Leather and Lace - Chapter One

9 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 16
Hello there! I haven't posted something in a while. Anyway, this is my most recent project and I'm looking for some good constructive criticism. This actually isn't the full first chapter, but I had to split it in half because it was too long. Anyway, here is the first part. Please let me know how I can make it better!

***

Chapter One

I stare up at the blue-haired boy standing on the porch. He doesn’t look familiar at all, and most people who visit House I either know personally or have seen before. Blue-Haired Guy doesn’t fall into either of these categories. He’s looking down at me with a blank expression on his face, a short white stick hanging out between his closed lips. He’s moving it around too much that I can’t tell if it’s a cigarette or not.

“Well hey, kiddo,” he says around the white stick, his speech only slightly muddled. “Are there any adults here?”

Well there goes any chance we had at having a nice relationship. I glare at him.

“I am not a ‘kiddo,’” I retort.

He blinks.

“Right. You’re what, 9 or 10? You’re a big girl now?” he questions, though it sounds more like a practiced statement.

“I’m seventeen,” I say, straightening up and sticking out my chin in an effort to look my age. “And what are you, a person I have never seen before in my life, doing on this porch?”

As he looks me up and down once with dark brown eyes which are somehow cold, his expression doesn’t change and it takes a moment before he speaks.

“Is Lex Charrimore here?”

“Is he expecting you?” I frown as I say this. Lex didn’t say anything about a visitor today.

“Mm, no.” Blue-Haired Guy turns the white stick over in his mouth twice. “But I’ve something to show him.”

I study the guy for a moment. With the way he so rudely assumed my age based on my appearance I should bop him on the head and send him away. But, if Lex found out, which he probably would, he would scold me and I wouldn’t be allowed to have peanut butter cookies for a week. And we cannot have that. So, after another silent moment to build up the suspense even though Blue-Haired Guy doesn’t seem to be affected at all, I sigh.

“Fine, come on. Don’t touch anything.” I nod my head, signaling for him to come in. I step back to let him in, but instead of coming in right away, he let out a low whistle to something or someone near him. A boy maybe around my age with shaggy brown hair emerges, hands clasped behind his back, smiling sheepishly at me. I watch him as he enters the house with Blue-Haired Guy behind him. I shut the door. “This way.”

I lead the two boys out of the foyer and down the hall to the basement door, occasionally glancing back to make sure the boys aren’t trying anything. I stop when we get to the basement door and turn to face them, my eyes trained mostly on the cute brown-haired boy.

“We are about to go downstairs where Lex’s study is. Only certain people are allowed in. If either of you are just playing a joke or trying to steal something or… just up to anything bad, then…” I smirk. “Pray that Lex has mercy on you.” They stare at me. “As Lex’s second assistant, I’m required to say that to anyone besides House’s tenants.”

“Second assistant?” The boy with the brown hair speaks for the first time, his grey eyes wide. “You’re… a child.”

I nearly growl. Twice in one day?

“I am not a child. I am seventeen years old. Look!” I point to my chest. “I have boobs!”

The boy with the brown hair blushes and looks away. Blue-Haired Guy, however, examines my only-slightly-noticeable bust and raises an eyebrow.

“If you say so,” he says finally, looking past me at the basement door.

I shoot him an evil look that he doesn’t notice, and then open the door and lead the way down the dimly lit stairs. We have to walk through the lounge area in order to reach the study. No one is down here, as per usual for the morning hours, and I’m relieved. I don’t exactly feel like dealing with the others at the moment.

I open Lex’s office door without knocking. He is sitting at his desk, the only light coming from one dying floorlamp, and is busy writing something. I can tell it’s important by the way he is slouching down and holding his forehead like he has a headache. He jumps in his seat when I flick on the overhead light. He squints at us, lingering in the doorway.

“Div?” he questions as he runs a hand through his messy cinnamon-colored hair. “Who are these people?”

“I don’t know,” I answer before I can remind myself that that’s probably not the answer Lex wants to hear. “I-I mean… they said they have something important to show you.”

Lex watches warily as Blue-Haired Guy claps his hand on the other boy’s back and pushes him forward.

“My name is Tuesday,” Blue-Haired Guy says. “I happened to find this poor one at the Fountain Portal and was told to bring him to you. Many people around here know of your work with poor ones.”

Lex purses his lips and narrows his green eyes. “So they do. What is this boy’s name?”

“Uh-“ the other boy begins after Tuesday gives him a look. “My name is Rory. I’m from… I’m from Colorado and-“

“You’re wondering where you are?” Lex guesses.

Rory nods.

“Welcome to Dream,” Lex says, his tone anything but welcoming.

