Note: Yes, I know the pacing isn't great. Please review other parts of it.
Okay, so today I'm going to focus my review on your pacing. First of all,
NO LOL I'M JUST KIDDING XD can't wait to read this part!!! <3
"We're bound to find something out here! Not only does the Clan need it, but it'll show off our skills to our mentors."
Yup, and I think more than showing off your skills is going to happen xD
"Hush, mousebrains."
OH MY GOSH MOUSEBRAINS LOL I love that insult xD
something I noticed is that the word "pelt" comes up a lot. like with a bunch of other words, it's hard to find alternatives since you're restricted to cat words :p you could try replacing some of them with wool, fur, coat, or something similar. or you could try to avoid using any word altogether, just having the action! just some ideas for you to consider c:
After a while, each of the apprentices had caught something-
JUST A RANDOM SUGGESTION, maybe you could specify what "after awhile" means? either by giving a specific time frame, or maybe something like "after the sun had started bleeding into the night" or whatever suits your fancy c"
Pinkpaw dropped her fish and leaped forward, claws unsheathed. "I'm coming!"
YESS PINKPAW, UNLEASH YOUR AWESOMENESS!! :D
Pinkpaw nodded and bounded off towards the old cat's yowls for help. At last, she saw his dark brown head bobbing above the water as he clinged to a tree branch.
if you're looking for spots to improve your pacing, this might be a nice spot! You said "at last," but it doesn't really feel like Pinkpaw was looking for a long time. You could create tension here by describing how Pinkpaw searched desperately in the waters, but perhaps pounding rain blinded her vision, or something like that! I know you said you don't want reviews on your pacing xD but I just thought I'd like to point this out as a nice spot that might help that while also creating tension! ^_^
"Slide your claws into my paws and hang on. I can handle the pain."
Aww, this is a touching and sweet moment in all of the chaos <3
"Hang on," the she-cat grunted, slowly backing up.
Once the tom was on solid ground again
This could be another spot to create a smoother transition. Maybe you could have Pinkpaw traveling a farther distance before she's able to set the cat down? I really don't think your pacing is bad; I think you're selling yourself short there. I think the main thing is that it doesn't feel "dramatic" or "omg everyone is going to die," you know? xD I think dramatizing what is going on, making the reader scared for everyone's lives (lol), and making the scenes more exciting can help you. It will also make Pinkpaw's warrior name receiving thing seemed SUPER well earned!!
The sky was still dark and swollen
I love the idea of the sky being swollen -> what a neat thought!
They have trained hard to understand the ways of your noble code, and I commend them to you as a warrior in their turn. Do you both promise to uphold the warrior code and to protect and defend your Clans, even at the costs of your lives?"
I think something that might be helpful is to explain a bit more about this ceremony, especially since you might have readers who haven't read the original series. Like maybe a cat gasps when they learn that this ceremony is happening, because it's an honour? and then you could reveal stuff about the ceremony through the cat's dialogue, making them go like "wow, cats only get this when they've done something super awesome" or "usually cats get their warrior name later in life" or something I don't know xD
I think another nice thing would be to get some emotions from Pinkpaw and Minnowpaw. this may not be 3rd person omniscient, so maybe the reader won't get to know their thoughts directly - but we could learn something through their expressions. for example, if their eyes where shining, or if their paws were trembling from nervousness and excitement, or if they wore bright smiles. whatever comes to your mind :)
AHHHH THEY GOT THEIR WARRIOR NAMES :O I don't really know the significance of that since I haven't read the original, but it sounds like such an honour 0.0 and the last statement from Ripplepaw makes me think that too! so I really liked how you included that last bit ^^ a subtle way to show how important the warrior name is to the cats of the River Clan <3
I'm so proud of the two cats, they all grow up too fast :')
Points: 29825
Reviews: 465
Donate