Here's what I could come up with -
@FireEyes - cinnamon swirl
@Spearmint - mint oreo
@Quillfeather - marshmallow fudge
@gremlingeodes - coffee cocoa swirl
@weathervane - earl grey vanilla bean
@Liminality - lemon graham cracker
@Elinor - red velvet
@BluesClues - raisin bran crunch (thinking of a flavor Edna might like!)
@GengarIsBestBoy - Blueberry Pie
@Meshugenah - monster cookie
@keystrings - key lime pie
@Rook - chocolate chip raspberry swirl
@AilahEvelynMae - pumpkin spice
@OrabellaAvenue - cotton candy
FireEyes wrote:what if we started tagging people and described them as ice cream?...Imma do it
@MomoMajesty: Cotton Candy with rainbow Sprinkles
@LadyMysterio: Black Cherry
@Carina: All the flavours that mesh well together at once with a single brownie on top
Link to original comment
Can anyone add some more YWSers and Ice Cream flavors to our lists?

Sep 19, 2023
I totally didn't look up ice cream flavors to get ideas... totally...
@alliyah - maple walnut
@GengarIsBestBoy - is waffle a flavor? If not, mint oreo
@vampricone6783 - pumpkin spice
@Ari11 - ice cream sandwich
@CarrotWrites - carrot, of course! (or caramel)
@IcyFlame - raspberry
@Liminality - pistachio
@alpacaboss - cotton candy
@Spearmint - mint!
@LuminescentAnt - strawberry
@ariah347 - cinnamon
@TheCornDogEnthusiast - butterscotch
@foxmaster - orange cream
@yosh - cookies and cream
@Rinisha - cake batter
I just went with flavors that I thought matched what little I know of everyone - also their general color scheme that I associate them with.
Sorry if I didn't mention you! I swear it's not because I don't like you.