Twitty-ditty-litty-hit!
I haven't reviewed in centuries so this will most likely be awful, but hey ho, that's how the cookie crumbles. I'm also searching through this hot guy's photos on facebook at the moment, so that may distract me, and that's probably not a good thi--omg, omg, omg, he has green eyes and I didn't even notice. Oh my days, I'm going to marry him.
But yeah, sorry, review. Here I go.
The letter was propped up against the teapot and morning muffins. I pulled out my chair and sat down, reaching for the cup of tea Effie had already poured. ‘Who delivered that, Effie?’
This is personal preference really, but I always want an opening of a novel to grip me, whether it be by shocking me or simply making me think. It's just that I don't get that here. If this had ended with Effie's face blowing up, I'd be having a whale of a time... Okay, that's a bad example, but it's something to think about, right?
‘Oh, sir, no!’ Effie pounced with a wet cloth. ‘Oh, I should have ironed them...’
This is 100% me knowing nothing about history, but I keep imagining Effie whipping out an iron and ironing the newspapers, and it's really rather funny.
I finished my tea and gathered the breakfast things together and took them out to the kitchen.
This sentence reads a little awkwardly to me. I think it's the repetition of 'and'... Could you maybe change it to I finished my tea, gathered the breakfast things together and took them out to the kitchen?
Overall
I found this very intriguing overall, I must say. Historical fiction is usually a genre I shy away from while hissing and jabbing a crucifix at the historicalness, so the fact that I was genuinely interested says a lot. I like the subtle mystery you've got in here, from the strange letter to your peculiar MC. As for the characters as a whole, I like what I've seen so far. Your MC seems unique, especially for the era this is set in and I love what we've seen of Effie so far because she doesn't seem like your average 18th century servant.
While I mentioned your opening not being the most gripping in the world earlier, I have to agree a little with barefootrunner about it not being a train crash because as I read on, my curiosity was taken by the letter having just appeared there and what not. Nonetheless, my OCDness still tingles a little because I know that there are freaks out there who wouldn't bother reading anymore if the first sentence or two weren't satisfactory enough for them. Stoopid people. In the end, it's up to you what you want to do with your opening chapter, and in all honesty, it would hardly be the end of the world if you simply left it as it is. If you can though, there wouldn't be any harm in experimenting with it a bit.
As a whole, I loved the tone and style of this chapter right here. It certainly suited the era well, and I appreciated the small details here and there that really gave it that old-fashioned feel. The only slight critique I have for you in terms of that is that the language you used in the narrative maybe could've been more fancy every now and then, simply because the MC is a posh old one.
I finished my tea and gathered the breakfast things together and took them out to the kitchen.
Take your use of the word 'things' here. It seems like the MC should refer to the breakfast 'things' as breakfast 'delicacies', or something like that. That's an awful example really, but does that kind of make sense? 'Things' is such a general word, and not really a word you'd expect someone like this guy to be using because it's expected his vocabulary would be quite colourful as a whole due to his obvious intelligence, wealth, social class e.t.c.
Stupid little nit-picks that aren't very helpful at all aside, I think that's it. There's not much else to say about this piece really because it's very clean and a really great read overall. I kind of want the ending to be more gripping, but then I'm some whacked up adrenaline junky when it comes to first chapters, so that's from a biased perspective. Sorry I've not been much help, but I believe you've done an overall awesome job here, Twit. I congratulate thee.
Keep writing,
xoxo Skins
Points: 44360
Reviews: 1087
Donate