Recently I’ve noticed how different Lex greets newcomers from when he first greeted me. Of course, I arrived when I was young and there was probably some law about being nice to little kids, and most of the people who arrived now are older. But his greetings seem so cold. Lex is not a cold person in the slightest; in fact, he is the closest person I have to a father figure here. But anyone now who is meeting him for the first time would never guess that. And it makes me sad. Sometimes I wonder if it’s because he’s aging and is learning more about how to deal with poor ones. He was in his mid-twenties when I came here, having only recently started House. Now, in his thirties, it seems like the life is slowly being sucked out of him.

“Dream?” Rory echoes. “So you mean I’m dreaming?”

“No, no.” Lex sighs and laces his fingers together in front of his lips. “You are somewhere other than your world. An alternate world, if you will. Dream is a world that makes you feel as if you’re in a dream.”

“It’s like Alice in Wonderland or The Wizard of Oz,” I add in. Lex shoots me with a brief grin.

“Divinity is right,” he says. “It’s almost as if you’re in a storybook.”

“So… I’m not on Earth anymore?” Rory asks, his voice uneven. I wonder if he’s going to cry. People have done that before.

“Technically, you are, seeing as in this dimension it is the same planet. But if you mean are you in the same world as your friends and family, then no. This isn’t some place that you can just take a bus ride back home. Oh, no.” Lex smiles, showing perfect white teeth that, if you look close enough, emanate light. “If you want to return, it’s a much bigger deal than that.”

“Well what are my family and friends doing right now? You mean I’ve just disappeared from where I was before?” Rory’s voice is quivering with tears so I position myself near the end table in case I need to make a quick grab for the tissues.

“To your friends it’ll appear as if you just excused yourself to go somewhere else,” Lex explains.

“My parents? My sisters?” Rory presses.

“They’re not even thinking about you. It’s as if thoughts of you have been erased from their minds.” The way Lex puts it sounds so horrible. He certainly didn’t say it that way when I first came. He told me my parents were being assured that I was safe and would be away for a while. Until recently I haven’t given any thought to that, but after hearing what Lex tells others about their families, I sometimes wonder if my parents are ever thinking of me, their only daughter.

A sniffle comes from the doorway. I look up to see two tears running silently down Rory’s tan cheek. Nearly knocking over the end table with my swiftness, I grab the box of tissues and go to hand it to him. He doesn’t seem to notice me, however, and instead wipes at his eyes with the sleeve of his black sweatshirt.

“So I’m gone? Gone from my home? I can’t go back?” His breathing is heavy.

“You can go back,” Lex says. “But it’ll take work.”

“I’ll do it,” Rory says without any hesitation at all, as if he didn’t even think about his answer before saying it. My mouth drops open as I stare at him.

Lex looks Rory over as if sizing him up. Finding myself feeling sorry for this boy in front of me, I almost reach out for him, but just as soon as the thought comes, I pin my arm to my side, wondering what in the world I was doing.

“That’s a big decision,” Lex says casually. “Are you sure about this?”

“Sure as I’ve ever been of anything in my life,” Rory replies. “I have a future back home. I have a family, I have friends, I have college applications to turn in, I have Calculus to pass, I have a girlfriend I’m planning on proposing to next summer, I have a dog to take to the vet… I can’t leave it all. I’m not going to throw away everything I’ve worked so hard to get.” His voice is hard, determined, sure, reminding me of the heroes in movies who make long speeches about goodness before defeating the villain. I then decide: I admire this boy. I admire his strong will and his scruples. I admire his strength to stop his tears.

“Well, then.” Lex grins again. “Looks like you’re going to have to go on a Pilgrimage.”

*

Lex sends me upstairs to show Tuesday out as he discusses the Pilgrimage with Rory. However, as soon as we reach the top of the stairs, Tuesday asks for some water.

“Water?” I repeat. “Why?”

“It’s hot outside,” he answers as if that’s all he has to say.

I roll my eyes and head over the other side of the house where the kitchen is, hoping that no one’s in there. But of course, Brinn is there making grilled cheese while Sky sits at the island, watching her. Brinn’s auburn hair is pulled back into a messy bun as always and some loose strands stick to the back of her neck, but she doesn’t seem to mind. She turns slightly and grins at Sky when she catches him looking at her. His dark, golden tanned skin darkens more on his cheeks and he buries his fingers in his black hair.

“Hey, Div,” Sky says when I walk in with Tuesday. “Who’s the punk dude?”

Brinn turns around at this, giving me a smile that fades away when she spots Tuesday.

“He came earlier to drop off a poor one,” I explain. “He wants water.”

