z

Young Writers Society


E - Everyone

Chapter 12.2: Aleveri

by Lightsong


After the ceremony was over, Ilami grabbed Aleveri’s hand. ‘There’s something I need to tell you,’ she said, rising. ‘It’s important.’

As Aleveri stood up, she patted Ilami’s hand. ‘I have to meet with the natron first. Mrs. Venaria told me I should do that after the event.’ She tilted her head, smiling. ‘But I think you can come with me.’

Ilami groaned. ‘I don’t want to meet Mother, and I definitely don’t want to meet the priest. Oh well.’

Both of them walked towards the stage. Students started to exit the place. Most teachers went out as well, accompanying the priests. Mrs. Venaria and Natron Kestari were the only ones who made no effort to move, waiting at their place for the arrival of Aleveri and Ilami.

Once Aleveri and Ilami reached them, Mrs. Venaria spoke. She gestured to Ilami. ‘Here is the student I have been talking about. Aleveri Uora.’ She smiled, then focused at Ilami. ‘And that is my daughter, Ilami.’

Aleveri bowed. Ilami followed, though Aleveri could sense the subtle force she put into the posture. ‘It’s my honor to meet you, Natron Kestari,’ Aleveri said. ‘To be honest, I’m not sure why you need to meet someone like me, an average student.’

Natron Kestari chuckled. ‘You’re too humble, child. I have heard from Mrs. Venaria about your profound healing skill. It has been a while since an Uora studied in the academy. I’m sure we will have a genius in the healing department soon.’

‘May the Naturals permit,’ Aleveri replied.

‘Ah, I can see why Serra blessed you with remarkable healing ability,’ Natron Kestari said, nodding. ‘There is kindness in your words; intelligence indeed glimmers in your eyes. I hope we will meet again, Ms. Aleveri. There will be a time when I myself are in need of your skill.’ He turned to Mrs. Venaria. ‘It slips my mind, but I think some of my priests have come up with an idea to fasten the progress of our project. You have to hear it immediately.’

‘Very well. We will meet again, Ms. Aleveri.’ With that, both of them left Aleveri and Ilami.

‘So rude,’ Ilami said.

‘Hmm?’

‘They didn’t even speak of me once!’ Ilami frowned. ‘I thought Mother would do more than introduce me to the Natron. It was like I didn’t exist.’

‘They’re pressed for time,’ Aleveri said. Grabbing Ilami’s arm, they went out of the hall. ‘Didn’t you say you don’t like priests? We’ll meet him again, anyway.’ I don’t intend to spend time with him alone.

Maybe she read the Natron wrong, but after the conversation with him, Aleveri could see how his eyes reflected truer than his gestures or voice. There was a mystery in there, one she didn’t dare to know. And what about him needing her skills? Surely a few Serra-blessed joined the church. Naturals didn’t interfere with humans’ activities regularly. In fact, they usually connected with their people through their priests. Because of their rare intervention, some people chose to worship the god who didn’t give them the blessing.

As per her insistence, they went to Ilami’s room, passing the dorm which was magically-enhanced to be brighter and warmer than the rest. Ilami’s roommate was out as she usually did at the end of weekdays. Ilami’s bed was neat as usual. The white blanket and brown pillows were arranged at the corner of it, and the writing equipment were put inside a cylindrical case on the study stable. Aleveri inhaled deeply, smelling a hint of jasmine fragrance Ilami had sprayed around the room. It wasn’t strong, but its difference with Aleveri’s lavender made it refreshing.

‘What is it you want to talk to me about?’ Aleveri asked, sitting beside Ilami on the bed. She gasped. ‘Is it something to do with Haka? Did you find his dark secret?’

‘I - no, of course not,’ Ilami said. She adjusted the robe on her lap. ‘It’s something else. It’s about me.’

Taking a deep breath, she told Aleveri her past. How Mrs. Venaria’s servant, Jaxin, had been training her. At the end of her lessons, Mrs. Venaria gave her a final task. She was to beat a stranger. The twist was she didn’t know when and where it would happen, but suffice to say, when it happened, she wasn’t prepared. She ended up running away from the man, and when she managed to catch him off-guard instead and used the element of surprise to beat him, he revealed a horrible truth to her. Beating him wouldn’t give her the victory.

She had to kill him.

