is this a good start?

6 posts
Random avatar
Gender None specified
Points 300
Reviews 0
raven stared helplessly out of the classroom window, she wanted class to be over so she could go home and start her part-time job.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1157
Reviews 6
Hi, Review time!!
Okay - to be honest with you: its not bad, but its really not great. A story beginning should grip you, not bore you.
raven stared helplessly out of the classroom window,

Okay, this bit is quite good. It makes you wonder and question about whats happening.
she wanted class to be over so she could go home and start her part-time job.

Now this is the bit which lets you down. You slightly kill the wonder you provoked in the first part of the scentence. Also its a bit confusing - go home and start her part time job - What, is her job at home?
Maybe think about putting something more into it. Bulk it out a bit.


How about:
"Raven stared helplessly out of the classroom window. She desperately wanted to get out. If Mr Wilson said anything more about trigonometry she thought that she might scream. The only thing in her head was to get out of that classroom, and get to the part time job that she was so desperate to start."
I dunno if you like that - keep it if you do, but if you dont leave it :D
Its a good start, and what looks like a good idea - you just need to bulk it out a bit. Remember that writing should never be rushed.
Take Care
If you want anything else reveiwed PM me
Theres noone better to write for young people than young people...




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 10262
Reviews 77
I think that it is interesting, but the first sentence of a story isn't what draws me in, but the first paragraph draws me in. I like the name Raven, but you may want to capitolize it in your next editing.

Now then, I get that she wants to go "home and start her part-time job," because she wants to be able to go relax and then go to her job. But, if she is in school, you could probably guess that it is part-time. You could say that she couldn't wait to go to her waitressing job at... Applebee's, or maybe that she wanted to go flip the burgers at Mcdonald's.

Also, your sentence is a comma splice. And you need a capital at the beginning of your setence. Sorry.
Courage doesn't always roar. Sometimes courage is the quiet voice at the end of the day saying, "I will try again tomorrow"
-mary anne radmacher




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 3121
Reviews 108
Hey!

Well, you didn't really give us much to work with, so I can't really tell where you're going with this. It was interesting, but a tad bit too short. Flesh it out more! I'd suggest posting the first paragraph the next time you ask about your beginning.

rRaven stared helplessly out of the classroom window (Do a semi colon or a period instead of a comma) she wanted class to be over so she could go home and start her part-time job.


I pointed out a few grammatical errors, but it's nothing much.

I am a bit confused though. Is her part-time job at home, or does she want to go home, then go to her part-time job? Clear that up, please.

raven stared helplessly out of the classroom window


Now, as Kate said, this is a great beginning. We get a good mental picture of Raven, and we wonder what's happening. But...

she wanted class to be over so she could go home and start her part-time job.


This is a let down. You've already answered all of our questions in the first sentence! What else will we have to look forward to as we continue reading?

It's a good start, but you really need to flesh it out more. Have fun spinning your story, and I can't wait to read more!

~blu
Help! I can't remember if I'm the evil twin or the good one!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 3223
Reviews 86
This seems flat and honestly there could be a bit more here to work with. The person above me also has already said what is on my mind. When some one is reading a story they like to have a little mystery there that drives them to keep reading and find out why Raven wants to get out of school so badly. And then maybe what her part time job is and why she wants to get to work in such a hurry. There could be a bit more "meat" on the bones of this story so that we can see if the story will be a decent one. Maybe you could include the first paragraph to work with instead. And if this sentence was written with detail and depth and emotion then it could be a paragraph. Just add more depth here and it could be a decent story.
Living in a tower




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 5448
Reviews 56
This is Hero, here to review a bit.

To be honest, I didn't really like it. Its a sentence that tells too much, as Kate.Grace already said, but that's not really what I really disliked.
I just feel *headdesk* when there's a character called something like 'Raven' or 'Lemura' or 'Seyella' or anything fantasyesque; I tend to like to think of it as 'naming my own kids'.
First off, naming a character does not mean look for the most odd and crazy thing that suits the character to the bat. Seriously, I can almost guess what happens in the story, or at least, her character, and... well... yeah.
Personally, I would change the name, and then maybe give her a little less of the 'I hate school!' image of teenager. I just roll my eyes reading it; yes, no teen wants to be in school, but why does she want to go her job? If I had the choice of a job and going home to sit in front of computer trying to rack my brains, I would go for the latter.

So, yeah. Change the character a bit, and maybe we have a good beginning.
This guy is so evil you could put him in between two slices of bread and call him an evil sandwich.

Coming at you like a jetpack Shakespeare.

Hero's Reviews
http://www.youngwriterssociety.com/topic53905.html



The simple truth is that authors like making people squirm. If this weren't the case, all novels would be filled completely with cute bunnies having birthday parties.
— Brandon Sanderson, Alcatraz Versus the Evil Librarians