Too late. His cat had already dunked his paw in the coffee mug-- which was thankfully iced today-- causing the liquid to splash all over the counter. Flattening his ears in obvious distaste of the wet substance, Shrimp withdrew his paw, shaking it out and sending more droplets flying.
"Well, what did you think was going to happen? Silly baby," Shane groaned, but he went to pet the cat's head before he got a paper towel, lifting up the mug and smacking it down on the wet surface underneath.
"Nothing but fluff between those ears," Shane went on more affectionately, scratching the back of Shrimp's neck. "Certainly no brain in there."
Shrimp meowed at him.
"You're right. I am jealous of that," Shane said. "What wouldn't I give to have three thoughts a day and for two of them to be about food."
But no, he was cursed to have stuff on his mind. All the damn time.
At least right now, at this very second, the problem on his mind was how to keep petting his cat while also reaching for the coffee pitcher for a refill. Shane eventually managed it with a wide stretch that would've had any yoga instructor beaming with pride. He poured out the remainder of the coffee (with some regret) and was refilling it when his phone rang.
He swore to the Saints, if it was Flint--
Shane took out his phone, staring at the screen. It was Alan.
Ah. Wasn't that better?
He didn't feel immediately relieved, though. He'd checked earlier this morning, and the message he'd sent him a few days back had still been on delivered. Granted, it was far from an important text, but the silence didn't sit well with him. At least Alan was breaking it now.
Shane put a smile on his face as he answered the call so it would sound clear in his voice.
"Hey, Alan," he greeted. "How's it going?"
"Hey, Shane," Alan greeted back, his usual friendly tone present in his voice. "It's been going, for a morning on this island prison. How about you?"
"About the same here. Nothing particularly hellish, except Shrimpcito is being diabolical by stepping in my morning coffee." Shane moved the phone over to Shrimp. "Say good morning, you fiend."
Shrimp meowed and then tried to bite Shane's phone.
"There you have it," Shane joked, pulling the phone back to his ear.
There was soft chuckling on the other end. "It's too bad I can't understand cat anymore," Alan mused. "But my gut tells me I just heard a guilty confession."
"Thank you, Your Honor. I was worried because otherwise I would've been the only witness to the heinous act," Shane said, smiling a little more easily now.
"Hm, yes. Consider me your witness then," Alan hummed with another faint chuckle. He paused. "Oh, by the way Shane, I'm sorry I didn't get to respond to your text. I admit I prefer calling way more than texting. I appreciate you checking in though. It's been a hell of a week." Another pause. "Do you have free time this morning, by the way? I've been meaning to connect and talk to you about some things."
Talking was certainly good, even when it was bad. Shane nodded thoughtfully, then remembered Alan couldn't see that.
"Don't even worry about it. It's a cat picture with a silly caption, not an urgent request for backup troops or something," Shane promised. "And I get that things are hectic. I'd love to talk to you too. I shouldn't have anything going on today, so I'm quite free for that."
"Sweet. I'm free all morning," Alan said. Then promptly asked, "Where do you want to meet?"
Good question.
"No preference. But," Shane added, with a slight chuckle, "do you remember how I ate all the berries in your cabin on our second day here and promised to return the favor sometime? The berry debt's growing old, but I could finally pay it off if you wanted to meet here."
"Oh yeah?" Alan huffed out a laugh. "I do remember that, but I don't think I like blackberries as much as you, so please eat as much as you want, save for maybe one or two. Meeting at your place is fine by me, though."
"Great," Shane said with another smile. "Does coffee sound better? I can attempt to keep Shrimp away from it."
"Leftover coffee and whatever stale breakfast foods you have lying around sounds fantastic," Alan said, more clearly with a smile in his voice now.
"Stale?" Shane clicked his tongue, speaking in a tone of fake outrage and indignation while he grinned slightly. "I don't know what to be more offended by, that you underestimate my hospitality or our cooking. You've just earned yourself a full breakfast for that comment, sir."
