The Secret of Hidden Gardens (One)

14 posts
User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 8135
Reviews 31
I sat in the small economy seat of the Qantas plane, playing with the model airplane Ben had bought me from the airport’s gift shop, a last minute present. On my lap a small photo album rested, a hundred odd memories bundled into one, tightly bound black book.

Out the tiny plane window was a sky of never ending blue, a colour that made three quarters of the passengers on the aircraft excited that they were going to the unknown. For the rest of us - us being the business travellers, the people returning home and me - it was the colour we wished our moods could be.

One of the flight attendants came round with a trolley, asking passengers if they’d like something to drink.

The man next to me took a can of Fosters from the woman, cracking it open too loudly for my liking. I picked up the water bottle I had on my tray, popping a Panadol into my mouth. My head ached like something chronic, and the smell of beer fumes was not helping.

Resting my head on the back of the seat, I let the classical music from my iPod filter through my ears. It was relaxing, and I could ignore the sounds around me.

In between the palms of my hands was my entire life in photographs. I undid the little black cord that held the leather covers together, turning to the first page.

The first photograph was one of those old Polaroid ones, the type that come out instantly after the shot has been taken.

We were at the beach. He was holding me as I was perched on his shoulders, my blond hair wet from the salty water. I could remember that day, when I was eight. The smell of salt, the squawk of the seagulls as they circled overhead, trying to scavenge remnants of our fish and chips lunch. The way the sand clung to my reddened skin. It was the summer holidays, and we’d gone on a camping trip down south to Margaret River. That was the year I lost my first tooth. The white bottom of the photograph read ‘To my darling Luca’.

I opened my eyes, remembering I was sitting on a plane to England, not on my father’s shoulders. The same emotions I’d been feeling over and over in the last three weeks crashed through me, and I turned my head to the window so the man next to me didn’t see the tears.

There was still at least six hours of the long haul flight to London Heathrow. I’d slept for the first five, then watched half of a bad drama starring Harrison Ford. I was running out of things to do, and patience. Even my book - Jane Austen’s Northanger Abbey, a personal favourite, didn’t interest me.

I flipped through the thick pages until I reached the end of the photo album. The last photo had been glued in carelessly, as if the maker hadn’t had enough time to stick it in properly.

It was the four of us. Our perfect summer, a month before our last year at high school. A month before the accident. Before everything changed. My arms were around Ben’s neck as he held me in his arms. Next to us was Natalie and Sean, copying the same pose. We were at the boat harbour, where we’d spent most of the day, hanging out at the aquarium, where Ben worked.

Everything was different now. It was meant to be summer time, but instead I was heading for winter’s cold touch. I’d never even knew we had relatives that lived in England, but I guessed that was why they called them distant. From my mother’s side, someone I’d never had the chance of knowing. Now I was going to be spending however long in a place unidentifiable even by Google Maps.

And I had no idea what to expect.
I will eviscerate you in fiction. Every pimple, every character flaw. I was naked for a day; you will be naked for eternity.
Chaucer, A Knight's Tale

Deceiving others. That is what the world calls a romance.
Oscar Wilde




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 53415
Reviews 1125
Hey Austen, Stella here!

I. NITPICKS

I sat in the small economy seat of the Qantas plane,


Sitting. What an exciting action to begin with.

it was the colour we wished our moods could be.


She wished she was blue?

Alright.

II. ARC

So, I know this is only a first chapter, but let's take a look at it. She sits. She gets a drink. She has a headache. She looks at photos. It's not really very exciting. She talks about her father then suddenly skips to her friends. What you need is an arc, you need something to begin to hook us. This is only a beginning so I'm not expecting you to have your big climax here. But you should begin building, at least one action or two that has something to do with the story. Right now, it's as if she's waiting for the story to happen herself. And what are we doing? Reading about her wait. And that's not fun.

III. OVERALL

That said, it's written very elegantly and I would definitely not want to put you off.

Hope I helped, drop me a note if you need anything!

-Stella x
"Stella. You were in my dream the other night. And everyone called you Princess." -Lauren2010




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 3793
Reviews 143
Hello, Austenite! Loveless here to review your story. The things in green are removals.