I head to the fridge to get a bottle of water. Brinn stops me with a sound of exclamation.

“Give him a glass, Div,” she says, her perfect tinkly voice echoing through the room. “Bottled water isn’t as good for you.”

“Do I care?” I scoff. “He didn’t ask for annoying health tips. Water is water. Besides, he’s about to leave.”

I pull out a bottle of water, all the while challenging Brinn with a look. She shrugs, unfazed, and turns back to the grilled cheese.

“Nice dye job,” Sky says to Tuesday as I hand the blue-haired guy the water. “Where’d you get it?”

“It’s natural, actually,” Tuesday replies. He takes the white stick out of his mouth, which I now realize is a sucker.

“Really?” Sky squints at him. “Don’t believe you.”

Tuesday glances at Sky as if he doesn’t really see him, and then shrugs. He examines the purple candy in his hand closely before biting the rest of it off, licking the stick clean afterwards. Sky scowls at him before pointing a sock-clad foot at the trash can in the corner. Tuesday throws the stick away and then looks after it with the first emotion I have seen on his face: depression. Brinn notices this, of course.

“Is something wrong?” she asks, her almond-shaped brown eyes which give away her Asian background widening in concern.

Tuesday looks at her.

“Candy,” he says with a shrug. “Now I have to wait until I get home for another one.”

“Oh, well we have some suckers.” Brinn turns to me and I try to look as busy as possible. “Div, could you get him one of the suckers from the pantry?”

Apparently picking at the wood on the island doesn’t count as “looking busy.” Bummer. I sigh and head to the pantry, which is right across from where Tuesday is standing by the trash can. The giant bag of suckers is at the way back of the dark pantry. I pull out a random one and then head back. Tuesday is leaning against the door frame with his arms folded. With the light from the kitchen shining behind him, he looks only like a shadow. I hand him the sucker and we step out together. He unwraps the candy in one swift motion like I’ve never seen before and licks it before pushing it into his mouth.

“Are you going to leave now?” I hope my voice sounds as insufferable as I want it to be.

He shrugs, walking to the island and picking up his bottle of water. He places it on the side of his face, looks around the kitchen at the three of us, and exits the room. I go to follow him out. When I see the door close behind him, I sigh in relief knowing I won’t see him ever again and return to the kitchen where both Brinn and Sky are eating grilled cheese sandwiches.

“I want one,” I whine.

Brinn looks up.

“Oh, sorry, I didn’t know. The stuff is still out if you want to make your own,” she suggests.

I shake my head. Too lazy. Instead, I go to the cookie jar labeled, “Divinity’s Stash. Get Your Own.” I pull out three of the peanut butter cookies Brinn and I made two days ago and start eating. Brinn sighs.

“You can’t eat cookies all the time,” she scolds.

“I don’t,” I protest. “I also eat chocolate cake and popsicles.”

“But you also need to eat real food. I keep saying if you’re hungry you can eat a ham sandwich. They’re easy to make.”

“But are they as accessible as peanut butter cookies?” I don’t give her a chance to answer. “I didn’t think so.”

As I munch on the cookies, I watch Brinn and Sky. They had been an item up until yesterday afternoon when they decided they were better off as friends. The two have taken it quite well in my opinion. In fact, the only difference is that they no longer go around holding hands and cuddling and you aren’t scared to go onto the veranda for fear of catching them kissing on a lawn chair. Now as they eat grilled cheese together, they chat casually about the upcoming party and about the new play’s opening night that all of us were invited to. It’s a sweet thing to watch. Normally, Hannie says, breakups are messy and the people can rarely go back to being just friends. But it seems to work out perfectly for Brinn and Sky and that makes me warm inside. There must be hope after all.

After Brinn and Sky are finished eating, Brinn starts to wash the plates just as Lex comes in with Rory trailing him.

“This must be the poor one,” Sky says, leaning back against the island.

“Mhm,” Lex answers. “Where’s Hannie?”

Just then Hannie enters the room from the opposite doorway.

“Here!” she exclaims. Her golden blonde hair is curled to perfection, her yellow dress is strapless, checkered, and hugs her curves. Not for the first time, I feel jealous of her natural beauty.

“Hannie, this is Rory. He’s a poor one,” Lex says.

“Nice one,” Hannie comments, looking Rory from head to toe like a butcher sizing up a cow. Rory blushes.

“He’s decided to do the Pilgrimage.”

“What?” Her face immediately falls. “Why? Why are you doing this? Don’t you want to stay here?”