"Oh noooooooo," Alan drew out with feigned defeat. "Woe is me. I guess I'll just have to go to your place hungry, then. Good thing I haven't eaten yet."
"You'll rue the day you implied the food would be stale," Shane said. "Prepare for the best waffles of your life. No pancakes here."
"Can't wait. I'm looking forward to it." Alan paused. "Thanks, Shane. Can you text me when you want me to come by?"
"Of course. It'll be as soon as the food's warm," Shane promised with a smile. "See you soon, Alan."
He turned on the waffle oven (which was already plugged in) the moment they each hung up, then darted to grab a mixing bowl. It took longer, but he'd never used a waffle mix before in his life and he wasn't starting now. He made the batter from memory, and quickly set out the toppings before grabbing a pack of whipping cream from the fridge. He set the stand mixer to work on this, adding in some vanilla sugar from time to time until the cream was perfectly light and fluffy. Last, while the first waffle was cooking, he reheated coffee for Alan, regretting that he'd never heard from him how he liked it best. He'd seen him drink it black before, but remembering their orders at the plaza cafe, he took a gamble and made him a latte with rosewater. Once he'd made the rest of the waffles, he plated everything and set the counter ready for two, then texted Alan.
Shane wrote:Ready for you!
~ ~ ~
Ignoring the silverware set on his plate, Alan picked up a fluffy waffle, tearing off a quarter-piece and dipping it on the homemade whipped cream he had slopped on the side.
"Are your cabin mates home?" Alan asked glancing towards the stairwell and as he munched the waffle.
Shane grinned softly at the action, deciding to take it as a sign that the waffles were good-- or at least that Alan had showed up hungry. "James and Hild are here. But they got back from their run, so I think they're upstairs for a while," he said, cutting off a bite from his very berry-heavy waffle.
"Ah, okay," Alan said with a nod, tearing off another piece of his waffle. With brows slightly furrowed, he stared at the piece with more focus, a contemplative expression washing over him. "Well. I appreciate your time, especially with this breakfast you cooked up. Really." A pause, and he hesitantly glanced back at Shane. "I've been meaning to talk to you about some things, mostly about myself. Is it fine if I have the floor and talk?"
Hopefully this was fine. Shane had to remind himself that it was always fine for Alan to share what was on his mind. Even if any mention of a serious talk always sent a flicker of panic running through him at first, regardless of whether it turned out to be good, bad or neutral.
"Of course," Shane said invitingly, taking a quick bite of his waffle and setting down his fork. "More than fine. I'll listen to whatever it is. That's what friends do."
"Yeah..." Alan smiled slightly, casting Shane another appreciative glance. "Thanks."
Alan sighed, setting his elbow on the counter, lightly nibbling at the waffle piece before shoving it entirely in his mouth, his cheeks now ballooned to be full of waffle. It felt illegal not to smile at the sight, so Shane did for a moment, watching with amused patience. As Alan ate through this bite, he repeated this action, idly tearing off another piece.
"I feel like I've been doing a lot of soul searching," Alan finally said after he finished through the bite. "Maybe that's not the right term. I don't know." He fiddled with the waffle piece, bringing it closer to his eyes, squinting at it. "I feel like I've been searching for something for the past few years, endlessly chasing a ghost of a feeling. And..."
Alan sighed, bringing his arm down to be flushed on the table, waffle piece pointing up. "Yeah, I don't know. I feel like I'm facing this head-on now, though. And it's staring at me right in the face." He turned back to Shane, uncertain. "Does that make sense?"
"It does," Shane said with an understanding nod. "Going through introspection from time to time is valuable. Even if not always easy."
Alan nodded, briefly awash with relief. "I agree. And I think..." He turned his focus back on the waffle piece he held, fiddling with it. "Well, it's hard for me. I don't know why. But..." He trailed off, scrunching his brows together, frowning. "Okay, well."
Alan waved the waffle loosely in the air. "Let me backtrack. I don't have troubles being introspective. I want to be introspective. To grow and improve. But there's a difference between thinking it... and acting on it."