I sat in the small economy seat of the Qantas plane, playing with the model airplane Ben had bought me from the airport’s gift shop, a last minute present. On my lap a small photo album rested, a hundred odd memories bundled into one, tightly bound black book.

Out the tiny plane window was a sky of never ending blue, a colour that made three quarters of the passengers on the aircraft excited that they were going to the unknown. For the rest of us - us being the business travellers, the people returning home, and me - it was the colour we wished our moods could be. Why would you want to be blue? Blue meaning sad in my mind. Maybe you mean blue as in happy... I don't know.


It was the summer holidays, and we’d gone on a camping trip down south to Margaret River.


There was still at least six hours of the long haul flight to London, Heathrow.


Next to us was were Natalie and Sean, copying the same pose. We were at the boat harbour, where we’d spent most of the day, hanging out at the aquarium, where Ben worked.


This was very well written, I enjoyed reading it. There is not really a lot going on in this chapter, but I won't make a fuss about it since this is the very first chapter.

I don't know many things about what's going on. I know there was an accident and I'm guessing that the parents of this Luca character probably died, or something along those lines. I know she has Ben who is probably a boyfriend. She's on a plane going to England to live with some family member. Am I on the right path here?

This has the potential to be something really great and I'll be sure to tune into the next chapter.

Loveless~
LoVeLeSs I review short stories and novels.

Always remember that you’re unique. Just like everyone else.

The early bird may get the worm, but the second mouse gets the cheese.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 10397
Reviews 93
Hey austenite!
Since the other reviewers have already touched upon most of the things I would, it will be a quick review here.

You are talented in writing :) but unfortunately this chapter doesn't showcase (what I believe) is the best of your abilities! It's a plain chapter, nothing interesting happens. I can't really connect to the main character because everything she does is mysterious. Your first chapter has to capture readers, that way they read the next chapter! I'm sure if you explain the photographs in more detail you can give the readers a connection to the main character and make them want to read more.

Good luck! PM me with any questions!
-SodapopLunchbox
I hope you like the stars I stole for you,
One hundred million twinkle lights in neon blue.
I'll be the brightest,
You'll see!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6453
Reviews 28
Hey there :) I'm Eddie, and this is my first review of Review Day, aren't you lucky!

Red - Mistakes
Green - Corrections
Purple - Bits I Liked
Pink - Suggestions

austenite wrote:I sat in the small economy seat of the Qantas plane,

Have to agree with Stella here, the fact that she's sitting down put me off right away. You could go back a little bit and write about her thoughts whilst she was boarding the plane, just a suggestion. At least then something would be happening.

playing with the model airplane Ben had bought me from the airport’s gift shop, a last minute present. On my lap a small photo album rested, a hundred odd memories bundled into one, tightly bound black book.

Out the tiny plane window was a sky of never ending blue, a colour that made three quarters of the passengers on the aircraft excited that they were going to the unknown. For the rest of us - us being the business travellers, the people returning home and me - it was the colour we wished our moods could be.

I know a lot of other people have picked on this line, but to me it doesn't make a lot of sense. I'm sensing that your MC isn't all that pleased about flying to England, so I understand the reference to the blue sky being like her blue (sad) mood, I'd suggest re-thinking this and re-wording it slightly so that it isn't as confusing.

One of the flight attendants came round with a trolley, asking passengers if they’d like something to drink.

Seems a little obvious to me.

The man next to me took a can of Fosters from the woman, cracking it open too loudly for my liking. I picked up the water bottle I had on my tray, popping a Panadol into my mouth. My head ached like something chronic, and the smell of beer fumes was not helping.

Resting my head on the back of the seat, I let the classical music from my iPod filter through my ears. It was relaxing, and I could ignore the sounds around me.

In between the palms of my hands was my entire life in photographs. I undid the little black cord that held the leather covers together, turning to the first page.

The first photograph was one of those old Polaroid ones, the type that come out instantly after the shot has been taken.

