Sacred! I sat down this morning to knock out my reviews for the week and thought to myself, what should I review? And I remembered I had more chapters of your story to review and got so excited. And it did not disappoint!
First things first (and lordie I hate nitpicks so much but I want to mention this cause the line itself is so fab):
He tied his spaghetti into bows, his tied ties into bows, his victims intestines into bows, even his tail into bows.
I am a BIG FAN of this kind of description and sentence structure. I'm a fool for lists. I'm especially a fool for lists that end unexpectedly, which you're so close to here. The item "his victims intestines into bows" is so creepy and specific and telling, however since it's buried in the list instead of at the end it loses some of its impact.
A good rule of thumb for ANY punchy line is to put it at the end of a paragraph. And the punchiest bit goes at the end of a sentence. So here, I would swap things around like:
"He tied his spaghetti into bows, his ties into bows, his victims intestines into bows."
I'm a bit wishy-washy on whether "his tail into bows" ought to go before "his victims intestines into bows" or be left out altogether. There's a certain rhythm at work with these three and my head can't wrap around sliding "his tail into bows" into that rhythm. But that's me! Maybe something else sounds better in your head. Anyway, if it were me I'd also end the paragraph at this sentence, and make the rest of the paragraph it's own paragraph. Wherever you put the punchiest part of a paragraph, everything that comes after it is dulled. Which is why you're supposed to always put the most important detail at the end of a paragraph ("supposed to" -- every rule can and should be broken when it makes sense). But I think you can also get away just fine with leaving the paragraph as it is. It's up to you!
Anyway, grammar/structure ramble over.
I was definitely not expecting to switch into another character's perspective, let alone a DEMON, but I am totally on board. You do a really solid job of keeping us in the same story by connecting us back into Nei Li, and by using this chapter with these characters as an opportunity to expand upon our understanding of Nei Li since it appears this whole story will circle around this strange old man. Kudos!
I don't really have any CRITIQUE of this chapter, because I think it's really solid as it stands within my understanding of the story (sometimes it's hard to comment on how well things function until you have the whole story laid out in front of you, so expect me to continue to return to earlier chapters as I review later chapters, and so forth ). I DO wonder, though, about the length you've chosen for your chapters.
These first two chapters, at least, have been short and snappy which is perfectly acceptable and fine! There are no rules on chapter length. I just want us to think about chapter arc, as well as story arc, for a moment. So, stories obviously have arcs to them (character, plot, etc! beginning, middle, end!) but something that took me ages to learn, even though in hindsight it seems quite obvious, is that chapters should also have arcs. Even when a chapter is one sustained scene, like this one, there should be a clear rising of action toward a mini-climax, and something to push us toward the next chapter.
Here, we've got a strong skeleton for that kind of arc. We meet two new characters who are in the process of doing something questionable to a young woman they have presumably captured. Stakes rise as it's revealed they have to kill her, and as we begin to learn a bit more about them they receive instructions to go after a character we've already met, Nei Li, who we learn they will attempt to kill (even though he doesn't match their usual target, which is ripe with great story tension). I think, though, there are a few places where this chapter could expand to fill out this arc and make it even stronger.
For example, I'm a little confused about what these demons are doing specifically (what's the purpose of it) and who they're doing it for. There's mention of a rebellion and a war. Are they a part of the rebellion? Who are they rebelling against? You can give us brief answers to questions like these that don't go into a long backstory if you're not ready to give away all that information. But understanding the stakes these demons are up against (what do they want, what do they have to do, what will happen to them if they don't get what they want or do what they've been instructed to do, etc) will really ramp up this chapter and draw readers even further into your story.
Overall, I really enjoyed this chapter. Looking forward to reading more!
Keep writing!
--Lauren
Points: 370
Reviews: 541
Donate