Character Protects Life

8 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 58538
Reviews 553
This literally sucks, I know. This might not be what the title has to say, but that is the lame, weird, boring topic we've been given for an essay competition. So, if you have points which I can add, it would be gladly appreciated.

“Character is a diamond which scratches all other diamonds”, were the words echoing in my mind while I sat to write this. But then as something struck me like a pin being pricked-I didn’t know exactly what a character is. What exactly could I write when I didn’t know the core meaning of the main word?
One dictionary defines character, as "the complex of mental and ethical traits marking a person." In another dictionary, character is said to be "the stable and distinctive qualities built into an individual's life which determine his or her response regardless of circumstances. As an oblivious teenager, I got gist of the second definition only. My mother always says that regardless of what the situation is, regardless of the tough examination God is taking of yours, you have to choose what is right, choose what you truly believe in- that is the main character aspect, to believe in anything from your heart and going with your heart, rather listening to what the ancestors had left us to follow. Make your own trail.
Abraham Lincoln said, "Reputation is the shadow. Character is the tree." Our character is not just what we try to display for others to see, it is who we are even when no one is watching. Good character is doing the right thing because it is right to do what is right.
Many people around me have indulged in activities which are morally not correct, and no matter what those people say about the honesty winning; these people have found their way. But I know that when they get up in the morning and face themselves in the mirror, they can see their skin mottled with patches of disgrace, of cowardice, and the biggest of all what they can see is the coal like blackness hidden in their soul all because they didn’t listen to their heart, they didn’t do what was right, right for the humanity, and right for themselves. A bad character may bring you things which a good character cannot initially but at the end world would come to know what lies behind you, whether good or bad. Being a drug addict might seem cool now, but after two three years no one, not the people who had encouraged you onto doing this, or the people who thought you were too cool, would have to suffer, but it would be you. So, a good character saves no one else, but you.
Character is just like a wall we build all around us, which protects us from the external negative energy. A person with good character skills would never find it hard to adjust with others because they know and would always do the right thing, and someday you would be able to win the hearts of the people. For example, throughout you’ve been a good student and one day your teacher gets you in brawl with another student although it’s not your fault. But the teacher might not punish you, knowing that you are a good child, and you don’t deviate from your path of doing the right thing. Character is not what we only we can feel and know, but others also know your character and the actual person behind you. A good character would always save you and no matter what even when once you’re not happy being always right and not doing tempting things, later on you would see for yourself the fruits it bore you. You would never be punished for what you haven't done, and if your character and inner self is pure.
At last, I would like to leave you with a famous quote by Martin Luther King, Jr., with the same incandescent hope burning in my heart-“I look to a day when people will not be judged by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character.”

~Shubhi :)
Last edited by MiaParamore on Tue Aug 24, 2010 2:59 pm, edited 1 time in total.
"Next time you point a finger
I might have to bend it back
Or break it, break it off
Next time you point a finger
I'll point you to the mirror"

— Paramore




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 805
Reviews 336
Hey,

Quite frankly, this wasn't as terrible as you made it out to be. It was intelligent and to me, a teenager who doesn't really enjoy reading essays, I found this pretty interesting. I like the end but the begining quote wasn't that great in my opinion. Umm, I don't have much else to say. This was pretty good. :)

~Jas

P.S As Tamara said, add more. It seemed short to be an entire essay.
Last edited by Jas on Mon Aug 23, 2010 9:10 pm, edited 1 time in total.
I am nothing
but a mouthful of 'sorry's, half-hearted
apologies that roll of my tongue, smoothquick, like 'r's
or maybe like pocket candy
that's just a bit too sweet.

~*~




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 27927
Reviews 532
Hiya Shubhi!Here as requested! 8)

First of, I would like to say that I won't be nitpicking on specific grammar, but I'll mention it later on in the review. :)

I think that the length of this could be longer if you added some more quotations and opinions. Although, I think that even if you kept it like this it would be okay too. I'm not sure about this but sometimes there would be a quotation with out any quotation marks, so it's like it's you who is saying it. To make this essay better organized, you could have one paragraph with one quote and your views on it and another paragraph with another quote and your opinion. However, I don't think that you should change your second paragraph. It's one of the best, you've balanced out fact and opinion very well here. The way that you've analyzed what you think a character is is very good, by looking at other peoples views and then comming up with a conclusion. Although, most of the time, what you think a character is should come at the end, it looked quite good here. Like I said, I won't nitpick about the grammar, but there are a few commas missing, and at one point you didn't end the quotation.