We were at the beach. He was holding me as I was perched on his shoulders, my blond hair wet from the salty water. I could remember that day, when I was eight. The smell of salt, the squawk of the seagulls as they circled overhead, trying to scavenge remnants of our fish and chips lunch. The way the sand clung to my reddened skin. It was the summer holidays, and we’d gone on a camping trip down south to Margaret River. That was the year I lost my first tooth. The white bottom of the photograph read ‘To my darling Luca’. (This part should be in italics)

That's a very nice flashback there, it paints a pretty image - well done.

I opened my eyes, remembering I was sitting on a plane to England, not on my father’s shoulders. The same emotions I’d been feeling over and over in the last three weeks crashed through me, and I turned my head to the window so the man next to me didn’t see the tears.

You have some really lovely and subtle little sentences and gestures in here, so simple yet so effective.

There was still at least six hours of the long haul flight to London Heathrow. I’d slept for the first five, then watched half of a bad drama starring Harrison Ford. I was running out of things to do, and patience. Even my book - Jane Austen’s Northanger Abbey,hyphen a personal favourite,hyphen didn’t interest me.

I flipped through the thick pages until I reached the end of the photo album. The last photo had been glued in carelessly, as if the maker hadn’t had enough time to stick it in properly. (This makes me wonder just exactly who made this photo album.)

It was the four of us. Our perfect summer, a month before our last year at high school. A month before the accident. Before everything changed. My arms were around Ben’s neck as he held me in his arms. Next to us was/were Natalie and Sean, copying the same pose. We were at the boat harbour, where we’d spent most of the day, hanging out at the aquarium, where Ben worked.

There's a slight overuse of commas in that sentence, and I have the exact same problem. Some of them aren't needed.

Everything was different now. It was meant to be summer time, but instead I was heading for winter’s cold touch. I’d never even knew we had relatives that lived in England, but I guessed that was why they called them distant. From my mMother’s side, someone I’d never had the chance of knowing. Now I was going to be spending however long in a place unidentifiable even by Google Maps.

And I had no idea what to expect.[/

Very nice ending line, instantly makes you wonder. However that being said I wasn't sure why she was worrying so much, to me it seemed like a simple flight to another country, nothing much to worry about. If there is some kind of danger on the other side, add in a few more hints that she has things to worry about - just a suggestion.

Overall this was a pretty beautifully written piece, I saw next to no mistakes or typos, so good job for that. I was engaged almost instantly, although again I have to agree with Stella. Not much happens, which was a shame because it is such a well written piece. Your descriptions and flashbacks are lovely, you just need to think about what the aim of this paragraph is about.

Hope this helped!

xo
"If you want to be a writer, you must do two things above all others: read a lot and write a lot. There's no way around these two things that I'm aware of, no shortcut." - Stephen King.

EDDiE. :]

Want an honest review?
topic67916.html




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 42011
Reviews 922
Seems most of the nitpicks have been pretty well-explored, so I'll stick with general impressions.

1) Character - Your character feels very... blah. All we know about her is that she is going to live with distant relatives and doesn't seem to excited about it. Why not? What is the situation that is making her live overseas? How does she actually feel about this? I get a sense of melancholy from the piece, but I don't know if that's actually how the character feels, since we don't get much from her beyond the "blue" line that everyone's already talked about. Is she resigned to this fate? Is she angry? Is she scared? Does she care at all? Not to say that you should bury us in her wangst, but a little more clarity would help us connect to the character. Right now, we are so distanced from her, not knowing anything about her, that it's hard to connect to her and care for her.

2) Story - It's already been said, but nothing much happens in this chapter. I enjoyed reading it all the way through, but by the end, I was like "and then what?" Beyond a little mystery at the end, there's nothing to hook a reader. Sure, they might keep reading to find out what happens next and to enjoy the lovely writing, but there's really no action going on. You don't need to put in a car chase, but something happening might be nice. You've started the story before the story actually kicks off and now we're just waiting for the story to catch up.

