Bear My Witness

6 posts
User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 890
Reviews 18
So this was an english essay and the prompt I used was to write about something that deeply affected you and or changed you for the better. So I'm having a little trouble with some of the sentences, the first one especially so if you could help me I'd be really grateful!!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the United States Holocaust Museum I rounded a corner into a cold, plain room, and was bombarded by my senses and emotions all at once. The pungent smell of old, musty leather hit my nostrils, and the sight of hundreds of pairs of shoes reached my horrified eyes. A bridge stretched before me to the other side of the room, and laid out beside and beneath it lay shoes, nestled together in remembrance of the owners whose lives were tragically lost. Those shoes bear testimony that the Holocaust happened, they bear testimony of the human beings who wore them moments before they died.

In that room of shoes taken from concentration camp victims, I was changed forever. Leaning up against the bridge railing I was tempted to reach slowly out and brush my tingling finger tips against the old leather. Tears filled my eyes as I focused them on a tiny pink shoe, a little girl’s shoe. In that moment the people who died in the Holocaust became real before my eyes. They once had worn these shoes. In that room of cement walls I realized that lying all around me was all that remained of those people... it was all that remained of their hopes, and their dreams, the last remaining proof of their very lives.

“We are the shoes, we are the last witness. We are shoes from Grandchildren and Grandfathers, from Prague, Paris, and Amsterdam, and because we are only made of fabric and leather, and not of blood and flesh, each one of us avoided the hellfire.” The words written across the wall blurred as tears ran down my cheeks. In that moment everything I had ever had the courage to believe in burned deep inside my very being.

An icy hand clenched my stomach as I realized I could have worn a pair of those shoes. Those girls had been just like me. They dreamed of big futures, of getting married, and having

families of their own. They were crazy about boys, and studied late into the night cramming for a chemistry exam that awaited them in only a few hours. They laughed on warm summer days in the park with their best friends! What had they done to deserve death? The answer that breaks my heart still is that they were Jewish, and they were born unfairly into a hateful world.

They were just like me.

The apathy of mankind was splayed around me, in a cold, dim room, just like the chambers that the owners of those shoes had been murdered in. My sympathetic heart shattered and in that moment whatever faith I had left in mankind was abolished.

And yet... in many ways I was given hope. Hope that through what I had now witnessed I would no longer be afraid to stand up for what I believe in. In my heart burned the new belief that somehow I can have an impact on mankind. I know now that even though I’m only one person I can change the world in someway for the better.

As I stared down at that little pink shoe I understood why one must speak up, why exactly one must be heard. The reason? Because if you remain silent eleven million people could die. If you go along with what you don’t believe in, others will suffer the consequences. I believe that I can make a difference. I believe that every human being is worth something, and I believe that I can help others to see the good in themselves.

Those shoes of the past, speak to the people of the future. They tell a horrifying story, that maybe in years to come will seem distant and almost fictitious. Yet they will lie in that museum forever, reminding the world that it was not a fictitious event. It happened.

Four words are written boldly across a wall in the lobby of the museum. Those words will be engraved on my soul for an indefinite amount of time. They read:

“You are my witnesses”

I am their witness.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 6
Wow, I liked it a lot. We had a Holocaust survivor come talk to our class once and it eliticted a similar response from me as the shoes did to yourself. The writing pretty vividly captured that. The way that you kind of built the story around bearing witness for the horror and erasing apathy was pretty cool, and worked well, especially at the end.

Nothing really struck me as being obviously wrong with it. The first sentence seemed awkward the first time I read it, but in the end it didn't really affect anything, and in hindsight worked rather well. It kind of plants the image in the reader's mind of this being an everyday event at first, and then evolving into something really powerful, and think it might show rather well the how your apathy was given a good shake from walking into the room to walking out.

You did a pretty good job on this, and I would be suprised if you didnt get a good grade on it.

BTW, that sounds like a wicked powerful memorial. What a way to remember them and get people to care. Unfortunately, the one thing I've heard about it other than your account was of my friend's screaming at each other in faux German and goose-stepping around on a field trip there. (sigh)

Well, good job.
He thrusts his fists against the posts
And still insists he sees the ghosts

www.myspace.com/penofwrath




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 72
Since you said it "was" an essay I'll assume you've already handed it in for a grade. But because I've been spoken to by two holocause victims I'll crit. ^_^

Dreamgirl wrote:they bear testimony of the human beings who wore them moments before they died.


I suggest you take out the "beings" and just put "people". It seems odd to me to leave it as "human beings". Though, that could just be me.

Dreamgirl wrote:In that room of shoes taken from concentration camp victims

This phrase is a really awkward sentence. It's too long and you could make it simpler. Though I don't really know how, I do suggest rephrasing that sentence.

Dreamgirl wrote: Leaning up against the bridge railing I was tempted to reach slowly out and brush my tingling finger tips against the old leather.

You don't need the details in this line, it works fine without them. You could change it to "I was tempted to reach out and brush my fingertips against the aged leather." Aged sounds a bit better as opposed to old.

Dreamgirl wrote:What had they done to deserve death? The answer that breaks my heart still is that they were Jewish, and they were born unfairly into a hateful world.


I don't really like the fact that you pose a question in this paragraph. And I suggest you take out the "born unfairly" and simply put "born". They were born into a hateful world just as much as we were and our own children will be. So to say it was unfair is a bit demeaning to them and prideful of our own stance. We have unfair treatment of people everywhere. They weren't the only ones born into it. We were too. Okay, sorry, ranting.

Dreamgirl wrote: My sympathetic heart shattered and in that moment whatever faith I had left in mankind was abolished.

You already mentioned your heart being broken before, its repetitive to say it again. Rephrase it.

Dreamgirl wrote:And yet... in many ways I was given hope. Hope that through what I had now witnessed I would no longer be afraid to stand up for what I believe in.


Take out the ellipses (...) and merge the sentences together.

Dreamgirl wrote:As I stared down at that little pink shoe I understood why one must speak up, why exactly one must be heard. The reason? Because if you remain silent eleven million people could die.


Take out the exactly and merge the last two sentences. "The reason?" is a fragment and I don't think questions add to the composition.

Dreamgirl wrote:Those words will be engraved on my soul for an indefinite amount of time.


Instead of saying an "indefinite amount of time" just say "forever" far more simple and puts the exact same point across to the reader.

Okay. That's the end of my crit. You aren't too bruised are you? Hope this helps you somehow! I did like it though, the closing with the quote and your statement was a nice way of finishing this piece.

LUNA
I cannot name this
I cannot explain this
and I really don't want to
just call me shameless.

-Ani Di Franco "Shameless"




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 890
Reviews 18
Hey thanks for the critic, and no you didn't bruise me, lol I like being ripped on sometimes :P And as for the part with the rant when I said "Unfairly" I totally see what you mean. I feel bad that comes across the way it does I really didn't mean for it to be that way. The funny thing is as I reread it I'm not even sure why I put that.

But anyway thanks for the critic it was awesome!!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 171
wow emotional subject. How did you find out about the info etc??
I think its well done... keep up the good work.
When did I realize I was God? Well, I was praying and I suddenly realized I was talking to myself. - Peter O'Toole




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 890
Reviews 18
Thanks :D

The info? Well I mean most of it is my feelings when I went there. But I guess if there are facts about the Holocaust and stuff because I won this essay contest Holocaust Remembrance thing, and I spent a week with seven survivors.

Thanks again!!!



Find wonder in the everyday, find everyday language to articulate it.
— Maurice Manning