“I’d like to go home,” Rory says with all the conviction he had downstairs. His face, which before I had thought made him look younger than he is, now seems to have the hard angles of a man, though with some boyishness yet to be shed. He is quite handsome, I note, not that I would ever tell that to anyone but my friends.

Hannie pouts. “Too bad. We could have been friends.”

“Anyway,” Lex continues loudly. “You three and Micah are going to accompany him.”

“Great. Another Pilgrimage,” Sky says.

“Glad to see you’re enthusiastic about it,” I murmur so only he can hear me.

“Yeah, like you want to go,” he replies in a low voice as well. “Midget.”

“Dumb butt.”

A corner of Sky’s mouth twitches. Not hiding my own grin, I nudge him. He scoots away from me and I sit on the corner of his chair without invitation.

“What about Cupcake?” Brinn asks.

“What about Cupcake?” Lex tilts his head in confusion.

“Well, you told Div to be Cupcake’s caretaker. She’s can’t take care of Cupcake if she’s off on the Pilgrimage.”

Right. Count on Brinn to be the responsible one. Sometimes I just don’t understand why Lex assigned me the job of taking care of the eccentric Cupcake. Cupcake’s personality isn’t much different than mine. How could he expect an irresponsible person to take care of an irresponsible and childlike person? It should have been Brinn’s job.

“Right.” Lex scratches his head. “Forgot about her.”

“How can anyone forget about that loon?” Sky mutters.

“Shut up,” I say. “That’s not nice.”

“And you’re a perfect saint.”

“Well, my name is Divinity.” I grin.

“Cupcake will have to go, too, then.” Lex sighs in defeat.

“What?” I screech.

“Well you’re my second assistant so you have to go, and I can’t keep Cupcake here and throw her on someone else so she’ll just have to go with you.” He rubs his head. “I trust that you’ll keep her safe.”

“We will, Lex,” Brinn vows.

Sky, Hannie and I snicker. Lex shoots us a frown. We shut up.

“You’ll leave tomorrow.”

I look at Rory. He doesn’t seem too happy about leaving so much later, but seems to accept it. He keeps his chin down and never makes eye contact with any of us. Again I find myself feeling bad for him. When I came here, I had never thought much about my future. I only lived in the now, much like I do nowadays, and so it never occurred to me that by staying I would be giving up my normal life. But Rory is obviously older than I was then and he has plans. He’s probably thinking about how his family won’t miss him, he’s probably wondering if his girlfriend is going to give up on him and find someone else. He’s probably wondering if he ever will get home. And once again, I want to reach out and touch him, reassure him, even though I have no idea how.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1068
Reviews 582
NITPICKS:


He’s looking down at me with a blank expression on his face, a short white stick hanging out between his closed lips. He’s moving it around too much that I can’t tell if it’s a cigarette or not.

You would be able to tell the difference between a cigarette and a sucker, just to let you know. A cigarette has a red, burning tip, and smokes and smells. A sucker stick is thin and longer.


Well there goes any chance we had at having a nice relationship.

This sentence just feels odd to me. It's weird that she wanted to have a relationship with him right off. It seems like she's just annoyed with him, so why would she want a friendship/relationship?


“Right. You’re what, 9 or 10? You’re a big girl now?” he questions, [s]though it sounds more like a practiced statement[/s].



“And what are you, [s]a person I have never seen before in my life,[/s] doing on this porch?”



“But I’ve something to show him.”

This isn't right. He has something to pretty much GIVE him.


I step back to let him in, but instead of coming in right away, he let out a low whistle [s]to something or someone near him[/s].



A boy maybe around my age with shaggy brown hair emerges, hands clasped behind his back, smiling sheepishly at me. I watch him as he enters the house with Blue-Haired Guy behind him. I shut the door. “This way.”

You don't really give us her reation to this boy. She obviously knows he's a poor one (which, by the way, I think should be capitalized so it reads Poor One) and later she notes how cute/handsome he is. Isn't she curious? Wary?


I lead the two boys out of the foyer and down the hall to the basement door, occasionally glancing back to make sure [s]the boys[/s] they aren’t trying anything.




“To your friends it’ll appear as if you just excused yourself to go somewhere else,” Lex explains.

You can do better than this. I know you can. Come up with something more creative. And why did this boy end up in Dream if he has a family anyway? He doesn't seem all that poor to me. Was he kidnapped? Did he stumble into a portal accidentally? We need more than what you're giving us.



LOOSE ENDS:

So you tell us about Cupcake, but you never really tell us who he/she IS and what she's doing at House. Also, while I don't want to know right away, or that would be too much of an info-dump, what are the others doing at House?


OVERALL OPINION:

I loved it. This first chapter is amazing, no joke. It's so rare that I run accross something that I actually enjoy, and this was a pleasure to read and review. I love Tuesday - you hit his character spot-on.

