Marigolds. Roses

3 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 540
Reviews 14
Note: I wrote this piece for the contest held back in November. We were to write a personal essay, in any form we pleased, about an experience that had a positive effect on our life. This piece didn't place, and I realize it isn't perfect. :D This is really my first post on this website, and I'd love some constructive criticism. Please be respectful! But please also be truthful. Thank you! And please enjoy!


Marigolds, Roses

I shivered. The winds were strong today, bustling and roaring like a restless spirit. I was seated at the park in town, reflecting upon this most grievous date. It was the perfect location. I never felt more comfortable than in the sprouting life of the outdoors.

How I needed this haven today! During school, I had grown very anxious. Sitting amidst the brisk air relieved that; it opened my senses.

The date was 0ctober 21st.

Not only was this the day of my birth, but a cursed anniversary. My father passed away exactly 18 months before, on April 21st of 2007. I cannot describe the grief my family felt at his death.

My father was a serene, humorous man. He never missed a single performance my siblings or I took part in.

We each were mourned in our own separate ways. My mother took to pill addiction. But, my father’s death was one I had anticipated. He was a fervent alcoholic who practiced little restraint. I knew he would eventually end his life during intoxication. And yet, I caught myself today, indignant. Did it have to happen? Why my life must be so unruly and despairing, I could not comprehend.

“Chloe! I knew just where to find you.” Gavin chuckled.
“What are you-“
“I wanted to apologize.” The weather never stifled him. He smiled a lively, warm smile at me.
“Apologize?”

“Yep. I avoided you all day. I shouldn’t have. It was stupid.” He took the seat next to me and handed me a hot cocoa. How splendid it felt, trickling down my throat. “I noticed you were down in class.”

“Oh, I’m fine.”

“No, no; you can’t lie to me… I’m here to make it up to you.” He looked out along the field, where the trees flailed. I wondered what he could mean as we sat there in awkward silence. After a minute or so, he rose and headed towards his truck, waving me to follow.

Ten minutes later, we arrived at the cemetery. I was astounded. He hadn’t indeed forgotten the date, as I anticipated he would.

“Take these,” he said, revealing two flowers he’d hidden in his truck. One was a crimson marigold with fluttering petals; the other, a golden rose.

“Gavin,”
“Here.” He placed them in my hands.
I protected them from the wind, but trembled. “They’re marvelous…”
“So you like them?” His eyes were attentive.
“Oh yes! I believe they’ve done me tremendous good.”

On the grave, I placed these beauties, where they remained unstirred amongst the blistering winds of Kansas.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1361
Reviews 106
I'm sorry no one has commented on this. Someone should have!

I enjoyed reading this. You have an interesting, old-fashioned style.

The winds were strong today, bustling and roaring like a restless spirit.


I enjoyed this line when I read it. But looking back on it, it is even more delicious, based on the theme of the piece.

I cannot describe the grief my family felt at his death.


I understand this would be a hard feeling to express. And I don't mean to negate your feelings, but I think this line is a little cliche. Is there a way to keep the feeling but make this line more literarily interesting?

We each were mourned in our own separate ways.


This sentence doesn't make sense gramatically. I think you mean to say either:
"We each mourned in our own seperate ways." or
"We each were mourning in our own seperate ways." ?

You said your dad was serene, then said he was a ferven alcoholic who practiced little restraint. I obviously don't know your dad, but this sounds a little contradictory to me. Could you add more detail or explain him differently so the reader understands him better?

Chloe! I knew just where to find you.” Gavin chuckled


Is this period supposed to be a comma? Or is this two different sentences? If it is one sentence, it should be a comma.

The weather never stifled him. He smiled a lively, warm smile at me.


love this line.

He hadn’t indeed forgotten the date, as I anticipated he would.


I think this should be "had anticipated" because you anticipated it in the past, right?

One was a crimson marigold with fluttering petals; the other, a golden rose.


“Gavin,”


I don't think there should be a semi-colon there, just a comma. And the comma after Gavin should be a period.

“Oh yes! I believe they’ve done me tremendous good.”


This seems a little cliche to me, but it actually kind of goes with your whole voice in the piece, so maybe i'm wrong : )

On the grave, I placed these beauties, where they remained unstirred amongst the blistering winds of Kansas.


A beautiful ending. I like the closure it provides to your distress, the way the flowers don't blow in the wind.

Sorry to be so nitpicky about grammar, but grammar is subordinate to the feeling you create in the piece, which was truly lovely. It left me with some questions though: Who is Gavin? : )

well done!
"He found his voice tended either to disappear or to come out too loud." -William Golding




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 540
Reviews 14
To NixonBlitzen:

Thank you! I appreciate the nitpicking! :wink: It helps me improve my writing!



We each were mourned in our own separate ways.


This sentence doesn't make sense gramatically. I think you mean to say either:
"We each mourned in our own seperate ways." or
"We each were mourning in our own seperate ways." ?


I did mean "each mourned" instead of "were mourned" lol. :D


One was a crimson marigold with fluttering petals; the other, a golden rose.

“Gavin,”


I don't think there should be a semi-colon there, just a comma. And the comma after Gavin should be a period.


I always get messed up on those cases of punctuation lol. Thank you for clearing it up!


Also, I do think a lot of my phrases can be a bit cliche. I need to work on those. But I'm so glad you liked my piece! I'll be sure and edit it :D



"You know, sometimes all you need is twenty seconds of just embarrassing bravery. And I promise you, something great will come of it."
— We Bought A Zoo