Aleveri’s eyes went wide hearing that, her hand covering her mouth. Ilami looked guilty when she talked about murdering the man - it was clear. And yet... she did it. Regretful or not, she killed the man. She was so young and she succeeded in ending one’s life. Even if she was forced, she shouldn’t have the capacity to kill.

‘How could you do it?’ she asked.

‘I didn’t have other choice,’ Ilami said. ‘It was either me or him.’

‘You killed him. You could choose to spare him and fail the test. You didn’t need to take someone’s life just to pass it.’

‘I -’ Ilami bit her lips. ‘I didn’t think of that. But in my defense, the man asked for it. To save his family who were in Mother’s grasp.’

Aleveri shook her head. Ilami didn’t think failure was a choice? In a situation where the man couldn’t harm her but she could him, she didn’t think it wasn’t worth it to taint her hands with blood just for Mrs. Venaria’s approval? If Mrs. Venaria was capable to hold the information about the true nature of the test back from her, how could she be certain the man’s family would be safe once he died? The way Ilami saw it, his death allowed Mrs. Venaria to do whatever she wanted with them.

Looking down, she forced her trembling hands to stay still.

‘His name is Zivil Ayesis.’

Aleveri’s head snapped up to the name. ‘Ayesis... Father to Dayel Ayesis, the dead student?’

Ilami nodded slowly.

Aleveri rubbed her face and massage her temples. Her head started to ache. This is all too much, she thought. I’m supposed to be a healer. How can I concentrate on treating people when I have to deal with this?

Ilami grabbed her hand, forcing her to look at Ilami. Ilami’ eyes were glassy. ‘I know I’ve done something wrong, Aleveri, and I’d never forgive myself for it. I’ll remember it until the end of my life, but doing that won’t solve the issue here. Mother instructed me to kill. She silenced the others affected by Dayel’s death. Rumors had it Alyosha was the cause of Arafel’s death, which Mother hushed down. There was something wrong with the Restricted Area both students entered, and I along with Gael and Haka needed your help to find out what was it.’

The last part shook Aleveri’s away from her dwelling of Ilami’s killing. ‘It’s insane to enter the Restricted Area when you know both students died because of that. And you want my help... to heal?’

Ilami nodded.

‘Then that means you’re not confident with your plan. You suspect there’s a high chance one of you is going to get hurt, and I can heal whoever that would be without alerting the school. So many risks and so flawed is the plan.’

Ilami’s face reddened. ‘We haven’t finished planning yet. I assure you we’re going to consider everything about it.’

Aleveri kept her silence, thinking. Not about the part of her involvement because it was as clear as the sky she wouldn’t help. She wasn’t a risk taker, and she certainly wouldn’t want to venture into something that was potentially fatal. But this was Ilami, and she so much wanted Ilami to be her friend. It wasn’t that she didn’t have ones; it was just that Ilami was the only one who was honest with her and paid attention to what she said. The rest, they wanted her to help them in their school works.

What would I get out of this if I accept? she thought. What would Ilami give that I want so much?

Surprisingly, it didn’t take long for her to find the answers.

‘I’ll help you,’ she said, prompting a weak smile to creep to Ilami’s face, ‘but with one condition.’

‘What is it? I’ll do anything you want,’ Ilami said, earnest vibrating in her voice.

Aleveri squeezed Ilami’s hands hard. ‘Promise me you will never kill again, no matter who demands you to do so. Especially not when you want to do so. If you have to kill to save someone’s life, then find another way that doesn’t involve that. Continue to do so until you find one. If you have to kill to defense yourself from someone, find a way to stop her from killing you. Knock her out or threat her. I don’t care. As long as you do not kill.’

Ilami stared at Aleveri, her mouth stayed still. Then, she squeezed Aleveri’s hands. ‘I promise you I will never kill again,’ she whispered.

Aleveri nodded, assured with Ilami’s guarantee. She didn’t want Ilami to be like Alyosha.


Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.







Is this a review?


  

Comments



User avatar
4100 Reviews


Points: 253913
Reviews: 4100

Donate
Tue Oct 26, 2021 7:28 am
View Likes
KateHardy wrote a review...



Good Morning/Afternoon/Evening/Night(whichever one it is in your part of the world),

Hi! I'm here to leave a quick review!!

First Impression: I really liked the ending to this chapter. We started it by getting to know Aleveri a bit better and now we get what I think is certainly a pretty accurate reaction by her to this whole plan and Ilami's shocking news. And there's just a hint of a interesting bit of information at that very last line.