You'd better keep writing. I want more of this.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 5404
Reviews 97
“I am not a ‘kiddo,’” I retort.

It is best to just say "Said."

“Right. You’re what, 9 or 10? You’re a big girl now?” he questions,

"He" should be capitalized.

A boy, maybe around my age,

There should be a comma between "Boy" and "Maybe" and another after "Age."

, with hands clasped behind his back, smiling sheepishly at me.

I think that makes that sentence better structured.

I stop when we get to the basement door and turn to face them, my eyes trained mostly on the cute brown-haired boy.

I would have liked it better if you didn't just describe him as "Cute" so straight-forwardly. Perhaps telling of his physical appearance, and how it made the MC's stomach flutter.

and then opens the door


But anyone now who is meeting him for the first time would never guess that, and it makes me sad.

I think that should be made into one sentence alone.

“Do I care?” I scoff.

Again, it is a whole lot better to just say "Said."

“Here!” she exclaims.

The word "She" should be capitalized.

Overall:
I loved this piece. I adore how different Divinity is from the generic main character in most stories, and she also reminds me of myself. I am nearly 16, though i get mistaken for being around 12 or 13 (it bugs the crap out of me). I also like how uncommon the names you have chose for your characters are (and i wish to name my daughter Tuesday, so when I learned of the Blue-haired Guy's name I shreiked). This is a very nice plot, even though I know not very much about it yet. Very different. You're writing skills are great, you have a bit of mistkaes here and there. Who doesn't?




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1068
Reviews 582
I know I already reviewed, but I had to point something out that the previous reviewer stated:

“Right. You’re what, 9 or 10? You’re a big girl now?” he questions


"He" should be capitalized.


This is wrong. It shouldn't be capitalized. You're fine, Cammie. Leave it as it is, otherwise the punctuation will be incorrect and people will keep pointing it out.

And one more thing. I hate feeling like I'm trying to start a debate or something, but I like the fact that you're using tags beside "he said" or "she said". "Retorts" and "scoffs" are excellent uses and give me a good mental imagery of what's happening in your story.

Anyway. Just had to say that. Sorry. I've got it all out, now.

Keep writing. I meant it when I said I wanted to see more.

Your friend,

KJ




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 5404
Reviews 97
KJ wrote:And one more thing. I hate feeling like I'm trying to start a debate or something, but I like the fact that you're using tags beside "he said" or "she said". "Retorts" and "scoffs" are excellent uses and give me a good mental imagery of what's happening in your story.

I've just read "On Writing" by Stephan King and "Elements of Style" by E.B. White and William Strunk for my up coming AP English class next year, and both books stated to not use those words instead of "Said." I am going by the tips of three successful writers, and not just my personal opinion.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 16
Thanks bunches for your critiquing, guys! It's really helping. Also, about the "said" thing: I've heard both sides, that "said" is better than other words and that other words are better than "said." I prefer to not use "said" so much because it sounds boring. I don't always use dialogue tags, though, so sometimes I just avoid both.

Thanks again and I should be posting the next chapter soon.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1390
Reviews 40
Good Morning, Cammie.

Here are some of my thoughts upon this chapter:

1) I'm not very good at giving criticism but I shall try my best for you!

2) The House: The place you call Dream reminds me a lot of a storybook, just like you mentioned. Those people act like family, even though the House is like the end point for the poor ones, but then they can still go on that pilgrimage. The House is...very hard to even explain what I feel about it. It's like this mythical land that people stay at before something drastic happens to them. It's like a ghost who's stuck from being dead and going on into the afterlife. The House reminds me a lot of that.

3) Characters: The names you choose, are very unusual. Very unique in a way that I actually haven't seen someone use those names. Kudos to you! For Lex, I can't say much for. He's just this aging man who runs the House and acts like a fatherly figure towards Div. When I read about Sky, I thought he was a girl. Is his name short for Skylar? Brinn acts like that motherly-sisterly type. I kind of like her. Hanni, don't know so much of. But, hopefully you'll have more of her? Tuesday (what a strange name), he's...an odd sort of fellow. And Sky just stole the words right out of me, he is a punk kind of dude. And Rory. You wrote is character to be really sad for. I wouldn't say pitiful, though. Sounds rude. I do feel for him and his loses.

4) Others: Tuesday and Div eat a lot of junk food. He eats the suckers and she eats the peanut butter cookies. (I love peanut butter cookies!) Talk about not being healthy. Anyway, Cammie, I know this was more of a review then the critique that you wanted, so I'm sorry about that. Oh, this novel of yours sounds more of a science fiction novel that a romance, though.

