z

Young Writers Society


Yet another The Pact rewrite



User avatar
42 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 269
Reviews: 42
Wed Jun 04, 2014 9:07 pm
horrendous says...



Once again i am drawn back to this story, and once again i'm dissatisfied with it. i hate to sound vain, but i sort of want this story to be my flagship in my amatuer career (not that i ever plan on going pro), so i keep re reading it and thinking "still too amatuerish". so i've got a question and a chunk of text for anyone interested to read.

the question is, is it harmful to continually revisit a story, especially one that you didn't finish in the first place? i sort of think that this is a never-ending cycle of writing, losing interest, re-examining and rewriting. but i'm compelled to rewrite.

anyway, here's the story so far. i apologize in advance for its length:

Despite his love for war and blood, the soldier lived for only one reason. To protect his family was his self-appointed charge, and his reason for delving into his finely honed craft of killing after burying it for so long.

*Those goddamn animals, the soldier thought with a grimace, grasping his wounded arm which still bled anemically, despite heavy bandaging. Each footfall of the horse below him sent fresh pangs of pain through the soldier's bicep, but that might as well have been in a different world. He had long ago learned to either ignore pain or thrive on it, and since there were nothing to focus his killer instinct on, he chose the former.

*I've never fought such a brutal foe. It's like they fight entirely on instinct.

The soldier grinned grimly.

*Lucky for me most of them couldn't follow their instincts out of a dark room. I must truly be getting soft to let them mark me.

The soldier had been traveling since that afternoon, and it was now halfway to dusk. He had left the battlefield after a throng of barbarians had temporarily overpowered him and managed to gravely wound him. His right arm hung in a sling and would barely move, even with great effort.

The soldier's long goatskin traveling cloak flapped in a light breeze, his short black hair rippling. A muted sound, like a steady mechanical heartbeat droned monotonously from a pack which was seated behind the saddle. In it the soldier's armor rattled in time with the horse's stride.

The plains rolled on for endless acres, and the peace they offered were welcome to the lone rider. He realized his train of thought was becoming a bit disgruntled and switched his focus to something else. It's something he taught himself to do when his daughter was born.

*I miss you, little one. I'll see you soon.

He smiled.

*Karlya.

Lost in thought, the soldier failed to notice a figure leaning against a dead, withering tree on the side of the road about thirty yards ahead. Around the figure, the green grass turned colorless and limp.

*I hope she's been doing alright without me. She's so fragile... but she has her big sister to watch out for her. Thank the gods for Ellyn, she's so good to Karlya. I'm glad we were lucky enough to -

"Heading back already? Had your fill of death, then?"

Startled, the soldier's body tensed and he grasped the hilt of his weapon, a greatsword which hung to the side of his saddle. He quickly acquired where the voice had come from - damn, had he been there all along?

"Identify yourself!" called the soldier, the sudden ruination of his train of thought putting him in a foul mood.

The soldier kicked the sides of his steed and rode up close to the cloaked figure, drawing his greatsword. A hood covered the stranger's face.

"Have you something to say?" spat the soldier.

"Plenty," replied the stranger, "But you're clearly not ready to listen."

The soldier pointed his blade at the stranger's neck, holding it perfectly steady in one hand.

"Show your face or die where you stand."

The stranger looked up at his assailant, who was taken aback by what he saw. It was a mask, long, white and without decoration. Two narrow horizontal slits were placed over the eyes, three vertical ones over the mouth. The soldier saw a light trail of smoke drifting from either eye slit, and a red glow from beneath them. He stared in disbelief, eyes widening.

"I see I have your attention, Adremalech."

"That's... how do you know that name? Answer, demon!"

The stranger grunted laughter. "Or what? You'll slay me single-handedly? I wouldn't be so confident. But enough pleasantries. I'm here to warn you, Adre. You're heading toward your fate at this very moment."

Adre flushed with anger and dismounted in a hurried leap. He approached the stranger and held his blade out behind him, ready to strike.

"I'm going to be the last person you see in this life if you don't start making sense! How do you know my name!?"

"That's unimportant. What is important is that you're going to have to make a choice. You will either damn the world or save it, depending on what you choose."