Looking defeated again, he slumped forward, stretching his arms against the counter, still pointing the waffle in the air. "Does that make sense?" he finished with a mumble.
"Yes," Shane confirmed, flashing him a faint smile that he knew he was awash with some concern. "Everything you've said so far is fine and clear, Alan. I'll let you know if it isn't, trust me."
Alan let out a long, deep sigh, his chest moving with his breath. He abruptly sat back up, now with newfound determination to keep on going. "So that's where I'm at right now," he said pointedly, intensely focused on the cabinets directly in his line of view. "I am acting on this thought I've had for a long time, that, well--" He faltered, squinting. "It sounds silly to say, so I won't say it. But point being: I realize I need to be honest with myself. I need to figure out what I want. Even if it's not easy. Even if I can't please everyone. I need to be honest with myself, first."
He emptily stared down at his plate, weakly sliding the waffle piece back on. "That's it on that," he finished, just above a mumble. "I wanted to preface with that."
Shane watched the side of his face attentively, taking in every familiar feature as well as every new expression he took on. His was a face he wished to be able to read like a book someday. For the time being, he wanted to hear it from Alan rather than piece it together himself.
What was he to brace himself for? That question should've unnerved him. But for now, at least right now at this particular moment in time, his concern for Alan outweighed the concern he had for himself.
"I'm listening, Alan," he promised softly. "What you're doing is good. I want you to have whatever it is you want, too. I mean it."
"You may mean that," Alan began, holding his head with his hand, "but how can it hold any merit if I don't know what it is that I want?" He let out a long, tired sigh, continuing on lowly. "I'm tired of being a mosaic of other people's wants and desires. Yet at the same time, I'm afraid of stepping into the dark, starting this journey blind. Sometimes I wish I can run away or burn my metaphorical life into the ground, start anew from the ashes. But if the roots of my seed are rotten, I'll always be doomed to be a poison."
Shane felt some sadness wash over his expression as he kept watching Alan. It felt a bit like an extended stolen glance, to be looking at him for this long without being looked back at, to study the sharp curve of his jaw and the shine his eyes caught the light with and feel like he was finding more beauty in his soul moment by moment. It was good Alan was discovering himself. It pained him to think that he might not like everything he saw.
"You'll never be doomed to anything, Alan," he said with soft sincerity. "Not as long as it all leads back to your heart."
Finally, Alan cast his gaze in Shane's direction, searching his face for a moment. "I used to think that too," he said quietly, mustering a faint smile before turning away again.
He didn't leave much room for a response, continuing on. "Shane, if it's alright with you... I'd like to talk about what happened during Ooktoberfest. I feel like this conversation is long past due. I know that's my fault."
Shane felt his heartbeat thudding in his neck all of a sudden. For a moment, he'd forgotten anything could happen here that could scare him. He'd forgotten he might need to be brave today when he felt so, so tired and small.
What would happen if his bravery didn't go far enough? If it didn't cover his heart all the way?
It would have to do. The question was asked. And he was already committed to wanting what Alan wanted.
He prayed he had this in him.
"Okay," Shane said quietly, steeling himself and keeping his voice steady as he kept his eyes on Alan. "If you think we should, then we should. I'll do my best to stay present with you. But please don't hold yourself at fault for the conversation's delay. I... haven't wanted to talk about it much either."
"That's alright. I haven't either," Alan murmured in response. He picked up the waffle piece, spent half a second nibbling it, then pressed on, waving the waffle in his hand as he motioned around them. "And I think there are so many-- too many-- subjects I don't want to talk about. Because it's uncomfortable. But, I don't know..." He bowed his head towards his food, looking defeated again. "If I don't talk about it, or think of it, or take action-- I'll never grow. And I'm so sick and tired of being so fucking stagnant. I feel like I'm losing my mind. I don't even know who I am anymore. I don't know if I ever have. Because I've bought into the idea, for so long, that..."
Alan groaned, slumping forward and slapping both hands over his face. "I feel like I'm incoherently rambling," he mumbled, rubbing his eyes.