Melly




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1647
Reviews 57
Hello!

I review as a go along, so if I mention anything that you fix later on I'm sorry!

He’s looking down at me with a blank expression on his face, a short white stick hanging out between his closed lips. He’s moving it around too much that I can’t tell if it’s a cigarette or not.

Good visual


“Right. You’re what, 9 or 10? You’re a big girl now?” he questions, though it sounds more like a practiced statement.


Always write out numbers smaller than ten. So, "You're what, nine or ten?"

“I’m seventeen,” I say, straightening up and sticking out my chin in an effort to look my age.


Especially follow that rule if later you write out larger numbers.

But, if Lex found out, which he probably would, he would scold me and I wouldn’t be allowed to have peanut butter cookies for a week.


This seemed oddly out of place. It's almost like a joke but she's not kidding. It comes off strange.

I step back to let him in, but instead of coming in right away, he let out a low whistle to something or someone near him.


This might just be a me thing, but whenever I hear the words "low whistle" together, I either take it to mean expressing being impressed or calling someone attractive. I might change it to a "quiet whistle" or something else.

I lead the two boys out of the foyer and down the hall to the basement door,


I got the impression that Blue-Haired Guy was older...? Maybe I misread.

I’m required to say that to anyone besides House’s tenants.”


Is House a person? Or is it literally a house? If it's the second it should be "the house"


“I am not a child. I am seventeen years old. Look!” I point to my chest. “I have boobs!”


Ha. *snort*


Lex shoots me with a brief grin.


I think this would read better without the "with".


This isn’t some place that you can just take a bus ride back home. Oh, no.”


Lex doesn't really sound cold here...he sounds more menacing...I'm not sure if that's what you're going for.




Lex sends me upstairs to show Tuesday out as he discusses the Pilgrimage with Rory. However, as soon as we reach the top of the stairs, Tuesday asks for some water.

“Water?” I repeat. “Why?”


I'm kind of confused by this...why is it strange to ask for water?


“Give him a glass, Div,” she says, her perfect tinkly voice echoing through the room. “Bottled water isn’t as good for you.”


Why is there bottled water if they don't drink it? Or is Brinn just being welcoming for a guest?

“It’s natural, actually,” Tuesday replies. He takes the white stick out of his mouth, which I now realize is a sucker.


He reminds me of House. :)

“Really?” Sky squints at him. “Don’t believe you.”


“Is something wrong?” she asks, her almond-shaped brown eyes, which give away her Asian background, widening in concern.


“Oh, well we have some suckers.” Brinn turns to me and I try to look as busy as possible.
“Div, could you get him one [s]of the suckers[/s] from the pantry?”


Don't need to repeat.

I sigh and head to the pantry, which is right across from where Tuesday is standing by the trash can. The giant bag of suckers is at the way back[s] of the dark pantry[/s].


Don't need to repeat.
I pull out a random one and then head back.


I pull one out at random and then head back.

I hand him the sucker and we step out together. He unwraps the candy in one swift motion [s]like I’ve never seen before[/s] and licks it before pushing it into his mouth.


“Anyway,” Lex continues loudly. “You three and Micah are going to accompany him.”


You three meaning Sky, Div and Brinn? What about Hannie?

Overall:

Very nice! I'm really intrigued by this whole situation. Some of the ideas seem slightly familiar, but I can't think of from where, so I'm just assuming that the whole fantasy concept itself is just popular. I like Div, she seems like she'll be trouble in the future though. You give alot of detail and in the right places, just make sure you don't repeat yourself. :) I hope you plan to post the second half of the chapter soon.

-Maggie
"Why kill time when you can kill yourself?"
-Voltaire




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 4362
Reviews 263
Hey Cammie ^^ I'm Shina and I'll be your reviewer this afternoon.



I stare up at the blue-haired boy standing on the porch.

Yes! Finally someone who can include multi-colored hair characters in their story. There's nothing wrong with blue hair or purple because it's a novel xD

He doesn’t look familiar at all, and most people who visit House I either know personally or have seen before.

This sentence seems a bit confusing. You should switch the second part around to "and most people who visit House are either personal friends of mine or people whom I've seen before."
Something like that because the second part of the sentence needs some switching around.


*Blue-Haired Guy doesn’t fall into either of these categories. He’s looking down at me with a blank expression on his face, a short white stick hanging out between his closed lips. He’s moving it around too much that I can’t tell if it’s a cigarette or not.

You refer to him as "Blue-haired boy" earlier in the story and now he's "blue haired guy". Choose one or the other because in the beginning I get the feeling that he's young, and now he seems old with the cig?

he says around the white stick,

You can't really say something "around" the white stick, can you?



