I. NITPICKS
nightshine wrote:"The first day of school." I said quietly to myself with a sense of dread . My name is Louis Nightshine. I'm your typical 13 year old eighth grade student with you typical parents, friends and life. My life was pretty boring, just living from day to day. There wasn't anything very distinguishing about my appearance. There was one thing though, on the back of my neck. I had a strange marking that sort of resembled a V-shape. My parents called it a birth mark but it has always intrigued me.
I will reiterate. This is one big, info-dump. This is not a character profile - this is the first chapter of your book. The thing that hooks in your readers. Info-dumps bore readers even if the information is informative and very crucial to the character. Why? Because you're telling us all this stuff rather than letting us learn this by you showing us this through your novel. If you are writing a book/novel/novella you have plenty of time to tell us what your character looks like. It's not needed on the first page.
"Hey Lou!" One of my friends called to me as I walked into the big brick building that was my school. It was more a prison than a school, I thought. I walked over to my friend. "Yo steve! Have a nice summer? I didn't see you all that much." I asked. "Well maybe If you would get your head out of a book once in a while, you would have! Anyway, when was the last time you got a haircut? Your head looks like a brown mop!" he said. "yeah, yeah." I replied, briefly shrugging off the comment. "Hey, I got to go. I'll see you later?" We exchanged our goodbyes and went our seperate directions.
Break this up and use capitilization! Whenever someone starts talking you use a new paragraph. Like this:
"Hey Lou!" I called out to one of my friends.
"Yo steve!" Have a nice summer? I didn't see you all that much..." I asked. etc.
Most of the clubs, groups, or electives I found uninteresting or too physically demanding of me because I wasn't very big. There were things like Football, Soccor, Baseball, Wrestling, and others. I wouldn't totally suck but I wouldn't exel in any of them either so I didn't bother. But I had to pick at least 3 ways to spend my time besides my regular schedule. I began to sift through the choices in my head. There was a book club. As soon as I saw that I signed up immediately. I loved books. I loved everything about them. It's as if inside every book are new and exciting characters, a new world, a new universe! They're so unpredictable. The moment I picked up a book and began to read my mind would become a canvas and detailed and adventure filled pictures would fill it as quickly as water flows from a waterfall. I read a lot. My room is filled with books. I read them to get away from my boring, uneventful life. I began to look through the list again. I figured that it might be interesting to join the school newspaper. I signed up for that too, I was about to sign up for a gardening and landscaping club in the hope that we would install a pond or two. Beside reading, there aren't that many things on this earth that I enjoy, but I am very relaxed when I see still water. Just a silent, still, pond so still that it looks like a sheet of glass. I find that very relaxing. But I never signed up for that club, because I looked at the other names on the list and I saw a name. written in terrible handwriting was the name "Mike Liller".
You took this directly out of the un-edited version right? Anyways, another big info-dump.
II. OVERALL IMPRESSION
I guess this was better than that last one, but you didn't really change much. You still used all the info-dumps that your past reviewers specifically pointed out. This seriously needs some pruning. Remember, show don't tell it's the difference between:
EXAMPLE OF TELLING wrote:Sarah hates red muffins. They remind her of blood.
EXAMPLE OF SHOWING wrote:Sarah glared at the red muffin on her plate for a few moments in silence.
"Eat Sarah," I said. "You love muffins."
"No," she grunted shoving the plate away from her.
"Sarah, you have to eat...please..."
I pushed the plate two her and broke the muffin in half and placed one of the severed pieces in her hand. She screeched as soon as my hand pulled away.
'"No! No! Blood!"
See t he second one conveys to the reader that Sarah doesn't like red muffins and it doesn't break up the flow of the story. It's just a morning breakfast with Sarah and then she has a reaction. Instead of a morning breakfast and then a sentence explaining her aversion to red muffins.
Points: 890
Reviews: 99
Donate