"No," Shane said slowly, with a shake of his head. "You haven't lost me yet."
It was true he wasn't confused, but there was some talking in circles happening here. And although he didn't want to feel this way, he felt a little like cornered prey, a rabbit that a fox was now slinking around. The distance could be closed in a heartbeat and the teeth could sink in then. But the moment before the strike was being drawn out, stretched out to the point where ending it all almost like the kinder path, as Alan remained in silence for several moments.
Shane could almost look forward to the hunt being over.
"Shane," Alan gently called, breaking the short silence. He meekly turned toward his direction, lowering his hand. "You said your effect during Ooktoberfest was a confidence boost. Right?"
Shane took a steadying deep breath, rubbing at his face.
"Right," he said. "It must have been, or else it had the same result. It wasn't a boost to 'normal' confidence levels, either-- it felt like it went farther than that. I couldn't hold on to doubt for more than a few seconds, and it was like everything I wanted to be true... was true. No second thoughts, no skepticism. Just unwavering faith."
It had felt perfect, to be in a world where he knew what people meant and they meant what they said for a few hours. Now it just felt cruel. He'd never live that way again.
Alan quietly listened, still holding his head with one arm, and fiddling with his fork with his other hand. He seemed focused yet distant, like he was waging a war in his mind, only showing Shane the surface of its depth.
"I don't know how the DMV manages to do such a thing," Alan continued on distractedly, voice just above a murmur. "Then again, I don't know how the hell they manage any of this. I should have questioned things when Kazimir acted like a shark. It's like, somehow, they know all our insecurities. And then dangle it in front of a camera for the world to see. Like they're testing us. But I thought we were here for magic? And yet..." He sighed, sinking into his hand. "None of this makes any sense to me. I wish I could understand."
Shane bit his lip. Thanks to James, he did think he knew a little more about what the DMV was trying to do, but that would be a lot to divulge right now, and only tangentially related to the topic at hand.
"Yeah," he said a little quieter. "I don't know why. If this is a test, I've already failed."
"Yeah..." Alan sighed. "Me too."
But when had Alan failed? Shane couldn't spot when that had happened, or what he was referring to. He swallowed.
"Why do you ask?" he asked finally.
"About..." Alan fidgeted again, pulling himself to sit straighter. "...Ooktoberfest?"
"What effect I had," Shane clarified quietly. "It sounded like you had some purpose by that."
"I..." Alan weakly nodded, thumb brushing against the counter as he stared down at it. "Yeah. I do." He took in a long, deep sigh. "I was curious, because I wasn't sure, exactly. And thought, maybe, considering what happened, it would give me some insight into what mine was. Which..." He shifted uncomfortably in his seat. "Well, I don't think it really told me anything. I don't really have any hints. I'm just guessing here. Filling in the blanks. Making sense of things. Weeks later, because I keep delaying everything, but at least I'm doing this now. Being introspective. Talking, taking action. Whatever."
Shane tried to think back to what Alan had said that very day after Ooktoberfest, but he'd been vague then and he was vague now. He wasn't saying enough.
"You told me you were acting rash and impulsive," he said quietly. "Saying, doing things you weren't ready to mean. Do you still think that?"
Alan barked a sharp mirthless laugh, shaking his head as he rubbed his face. Shane jumped a little in surprise, not expecting that reaction. What had he said?
"Did I say that?" Alan lowly hummed. "Well, I don't need a DMV dictator spell to do that. I do that plenty. Which, I feel like, has been greatly exacerbated on my time in this stupid prison. Maybe, this is all part of the plan!"
With a scoff, Alan threw his hands up in the air in annoyance before leaning forward again, hand squished against his cheek. "So, yeah. Maybe this is all part of the grand plan. Who even knows anymore. I don't. Whatever," he went on, then sighed, the end of his breath turning to a frustrated groan. "Sorry. I'm taking out my frustration over my dishonesty out on you. Or, um..." Alan weakly shrugged a shoulder. "Being a crazy mess, I guess. Though what even is the difference? Corporate says it's the same fucking picture."