Adre swung down at the stranger, who knocked the blade away with one armored hand. The greatsword was flung into the distance, leaving Adre defenseless. The stranger stepped forward and grasped the front of Adre's cloak, a heavy, dark gauntlet covering his hand. He lifted Adre off his feet, and the glow beneath the stranger's mask seemed to intensify.

"Listen to me, Adre!", commanded the stranger. "If you choose the dark path, the world as you know it will end. A tidal wave of destruction will consume all that you know. Do you understand?"

Adre nodded, confused. The stranger released him and he flopped to the ground and staggered backward.


"One way or the other, you're going to die tonight. Remember, you must resist the temptation of the dark path. This world depends on it."

The stranger turned and began walking in the opposite direction that Adre had come.

"Wait!", Adre called after him. "What do you mean? What dark path? How will this world end?"

The stranger made no reply. Adre felt no incentive to chase him - he had been overpowered so easily. Instead he gathered his sword, sheathed it and climbed back atop his horse. When he looked back over his shoulder, the stranger was gone.

The asterisks represent where i'm going to add italicization (sp?), since i write on a cell phone notepad app. i'd like your guys' opinions on whether this is a satisfying opening to you. also i'm sure i made some spelling and grammar errors in there, please ignore them.
hor·ren·dous
adjective: shockingly dreadful; horrible
synonyms: appalling, frightful, hideous

--

Life is like a box of chocolates. Too much will make you sick.
  





User avatar
1272 Reviews



Gender: Other
Points: 89625
Reviews: 1272
Wed Jun 04, 2014 9:30 pm
Rosendorn says...



the question is, is it harmful to continually revisit a story, especially one that you didn't finish in the first place?


Yes. Absolutely positively no wiggle room about it yes, constantly rewriting is completely detrimental to your progress as a writer.

Finish a draft. Everything you write will be too amateurish until you finish, because amateurs don't finish and therefore don't have the experience of writing a whole, complete stories and editing things in their entirety.

Think of writing as a giant puzzle, only there's no picture on the box and you've got a few boxes mixed together as you're sorting through. As you write, you pull various puzzle pieces and fit them together, building up a picture as you go.

If you finish the story, then you get to see the whole picture you've built. Sometimes, you don't like the majority of the picture so you toss out what you don't like and pick new pieces out of the pile. Other times, there seem to be two puzzles, two completely different stories, so you split them apart and work on one until it's done (or work on both). Sometimes you have the single most beautiful part of the story but it doesn't fit so you carefully lay it away and work on getting the story working.

If you don't finish a story, you're looking at snippets. You might have one piece that doesn't quite fit but you're not sure if you should remove it or not, you don't know if you're pulling the best pieces, and you can't tell because you're looking at an incomplete piece, not a full picture.

And yes you'll think "this feels terrible I am pulling all the wrong pieces" and yes you'll think "this really doesn't fit I need to remove it now". Don't listen to them. Finish the draft.

You will get nowhere until you finish the draft.
A writer is a world trapped in a person— Victor Hugo

Ink is blood. Paper is bandages. The wounded press books to their heart to know they're not alone.
  





User avatar
42 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 269
Reviews: 42
Thu Jun 05, 2014 6:51 pm
horrendous says...



i was afraid you'd say that. i never got that far into the original draft anyway, i suppose i could finish what i've currently got and use it as the prologue, keep the rewritten second chapter and work my way from there. thanks for the reality check Rosey.
hor·ren·dous
adjective: shockingly dreadful; horrible
synonyms: appalling, frightful, hideous

--

Life is like a box of chocolates. Too much will make you sick.
  





User avatar
1272 Reviews



Gender: Other
Points: 89625
Reviews: 1272
Thu Jun 05, 2014 8:34 pm
Rosendorn says...



No problem! I used to rewrite my novel a lot, to the point I have drafts in the double digits, and while my technical skill improved, my story crafting skill didn't. I could actually feel myself getting better as I kept writing the story, and now that I'm finished, I actually know where I want to take the story, what my weaknesses are, and how to make the plot arc interesting in slow spots.

Plus finishing a piece is a massive ego boost that is well worth slogging through the rough spots of a draft to get.
A writer is a world trapped in a person— Victor Hugo

Ink is blood. Paper is bandages. The wounded press books to their heart to know they're not alone.
  








Brain freezes are temporary, but milkshakes are forever.
— SilverNight