story in very little words. It didn't feel too short at all. I also want to congratulate you on writing something involving those three elements and not making them seem out of place. Each element plays a fairly major role in the piece, but it doesn't feel like it was written to include them. One thing confused me, though, so maybe you could clear it up: It's night time. He ate the watermelon in the morning. So why does he still have a seed in his mouth? That's a long time to keep something as big as a watermelon seed in one's teeth! Maybe you could add the bit about spitting the seed as a flashback? Or maybe he could have eaten the watermelon more recently? ...Or maybe I'm just confused and there really isn't any problem at all, in which you should just ignore all this. ^.^

Also, as Pinky mentioned, I forgot it was raining. I would like a few more reminders of that throughout. You mention that Crux is wet, but that could be sweat, couldn't it? Or is it really cold? You could consider a few more mentions of this type of thing. I would also like a little more information about Crux's life before this moment. You say that he walked among them, but what does that mean? I assumed that to mean that he had always been a thief, but nobody realized before now. But how does that work? How could he live in a village and make them all think he was one of them when he was actually stealing from them? Did he have a home? Did he have friends in the village? Once again, just a few mentions would go a long way. You don't need to spend a lot of time explaining stuff like this, but if you developed it a little better in your own mind, then maybe you could clue to it subtly? It just feels like right now the story is rather simple. It's beautifully told, but it's lacking something at some level, and I can't quite put my finger on it -- but I think it may have something to do with Crux's character and his relationship to the villagers. Did he really think he could trust them? Was he supposed to be surprised that they were hunting him down? Was the reader supposed to be surprised? Along those lines, I don't think you need the last line. In my opinion, if you stopped after "Slowly they turned away, shedding bitter tears over their loss." that would be a much more powerful end, because it would leave us wondering if they were weeping over his death, their treasure, or both. That might be a good ambiguity to complicate the emotion of the piece. But it's up to you, of course.

The other issue I had was the tone. The beginning is very eloquent and literary, but then it gets much more conversational with "You couldn’t blame the chap, though, he had to steal the darn stuff..." Is that intentional? It just felt a little abrupt to me. I also wonder if you might spread the imagery around a little, since the beginning (the first four paragraphs, I think) was densely descriptive, then the rest of it was a lot more plot-driven. Maybe you could even it out a little more? Or remove one of the descriptive paragraphs in the beginning and instead add one in the end? I don't know -- it just seems a bit uneven.

Anyhow, I liked this overall! Crux is an interesting character... I am intrigued by the way he justifies stealing. I wish the piece were longer so that I could know more about him! But I think it works quite nicely at this length. I hope some of what I've suggested is somewhat helpful to you. Please let me know if you have questions/comments about anything I said.

Good luck with the contest!
a

[EDIT]: Ahh! This review is about 150 words longer then your story! Nice job Azila. >.< Sorry I rambled so much. I hope you can make sense of some of it...




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1066
Reviews 18
Wow! I thought this was very well written and gripping from the start. The tension you started with pulled me in and held me. Great work!Your descriptions are great and you have a very smooth style.
As for critiques, watch your repetition in words. For example,
"His right hand he held close to his chest, guarding the chest of stolen goods, and his left swung to and fro as every fiber in his body bent towards escaping."
Now, I know the word, "chest", is used in two different meanings but it still makes it a bit choppy seeing it in such close context. As for the second part of the sentence beginning from, "and his left arm", seems out of place. You describe what his arms are doing and then go into the "fibers of his being bent on escaping". It doesn't fit. It's good description but again, choppy. I would suggest just finish the sentence with the left arm and then begin a new one with his whole body focused on that one purpose, escape.
The next thing that caught my eye was the use of this, narrator to reader sentence. It always creates a problem to switch from one view to another. In this case, third person to narrator's perspective. "You couldn’t blame the chap, though, he had to steal the darn stuff." I would suggest maybe something more like, "He chuckled at himself. The chest had practically begged him to steal it as he entered the town earlier that day. Little security, lax society, and a perfect thief made an easy job." to keep it in one perspective.
There were a couple of other things but you'll probably find them if you ever decide to go back over this. I just had one last question; If his ears were so in tune with the sounds of the night, why did he not hear the stream? Just a thought. Great work!




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 13307
Reviews 350
Thanks so much for the reviews, guys! I'll work hard to make this better. :D

@born2be: He 'walked among them' because they didn't know he was a thief. He was in their village casing the joint, so to say. :)
-ж-Ж-ж-




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 771
Reviews 180
Wow. This is quite nice, very interesting and engaging. And, even if I'd like to see more of this world, I can tell it has ended--just as Crux's life did.