"Alan," Shane said softly, watching his face again. He wasn't sure what he hoped to achieve by saying it. Maybe to settle him, or to just buy himself time to say something more in depth. Either way, he spoke his name with gentleness, almost short of breath on the word.
Hesitantly, Alan flicked his eyes towards his direction a few times, visibly relaxing. He briefly closed his eyes, taking in a deep breath.
"Sorry," he murmured. "Sorry. I'll calm down."
"It's okay. You're okay," Shane promised softly, taking a deep breath.
He felt the instinct to reach out, for some reason, but instead folded his hands into his lap. It felt as wrong as it felt right.
"I know. I know I am," Alan said quickly, frowning down at the waffles again. "It's not that I don't feel okay. I'm just..." He circled his hand in the air, searching for his next word. "Confused, I guess? I don't know." Alan sighed in defeat. "This is strangely difficult to articulate, and I don't know why. Thanks for bearing with me here."
Shane managed the barest sad smile for a heartbeat, even though Alan wasn't looking at him. "Of course," he said quietly. "This isn't easy for you, and it's really not easy for me either, but... I'm glad you're doing it, you know?" He swallowed. "Confused is alright. I'd be surprised if you had all the answers already. It still means something that we're talking without you knowing everything yet."
Alan was sat still, frozen in time as he seemed to be deeply pondering his words. With a bare smile, he cast Shane an appreciative glance, quietly uttering, "Thank you, Shane."
Alan turned back, taking another deep breath, now with more focus and determination in his eyes. "Okay. Yes. I should get to my point." He sat up straighter, elbows on the table as he motioned with his hands, gesturing ahead with stiff, straight palms.
"I wasn't myself during Ooktoberfest," Alan finally said. "I lost my inhibition. Though... well, I don't think that was my effect, but that's not really important right now. What is important is that, after this was all said and over, I committed to a role that wasn't..." He squinted ahead, dropping his hands before finishing with: "...me."
After the mumble of the word, Alan hung his head and sighed. "It was like... acting. But I know real life isn't some play. I don't need to appease the characters to satisfy the audience. I don't have an audience." He frowned, mulling that over. "Okay, well, this setting is a bad place to make this point. But life isn't supposed to have an audience. You know? I could-- should-- just be myself. Without worrying how others will perceive me.
"But my god, this is easier said than done. Especially when I keep minimizing myself. Thinking this isn't important. But it is important. I know it is. But again, there's a difference between thinking it, feeling it, and acting on it, and..."
Alan trailed off, shaking his head. "Yeah. Never mind. I'm getting ahead of myself here. That's the point I was trying to make." He paused. "I think so, anyways. I hope that made sense."
It did. It just took some processing around the backtracking and the filler. Shane nodded carefully.
"Yes," he said. "You should just be yourself. I do want that for you."
It still felt like the fox hadn't bared its teeth yet, though. Like they might've uncovered something, but not the thing.
"Is it, though?" Alan asked weakly. "What if what you want isn't what I want, or vice versa?"
Shane blinked, watching him closely. That... okay. What if?
"How might those be in conflict?" he asked instead.
"I..." Alan rubbed his fingertip against the counter, distracted. "I feel like you don't really know me." He paused, wincing. "But that's okay. I don't even know myself. I'm still discovering it."
"I want to," Shane said quickly, then ducked his head for a moment to indicate for him to keep talking. "Sorry. Go on."
Alan hung his head even lower, still idly brushing his fingertips against the counter. "This isn't your fault, Shane. I am telling you all this now so you aren't kept in the dark, and I want to be honest with you. I take full responsibility for... leading you on. For being dishonest. Not being true to who I am affects not just me, but you too. And others. And that's why... I'm here. To be more open. More honest. To have uncomfortable conversations. To change." He paused. "That's a part of life, I guess."
Shane kept scanning his face, but this time he was searching for something that gave more meaning to the words. Not hoping to find anything that disproved them, just... looking for any kind of context. An emotional footnote. A nuance that might mitigate the sinking feeling he had now.