3) Brand Names - This is pretty minor and probably mostly a personal nitpick, but you included a few specific brand names in the story, some quite unnecessarily. Sometimes brand names are nice, adding a bit of concreteness to something, but other times, they just sort of stick out like a sore thumb. Why write "Fosters"? Why not write "beer"? I didn't even know what a Fosters was until a few lines down when you mention the smell of beer. Is the brand name so important? All it did was confuse me at first. Same thing with Panadol. Why not just "pain reliever" or "asprin"? Is the brand name really important? I mean, if a character has a particular quirk where they will only ever buy one brand of something, maybe then it could be pointed out, but usually, just the generic name of the product is fine.

Polaroid was the exception, since Polaroid is one of those brand names that people apply to everything (like Kleenex for tissues) and you were using it to be really specific as to what kind of photograph it was. Here, the specific brand name can be really helpful.

4) Overall - I really liked the writing in this. It was simple and elegant and fun to read. It's just sort of waiting. Is it really necessary to have this taking place on the plane? It couldn't happen in a taxi on the way to the relatives' house? These thoughts couldn't take place after she's run into them at the airport and she sitting alone in her room later? Like I said, it's beautifully written and the photographs and thoughts with them are lovely, but without something to ground us and make us care about what's going on, it just feels like a strange scene of not even anticipation. More like just flipping through a book of photos rather nostalgically. There's no real connection to the fact that she's leaving. I mean, we get something like this
The same emotions I’d been feeling over and over in the last three weeks crashed through me

but what exactly is that emotion? Fear? Anger? Sorrow? All of those could cause tears. Dive into the connection to the photos a bit more and it would make the impact greater.

All in all though, I did really like this. I would love to see where it goes.

~GryphonFledgling
I am reminded of the babe by you.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 44360
Reviews 1087
Heya austenite :D

It's reviewing day, so yeah... I'm here to review. You've already gotten some nice reviews, so I'll try not to repeat anything that's already been said unless I think that it's really necessary. I'll start off with any nit-picks r grammatical errors that I find, and then move on to my overall opinion.

I sat in the small economy seat of the Qantas plane, playing with the model airplane Ben had bought me from the airport’s gift shop, a last minute present. On my lap, a small photo album rested, a hundred odd memories bundled into one, tightly bound black book.

My main issue with this as an opening paragraph is the fact that it's rather boring. The first few lines of a novel are very important because they're what draws the reader in. Like the other reviewers have said, you need to make this more interesting instead of just saying that your MC was simply sat in a plane.

Out the tiny plane window was a sky of never ending blue, a colour that made three quarters of the passengers on the aircraft excited that they were going into the unknown.


One of the flight attendants came around with a trolley, asking passengers if they’d like something to drink.

It sounds like you're saying that the flight attendants were round or something. You should either put an "a" in front of the word "round" or put an apostrophe there.

The first photograph was one of those old Polaroid ones, the type that came out instantly after the shot had been taken.

Tenses. ;)

We were at the beach. He was holding me as I was perched on his shoulders, my blond hair wet from the salty water. I could remember that day, when I was eight. The smell of salt, the squawk of the seagulls as they circled overhead, trying to scavenge remnants of our fish and chips lunch. The way the sand clung to my reddened skin.

Some nice imagery here, well done.

It was the summer holidays, and we’d gone on a camping trip down south to Margaret River. That was the year I lost my first tooth. The white bottom of the photograph read ‘To my darling[color=#FF0000], Luca’.[/color]

I don't really like the way you've jumped from describing a memory to describing the photograph itself. It seems a bit sudden to me. Instead of simply saying, The white bottom of the photograph read ‘To my darling, Luca', try not to make it so sudden. Say something like, As the memories flooded my brain, my eyes were drawn to the white bottom of the photograph that read 'To my darling, Luca.' Although it's not that different, it flows a lot nicer. :)

I opened my eyes, remembering I was sitting on a plane to England, not on my father’s shoulders.

If her eyes were open, how did she read the note at the bottom of the photograph?

There was still at least six hours of the long haul flight to Heathrow Airport, London

This sounded better like this and it was easier to understand.

We were at the boat harbour, where we’d spent most of the day, hanging out at the aquarium, where Ben worked.

