Hi Sunset! I know this is a quite old piece, but I'm working through the Review Checklist challenge this month, and you're the first person who left me a review when I joined YWS. So this may be a nice surprise if you ever pop back in ^^
Also, since this is an older piece, I'm sure your style of writing has grown with you. I'll make a few technical comments, but I'll focus more on the content of the piece, so that you can refine the ideas if you ever decide to revisit it ~ Let's jump in!
To start off, it took me a couple of paragraphs to figure out what the piece was about and who this narrator was. We're told right off the bat that Stacy is "one of the little guys", but it wasn't clear to me what that meant. Since the opening paragraph talked about birds and humans, I thought it might be a story about an insect (like a grasshopper or an ant) wanting to fly, and it didn't occur to me that Stacy is actually just a small person. This may want to be made clearer, and you could take a variety of approaches. Maybe you could show us Stacy interacting with people in her village, before throwing in the twist that they're not normal people, but are in fact very small! This would be a much more engaging start to the story.
I do like that throughout you establish Stacy's voice through the narration. She comes off as a dreamer, and she has the brains behind those dreams, which makes her an inventor. Her stubbornness comes through the narration, since she struggles through the wind to test out her invention anyway. Also, the way she talks about the other villagers in town characterizes her more as the outsider, which lines up with her as a dreamer. So good job on conveying all of these characteristics through the narration! If you were to revisit, it may also be helpful to contrast her personality with some of the other villagers, so we can see the dynamic in action and more easily make these inferences!
One more suggestion is that you may want to expand the story a bit to show the trial and error of Stacy throughout her journey of creating her wings. It would build tension throughout the story, so the when the climax comes and she sores through the wind, it feels like such a big success since we saw her struggle for it, rather than setting up the struggle before and just giving us the end part. It’s much more rewarding that way
Otherwise, this was a cute tale! If you ever decide to revisit it, here’s another viewpoint ^^ Happy writing!
~ Wolfe
Points: 26330
Reviews: 767
Donate