z

Young Writers Society


~Black~ Reviews.



User avatar
303 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 11152
Reviews: 303
Mon Jun 24, 2013 5:49 pm
StoneHeart says...



Okay, so this is the place where I divy out my reviews!

If you need a review (I review literally anything), then just drop me a link, a time limit as to when you'd like the review, and any specifics you want covered, then I'll give you what you want!

Bring it on!
For I who am poor have only my dreams
I spread my dreams under your feet . . .

. . . tread softly for you tread on my dreams.


We are masters of our silences, and slaves of our words
  





User avatar
1087 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 44360
Reviews: 1087
Mon Jul 01, 2013 9:43 am
Sins says...



Yo, Black!

Would you mind checking out the first chapter of my novel for me? I already have some awesome critiques on it, but I've edited it quite a lot with the help of those critiques, so I'd like some fresh reviews to see if my editing has paid off.

The Boy Who Broke Mirrors (Chapter One)

Please and thank you! :)
I didn't know what to put here so I put this.
  





User avatar
98 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 273
Reviews: 98
Mon Jul 01, 2013 2:08 pm
Rainn says...



Hey, I just wrote a poem and wold love a review whenever you get the chance :)

Undisclosed(edited)
"My Specialty is the Arts."
  





User avatar
303 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 11152
Reviews: 303
Mon Jul 01, 2013 5:18 pm
View Likes
StoneHeart says...



I'm on it! Both of you!
For I who am poor have only my dreams
I spread my dreams under your feet . . .

. . . tread softly for you tread on my dreams.


We are masters of our silences, and slaves of our words
  





User avatar
286 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 625
Reviews: 286
Tue Jul 02, 2013 8:27 pm
silented1 says...



Captured.

Thanks.
[quote]If it's arguable, then it probably is." - Xeriana X

Link to my will review for food thread: topic71713.html
  





User avatar
560 Reviews



Gender: None specified
Points: 30438
Reviews: 560
Wed Jul 03, 2013 9:50 am
Tenyo says...



This is rated [16+] for swearing, so feel free to refuse.

Truths and Trials [16+]

Honest opinions on the theme, language and tone of it would be great! And anything else.
I'll return the review, so if you want anything in particular reviewing pm me the link. Elsewise I'll just scour through your portfolio and find something pretty.
We were born to be amazing.
  





User avatar
303 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 11152
Reviews: 303
Wed Jul 03, 2013 1:32 pm
StoneHeart says...



@Skins

@Rainn

I'm done with ya'lls! Feel free to rate my reviews! :D

I'm on it Tenyo and Silented!
For I who am poor have only my dreams
I spread my dreams under your feet . . .

. . . tread softly for you tread on my dreams.


We are masters of our silences, and slaves of our words
  





User avatar
303 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 11152
Reviews: 303
Sat Jul 06, 2013 4:55 pm
StoneHeart says...



Done @Tenyo @Silented!
For I who am poor have only my dreams
I spread my dreams under your feet . . .

. . . tread softly for you tread on my dreams.


We are masters of our silences, and slaves of our words
  





User avatar
83 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 1115
Reviews: 83
Mon Jul 08, 2013 1:23 am
View Likes
skorlir says...



It may not be an easy read, because of its style (not grammar), but if you wouldn't mind trying it out, I'd appreciate a review of this.

All is Well, Perforce.
  





User avatar
303 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 11152
Reviews: 303
Mon Jul 08, 2013 4:54 pm
StoneHeart says...



On it man!
For I who am poor have only my dreams
I spread my dreams under your feet . . .

. . . tread softly for you tread on my dreams.


We are masters of our silences, and slaves of our words
  





User avatar
22 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 451
Reviews: 22
Mon Jul 08, 2013 6:52 pm
View Likes
Paige says...



Hi Black!

I posted the 3rd chapter of Identical yesterday, and the first two chapters got immediate likes and reviews, but this time, not many people have responded to it at all.

So if you have a chance, could you please check out Identical: Chapter Three - Reactivity?

I don't know if you've read any of the previous chapters, but I'd love to have feedback from you!

With Love,
Paige
  





User avatar
560 Reviews



Gender: None specified
Points: 30438
Reviews: 560
Tue Jul 09, 2013 8:30 am
Tenyo says...



Awesome review! It's much appreciated.
We were born to be amazing.
  





User avatar
303 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 11152
Reviews: 303
Wed Jul 10, 2013 1:16 pm
StoneHeart says...



@skorlir

Review done!

Tenyo! Thanks!

@paigesharrow

I'm on yours now (sorry for taking so long).
For I who am poor have only my dreams
I spread my dreams under your feet . . .

. . . tread softly for you tread on my dreams.