“I am not a ‘kiddo,’” I retort.

forgot the ' at the other side of "kiddo".

He blinks.

This doesn't seem like the right word because humans tend to blink all the time. Maybe closes his eyes, or recoils?


“Right. You’re what, 9 or 10? You’re a big girl now?” he questions, though it sounds more like a practiced statement.

In writing you need to write numbers with the proper spelling, even in dialogue, unless it's over 100. So change it to "You're what? Nine or ten?" You also need another question mark.

“I’m seventeen,” I say, straightening up and sticking out my chin in an effort to look my age. “And what are you? A person I have never seen before in my life, doing on this porch?”

What the MC says is a little, too formal. You don't usually just say "What are you, a person I have never seen before in my life, doing on this porch?" It's so formal, so awkward. When people see a stranger on their porch they say either say they don't like strangers or ask why there's a stranger on their porch. The question mark also needed to be added there.





so rudely

Should be "so-rudely" and either in quotes or italics.

But, if Lex found out, which he probably would, he would scold me and I wouldn’t be allowed to have peanut butter cookies for a week. And we cannot have that.

She's 17? Sure about that?

So, after another silent moment to build up the suspense even though Blue-Haired Guy doesn’t seem to be affected at all, I sigh.

This is a long sentence and I think you should break it up. Also, "so" isn't supposed to really be used in 1st person narration. "After another moment of silence to build up the suspense, Blue-Haired Guy doesn't seem to be affected at all. I sigh."


“Fine, come on. Don’t touch anything.” I nod my head, signaling for him to come in.

Try "gesturing" rather than "signaling".

I step back to let him in, but instead of coming in right away, he let out a low whistle to something or someone near him. A boy maybe around my age with shaggy brown hair emerges, hands clasped behind his back, smiling sheepishly at me. I watch him as he enters the house with Blue-Haired Guy behind him. I shut the door. “This way.”

Ohh, this new character seems interesting ;) Nice sudden addition here.


my eyes trained mostly on the cute brown-haired boy.

Rather than just telling us he's cute, you could have the MC examine him so you can illustrate more of him.

“We are about to go downstairs where Lex’s study is. Only certain people are allowed in. If either of you are just playing a joke or trying to steal something or… just up to anything bad, then…” I smirk.

This dialogue is awkward, isn't it? You don't just go up to someone and speak in present tense. "We are about to go downstairs..." That's more like you're someone on camera telling the audience. Change it to "We were about to go downstairs where Lex's study is."



“Second assistant?” The boy with the brown hair speaks for the first time, his grey eyes wide. “You’re… a child.”

"grey" should be "gray" unless you're from the UK.



“I am not a child. I am seventeen years old. Look!” I point to my chest. “I have boobs!”

Okay, the first line of this really makes her seem like she is a child. So either put italics on "not" or change it to "I'm" because it's too formal again. Change "look" to "See?" because telling someone to look at your chest isn't really how it goes... Also, she should refer to it as "chest" because "boobs" is really middle-school and and immature-kid phrase. Unless she's immature, change it.

The boy with the brown hair blushes and looks away. Blue-Haired Guy, however, examines my only-slightly-noticeable bust and raises an eyebrow.

“If you say so,” he says finally, looking past me at the basement door.

xD This is hilarious. Your MC is hilarious. But if she's flat, why would she bring it up? Shouldn't she be embarrased a little?


I open Lex’s office door without knocking. He is sitting at his desk, the only light coming from one dying floorlamp, and is busy writing something.

Try to show rather than tell and paint a picture for us. The narrator is ranting too much and rather than saying that Lex is busy writing something, you can say he's "scribbling furiously on a page" or anything along the lines of that.

I can tell it’s important by the way he is slouching down and holding his forehead like he has a headache. He jumps in his seat when I flick on the overhead light. He squints at us, lingering in the doorway.

Good description ^^ Change the last sentence to "He squints at us as we linger in the doorway." because the way you put it makes it seem like Lex is lingering the doorway.


Lex watches warily as Blue-Haired Guy claps his hand on the other boy’s back and pushes him forward.

You don't clap a hand on someone's back? You would shove your hand, place your hand, pat your hand, or another word.

“My name is Tuesday,” Blue-Haired Guy says. “I happened to find this poor one at the Fountain Portal and was told to bring him to you. Many people around here know of your work with poor ones.”

Interesting. Didn't expect that.

“Welcome to Dream,” Lex says, his tone anything but welcoming.

D: Goodness! What's Dream?! Tell me more!