You seem to have a better understanding of what a character is from the start of the essay to the end of it. I, too, also have a better understanding of character. Although at some times, what I thought you were saying was a bit irrelevant to the subject itself, it's all about your opinion. Just remember when your writing not to drift off. You haven't used much detail in what you thought about each quote, nor some lively language. You could improve the piece by adding this on. I definately think that you did good research abou this, but if you want to add something, maybe look for other people's views and why you agree or disagree and why. You could also compare two quotations to really make this piece better.

So to sum up eveything, I'd say that your strengths are your balance between quoteationand your views about it. Your weaknesses are grammar and layout skills. Things to add on to this could me comparing two quotes with a full explanation and saying why you agree of disagree with one. I think it would be interesting to hear why you disagree with something.

I don't really do non-fiction critiques that much, but I tried my best!
~Tamara
:) xo
Someone told me there's a girl out there, with love in her eyes and flowers, in her hair.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 44887
Reviews 816
Hi Shubs!
I saw you posted something and I giggled and was like "must review" :)
Okay, so anyways, here I go.

Character is a diamond which scratches all other diamonds”, were the words echoing in my mind while I sat to write this. But then as something struck me like a pin being pricked-I didn’t know exactly what a character is. What exactly could I write when I didn’t know the core meaning of the main word?

Okay, beware of tenses here. You wrote 'sat' then used 'is' and I'm left confused to which tense you're writing in.
Unless I'm missing something.

"the stable and distinctive qualities built into an individual's life which determine his or her response regardless of circumstances.

Quotation mark at the end?

Good character is doing the right thing because it is right to do what is right.

I know what you mean here but the choice of words is odd in my opinion. Also, the repetition of 'right' is kind of annoying and hard to read.
Hmmm, something more like...
Having good character is being able to make right choices.
I know that's very simplistic of me but I can't find the right words a this time. If I think of anything better, I'll edit this part later.

So, a good character saves no one else, but you.

