Young Writers Society

Whatcha! I would love to hear your interpretation of this poem, since it looks like readers are taking it in a few different directions.

I interpreted the poem to be about someone struggling with emotional extremes, perhaps bipolar disorder, or anxiety, or just events continually coming at them unexpectedly. The emotions I get from it are a lot of trepidation at the beginning especially when the speaker is cautiously, cautiously dipping their hand into the water - only to realize it's boiling!

{ It reminds me of my grandma who used to be able to reach into a pot of boiling water to pull out tomatoes that she was boiling... she said that was the best way to keep them whole for canning. }

But definitely not a good sensation! And as a reader I can definitely get kind of a sense of that heart-racing feeling of "what's going to happen". I like that you also subvert expectations with instead of the speaker having a big reaction when they've encountered something they didn't expect, they just make a little note in their notebook -- it seems odd and removed and very unemotional compared to maybe how we'd expect them to react.

Interestingly I see some of the themes from your previous poems in this too! The alienation from the body (with the "numb appendage" and "five-pronged ice cube mold") and the theme of kind of second guessing one's self, and then also the scientific flair with the little technical notes about the water's freezing and the temperature being inconsistent / consistent.

For the last chunk of the poem I'm not sure the narrator is finding peace in realizing that things aren't what they expected, or coming to terms with the inconsistency, or if the end is them sort of giving up on the experiment altogether.

One tiny form suggestion -> is you could add a strike-through to "consistent temperature" to mimic what the speaker is doing with the words.

I liked the different letters / sizing you used for VERY HOT and very cold, to further illustrate the extremes between the two. And I'm impressed by how much emotion you were able to get into a poem that has a lot of sciencey language which isn't necessarally naturally emotive. Overall the imagery is easy to see / imagine and really slows down the moment being described too, heightening the drama - and I think that's a big strength of the piece.

I think the ending could be clarified a little bit on what the speaker's emotional conclusion in, but this is another good poem!

~ alliyah

Hi there, whatcha!

I interpreted this fascinating piece of yours along the lines of emotions. It's almost as though the speaker's feelings are inconsistent, and they are fumbling to adjust to their changing moods. This is highlighted by the apparent detachment of a science experiment and their observations about the temperature.

I'd say the biggest strength of the poem is the narrative and how you've unified the images around it to contrast the 'hot' and the 'cold'.

Language

I love how you've packed your descriptions with strong verbs like "trace" and "darts" and "heave". They make the imagery vivid, especially in lines like:

dragging the bucket
to the stove,
pulling at its molten rim . . .

molten rim [. . . ] frosty sides

surface taut with tension

surface tumultuous
with tangled tides

there's ice in there
i put some there

I'm not sure what this poem is meant to talk about, but hey, I'll try my best, yeah?
I think this is meant to talk about the tumultous mess that 2020 was, which sort of links with the frantic tone I was sensing. Finding a balance between hot and cold temperatures to find a medium is a perfect allegory for what this year was.

I hope this helped a little bit.
Here's to 2021, I guess ^w^
Also, I loved the format this was put in! It was gorgeous!

<3

IzzyWidgeon

We at the guild appreciate the light-hearted tone of this poem. You don't often see something like that in 2021 (course it's only been twelve days). This pail intrigues us. Our world is filled with sword and sorcery acts, however, it does not feel like that is how your world operates. We believe the pail to be some sort of metaphor for something, or perhaps, such as the case is with other poems we've reviewed, it is meant to simply be ridiculous (another thing we greatly appreciate).

"my pointer finger darts in before quickly retreating"

We like the personification, as well as vocabulary, of this sentence. It conveys the movement of our narrator's hand very well. We can see them in the mind's eye, tentatively jabbing a hand at this mysterious bucket. Very well written.

We also appreciate the alliteration of the "polar plunge" line in the very first verse. It rolls off the reader's tongue very well, giving a bouncy, jaunty feel to poem, lifting the overall tone of it.

As a whole, we like the feel of the poem, while at the same time being slightly confused by it. Everything a poem should do!

Sláinte,

The Cidrian Writer's Guild