“Dream?” Rory echoes. “So you mean I’m dreaming?”

“No, no.” Lex sighs and laces his fingers together in front of his lips. “You are somewhere other than your world. An alternate world, if you will. Dream is a world that makes you feel as if you’re in a dream.”

“It’s like Alice in Wonderland or The Wizard of Oz,” I add in. Lex shoots me with a brief grin.

“Divinity is right,” he says. “It’s almost as if you’re in a storybook.”

Seems to get better and better. But the "Divinity" thing is confusing. You wouldn't know that's the MC's name unless you look back and check. You refer to her as "Div" in the earlier part.


“They’re not even thinking about you. It’s as if thoughts of you have been erased from their minds.” The way Lex puts it sounds so horrible.

Again with the telling? You need to show emotion, some feeling in Lex's voice. Is their quaking, is it grave? Is it solemn?

A sniffle comes from the doorway. I look up to see two tears running silently down Rory’s tan cheek. Nearly knocking over the end table with my swiftness, I grab the box of tissues and go to hand it to him. He doesn’t seem to notice me, however, and instead wipes at his eyes with the sleeve of his black sweatshirt.

Guys usually don't cry, and assuming he's manly? Then have him try to fight away the tears or have his cheeks flame from embarrasment,

“I’ll do it,” Rory says without any hesitation at all, as if he didn’t even think about his answer before saying it.

The second part of this sentence isn't necessary, it's a repeat. Also you're telling again and not enough showing.
“Sure as I’ve ever been of anything in my life,” Rory replies. “I have a future back home. I have a family, I have friends, I have college applications to turn in, I have Calculus to pass, I have a girlfriend I’m planning on proposing to next summer, I have a dog to take to the vet… I can’t leave it all. I’m not going to throw away everything I’ve worked so hard to get.” His voice is hard, determined, sure, reminding me of the heroes in movies who make long speeches about goodness before defeating the villain. I then decide: I admire this boy. I admire his strong will and his scruples. I admire his strength to stop his tears.

This seems a bit quick. Shouldn't he pause first to think about his family, his life back home, even just a brief pause, and then answer?



Brinn turns around at this, giving me a smile that fades away when she spots Tuesday.

I love the names your using ^^ My friend's sister's name was Brinn. However the name "Divinity" is still... it doesn't connect. Also you need to either go with "Div" or "Divinity" because it gets confusing, like I said, or establish that "Div" is her nickname.

“Is something wrong?” she asks, her almond-shaped brown eyes which give away her Asian background widening in concern.

You don't really need to tell us that her almond-shaped eyes give away her Asian background. Find another way to tell the readers.

“I want one,” I whine.

Div is definitely not 17. She seems too kiddish, unless that's what you wanted.

I shake my head. Too lazy. Instead, I go to the cookie jar labeled, “Divinity’s Stash. Get Your Own.” I pull out three of the peanut butter cookies Brinn and I made two days ago and start eating. Brinn sighs.

Divinity seems like a beautiful, powerful name, yet it doesn't fit this 17 year old girl who acts like a toddler. What's with the peanut-butter cookies? Does she have autism? Was she born this way? You need to justify it because the age and her actions confuse the readers.

“I’d like to go home,” Rory says with all the conviction he had downstairs. His face, which before I had thought made him look younger than he is, now seems to have the hard angles of a man, though with some boyishness yet to be shed. He is quite handsome, I note, not that I would ever tell that to anyone but my friends.

Why would Div have any interest in guys if she acts like a toddler, and again with the telling.
----------

I'm going to stop there, because the problems repeat.

Plot: The plot seems interesting and there is definitely a hook.

Character Devlopment: Divinity is bugging the heck out of me. She's a 17 year-old toddler who eats peanut butter cookies, hits on guys, and points at her "boobs" to justify herself. You either need to change her age, justify why she acts so young, or change her personality.

The other characters are interesting though, but so many of them seem to flood in at the beginning.

Conflict: The conflict was okay. Just Rory wanting to go back home. It's decent, but you need to give Rory a reason to want to come back other than just saying he's got a family.

Description: You need to stop telling the readers and start showing. Paint an image for us! There are no emotions, no feelings, no pounding, nothing.

Dialogue: Div's dialogue doesn't match her personality or age or anything. Everyone else seems okay but Rory talks to the group like he's known them forever.

Hope that Helps ^^
-Shina
You cannot dream yourself into a character; you must hammer and forge yourself into one.

The writer, when he is also an artist, is someone who admits what others don't dare reveal.



So verily with the hardship, there is a relief, verily with the hardship, there is a relief.
— Quran Ch 94:5-6