Total thumbs up!

~~~


Overall
Okay, I love your essay but as Tam_ara said, it seems short. I was thinking two pages or maybe three but yours seems slightly shorter than both. Anyways, aside from the length, this was better than I thought. You gave some solid quotes and backed it up with thoughts and ideas. Your format was well and your points were clear.

Also, I liked the part where you explained how people do things just to be seen as 'cool' or more favorable in other peoples eyes but when they look in the mirror they see rotting figure of themselves. In all honestly, my mom and I talk about this countless times. See, we also know people like that and we think how they could do such things and live with themselves. Seeing that, I'm sure I'm not the only one who has encountered such people, everyone has. And thus, you writing is sure to connect with a lot of people and dig deep, hopefully letting people come to realization that in order to be not just an all around good person but to have good character is to do the right thing.

As mentioned, I do think your writing lacks in some areas. There were a few sentences that were oddly worded but I think that might just be the language barrier, seeing that you are in India and probably use medium English. I think. But, still, I was able to understand the meaning behind your words and the point you were trying to get across.

Overall, I seriously loved the points you made. I felt like I could relate and connect to a lot of the things you mentioned, making me like this even more. Well, that's all I could point out right now. I wish you luck in the competition!
Much love,

~Pink

P.S. I'm not used to reviewing essays but I tried on this one. Hopefully I helped, although I doubt it. XD
Oh, and also, I think I like the title. Once I read the essay and understood it, I realized that "Character protects life" is actually quite the perfect title for this.
There are three rules for writing a novel. Unfortunately, no one knows what they are.
-W. Somerset Maugham




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 14688
Reviews 193
Hey Shubs, Anger here as requested.

“Character is a diamond which scratches all other diamonds”, were the words echoing in my mind while I sat to write this. But then as something struck me like a pin being pricked-I didn’t know exactly what a character is. What exactly could I write when I didn’t know the core meaning of the main word?
At the point thats in bold, I think you put a little bit too much in. I would have prefer it if you had said 'Something struck me' instead of adding the pin-prick into it, but that's just a suggestion.

One dictionary What dictionary? It might not be needed but it adds a bit to the essay. for example, if you were to put, Oxford dictionary defines character as ....it sounds betterdefines character, as "the complex of mental and ethical traits marking a person." In another dictionary, character is said to be "the stable and distinctive qualities built into an individual's life which determine his or her response regardless of circumstances. As an oblivious teenager, I got gist of the second definition only. My mother always says that regardless of what the situation is, regardless of the tough examination God is taking of yours, you have to choose what is right, choose what you truly believe in- that is the main character aspect, to believe in anything from your heart and going with your heart, rather listening to what the ancestors had left us to follow. Make your own trail.
I think I understand the explanation from the first dictionary better, and I liked the bit where you gave your explanation of what character is. I related to it a lot more.

Many people around me have indulged in activities which are morally not correct, and no matter what those people say about the honesty winning; these people have found their way. But I know that when they get up in the morning and face themselves in the mirror, they can see their skin mottled with patches of disgrace, of cowardice, and the biggest of all what they can see is the coal like blackness hidden in their soul all because they didn’t listen to their heart, they didn’t do what was right, right for the humanity, and right for themselves
I completely disagree with this bit because I believe to that right and wrong are two completely different things to different people. Also at times what humanity thinks is right isn't always what is right for ones self. Sometimes people are dishonest in order to do the right things, and people also do wrong things thinking that its right. I strongly believe in the fact that the understanding in right and wrong differs in each person.

Being a drug addict might seem cool now, but after two three years no one, not the people who had encouraged you onto doing this, or the people who thought you were too cool, would have to suffer, but it would be you. So, a good character saves no one else, but you.
No one chooses to be a drug addict, people who are addicts now never woke up saying 'Oh, I'll just go be a drug addict now.' I think what you're trying to say is that 'doing' drugs might seem cool now.

A character is just like a wall we build all around us, which protects us from the external negative energy.
The 'A' is not needed seeing as you're talking about Character itself.

At last, I would like to leave you with a famous quote by Martin Luther King, Jr., with the same incandescent hope burning in my heart-“I look to a day when people will not be judged by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character.”
The Martin Luther King quote was really the big bang that this essay deserved to go out with. I also hope for that day too.

Sum Up

I enjoyed reading this, and I liked your views on character. This had a great general build-up through it, and I really liked the name of it. I'm sorry that this is going to be a really short review -.-

There were a few mistakes, but they weren't really easy to pick up on, your spelling is fantastic and I couldn't find one spelling mistake in your entire piece. I didn't find this boring at all, I actually found it a bit refreshing. I would love to read more essays from you because you explained yourself perfectly.

Anger :D
Dont tell me the moon is shining, show me the glint of light on broken glass.

Anton Chekov




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 44360
Reviews 1087
Heya Shubhi :)

I'm very sorry that I got to this a bit late... I seem to have gotten here very late because everyone else has given you some seriously awesome reviews. I'm not sure if I'll have much to say at all... I'll try my best though! As you know, non-fiction isn't really something I know much about, so I won't be able to give you the best review ever. Also, don't say that your work is bad because it certainly isn't! You're starting to sound like me... ;) :lol:

But then as something struck me like a pin being pricked-I didn’t know exactly what a character was.

As well as changing the tense, I also italicized this because I thought that it would add a good effect to what you were saying.

One dictionary defines character, as "the complex of mental and ethical traits marking a person." In another dictionary,

I agree with what AM said here. It would be a lot better if you mentioned what dictionary exactly you got these quotes from. ;)

that is the main character aspect; to believe in anything from your heart and going with your heart, rather than listening to what the ancestors had left us to follow.


