Save Her

4 posts
User avatar
Gender Male
Points 67823
Reviews 254
Spoiler
There is this thing in India to kill the baby girl child even before she is born that is in the womb of her mother especially in the rural areas and even if they are born the society does not let them live..... So this poem is dedicated to them... Please save the girl child



Let her live.
She does not deserve to die.
She hasn't even seen the world.
She can't even cry.



They say “Raising girls is like
watering someone else’s lawn”.
She is an asset.
Why do all forget?


When she is in poverty.
She is treated like property.


Bruised.
Accused.
Abused.
Scarred.


They ask "Girl child is a curse or blessing?"
A girl is always a blessing.
She gives birth to breathers.
How can she be a curse?


Without a girl,
a house is incomplete.
Without a girl,
we all are incomplete.


So let her live.
She does not deserve to die.
She hasn't even seen the world.
She can't even cry.



They suffocate her.
They bury her alive.
They strangulate her.
To give her poison they contrive.


Where are we heading?
A land with no girl!
But without her,
all would suffer mayhem.


So let her live.
She does not deserve to die.
She hasn't even seen the world.
She can't even cry.
Are you living for the things you are praying for?




Random avatar
Gender None specified
Points 827
Reviews 45
Wow. You are very good at setting mood. Fantastic work.
I dream by day.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 13952
Reviews 168
Hello I'm LastPaladin and I shall be your reviewer for today. I've noticed a depressing pattern in your poetry, it comes across as simplistic and dare I say it generic. It's why I'm forced to review another poem by you. I warn you now this will be harsh as I really wish to help you, as people helped me. So without further ado I shall begin.

Here's my main problem with this, it's simplistic to a letter and it doesn't inject any captivating imagery, in fact it follows along the line of 'telling' us and not 'showing' us. This doesn't bode well as poetry should evoke some emotion, it's a theme that should really give us a powerful feeling -- instead it seems more like a case report with flowery prose. It doesn't achieve what you wish to open our eyes.

In this case it does more than that, it just comes across as generic and weak. The theme presented here should interest, but somehow you've presented it in the blandest way possible. It exploits clichés in such a way it's degrading and detracts from the important theme you have presented.

Your choice of words weaken this further, word choice can save a poem like this. It isn't the case here, you use girl far too much. I understand this poem is focusing on this, but with something like this, you should be subtle screaming it out come across as preaching and literally quite annoying. If the issue means so much to you, show us don't talk us through it like some saccharine politician who only trying to get re-elected.

I did like one stanza, except it's a little twee.

Without a girl,
a house is incomplete.
Without a girl,
we all are incomplete.


It's not bad idea, but you could have written a love poem from this stanza, it just doesn't fit here. It just comes out of nowhere and hits you. The idea is sweet but it just doesn't belong.

Overall: You need to understand a poem like this can't rely on telling us the story it should capture the feeling with imagery and superb word choice, you have neither, you resort to cliches and tiring repetition and you come across as a hollow voice who feels guilty, but doesn't feel anything for this. It's exactly what you don't want, but sadly it happens and I can only say, work slower and remember a poem only as strong as say the way it captures. In your case this feels rushed half-done and more like a skeleton, more like a brainstorm of ideas. I'm sorry can't say much nice about this.

Hope this helped.
You poor take courage
You rich take care
This earth was made a common treasury
For everyone to share
All things in common
All people one
We come in peace
The orders came to cut them down

Billy Bragg - The World Turned Upside Down




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1125
Reviews 368
Try putting in some more stronger emotions into it.I would suggest rewriting this with a nice flow and make it more explanative.

Keep writing!
"A good plot is like a dream.If you dont write down your dream on paper the moment you wake up,the chances are you'll forget it and it'll be gone forever"-Roald Dalh.



One of the things I love about YWS is the quote generator. For example, I'm reading a really serious work, and then I see "Moo. - cow" at the bottom of the page.
— Darlet