Hiya, Oli! Another quick review.
There's definitely a disconnect between this scene compared to the first half of the chapter. They don't feel connected at all, and you don't give us quite enough description to guide us from one location to another, so it took me a while to visualise where the characters were. There's a marked lack of description throughout the whole scene, come to think of it. It's very dialogue-heavy, which is fine, but I'd like a few more lines and details to help me transition between the locations. Maybe mention the warmth of the apartment, or the smell of tomatoes and garlic from the kitchen; I didn't immediately realise that they'd gone inside, so you could signpost it a bit better.
It's odd that the meeting didn't come up at all - I'd expect that to be the first thing Ethan asked about. I think my understanding of the whole conversation with Turner and such was a little lost on me, seeing as I must have missed the chapter where Rhys slept with them. Lip is annoying me. I know Rhys hasn't exactly been acting brilliantly in this whole situation, but Lip's got a lot of nerve acting so snarky after how he treated Rhys. Like Bisc says, I don't really get why Leah is acting so judgy either. It doesn't seem that in-character for her
I don't find it that realistic that Turner would cosy up to Rhys in front of other people and start making suggestive comments. Especially when he doesn't really know him. Rhys is with a friend, as well, which would probably make him less approachable.
This segment doesn't make a huge impression on me, overall. Rhys doesn't really do much, and it is pretty low stakes after the big turning point in the first half of the chapter. I'd like you to keep up the momentum from that scene, focus more on how Rhys feels about it, and how it's going to impact him going forward. In this segment, we're back to Rhys reacting rather than acting, so while it's a decent enough scene and it raises some mysteries (about Lip's true feelings, particularly) it doesn't feel like it fits here.
That's all for now. Keep writing!
~Pan
Points: 46598
Reviews: 641
Donate