Anyway let's get right to it,

After the ceremony was over, Ilami grabbed Aleveri’s hand. ‘There’s something I need to tell you,’ she said, rising. ‘It’s important.’

As Aleveri stood up, she patted Ilami’s hand. ‘I have to meet with the natron first. Mrs. Venaria told me I should do that after the event.’ She tilted her head, smiling. ‘But I think you can come with me.’

Ilami groaned. ‘I don’t want to meet Mother, and I definitely don’t want to meet the priest. Oh well.’


Okay...well, it looks like that didn't take long. One line into this and Ilami already wants to drag Aleveri off to tell her although not it does appear as if they're going to have to wait for just a little bit longer before getting back around to that conversation.

Both of them walked towards the stage. Students started to exit the place. Most teachers went out as well, accompanying the priests. Mrs. Venaria and Natron Kestari were the only ones who made no effort to move, waiting at their place for the arrival of Aleveri and Ilami.

Once Aleveri and Ilami reached them, Mrs. Venaria spoke. She gestured to Ilami. ‘Here is the student I have been talking about. Aleveri Uora.’ She smiled, then focused at Ilami. ‘And that is my daughter, Ilami.’


Hmm, well for all the suspicious and dislike that Aleveri showed earlier, she seems to be pretty good at hiding that here as she goes in and acts like everything is totally normal. Only Ilami seems to be making an effort to send a subtle message of dislike to either of the two there.

Aleveri bowed. Ilami followed, though Aleveri could sense the subtle force she put into the posture. ‘It’s my honor to meet you, Natron Kestari,’ Aleveri said. ‘To be honest, I’m not sure why you need to meet someone like me, an average student.’

Natron Kestari chuckled. ‘You’re too humble, child. I have heard from Mrs. Venaria about your profound healing skill. It has been a while since an Uora studied in the academy. I’m sure we will have a genius in the healing department soon.’

‘May the Naturals permit,’ Aleveri replied.


Hmm, well that's a bit too specific with the flattery there, I could just be influenced by the thoughts that Ilami had earlier but if I had to guess it looks like this Natron fellow is trying to make a case for eventually recruiting her for something specifically requesting her and doing praising her like that.

‘Ah, I can see why Serra blessed you with remarkable healing ability,’ Natron Kestari said, nodding. ‘There is kindness in your words; intelligence indeed glimmers in your eyes. I hope we will meet again, Ms. Aleveri. There will be a time when I myself are in need of your skill.’ He turned to Mrs. Venaria. ‘It slips my mind, but I think some of my priests have come up with an idea to fasten the progress of our project. You have to hear it immediately.’

‘Very well. We will meet again, Ms. Aleveri.’ With that, both of them left Aleveri and Ilami.

‘So rude,’ Ilami said.

‘Hmm?’

‘They didn’t even speak of me once!’ Ilami frowned. ‘I thought Mother would do more than introduce me to the Natron. It was like I didn’t exist.’


Oh, the priest definitely detected something and wanted to get out of there, you could see that very well in the sort of getaway that they made, if that wasn't a rushed excuse to run out of a place quickly, I don't know what is.

‘They’re pressed for time,’ Aleveri said. Grabbing Ilami’s arm, they went out of the hall. ‘Didn’t you say you don’t like priests? We’ll meet him again, anyway.’ I don’t intend to spend time with him alone.

Maybe she read the Natron wrong, but after the conversation with him, Aleveri could see how his eyes reflected truer than his gestures or voice. There was a mystery in there, one she didn’t dare to know. And what about him needing her skills? Surely a few Serra-blessed joined the church. Naturals didn’t interfere with humans’ activities regularly. In fact, they usually connected with their people through their priests. Because of their rare intervention, some people chose to worship the god who didn’t give them the blessing.


Okay...yeah well apparently she's having second thoughts after that...interesting, I for one only had those thoughts strengthened by the way he acted there. Also Ilami being annoyed there at being ignored is such a fun moment there, cause of how she at first hated having to go but then later still wanted to be noticed. It fits her personality nicely and its also a lovely touch of humor.

