Hey inktopus,
Shady back again for another review on this lovely novel you have posted. Let's get started...
Panting, Asha looked up at the night sky,
Why is she panting? Were they running? Cause I wasn't getting the impression that they were running... and if not, why is she panting? Just because of the fear/apprehension of being caught? That would make sense as well, but I feel like it would be good to imply that heavier so we understand better.
the moon, round and full like a silver coin caught mid-flip in the sky.
This is really beautiful imagery <3 Great job!
Black hair streamed behind her like dark water, headless of the gravity that slowly seemed to be pulling Asha to the ground.
Lol I think you mean heedless. Heedless = reckless lack of care or attention. Headless = without having a head.
~ ~ ~
I really like this chapter. It almost had a cinematic quality to it, and I had a very vivid image of the girls' flight and then the discussion between them. It was borderline over-dramatic (especially in the dialogue in the barn), like it almost felt like Yuni was going to confess her whole life story and that life story would be that she has no family and needs Asha to be her friend etc. But I think you pulled it off fine -- just be sure that you keep emotions consistent, don't have too many jolts of emotion or you'll jar your reader.
I do like the friendship you are forging here, however. I am a huge sucker for strong female protagonists, especially ones who come from a minority group. But I mean everyone needs rescuing sometimes (even awesome strong women) so I really like that you had another strong woman fill that role. I feel like it's often tempting for authors to toss a guy in at that point in a novel -- cause I mean COME ON built in love interest, amirite? But I like you having another woman there instead. It sets the stage for having a novel filled with a beautiful sisterhood and I'm excited for that.
As I mentioned in a previous chapter I would like more physical descriptors of your characters. I mean now I know that Asha is a POC, but I dunno much else about her at this point. Is she chubby? Slender? Petite? Does she have a big nose? What color are her eyes? How does she style her hair? How long is her hair? Same thing for Yuni. I feel like you might have briefly described her, but I don't really remember that either, so she could be improved upon by giving us a better mental image of what we should be imagining when we read her.
Honestly, I have a Korean friend named Yuna which is probably skewing my mental image -- but between her dialogue and her name I am very much imagining a Korean girl in the character of Yuni -- pale skin, black hair, you know? If that's not the mental image you're going for, you should very much make an effort to counter that with the correct view of Yuni.
I think that's all I have for now. This was an excellent chapter, as usual.
Keep writing!
~Shady
Points: 2806
Reviews: 935
Donate