High School

8 posts
Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 85
When I graduated Junior High,
I remember telling myself I’d be the same,
Crazy and fun,
And full of spunk.

When I graduated Junior High,
I remember telling myself I’d dress the same,
Bright orange shirts,
With ripped, pen marked-jeans.

When I graduated Junior High,
I remember telling myself I'd have the same friends,
The ones who are crazy,
And get you out of trouble.

When I graduated Junior High,
I remember telling myself I'd never follow the crowd,
When they wore black,
I'd were white.

When I got into High School,
I made a few new friends,
The kind that ran from cops,
And wore bandanas on their head.

Now I'm a Junior in High School,
And take what I say with caution,
Because it may change even the hardest of people,
And things may never be the same.

I'm a Junior in High School,
Thought growing up would be fun,
Thought everything would be the same,
But nothing's right and everything's wrong.

I'm a Junior in High School,
And my boyfriend's a Senior,
But while he graduates and has fun,
I'm stuck at home with the belly he gave me.

And while others move on,
And have the time of their lives,
I'll be at home with him,
Watching the baby.


What do you think?




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 915
pandoraswritings:


All of your recent posts reflect the same error: the narrator finds him or herself excessively interesting. The character you present in this is not anything to sympathize with. The poem is a boring, wannabe tear-jerker about how the narrator messed up her life.

Let me clue you in: we don't care, and until such time that you can craft narrators we would even want to relate to, I suggest you stop using repetition in your poetry--you obviously don't understand how to use it effectively.


Best,
Brad
"If I have not seen as far as others, it is because giants were standing on my shoulders." -Hal Abelson




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 2702
Reviews 867
I'd were white.


Wear.
Moderator Emeritus (frozen in carbonite.)




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 36
The poem is a boring, wannabe tear-jerker about how the narrator messed up her life.


Don't listen to Incan. He's a little too harsh. Besides, he could find fault in one of Shel Sylverstein's poems. I think it's a good story, but you should rate it pg13. Altough, I think you could make it a little better. Good luck.
lillizard was here.
If you are a dreamer, come in. If you are a wisher, a lier, a magic bean buyer. If you're a pretender, come sit by my fire, For we have some flax-golden tales to spin Come In! Come In!~Shel Silverstein




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 23425
Reviews 566
I think you could put the first four stanzas into one with less repetition and more description and imagery. As a reader I was a little confused as to how you intended me to feel towards the narrator - sympathetic or cold. The whole baby thing kinda came a bit suddenly as well, if you reworked and added to how things changed and what happened in high school, I think it would come a little more naturally. Keep at it.
Matt.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1040
Reviews 64
I loved the poem, there was alot of meaning behind it. And yes, some of these guys can be a bit harsh don't listen to eveyone.

I don't think you should change a single thing about the repetition, i found it suspensfull, and I knew that someone put thought into driving it into a poem instead of a coupld lines that might make sence, but the only fault if found, wich isn't even a fault.I think you should add a bit to your highschool years before you hit us with the baby.

And,"The wannabe tear jerker", I found the sudden baby at the end very effective, it is a powerfull and awe-inspiring litterary poem, that makes the reader think. weather there thinking to themselves,"I can relate", or"maybe I don't want to end up relating to this."

Keep writing and =)happy reading(=
~Everyone~

=) *wave*




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 8846
Reviews 531
Hello Pandora. (I can call you that, can't I?)

I think you have the start of something, you present to the reader, a narrator that we could relate to, would love to relate to, but in the end it doesn't carry through the poem. Why? First, you present a plausible senario, but your denotations are clichèd. Second, in the following stanza you set up the narrator as better than the reader, because obviously the reader does not know this:

Now I'm a Junior in High School,
And take what I say with caution,
Because it may change even the hardest of people,
And things may never be the same.


It makes the narrator seem cocky in her knowledge, and does not read well.

Third, the girl who gets pregnant and then her baby's dady leaves her is so over used all the media outlets of today, and the ending leaves us with a overused, tacky feeling. Not to mention, woe is me.

Four, this sentence right here is a poem wrecker: But nothing's right and everything's wrong. Trust me, it works like a demolition man's wrecking crew. Why doesn't it work? Well, it doesn't work because it makes the author's angst Mary Sueish. Two, it doesn't work because you create this idea that what the narrator is going through is the lowest possible low, which it isn't.

The biggest problem in this poem that I see is you don't create common ground with your audience. [i.e. See Daily Rantings for some common ground explanation.]

My first suggestion is to scratch all the repetitions at the beginning of the stanza, and pick out the lines you like best in the poem. Then free write from there.

Maybe what this poem needs is some substance behind the words, right now I'm only seeing carboard box, fill it.

My favorite part was this:

I remember telling myself I’d dress the same,
Bright orange shirts,
With ripped, pen marked-jeans.


- though I'd change the -with- to -and-.

Hope this helps, and good luck.
CL.

Courtesy of SPEW and Kitten Eaters Anonymous
Fraser: Stop stealing the blanket.
[Diefenbaker whines]
Fraser: You're an Arctic Wolf, for God's sake.
(Due South)

Hatter: Do I need a reason to help a pretty girl in a very wet dress? (Alice)

Got YWS?




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1040
Reviews 64
Quote:
Now I'm a Junior in High School,
And take what I say with caution,
Because it may change even the hardest of people,
And things may never be the same.



I love this stanza because of the way it starts it is almost alliteration and rolls off the toung coming after " I was in junior high" like it did.

I found this one of my favorite stanzas and the funnest to read
~Everyone~

=) *wave*



Who knew paper and ink could be so vicious.
— Kathryn Stockett, The Help