You don't need the comma that I highlighted here.

It was meant to be summer time, but instead, I was heading for winter’s cold touch.


I’d never even knew we had relatives that lived in England, but I guessed that was why they called them distant.


Now I was going to be spending however long in a place that was even unidentifiable by Google Maps.

This sentence sounded a bit awkward to me, although it might just be me being paranoid. :lol: I did rephrase it though so it sounded a bit better.

And I had no idea what to expect.

As a whole, I don't really like sentences that start with "And", but this one didn't actually bother me really.


Overall
This was pretty good! There were some areas that I especially liked, a lot of them being your descriptions. One thing that you did which I liked was showing and not telling. You have some really nice descriptions in this, especially in some of your flashbacks. One of the good things about your descriptions was the fact that they didn't take over the entire piece. You had a really good balance of descriptions and actions. In my opinion, that is always important in a piece of creative writing. I really liked the flashbacks in this, as well. They showed that your MC really loved those memories while she was living them and that she obviously missed them. You also create a rather sombre mood throughout the chapter, which is a very good thing because you set the atmosphere right at the beginning of the novel. I do have to agree with some of the other reviewers though when they said that it was rather uneventful and boring at times. Not much happened in this, did it? I understand that you wanted to create some mystery, but it kind of felt like you had a bit too much mystery in this piece of writing. When it comes to your spelling though, I didn't find any spelling errors. I did find a few grammatical errors but as a whole, your grammar is certainly good. :)

The mystery in this would probably have to be my main critique, to be honest. It's a good thing that you have mystery in the first chapter of a novel, but you have to be careful that you don't have too much of it. Mystery is one of the things that draws the reader in, but if you use too much of it, it can begin to confuse the reader and wonder what is going on. The only thing that we know is that Luca is going to live with relatives in England. We don't know where she's originally from, how old she is, why she's moving to England, what happened to her parents, what she looks like and lots more. I'm not saying that you should tell us these things straight, but I do think that you should at least hint a few things. I gathered that Luca's parents were dead, but I also thought that her boyfriend was dead because of the way Luca was describing him. Maybe he is dead, I don't know, but I kind of got that feeling. That's the problem though, I don't know. He could be dead, but then again, he might not be. What I'm basically saying is that I'm slightly confused. Mystery is a good thing, but confusion isn't. :lol: I don't want you to tell me Luca's life story, I just want you to clear some things up a bit.

My only other negative comment is the fact that not an awful lot happens in this. Luca is on a plane and then she looks at photos. That's basically it. Now, I don't want you to make the plane burst into flames and crash land or anything like that, but I would like to see a bit more happening. Maybe you could mention your MC boarding the plane or something? That would be a good way of letting us readers know a bit more about what is going on. The first chapter of a novel is very important. If the first chapter isn't effective and doesn't draw the reader in, then there is less of a chance that the reader will want to continue reading on. You have to make the first chapter exciting and make us readers want to know what happens next. You have done the last one pretty well, but you haven't made it as exciting as it could be. What I'm basically saying is that there isn't much going on. Thankfully, because you're descriptions and flashbacks are good, it isn't as noticeable as it could be. I would like to see you expanding things a bit though. You could describe Luca reaching England as well as boarding the plane to England.

Although I did find negatives, there was also some really good positives. Like I've already said, your descriptions are very nice and you have created some nice, effective flashbacks. Your grammar was really good and so was your spelling. All that you really need to do now is to take into consideration what us reviewers have said. Once you do that, you should maybe edit this up a bit. If you do that, you could have a really great piece of writing here.

Keep writing,

xoxo Rhian
I didn't know what to put here so I put this.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1040
Reviews 3
I just want to say that the whole secret garden, heavy key thing has been done before. Haven't you ever heard of The Secret Garden? It's both a movie and a book.




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 8135
Reviews 31
MyStoryline wrote:I just want to say that the whole secret garden, heavy key thing has been done before. Haven't you ever heard of The Secret Garden? It's both a movie and a book.


