Hey, Vox. I'm Nonny and I'm going to review this for you. At the beginning, I know you mentioned that your professor hated the peice. Did you ever get a chance to ask him what the issue with it was? I know that professors are very hard on peices of work, especially in college or late high school classes. It helps to ask them what the issue is and then see if you can go back and fix it.
Within the first paragraph: You mention at the very end that it was a hot day in late June. I think that this should be in the first few sentences because it's description doesn't fit well in the end.
For example: It was a hot day in late June and today was one of the first of many that I would spend in this room. My mom was seated beside me in the gray, waiting-room style chairs facing toward a red-orange, tattered (or slightly brand-new, ect. insert descriptive word about rug) rug.
You could also write something about the training room in the first few sentences by writing that your legs were sticking to the chairs. In a hot day, your skin (if you're wearing shorts) would stick to leather seats (if they are). I think it's all about description in this paragraph. You don't lack them but I think it could be combined and shortened.
With this sentence: “Ready?” Deb asked. I realized she was talking to the dog. “Mack. Hey, pup-pup-pup,” she called in a singsong voice as she hunched to peer in at him.
I think that it wasn't really implied that Deb was talking to you in the story. Maybe you could write something along the lines of,
"Ready?" Deb asked. I swung my head around to look at her when I realized she was talking to the dog.
The blonde behemoth nestled in the crate cracked an eye; golden lashes parting to reveal a warm brown iris.
I love this sentence. I like the description within it and think that it worked very well and described the dog nicely.
Any reservations about leaving the crate put aside, Mack rose, stretching like one might expect of a large cat.
I think this should be written as:
Against any reservations he might have had about leaving the crate, Mack rose to his feet. His stretch reminded me of the one of a large cat.
We were connecting, in a way unlike the other dogs had with me.
Would be better written as:
We had a connection, in a way unlike any of the other dogs had with me.
The rest of the personal narrative is written well. I think that you did a great job at letting your professor know about an experience that you had. However, I think the reason your professor might not have enjoyed it is because a personal narrative, in my opinion, is about soemthing that happened to you. This is more of a story between you and your best friend, Mack. When I write personal narratives, I try to write something that is incredibly fascinating. I'm not saying this story isn't, because it's actually very touching. I love stories between animals and humans. I'm just saying that it may not have been the personal narrative your professor wanted. My suggestion is to go and ask him/her what she wanted from the story, as that is really the only true way to know for future reference in their class.
Keep writing!
- Nonny
Points: 4117
Reviews: 87
Donate