Removed #9

4 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 3263
Reviews 158
Topic has been removed.
Last edited by thewritingdoc on Sat Oct 23, 2010 9:50 pm, edited 3 times in total.
    I'd rather write about this world than live in it
    and I'd rather play music all day
    and read and wander around bookstores
    and watch humans
    but not be one of them.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 900
Reviews 268
You know, I've been looking for something that I can read and say, "This is what I want to be doing right now. This is original, and fresh, and deep." This did that for me. That's not to say it's perfect, there are a few things I want to point out (just little picky things though). I just wanted to first congratulate and thank you for that.

"Let's go somewhere
the tide can take us there."
I think you should add a 'he said' to the end of this, in a new line.


I noticed that your capitalization is inconsistent. Either that or you didn't edit for proper capitalization or punctuation, because there are a few places where those are missing.
I'll just point out a few spots:

Away from an industrious city
Where no one exists like us-
'Where' should not be capitalized, because you don't capitalize the first letter of every line in this poem and it's not the first word in a sentence.


"Let's go somewhere
the tide can take us there."
There should be a period or semi-colon at the end of the first line.


it seems just yesterday I could have laid down and cried
after seeing a homeless woman taking shelter in a plain cardboard box,
who was once my childhood hero
thrust aside by society
and the effects of time
new saggy, wrinkled skin
somehow she still wore a smile
'it' should be capitalized.
There should be a comma after 'hero'.
There should be a period after 'time'.
The line 'new saggy, wringled skin' doesn't really seem to have a place in the sentence before it ("it seems just yesterday" etc.) or the sentence after it ("somehow she still wore a smile" etc.). You need to make a place for it, probably in the sentence before it, or in it's own sentence.


You can search for us
You won't find a trace
Unless you possess,
A creative mind
Ready to believe
in eternity.
In this stanza (except the last line), you capitalize the first word of every line, which is inconsistent with the rest of the poem. You should have: a period at the end of the first line, the first word of the second line capitalized, first word of third line not capitalized, no comma after the third line, first word of fourth line not capitalized, and a comma after the fourth line.


An everyday thing
For downtown New York;
that we shall leave behind.
This is a fragment, and the word 'for' should not be capitalized.




AIR!
YES,
DO YOU FEEL IT?
DO YOU SMELL IT?
All caps are a bad idea in general. In poetry, I personally think it's even worse. In this case, regardless of whether they're bad in general, I don't think that they fit the tone of these lines. Picture someone yelling those words (which is the impression all caps give) and you'll see what I mean, I think.



Away from an industrious city
Where no one exists like us-
the witty.
I wondered if maybe these were intended to still be in quotation marks? Because they are a continuation of the sentence that he says in the beginning.


Great job! If you ever want me to look over this again, I'd be very happy to.
"Half the time the poem writes me." ~Meshugenah




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 3
hey, wats up?
Im not a big fan of poetry, but this was pretty good.

"and I just want to sing along
to the strings of your untuned guitar"

I don't think using a guitar for comparisson there is quite right, but its just my opinion.

"Away from an industrious city
Where no one exists like us-
the witty."

I think there should be a comma after city.

"At this moment
I believe so strongly"

Another comma there, other-wise, to me it just breaks the flow.

Not sure if I helped, but keep writing, I'd like to see what else you can come up with.




"Posted: Mon Jan 05, 2009 12:34 am Post subject: Waiting to Cross the Tide...

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 803
Reviews 107
I loved this poem, it was really original and an amazing theme. Personally, I don't like too much formatting in a poem. But, it seemed to work well for you...The poem flowed well and it was pretty easy to read...This is a really bad review, but I couldn't find anything else wrong with the poem that hadn't been covered by the other two reviewers...So, excellent job on this, and gold star for you!

fluteluvr77<3
Love is the answer to life yet the slowest form of suicide.
Love is a paradox.
And that's why we love it.

Got YWS?



If a million people say a foolish thing, it is still a foolish thing.
— Anatole France