Yes, I have heard of the Secret Garden, thank you very much. I've only just finished reading the book, that's what has inspired this. Have you heard of if you don't have something nice to say, don't say it at all? I think that your comment was something extremely harsh to say. Have you heard of the book The Forgotten Garden? You've read what, 600 odd words of a beginning of a story and automatically have a biased opinion on it. Just remember that before you start reading works - everything will remind you of another book that you've read before, so it doesn't do well to be so judgemental.

To everyone else - thank you. Your critiques make me stronger as a writer. As we speak, I am completely re-writing this chapter, because I hate it, and I'm glad many others did not like parts of it as well!!! The end result, I hope, will be something better. Watch this space!
I will eviscerate you in fiction. Every pimple, every character flaw. I was naked for a day; you will be naked for eternity.
Chaucer, A Knight's Tale

Deceiving others. That is what the world calls a romance.
Oscar Wilde




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6915
Reviews 115
First of all, I absolutely love the opening, you do a great job at setting the scene. However, the beginning drags on a little bit before getting to "the good stuff" which in this case is the photo album because I can see that that will be significant.

and the smell of beer fumes was not helping

Maybe take out "smell of" because it seems a little redundant to me.

My arms were around Ben’s neck as he held me in his arms

Arms is repetitive, if you take out the second one it will still be clear.

Next to us was Natalie and Sean

Were instead of was because they are plural.

hanging out at the aquarium, where Ben worked

I'm pretty sure you don't need the comma there, plus having that many commas makes the sentence seem choppy.

It was meant to be summer time, but instead I was heading for winter’s cold touch

I think you could say "it was summer time" there, instead of "meant to be" because it still is summer only it will be cold, you know?

Overall, I really like this piece, you do a great job setting up the story and leaving enough cliffhangers (such as what happened to the teenagers and her father) to hook the reader. One nitpick is to introduce the main character a little more, because at this point you know absolutely nothing about her, not even where she is coming from. As I said, it drags a little bit in the beginning but I like your description. Lastly, your title is very intriguing and I like that.
"One sees clearly only with the heart. Anything essential is invisible to the eyes."
The Little Prince




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1493
Reviews 25
Well, I like this. But I think you need to describe your character a little more. It took me a while to figure out if it was a boy or girl (I'm still not sure, it's a girl, right?) And describe what she looks like.

That's about it for me. I'm not very good at grammar so I can't help you there. And, besides, I think it's really good.

~Dragonet~
I'm a JESUS FREAK!!!

Do you have any idea why a raven is like a writing desk?




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 314
Reviews 63
I would write every little thing I found wrong in this, just because that's how I am, but it seems as if everyone else has done it for me! I'd like to say that I thought this was a good start to the book, but it could be a bit more exciting, like Stella Thomas said in the first review. And, if I can say, I just loved how you handled MyStoryline. I just absolutely hate when people judge your book from the first chapter, as if they know right away what it's about, like they can tell something just from it's description! Just know that we're all with you.

Hope I could help some, I'll be following. PM me for anything.

-iheartbooks

PS: Jane Austen is pretty cool, I haven't read Northanger Abbey yet, but it's on my list of books to read.
"As the hungry are deprived of food, I am deprived of sympathy for those who deprive me of my sanity." ~Anonymous




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 8135
Reviews 31
Thanks!! As I said, I actually really hate this start, so I'm completely reworking it, and you'll all be the first to know when it comes up!
I will eviscerate you in fiction. Every pimple, every character flaw. I was naked for a day; you will be naked for eternity.
Chaucer, A Knight's Tale

Deceiving others. That is what the world calls a romance.
Oscar Wilde




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1184
Reviews 8
Personally, I really liked this beginning, the whole thing, sure there were a few confusing parts, and some grammatical errors, but i still think it was really good, and understood pretty much everything. I could understand that the passengers wished their moods were like the blue sky, bright and cheery blue, not the sad and lonesome blue. If it were me, I would keep your original, and continue playing with it. Don't just completely re-write it. I liked it. It was really awesome. I would love to read the rest of it.
Love is poison. Ink is lethal.



If all pulled in one direction, the world would keel over.
— Yiddish proverb