We are masters of our silences, and slaves of our words
  





User avatar
83 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 1115
Reviews: 83
Wed Jul 10, 2013 3:06 pm
skorlir says...



Ah... You asked me to rate your review on a scale from 1 to 20?

TL;DR version

Grammar : 4/4
Clarity : 2/4
Poignancy : 1/4
Politeness : 4/4
Just-how-
much-I-appreciate-you-
for-bothering-to-review-
you-wonderful-thing-you: 4/4
________________________________________________
Final tally: 14/20 (Reputable, but not sublime)

DETAILED, Nasty BREAKDOWN
(I tried to spoiler this out, but spoilers-within-spoilers... they no do.)

Alright. I'll let the small emotional bit go, first. If someone who is not Black is bothering to read this, they'll probably want to skip it, so I'll spoiler it out.

Spoiler! :
The passage you selected to suggest was "slow and boring," while perhaps admittedly wordy, was drawn out with purpose. Rohncroft's... roar, I call it, has a lot of significance to Serenity's departure. But your calling it "really unimportant seconds," ones elaborated upon in too much detail... Well, the seconds of and following the roar are really the most significant happenings in the whole piece. If you felt that it was unimportant, I feel I have failed to write it properly... And yet you do not really give suggestions for how this could be improved, apart from saying "Only a few words are needed to describe [these seconds]." I tried to avoid describing them at extreme length, but definitely desired to do greater justice to the scene than "Rohncroft lets out a mighty roar; flames spew out his mouth."

And when Serenity leaves... Mmh. I'll not be picky about your mention that, for a relationship, theirs seems fragile. But that is, also, a purposeful choice. I mean to give the impression theirs is a strained relationship; even to suggest that Serenity feels she has been taken for granted in the past. If that doesn't come across, I feel kinda like I failed there, too.


Qualms (or really quibbles):
  • What does "miserable" mean, as a descriptor of diction? That confuses me, and seems to suggest you didn't really like the read rather than actually say anything about my word choice... But alas.
  • Your criticism is acute, but slightly directionless, and
  • I also feel you can be redundant.
  • You say "READERS WANT FAST PACED ACTION." I can agree with this, but am slightly confused how you mean me to make use of it. I attempt to use verb-noun pairs to maintain active voice, and attempt to make sure my words flow as best as possible. Perhaps you get stuck on certain words? Or my flow falters somewhere? You should try to point things out in the text.

Tidbits and Floaties (Don't count towards the final score, so spoiler'd out):
    Spoiler! :
  • You somewhat assume I want my writing to be likened to popular works, but I purposely wrote this with soulful and perhaps occasionally overwrought language - in a way this is to express my yearning for more canonically appreciable literature. Although I never said that, so I can't blame you for making what is otherwise probably a very good assumption.
  • Your review... Well, it talked about how I was lengthy, but then it was rather lengthy (and as I said, a bit redundant). Just to keep in mind. I think your organization seemed good in your head, but got lost as you kept reading, and so you ended up repeating yourself.
  • Concerning directed suggestions - you say "fix your style": "think of good books you know;" "do they sound like this?" I personally believe the best books use complex language; but that's rather subjective. Shakespeare, who many esteem an excellent author (although he probably wouldn't be popular today), can be quite a dense read. So it doesn't really help. What would have been really helpful: you quote a few lines and provide highlights/little corrections. I use [ color ] tags a lot for this. Really point to whatever might help me see the focus of your suggestion.

Glowing Positives (The good part):
  • Your quotes pointed to important parts of the piece, so your holistic focus is good. (You just need to hone in on details.)
  • Mah gawsh you spent time on that. Plus points for effort (listed under some long hyphenated category above).
  • Polite while critical. Sometimes people are just plain mean (not that they do it on purpose), so it's very appreciated.

That's my first review-review, so I think I need to think up a sign-off...

Nah. I'll use my usual.

Be forever hortatory,

~Skorlir
  





User avatar
303 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 11152
Reviews: 303
Wed Jul 10, 2013 7:40 pm
View Likes
StoneHeart says...



XD, thanks man! I hadn't actually expected anyone to do it!

Remember something though when you're judging a review: A review tries to help a writer . . . not attack him. You don't need to respond as if it were!

But yeah, you have some valid points. My excuse for the hard-to-understandedness is that I had to write that review in just a few minutes, leaving me no time to re-cap and review.

. . . what I was trying to impress on you is that that piece almost put me to piece with the really nice and fancy wording. -_-

Thanks!
For I who am poor have only my dreams
I spread my dreams under your feet . . .

. . . tread softly for you tread on my dreams.


We are masters of our silences, and slaves of our words
  








"The adventures I enjoy are usually of a literary nature."
— Henry Winchester