Hiya, LordStar. Just popping in for another quick review.
Small nitpicks:
Today, however, a rainy Thursday, he let himself into Rhys' room, his silhouette a soft outline in the blue, dim light coming in through the window blinds. He was holding a piece of paper in his hand, practically vibrating with excitement.
"Rhys."
"What?" Rhys' voice was a bit hoarse from lack of use. He was curled up on the bed, his back to Ethan and his cover pulled to his shoulders.
This is a finicky point, but this story seems to be told in third-person limited, with Rhys as the viewpoint. If Rhys has his back to Ethan, how does he know what his silhouette looks like, or that he has a piece of paper in his hand? He might be able to hear the floorboards creaking as Rhys comes into the room, but visual description doesn't really fit.
"It's my fucking body," Rhys snapped, the end of his patience thin and frayed.
I'm not sure the bit in bold is necessary. It's kind of obvious from the dialogue that his patience has run out.
Regarding my general critiques, I think this chapter does a great job of exploring Rhys's depression and listnessness after the abortion. However, I would've liked the issue to be more explicitly present in his thoughts. Also - Ethan knows about the abortion, doesn't he? He seemed to, in the previous chapter. So I don't really know why he keeps asking what's wrong. That seems a bit shortsighted and insensitive of him - surely he must be able to tell that the abortion has unsettled Rhys a lot. I don't get why Rhys doesn't call him out on this at any point, even if it's just with a snappish 'what do you think is wrong?'
As with the previous chapter, I don't think you exploit and develop the central conflict of this chapter quite enough. When the self-harm comes up, the issue is dropped pretty quickly, and I can't visualise what the long-term effect of this argument will be. It's always tricky to write about characters when they're in the grip of depression or grief, because they tend to be passive by nature, which turns the plot more reactive than active. Hopefully this gallery showing is going to be an important development that changes the course of the plot. I also hope that the self-harm issue comes back in some meaningful way, because I can't imagine that Ethan would leave it alone.
That said, I still enjoyed reading this and like the grim reality of it. Rhys's response to the abortion feels fitting, and I hope it will continue to shape his actions. I gotta feel sorry for Ethan, too, even if he's not handling things that well. It's so hard to watch people hurt themselves and know you can't really do anything about it.
Keep writing!
~Pan
Points: 46598
Reviews: 641
Donate