As per her insistence, they went to Ilami’s room, passing the dorm which was magically-enhanced to be brighter and warmer than the rest. Ilami’s roommate was out as she usually did at the end of weekdays. Ilami’s bed was neat as usual. The white blanket and brown pillows were arranged at the corner of it, and the writing equipment were put inside a cylindrical case on the study stable. Aleveri inhaled deeply, smelling a hint of jasmine fragrance Ilami had sprayed around the room. It wasn’t strong, but its difference with Aleveri’s lavender made it refreshing.

‘What is it you want to talk to me about?’ Aleveri asked, sitting beside Ilami on the bed. She gasped. ‘Is it something to do with Haka? Did you find his dark secret?’


Okayy...well, it looks like we get our first look at Ilami's rooom? I feel like we haven't seen that one yet, we've only seen Aleveri's and Gael's so that's a good addition. And I love that little almost inside joke of sorts there between the two friends suggesting they are pretty good friends here. Well let's hope it stays that way after what is to come next. :D

‘I - no, of course not,’ Ilami said. She adjusted the robe on her lap. ‘It’s something else. It’s about me.’

Taking a deep breath, she told Aleveri her past. How Mrs. Venaria’s servant, Jaxin, had been training her. At the end of her lessons, Mrs. Venaria gave her a final task. She was to beat a stranger. The twist was she didn’t know when and where it would happen, but suffice to say, when it happened, she wasn’t prepared. She ended up running away from the man, and when she managed to catch him off-guard instead and used the element of surprise to beat him, he revealed a horrible truth to her. Beating him wouldn’t give her the victory.


Well, so the story is being told for the third time, and I like how you make it much more of a summary for this. The previous one was a good reminder but because of how close that chapter was it it got repeated in this one, it would've ended up being a little boring. This is a nice way of bringing it across instead of that.

She had to kill him.

Aleveri’s eyes went wide hearing that, her hand covering her mouth. Ilami looked guilty when she talked about murdering the man - it was clear. And yet... she did it. Regretful or not, she killed the man. She was so young and she succeeded in ending one’s life. Even if she was forced, she shouldn’t have the capacity to kill.

‘How could you do it?’ she asked.

‘I didn’t have other choice,’ Ilami said. ‘It was either me or him.’

‘You killed him. You could choose to spare him and fail the test. You didn’t need to take someone’s life just to pass it.’


Well, I don't think Aleveri's logic there works, but I love to see the clash in the ideas there, how Ilami immediately thought only of the victory and never about potentially losing out on anything and then of course later there is the whole family in danger thing, but Aleveri immediately thinking of the non killing approach there shows just what sort of person she is.

‘I -’ Ilami bit her lips. ‘I didn’t think of that. But in my defense, the man asked for it. To save his family who were in Mother’s grasp.’

Aleveri shook her head. Ilami didn’t think failure was a choice? In a situation where the man couldn’t harm her but she could him, she didn’t think it wasn’t worth it to taint her hands with blood just for Mrs. Venaria’s approval? If Mrs. Venaria was capable to hold the information about the true nature of the test back from her, how could she be certain the man’s family would be safe once he died? The way Ilami saw it, his death allowed Mrs. Venaria to do whatever she wanted with them.


I think Aleveri is just a little shaken with the news there cause she doesn't seem to be thinking of this from Ilami's point of view. In the state of mind she was in and considering her age, she definitely did what she thought was the best option and I think she made the right choice.

Looking down, she forced her trembling hands to stay still.

‘His name is Zivil Ayesis.’

Aleveri’s head snapped up to the name. ‘Ayesis... Father to Dayel Ayesis, the dead student?’

Ilami nodded slowly.

Well, here we goo..now that connection also happens, so well, it should be very interesting to see Aleveri's reaction here. The good news is it looks like Aleveri is not going to immediately denounce her friendship, although she might just be too scared to say something like that, considering we see her thoughts, I don't think the latter is the case. So that part of things went well, but the reaction to what comes next is definitely the one to watch out for.

Aleveri rubbed her face and massage her temples. Her head started to ache. This is all too much, she thought. I’m supposed to be a healer. How can I concentrate on treating people when I have to deal with this?

Ilami grabbed her hand, forcing her to look at Ilami. Ilami’ eyes were glassy. ‘I know I’ve done something wrong, Aleveri, and I’d never forgive myself for it. I’ll remember it until the end of my life, but doing that won’t solve the issue here. Mother instructed me to kill. She silenced the others affected by Dayel’s death. Rumors had it Alyosha was the cause of Arafel’s death, which Mother hushed down. There was something wrong with the Restricted Area both students entered, and I along with Gael and Haka needed your help to find out what was it.’