He was looking. He wasn't sure what he was finding.
"The dishonesty..." He pursed his lips, fighting to keep his voice and words as calm as he could. "What were you dishonest about?"
If any of it was a lie, he needed to know which parts were. Then readjust accordingly. Process. Plan again. Figure out what the hell to do with his heart.
He was so tired of bad data and false hopes.
Alan hesitated before finally responding, "About myself." He took in a deep breath before resuming. "I think I was working on autopilot, where I was telling you what I thought you wanted to hear, rather than say what I really mean and risk hurting your feelings. I find myself walking away later with an uncomfortable feeling I can't really name, but I... ignore it. And have been, for years. Until now. But..."
Wearily, Alan stared down at the pile of waffles growing cold. "But I know this isn't about me," he continued. "I'm not here to dump you my problems. I just... wanted to give you closure. I didn't want to leave you in the dark, forever wondering. That's all."
So the teeth had found the flesh. Shane closed his eyes, trying to shut out the pain pressing into the back of his head.
This was his conclusive evidence, then? That he should've just been a pessimist all along? He'd made this so much worse since this had started. Because goddamn it, he couldn't just listen when he heard he wasn't wanted, could he? No, he had to go back in time, take the parts where it seemed like he mattered, and stitch them together into a memory that meant it. Because the only times he could be cared about were when someone was out of their mind or guilty enough to act the part.
And he had guilted Alan, hadn't he? He'd never meant to. That was just another example of him being pathetic and in denial. Of course Alan had been the reasonable one all along, just trying to make up for whatever lapse in judgment he must've had to see anything in him at all. And Shane was the fool digging in his heels, clinging on to his own lapse in judgment that had him briefly believing in his own worth.
His worth. Shane wanted to laugh, but his voice might've cracked. And he should hold on to whatever dignity he had left in accepting this news rather than looking any more pitiful than he already was.
What was there to do, then, besides own up to his own foolishness?
Shane took a deep breath that shuddered in his lungs, and he squeezed his eyes shut tighter, trying to block out his setting.
"I've been an idiot," he muttered. "And it's hurt you. I'm sorry."
Alan rustled, shifting in his seat. "You didn't hurt me," he said softly. "I never said that."
"I didn't leave you room to be yourself. That's harmful." Shane pursed his lips again. "So is causing you to feel bad, because you have a wonderful, soft heart that can't help but feel guilt, and making you do things you didn't want to."
"I--" Alan stopped, the one syllable drawing an uncertain edge in his voice. "No, that's not what I'm saying. That's not what happened. Don't take responsibility for my patterns. This really isn't your fault. I'm not casting blame. Truly, that's not my intention here."
"You don't have to," Shane said quietly. "I get it. Really, I get it. I got it all along that you were the reasonable one and I was the fool. Like you, I was putting that off. You don't have to pretend I'm not anymore. Please, don't."
"I won't," Alan said softly. "But..." There was another hesitation. "I don't think you're hearing me, Shane. That's not what I'm saying at all. I want you to know that."
Shane opened his eyes, but he didn't look Alan's way. If he did, his face would give it all away. He was sure of it.
"What is, then?" he asked faintly. "With honesty."
"Of course. With honesty," Alan said back quietly, and Shane felt the weight of his gaze trained on him. "You deserve that much." He took in a deep breath. "I think the foundation of our friendship is weak, dictated and molded by the inauthentic, hostile environment of the island. For me, personally, it has made me unstable. And I know this means that I have to work on myself. I must work on myself." He paused again. "I think both of us-- me, especially-- could use time to do this. To work on myself. To figure out who I am, what I want-- and in a healthy, sustainable way. Does that make sense?"
It did. And it hurt.
Setting his jaw, Shane nodded silently, focusing his gaze on the counter.
His bravery was running out after all. He wasn't strong enough for this. There were only a few things he could still do.
Slowly, Shane turned his head to finally look at Alan again. Likewise, Alan had been searching Shane's face, expression softened. Even he seemed a little hurt, with pensive sorrow awash in his deep brown eyes. And Shane might've been avoiding looking his way, but now that he was, he wasn't sure how he could look away again.