But I know that when they get up in the morning and face themselves in the mirror, they can see their skin mottled with patches of disgrace, of cowardice, and the biggest of all what they can see is the coal like blackness hidden in their soul all because they didn’t listen to their heart, they didn’t do what was right, right for the humanity, and right for themselves.

This is awfully long to be one sentence. Maybe you should re-edit it so that it's more than one sentence and a bit less daunting to read as one whole, long sentence!

For example, throughout you’ve been a good student and one day, your teacher catches you in a brawl with another student, although it’s not your fault.

I rephrased this a bit so that it sounded a bit easier and nicer to read. :)

But the teacher might not punish you, knowing that you are a good child, and you don’t deviate from your path of doing the right thing.

----- New paragraph here -----

Character is not what we only we can feel and know, but others also know your character and the actual person behind you. A good character would always save you and no matter what, even when once you’re not happy being always right and not doing tempting things, later on you would see for yourself the fruits it bore you.



Overall

This is going to be a short review sorry, Shubhi. There isn't really anything that I want to mention that hasn't been mentioned already by other reviewers. The fact that I was impressed with this pieces also gives me less negative things to say about your essay! That's a good thing though, I suppose. As a whole, I really love how you've dealt with the task you were given for the essay. I think that you described what a character is very well here. One of my favourite things about this piece was actually the quotes that you included in it. I thought that they were seriously effective and certainly appropriate to what you were trying to say. The quotes really supported your points well and the quotes you did find were very good ones too. I especially like how you ended the piece with a quote. When it comes to your grammar and spelling, it was extremely good as usual! Nothing negative to say about that. :)

The only critique I can come up with is that I agree with what some people have said when they said that it was kind of short. You were saying some really good points and I'd love to see you expand on those points and be even more descriptive about them than you already are. I know that you disagree, but you are very good at writing non-fiction, in my opinion. I'm aware that you've got loads of work to do at the moment, so making this longer probably doesn't excite you all that much! To be honest, making this longer isn't completely necessary, but I think that you could make it a bit longer for that extra bit of effect and care. I do think that this piece could be more effective if you lengthen it, mainly because you will have written more and explained those extra bits as well. I completely understand though if you don't want to make this any longer; you do have a lot of work to do at the moment!

I'm really sorry that this is a short review. I don't have anything else to say now, if I'm honest! Like I said before, everyone else who's reviewed this has covered everything and anything that I myself would want to say. All that you really need to do now is to take into consideration what use reviewers have said. Once you've done that, you could maybe consider editing this up a bit; make the essay a little bit longer, maybe? ;) If you do that, I certainly think that you could have an epic essay here, Shubhi! I'm sure that you'll do very well in the competition!

Keep writing and good luck!

xoxo Skins
I didn't know what to put here so I put this.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 17359
Reviews 253
Hey Shubhi! Sorry this took me so long.

You know, one school year, I wrote at least one essay a week for several months, and then about an essay every other day for several more months, and since my entire grade in that class was based only on essays... Suffice it to say that I got pretty darn good with essays, and so that's where I'm coming from.

I agree with the others about this need to be longer, but my main points of critique are that you need more solid, less relative examples. The whole purpose of an essay, after all, is not only to explain your opinion on something but also to defend it (to the death!) using a combination of writing skillz and logical analysis/argument stuff.

Which brings me to my second main point here, which is that after reading this, I still don't know what your thesis was. You danced around it, and, judging by your title, it's something along the lines of "Character Protects Life." Which is a good start, but "Character Protects Life" is vague. You need to state how you define character, and whether life is biological life or spiritual life or emotional life or whatever. I love that you used dictionaries and your mother as sources, but you need to add your opinion about their definitions and opinions.

And, defend it with good, solid examples. This one,

For example, throughout you’ve been a good student and one day your teacher gets you in brawl with another student although it’s not your fault. But the teacher might not punish you, knowing that you are a good child, and you don’t deviate from your path of doing the right thing.


, didn't work for me. It's so speculative. It's a fictional example. You'd do better if you can find a moment in your life or the lives of people you know where good character corresponding to your definition of both character and good character paid off. Real life stories always trump imagined ones when it comes to essays, most of the time. Unless it's a narrative essay.

But, moving on. I don't know how many words or pages you were given for this prompt, but I'd suggest that you define character in your own words, then defend that defintion of character using other authorities and examples. Then, define good character and bad character and defend. And then, defend your position on character. And defend it to the death. You want to prove that you're right.

Unless this is supposed to be a personal essay type thing, in which case you can do less defending and more thoughts on what character means to you and why it means that to you... but... yeah.

Now I'm confusing myself, so I hope I didn't confuse you. Let me know if you have any questions! And sorry again that this took so long for me to reply to.

Rach
I don't fangirl. I fandragon.

Have you thanked a teacher lately? You should. Their bladder control alone is legend.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 58538
Reviews 553
Thanks to all of you, guys. This helped me a lot. I had to submit my report so couldn't take on Skins and Rachael's advice, though they were awesome, as I had submitted it.

Also, to all those who felt it was shot, I had word limit of 750 and it crossed that also, so I had to chop off some parts.

Annyways, thanks to all.

P.S. Tam, your reviews are getting great.
"Next time you point a finger
I might have to bend it back
Or break it, break it off
Next time you point a finger
I'll point you to the mirror"

— Paramore



Someday, everything is going to go right for you, and it will be so wonderful you won't even know what to do.
— Hannelore Ellicott-Chatham, Questionable Content