Well, I like how Ilami holds nothing back despite Aleveri's reactions and just gone on telling her the whole truth, now at least Aleveri will know exactly what's going on and be able to make a proper decision there with all the facts.

The last part shook Aleveri’s away from her dwelling of Ilami’s killing. ‘It’s insane to enter the Restricted Area when you know both students died because of that. And you want my help... to heal?’

Ilami nodded.

‘Then that means you’re not confident with your plan. You suspect there’s a high chance one of you is going to get hurt, and I can heal whoever that would be without alerting the school. So many risks and so flawed is the plan.’


I do like how she focuses immediately on the danger of the Restricted Area there and tries to talk about that to get her mind off of the whole killing thing which does seem to be bothering her quite a bit so far despite her not being disgusted with Ilami at it.

Ilami’s face reddened. ‘We haven’t finished planning yet. I assure you we’re going to consider everything about it.’

Aleveri kept her silence, thinking. Not about the part of her involvement because it was as clear as the sky she wouldn’t help. She wasn’t a risk taker, and she certainly wouldn’t want to venture into something that was potentially fatal. But this was Ilami, and she so much wanted Ilami to be her friend. It wasn’t that she didn’t have ones; it was just that Ilami was the only one who was honest with her and paid attention to what she said. The rest, they wanted her to help them in their school works.


Aww...well that's a nice little moment to bring up, its a good little moment to perhaps show why these two became such fast friends despite mixed initial reactions and all in all, it makes for a really neat moment there as she considers all of this.

What would I get out of this if I accept? she thought. What would Ilami give that I want so much?

Surprisingly, it didn’t take long for her to find the answers.

‘I’ll help you,’ she said, prompting a weak smile to creep to Ilami’s face, ‘but with one condition.’

‘What is it? I’ll do anything you want,’ Ilami said, earnest vibrating in her voice.


Oooh, an ultimatum, did not expect Aleveri to come out with something like that, she doesn't seem the kind of person to do that sort of thing but considering what Ilami is asking of her, it would make sense for her to do this.

Aleveri squeezed Ilami’s hands hard. ‘Promise me you will never kill again, no matter who demands you to do so. Especially not when you want to do so. If you have to kill to save someone’s life, then find another way that doesn’t involve that. Continue to do so until you find one. If you have to kill to defense yourself from someone, find a way to stop her from killing you. Knock her out or threat her. I don’t care. As long as you do not kill.’

Ilami stared at Aleveri, her mouth stayed still. Then, she squeezed Aleveri’s hands. ‘I promise you I will never kill again,’ she whispered.

Aleveri nodded, assured with Ilami’s guarantee. She didn’t want Ilami to be like Alyosha.


Well this is quite a moment here, I feel like this is maybe going to test some boundaries in the times to come for these two in their friendship. At any rate, it also ends with a very interesting thought there by Aleveri...so let's to think about at the end of this piece here.

Aaaaand that's it for this one.

Overall: Overall, a pretty good ending to this chapter. It seems like there's going to be an excursion of some kind into the Restricted Area very soon with Aleveri also tentatively agreeing. Anyway, that's about all I have to say about this one. :D

As always remember to take what you think was helpful and forget the rest.

Stay Safe
Harry




User avatar
641 Reviews


Points: 46598
Reviews: 641

Donate
Sat Dec 30, 2017 8:15 am
View Likes
Panikos wrote a review...



Hi, Lightsong! Pan dropping in for a quick review. Suggested changes in blue.

Nitpicks

She gestured to Ilami. ‘Here is the student I have been talking about. Aleveri Uora.’ She smiled, then focused at Ilami. ‘And that is my daughter, Ilami.’


Did you mean to say she gestured to Aleveri?

Aleveri bowed. Ilami followed, though Aleveri could sense the subtle force she put into her posture.


I don't know how well 'followed' works here. 'Followed suit' would be better, or something like 'Ilami did the same'.

‘You’re too humble, child. I have heard from Mrs. Venaria about your profound healing skills.


There will be a time when I myself am in need of your skill.’


That's a pretty ominous thing to say! Makes it sound like he knows he's going to be grievously injured.

Maybe she read the Natron wrong, but after the conversation with him, Aleveri could see how his eyes reflected truer than his gestures or voice


You're still telling us about the Natron's unsettling properties rather than really showing them. There was nothing in his dialogue that made me think 'yeah, this guy is definitely shifty'. He just seemed a bit bland and formal. His character has made very little impression on me so far.

