Smile, Child: Feedback Appreciated

6 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1344
Reviews 1
Children are supposed to be happy, but that wasn't the case for me. I was a solemn little girl with no time for the frivolities and social activities other children enjoyed. No, I was a quiet, angsty little thing. It wasn't because I had a bad life. I didn't. My grandparents, the ones I lived with, loved me. My aunt bought me whatever I wanted and I got along fairly well with my sister.

But still, I was a dark thing. Maybe I was lonely. I never really had friends. Only one, Brittany. She was a solemn little girl, too, but mostly she was just skittish and anxious. That's probably why we got along so well. I liked to make decisions for her in my unassuming way. It made me feel important to have control over her.

I always hated it when people told me to smile, especially at church. When my Grandma used to make me go, anyway. I don't anymore.

They would peek at me, as I hide behind Granny's best Sunday dress skirts, and I stared at thim. I think I scared them, because I never looked away. I always eyed them with wide, unassuming green eyes that never blinked.

Finally, they would attempt to talk to me. My Grandma would push me towards the person. They would ask questions. Sometimes I'd answer. Sometimes I wouldn't, and then, before they left, they would always give me a little grin that was supposed to be encouraging, but I always thought those grins looked creepy, uninhabited. Forced.

Then, they would say clearly, right before leaving, "Smile, child!" And when they noticed I wasn't going to, they left, a bit put out. I always thought they'd get over it.

My Grandma would be angry with me ('Oh, Tayah, what will they think of us raising you that way?') but I never paid any mind to her anger. She was a very hot-headed woman who liked to scold and nag just because.

I wasn't a happy child. Maybe my life wasn't so great. I distinctly remember my Memaw telling me at my mother's funeral, "You'll never see her again Tayah. Never ever!" And I remember her having to be pried off of my mother's casket.

In fact, I remember that day with stunning clarity. Some people think that you remember the good days, much more than you ever remember the bad days. I disagree. One of my best days was when I was in Florida with my family, but I can't even remember what month we went in. I can still remember what I wore to my mother's funeral. A black skirt with big, dark roses and a matching skirt. I still have it somewhere, I think.

Maybe all children aren't meant to be happy. I think I understand that now. Maybe some children are meant to grow up jaded, broken, and most importantly, without a smile on their plain little face.

'Will you smile for me, Tayah?'
__
A semi-autobiographical piece.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 28282
Reviews 884
Well I kind of wish this ended a little more positively, or at least reflected a glimmer of positivity, but maybe that's just the blindly-optimistic side of me speaking. It seemed like a depressing point though: children aren't usually able to be happy? Life is cruel? There's no reason to smile? Ouch. I think I'm going to go to my little hidy-hole and wail with the wolves 'til I'm feeling a little better. Anyway, I would have liked to see in the end a more positive spin on things, I'm not a fan of pessimistic personalities, but it was well-written and I give you props for that.
Keep writing,
StoryWeaver
Reading is one form of escape. Running for your life is another. ~Lemony Snicket




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 10397
Reviews 93
Hello antoinette!
Your story is good, my favorite part was when you said:
In fact, I remember that day with stunning clarity. Some people think that you remember the good days, much more than you ever remember the bad days. I disagree.

I couldn't agree with that statement more. Not to get too personal here, but I had a bad childhood, so I could relate to this story a bit. With that being said, I think you could use more emotion in this. Make other people feel the main character's angst and loneliness!
Also, on a grammatical note, make sure you remember what tense you're in! In the beginning, it was past tense, but I saw present tense scattered through the story as well. You should always stay in one tense while writing. Another grammatical nitpick is the short sentences. Sometimes short sentences can be okay, but here they shouldn't be used, because it just sounds awkward. A few examples?
But still, I was a dark thing. Maybe I was lonely. I never really had friends. Only one, Brittany.

I always hated it when people told me to smile, especially at church. When my Grandma used to make me go, anyway. I don't anymore.

Try conjoining some sentences, the reading will flow much better.
&Thats all I have to say!

-SodapopLunchbox
I hope you like the stars I stole for you,
One hundred million twinkle lights in neon blue.
I'll be the brightest,
You'll see!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1344
Reviews 1
Thanks, both of you!

StoryWeaver13: This was never meant to be a completely happy-go-lucky piece. I wanted to explore the rougher side of childhood, yet still weave parts of my own in. Hm? :) Thanks for the feedback.

sodapoplunchbox: I'm glad you liked that line - it was one of my favourites as well. I enjoy writing in present tense a lot, and when I don't I scatter them in my stories anyway. /: I need to work on that, haha. Thank you for the feedback!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2608
Reviews 86
Hello! (Mistakes are in Blue.)
I really REALLY like, no LOVE, this piece of work. It was well written and i liked how you ended it. Only a few small mistakes i picked up on.

...as I hide behind Granny's best Sunday dress skirts, and I stared at thim.

Was it ment to be them?

A black skirt with big, dark roses and a matching skirt.

Is this ment to be, "A black skirt with big, dark roses and a matching shirt.." OR "A black shirt with big, dark roses and a matching skirt. ??

I've only pulled up little things, but everything helps when you're trying to get your story to the best it can be.
Great story!
Born
xx
:D




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1344
Reviews 1
Thanks borntoshop! No, those where not supposed to be there, I just didn't catch them. I'll edit. Thank you again!



What really knocks me out is a book that, when you're all done reading it, you wish the author that wrote it was a terrific friend of yours and you could call him up on the phone whenever you felt like it. That doesn't happen much, though.
— J.D. Salinger, The Catcher in the Rye