I did notice the word "chest" a few too many times and missed the bit about watermelon seeds, but that might be me. Anyway, I'd also suggest, when you use dashes, to use two or a single line without spaces. For example:

Robin raced through the forest, dogs baying behind him. He glanced back to try and see them--only to trip over a felled branch and fall face first into a pool of water!

Yeah, something like that. I dunno. I liked it and I hope you win. Good luck! :)
My SPD senses are tingling.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1290
Reviews 7
Hi Jenthura,

I'm impressed with your ending! I like that it's abolute and (even though one can't help but think Crux a likeable guy) just.

I think you could do without so many descriptive words, particularly in the beginning. In his semi-memoir, On Writing, Steven King tells about the first article he wrote for his school paper. The editor of the paper tells him the piece is fine, it just has too many words. Then, with a fat, red pen, the older man proceeds to mark out all but a few of King's descriptive words. My point is, if you cut out the unnecessary language, I think you will find you can produce a clearer image.

As the author, only you know what image you mean to convey, so be sure the words you choose are consistent with your meaning.

I can't assume to know what words are important to you, the author, but I would probably slash these:

The light from the moving torches –their high flames undaunted by the stinging rain– threw long and hideous shadows over the men. The colour of their skin, their rippling leg muscles of the legs as they ran, the sheen of armour slicked in the rain: all reflected orange in the firelight, a single hue that burned the eyes of observers for miles about.


Also, the opening description doesn't sound like a mob of peasents (I don't imagine Russian peasants don armor to chase a thief through the woods).

You couldn’t blame him, though, he had to steal the darn stuff, the peasants’ security was so lax they deserved to have it stolen from them. In the future, they would constrict any other valuables: he was really doing them a favour.


That made me smile. I like Crux's reasoning.

Already he was deciding what to do with the loot. The silver and gold he could sell, but the jewels were far too valuable to just give up. He would definitely have to buy food. The last time he’d eaten was that morning, and even then it was just a sour melon. It would have been better if he’d skipped a meal completely, since he’d been spitting seeds all evening after that. Maybe–


I like how he gets lost in his thoughts and takes the reader with him. The sudden fall surprises us both!

The lid of the broken coffer flapped open and a single penny flew out, spinning in the cold air. When the face was turned towards Crux, moonlight flashed like a beacon; flash, flash, flash. He reached out towards it in sluggish motion, touching its edge with the furthest tip of his fingers.


Like a close-up in a movie. I can see it perfectly.

But nothing lasts forever, and Crux felt air rushing around his ears, the sickening drop in his heart, the final protest of his stomach. The night was black, and the water was black, and the very air was heavy with darkness, so he never saw how far he dropped. Bone-chilling waters closing over his head. The turmoil of the waters kept him underwater and current seemed to flow down, keeping him from any hope of ever resurfacing. The coffer was wrenched from his grasp. Gold, silver and jewels were swept away in a glittering cascade.


This image also is quite clear.

High above, the mob, now silent, stood at the edge of the Stream. They could see nothing and the roar of the river was muted by a similar roar of rain on the mountainside.
“He never heard it,” one of the Russian peasants quietly confirmed the thoughts of the others. “In he went and the treasure with him.”


Here I went, "oooooh, that's why!" Ha, ha. I think it's great you gave an explanation for readers like me.

Slowly they turned away, shedding bitter tears over their loss.


As I said, I love the ending! But "bitter tears" seemed a bit heavy. I think "Slowly they turned away" is final enough.

Hope I didn't over-critique...? I like the piece and wish you luck in your contest!

Sincerely,
RaeSuz




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 13307
Reviews 350
Thanks Rae! I tried to cut down a lot of words with the edit, but obviously not enough.
Originally, the ending was going to be, "Slowly they turned away, shedding bitter tears over their loss. None shed tears over the loss of a life." but Azila thought it would be better to cut it. Then you suggest to cut it even more! :lol:
I've read On Writing, but I always thought he was talking about non-fiction. I'll try another edit with your corrections. Thanks a bunch!
-ж-Ж-ж-




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 4646
Reviews 32
hey! I see that you have many, many reviews already, but I think you deserve one more, even if its just to say how good this is!
Really, I was impressed. Your writing style is very effortless, elegant even!
Of course, there are a few points on which you could improve, the most notable being the repetition of words in some sentances, such as "chest" and "water" in the section that Crux falls into the river. These are only small points, but they are little mistakes that I find can bring down a piece. A simple correction of these things could make this near flawless, in my opinion.

Apart from that, you are an excellent writer and you shouldnt ever, ever stop. I hope my simple, short review has been of some help, even if its all been said before!

PM me if you ever upload an edit of this, I'd love to look it over.

Well done :)
I will live forever, even if I die trying.



It's not nice to roast people when they're out of comebacks.
— Atticus