Because of their rare intervention, some people chose to worship the god who didn’t give them the blessing.


I agree with Mea that this line is quite confusing. It needs rephrasing to make the meaning clearer.

Ilami’s roommate was out, as she usually was at the end of weekdays.


I find it bizarre that we haven't actually met Ilami's roommate. It was a bit of a shock to realise that she's had one all this time. I'm not saying said roommate should be a mega-important character or anything, but I feel like we should've seen her at least in passing. Something to think about in future drafts.

It wasn’t strong, but its difference with Aleveri’s lavender made it refreshing.


Things are different to or different from something, not different with it.

‘Is it something to do with Haka? Did you find his dark secret?’


...What dark secret? Did they mention this before and I just can't remember it?

‘I didn’t have other choice,’ Ilami said. ‘It was either me or him.’

‘You killed him. You could choose to spare him and fail the test. You didn’t need to take someone’s life just to pass it.’

‘I -’ Ilami bit her lips. ‘I didn’t think of that. But in my defense, the man asked for it. To save his family who were in Mother’s grasp.’

Aleveri shook her head. Ilami didn’t think failure was a choice?


Okay, I'm pretty confused by this whole section. How can Ilami's reasoning be 'it was either me or him' when she was the one who had him at her mercy? And I thought the whole reason she killed the man was because Venaria had the man's family and would've killed them if Ilami hadn't murdered him? Why is she not impressing this on Aleveri more? It feels like you chop and change on Ilami's reasons for killing Zivil to try and give her extra justification, but actually you just muddy the motives and make it less clear.

I also don't get where the 'Ilami didn't think failure was a choice' line of thinking comes from, because failing the test would've meant the death of the man's family. Why doesn't Ilami tell Aleveri that? It's such a crucial detail. It's not like she just killed the guy because she didn't want to disappoint her mother; she killed him to try and minimise harm to others. Aleveri could still be unnerved that Ilami was able to bring herself to murder somebody, but I feel like the whole 'failure wasn't an option' claim is moot. However you slice it, Ilami wasn't thinking about herself in this situation.

I do understand Aleveri thinking that Ilami couldn't have been sure that killing the man would save his family. That's a valid point, one I'd expect Aleveri to raise. On the whole, though, I just found the whole scene a bit confusing. I didn't get why Ilami wasn't putting more emphasis on the fact that the man's family had been captured. I didn't get why Aleveri wasn't more shocked to learn that Venaria would hold innocents hostage for the sake of testing her daughter.

which Mother hushed down.


You hush things up, not down. Though 'down' does make a lot more sense. That's the English language for you.

There was something wrong with the Restricted Area both students entered, and I along with Gael and Haka needed your help to find out what was it.’


This is a bit of a messy sentence. Maybe rephrase it to something like:

Both of the students entered the Restricted Area before they died. There's got to be something strange happening in there, something Mother wants to keep secret. Gael, Haka and I need your help to find out what it is.

‘Then that means you’re not confident with your plan. You suspect there’s a high chance one of you is going to get hurt, and I can heal whoever that would be without alerting the school. So many risks and so flawed is the plan.


That last sentence is just a bit weird. It's syntactically strange - it should be something like 'the plan is so flawed and has so many risks', but even then I think it reads awkwardly. You don't need it.

It wasn’t that she didn’t have other friends; it was just that Ilami was the only one who was honest with her and paid attention to what she said.


The rest, they wanted her to help them with their schoolwork.


Surprisingly, it didn’t take long for her to find the answer.


Ilami said, earnest vibrating in her voice.


'Earnest' is an adjective, not a noun, so it doesn't work in this kind of structure. If I'm honest, I think you could delete the bold. I don't think it adds anything that the dialogue doesn't already give us.

If you have to kill to defend yourself from someone, find another way to stop her from killing you.


Knock her out or threaten her.


Ilami stared at Aleveri, her mouth stayed still.


Overall Thoughts

1) I like that Aleveri is shocked by the discovery that Ilami killed the man. It makes sense for her to be less forgiving than Gael. Her ultimatum at the end is naive but in-character, and it offers the opportunity for some grim character development. It would be interesting to see Aleveri realise that killing is sometimes the only option if you want to survive.