"As that happens," Shane started quietly. "Can we still be friends? Friends who made a mistake and started over? Or is that impossible now?"
Alan lifted the edge of his lip into a faint smile, nodding faintly. "Yes. We can still be friends," he confirmed with a quiet voice. "I think we will need to establish firm boundaries, but we can certainly remain friends."
Shane nodded faintly, letting the tiniest wave of relief wash over him. A tiny one. This wasn't over yet.
"What kind of boundaries?" he asked softly.
"Just..." Alan turned away, idly brushing his hands together. "You know. Friendship boundaries. As friends." He paused, clasping his hands together. "Friendship and romance can get muddled in my mind, so... that's why I brought it up," he finished quietly.
Shane kept his gaze settled on him, meaning to nod, but not sure how to. He managed it after a moment.
"No more poems, probably," he said in quiet agreement. "You can... get rid of the one you have, if that helps. I don't want you to feel like you have to hold on to that."
He didn't know why that came to mind. Maybe he just wanted the evidence gone.
"That's not what I'm saying," Alan said gently, but there was a hint of weariness in his voice. "I'm pretty sure friends can write friends poems. That's alright. It's just about intention."
"You're right. Sorry," Shane apologized softly. "It gets muddled in my mind too."
Alan faintly nodded. "That's alright. We can just try our best. That's all we can do. Try our best."
Shane nodded as well, taking a deep breath.
"I'll be trying," he said softly. "You only deserve friends who try, Alan. I want to care for you in the way you want and actually need, and you're worthy of every bit of effort I could put into our friendship." Shane managed a faint, sad smile, before letting it slip into a softer resolve. "I'm sorry you feel like I don't really know you. But if I don't, I want to. And I hope I get there, because every step of that would be an honor and joy. Even in the dark times." He paused. "The more you are of yourself, the more delight I'll have. I hope I can see everything you've ever wanted to change about yourself and care for you anyway. That's the way you deserve to be treated. You deserve to be embraced in the most unconditional and all-encompassing love I can give you."
Alan was quiet for a moment, softly smiling. He glanced at Shane, his gaze lingering for a few seconds before he turned away again, smile abiding. "Thank you, Shane," he said with a quieter, but sincere voice. "That's very kind of you." He paused, hesitantly glancing back at him with a wider, fonder smile to say, "You deserve that too. Always remember that."
Shane found it in him to smile fondly as well, but he didn't believe it. Not really. Or-- really, not at all. Maybe, if he didn't know any better, he could've. He thought he'd heard something like this from Ooktoberfest, and he might've begun to embrace it then. But he'd learned since then. Today settled it.
"I'll try to," he said softly nonetheless.
He didn't like that it felt like a lie of his own. He was running out of reasons to try, frankly. And maybe this was bad for a conversation all about being honest, but Shane didn't have the heart to admit he disagreed and risk guilting Alan all over again. He deserved to not be weighted down by any more pity for him. Because of course Alan would disagree with him in turn, and then he'd have to say good things about Shane that he didn't mean all over again. They had to move away from that. That was being honest.
Shane knew it. He just felt so... ill. Sick of himself. And while maybe it was selfish, he was aching for some comfort.
Shaking his head clear, Shane looked back at Alan's face with soft uncertainty. It wouldn't kill him to ask... would it?
"Would a hug lie within your boundaries?" he asked quietly.
Tenderly, Alan's smile grew, a glimmer of understanding in his eyes. He nodded, spreading out his arms. "It is," he affirmed, but didn't wait to lean forward and embrace him, wrapping his arms around him, thumb gently brushing his back.
Shane leaned into the embrace, hugging him back with a gentle tightness. He let a silent deep breath leave his chest to relieve the tension there, then slowly, almost hesitantly, let the side of his head rest on Alan's shoulder. It did something to help the crushing weight that seemed to press on his own shoulders. He held on, hoping Alan felt every bit of the appreciation and the faint relief this brought him, as well as all the affection he had for him.
