good evening- or whatever time it is when you have a chance to read this; i'm just here to drop by for a quick review.
this short story seems to be a sort of self-reflective short story, which i always enjoy as i tend to dabble in those myself.
this short story to me is about wanting attention. the main character is recounting a night to the reader when they seemingly walked around in public trying to make eye-contact/interact with strangers. as someone who hates people looking at me, i find this perspective really interesting.
I had wondered why I felt so wonderful when a stranger smiled and looked me in the eye. Maybe it was because someone, who never knew my past mistakes, saw something in me I couldn't see in myself.
these first two sentences here in the short story really hooked me, because i found middle school me kind of relating. when you meet new people, you can present yourself in whatever way you want; those new people don't know your past, and oftentimes if they have never heard about you, you have complete control over their perception of you. when i transferred schools, i felt like i was able to finally 'fix' the juvenile perception people had of me during elementary. so i find myself relating to this feeling described here.
for me, the story took a sort of turn at the fourth paragraph with the mention of the book from the bible, especially because i don't often find people quoting that particular book. at that point, the story went from a reflection on seeking out validation from others to a religious reflection on fixing this 'problem,' which was definitely something i didn't expect. it seems the message of the story is to stop seeking validation from others and to put god first.
i went ahead and looked up the verse to read it and further understand the story. i included the following verse because it helped me understand what the verse meant even further
ecclesiastes 11:9-10
You who are young, be happy while you are young, and let your heart give you joy in the days of your youth. Follow the ways of your heart and whatever your eyes see, but know that for all these things, God will bring you into judgement. So then, banish anxiety from your heart and cast off the troubles of your body, for youth and vigor are meaningless.
the main character of the story says to themselves in order to assure themselves of their actions that it was fine because,
Didn't it say in Ecclesiastes to enjoy being young? It felt like I had never enjoyed being young like this; I was never reckless, never ready to give away my heart or break someone else's
after reading the verse, it felt like the purpose of the mention of this verse was to show the main character misinterpreting the it to justify their actions, especially because later in the story the main character reflects on their actions and decides that they should be fulfilled with just their god. to me, the verse seems to be a sort of warning against following your heart, which lines up with other biblical verses such as Jeremiah 17:9-10 which reads:
The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately wicked: who can know it? I the LORD search the heart, I try the reins, even to give every man according to his ways, and according to the fruit of his doings.
if i were to improve this piece, i would suggest further exploring why exactly the main character is going out and about. at the beginning of the story, it seems like the main character is simply walking around the town because they like getting attention from strangers. however, at the end of the story, there's strong implications that the main character was actually also looking for a love interest. i would recommend showing that in the beginning portion of the piece, because in the beginning it seems like the main character's aim is to simply boost their confidence or make new friends.
another thing i would consider changing would be the tenses in the second to last paragraph. you wrote:
I realized that maybe I'm an attention-seeker. Maybe I need constant validation. Maybe I used to forget that God's love was enough.
for me, in this case, i think it would make sense to write: "Maybe I forgot that God's love was enough." with this tense, the sentence is saying that in that particular moment, the main character forgot this fact. i also think that this could work if it was written as: "Maybe I forget that God's love is enough," thus implying that it's not a one time thing, and every so often the main character forgets this fact. the way it's written with the 'used to' makes it sound like the main character will never ever forget this fact again, which i feel like is a little unrealistic.
overall, thanks for sharing this short story. i was able to follow along with the main character's train of though very well. the lesson, though unexpected, was able to tie everything together in the end.
Points: 201
Reviews: 37
Donate