2) As mentioned in the nitpicks section, the scene where Ilami tells Aleveri about the killing needs some work. I don't get why Ilami doesn't lead with the crucial information that Venaria, according to the man, had his family held hostage, and that they would have been killed if the test didn't end with one of them killing the other. That's the cornerstone of why Ilami did what she did. Aleveri can say 'you should've chosen to fail the test' all she likes, but the fact remains that taking a moral stand would've resulted in more death than killing the man did. I do not for the life of me understand why Ilami doesn't stress this more.

I'm not saying Aleveri has to accept Ilami's actions just because, logically speaking, they were justified. Understanding that you have to kill is one thing; going through with it is another. It takes a certain kind of person to be able to steel themselves to kill. Aleveri, even if she knows deep down that Ilami's actions may have averted more suffering, can still be unnerved that Ilami was able to commit murder at all.

3) The ending of the chapter is strong. Mea is right that the grammar gets a bit sloppier, but I like the actual progression of events with Aleveri only agreeing to help subject to Ilami never killing again. Nevertheless, I feel like it would be better if Aleveri was actually more crucial to the plan. If she really was indispensable and they couldn't carry out the investigation into the Restricted Section without her, I feel like the agreement would pack more punch. At this point, she's only needed on the off-chance that one of them gets injured. They could theoretically carry out the plan without her. I'd prefer if they had a stronger reasoning to want her on side.

That's all for now. Pretty strong chapter, but I'm keen to get to the actual infiltration now. It feels like we've been in a slower, more transitional period for quite a long time now; I'm keen to get back to the action.

Keep writing! :D
~Pan




User avatar
1085 Reviews


Points: 90000
Reviews: 1085

Donate
Wed Dec 27, 2017 8:18 am
View Likes
Mea wrote a review...



Okay, so I decided to just go ahead and review the next part anyway. :D

‘May the Naturals permit,’ Aleveri replied.

What are her thoughts here? Does she dislike being formal or not mind it? Is she preoccupied with trying to confirm her suspicion that he's not genuine? Is she embarrassed by the attention?

‘They didn’t even speak of me once!’ Ilami frowned. ‘I thought Mother would do more than introduce me to the Natron. It was like I didn’t exist.’

Okay, I can't decide if this is actually hilarious or just weird because literally a minute ago Ilami was complaining about having to meet the priest, and now she's offended? I would have thought she'd be glad the interaction was so short. Either way, this comment makes her seem a little egotistical. Why would they talk a lot about her when Venaria wanted Aleveri, not Ilami, to come meet them?

Because of their rare intervention, some people chose to worship the god who didn’t give them the blessing.

I didn't quite follow this. Are you saying that because the gods sometimes intervene, people chose to worship them even if those gods don't give them a blessing?

The way Ilami saw it, his death allowed Mrs. Venaria to do whatever she wanted with them.

I think here you meant "Aleveri" instead of "Ilami." Also, this is pretty much what I've thought the whole time. It might make more sense for the man to say that if he was dead, Venaria wouldn't need his family as collateral to make sure the man obeyed, so they would be set free. I'm not sure how that fits with her covering up Arafel's death, though.

Ilami didn’t think failure was a choice? In a situation where the man couldn’t harm her but she could him, she didn’t think it wasn’t worth it to taint her hands with blood just for Mrs. Venaria’s approval?

Wow. This actually gave me chills. This objection fits in perfectly with Aleveri's character. Of course Ilami could have just decided to fail, and that's what Aleveri probably would have done in that situation. But the fact that we know Ilami didn't even think of it at the time speaks volumes about her character. Great job with that part.

I hope Aleveri doesn't get over learning that her friend has murdered someone too quickly. She had Ilami make a promise, but that shouldn't be the end of it. I want to see some ramifications - involuntarily, Aleveri will see Ilami differently and treat her slightly differently from this point forth. Also, by the end, she already feels too "back to normal." Everything in this chapter should have shaken her more than that. She has a lot to be worried about or shocked by, but although her shock is clear in the first half, the emotion in the last part is lacking.

The last third of the chapter had a lot more grammar mistakes than the rest of the chapter, so make sure to go through it carefully and check your verb tenses especially.

And that's about all I've got! Great chapter, very strong. I'm eager to get to the infiltration.





I have writer's block. I can't write. It is the will of the gods. Now, I must alphabetize my spice rack.
— Neil Gaiman