"I think I'm going to look forward to this," Shane said softly.
"Oh yeah?" Alan continued to rub his his back in gentle, rhythmic motions, softly humming. "I'm glad. And I'm sorry that this is so messy. I wish things were easier..." He paused, now keeping his hands still. "If it's easy, then it's not real. And I think both of us could use something true and authentic... even if it's hard. Especially when things are hard."
Shane nodded quietly, letting himself melt into the security of the hug just a bit further.
"I'd much rather have something real with you," he said softly. "You're right, I certainly could use it. If this is built on stable ground that we can both rely on because we trust that the foundation exists, the hard times can be dealt with. I'd gladly embrace any messiness that came with truly knowing you-- the reward of that is worth every bit."
He paused for a moment, trying to determine if he could hear Alan's heart. There it was. It thudded evenly against his chest, like a steady rhythmic drum. Nothing like the rapid fluttering of Shane's heart, like a scared bird in a cage of ribs, although that was starting to slow and soften. He tried to match his breathing to the march of Alan's heart.
"I once said that what matters most to me is that the you I know is really you as you are. And I stand by that even if my intentions are different now. Who you are is too precious to keep behind smoke and mirrors, Alan."
Alan held on to Shane tighter, pressing his palms into his back and hanging his head lower against his shoulder. After taking in a deep, shuddered breath that moved with his body, Alan sat still, embracing the peace and quiet, as well as Shane. Shane closed his eyes, likewise holding still. He wouldn't flinch at this shred of tenderness that felt like far more than he deserved. He could act like it didn't feel overwhelming to his heart, like it didn't pain him to think he shouldn't be held like this. In hindsight, he could see that he could be given very little and he would try to build a whole future with it.
It was not enough to be briefly beloved. It was not enough to love more in hopes of earning that back. He was not enough except for when he was too much.
But in this battle between craving tenderness and wanting to reject it, this felt just right, just for a moment.
Finally, Alan heavily pulled away, his hand lingering on Shane's shoulder for a few seconds longer before he pried away, taking another deep breath. It was only a hug, but deep exhaustion weighed heavily in his eyes.
"Thank you," he said softly with a small, tired smile. "I really appreciate you. Truly."
Shane smiled back faintly, letting his hands slip from Alan's shoulders. "I appreciate you too," he said in the same soft tone as Alan. "Thank you for still wanting a friendship."
Alan looked down at his plate of now-cold waffles, soft smile lingering. "And thank you for listening over a plate of delicious waffles."
Shane dropped his gaze to the plate that had one bite taken from it in front of him, with some surprise.
"...I kinda forgot my berries with a side of waffles were there," he admitted with a slight laugh.
"It's alright. I did too," Alan said with a growing smile, but it immediately began to fade. "I can, um..." He paused, lining his fingertip along the plate. "I can stay here, if you'd like. Or I can leave. It's up to you. Either is fine."
Shane paused, feeling his smile drop as well. He hadn't considered Alan might want to leave before breakfast was over. Or that Alan thought he wanted him to leave, if that was the case instead.
"If you didn't know I wanted you to stay," he asked gently, "what would you want to do?"
"Shane," Alan said with a small smile. "Your opinion matters just as much as mine. I can tell you if I do or don't want to do something, but I care about your opinion too. So.." He set his elbows on the table, picking up the waffle piece he tore off a while ago, finally biting into it.
Even with a full mouth, Alan went on to say, "I'm staying here to eat this," even though his words were muffled from the bite.
Shane felt a new smile slowly spreading over his face again. That didn't really tell him that Alan wanted to be here. But if he was sticking in the earlier theme of the conversation of doing what felt right to him, and he hopefully was...
Well. There was some hope that he actually did want it.
"You're welcome to stay as long as you like," he said, smile warming a touch. "Host's rules say no kicking you out."
"In that case," Alan said with a smile as he pointed the remaining waffle piece at him, "we have more waffles to eat."
Gender:
Points: 3630
Reviews: 140