Hello!
Wow, powerful story you've got here! It's also pretty well told
I'm going to get right into the nitty-gritty here and jump into my nitpicks:
The red plastic cup in his hand symbolized a party. People were gathered here to drink and socialize, to have fun and be young. Nathan watched from the kitchen as poisoned minds connected with each other by slurred speech.
I really liked this opening because it immediately sets the scene and tells me a little bit about what is going on, who our protagonist is, and what he is like.
"You wan' a shot?" The man pouring the liquor was too drunk and overfilled the glass. Inebriated commentary flew in from those who were close by and laughter exploded off of the compact walls. Nathan walked out of the kitchen and to the living room where most of the other people were enjoying themselves. He was happy to get out of there, the alcohol was tempting. Not this time. He thought.
After the dialogue, is the man offering it to Nathan? I would put a little cue in for that an then add the description about the man. New paragraph at "Inebriated commentary" and new paragraph at "Nathan". They are different topics and will help break up a longer paragraph.
"Yeah, nothin' wrong with that. Just make sure you don't puke all over it!"
The second sentence seemed odd to me and didn't fit as well for me...
Nathan slipped out a chuckle to appease the man's attempt at being humorous. The time he spent partying was something a lot of people knew him for.
New topic at "The time spent at parties" so new paragraph.
Illegal substances that he ingested were able to latch onto his undesirable feelings and strangle them to sleep.
I personally think "The illegal substances he ingested" sounds better.
to continue hiding in his body and soul. As he walked away from the man,
New topic at "As he walked", new paragraph.
he met eyes with
Sounds clunky. Try "His eyes met"
Surprise exploded from Lenon.
This sounded a little awkward to me. Maybe try "Lenon was far too excited" or something like that.
He wasn't concerned with the past anymore, he wanted to talk about the present and the future.
This sounded a little awkward to me too. You could just say that Nathan didn't want to dwell on the past anymore and leave it at that.
Nathan was crossing his fingers, hoping Lenon wasn't referring to the party where he was on too many painkillers and couldn't stand up straight by his own will. On that night, he eventually stumbled into Lenon causing him to spill his drink all over himself. Lenon took it about as well as anyone because the small amount of vodka and sprite could pass for water. However, Nathan's condition hadn't climaxed yet, and after being helped to his feet, the room and the contents of his stomach began swirling in unison. In an act of sobriety, Nathan stood tall and straight, his eyes looked forward at the blurry room, and he prepared himself for the emptying of his stomach. Projectile vomitus landed on Lenon's shoulder and carved itself into his memory.
I would condense this re-telling because it's a huge block of text and feels like it's going on and on. What are the crucial bits of information? Everything else could be cut out.
The fermented yeast grabbed hold of his mouth and forced a mysterious smile on his face.
Okay "the fermented yeast" is a horrible visual. This whole sentence sounds really awkward to me. It doesn't really make sense.
a desperate laugh to remind Nathan to have a good time. Under most circumstances this would have been successful,
New paragraph at "Under most circumstances"
mind-altering party favors. In this moment though, he remembered what his Preacher said to help him fight back these urges. Baby steps. The voice of his Preacher echoed the words inside his head. Baby steps. He had strength with him now. He wasn't alone and he had a plan.
New paragraph at "In this moment though". Also, when you are recounting the memory of what his pastor said, I would put it in italics for clarity.
She was as beautiful as ever. Nathan broke his gaze on her
Great description of Stacy! New paragraph at Nathan.
However, Nathan was never able to see the subtleties in the way women speak so he stuck to his plan.
I don't think you need this sentence. We'll see that Nathan can accomplish this in the next paragraph so you don't need to state it before then.
He was afraid the couple with white trimmed noses would offer him something he couldn't refuse.
Huh?
Nathan was caught off guard by her physically grabbing him and a vision of the girl's beautiful hand caressing his cheek as her perfectly moist lips pressed against his own struck his mind as quickly as lightning touches ground. Then (When) they entered the kitchen where the Russian nightmare labeled, "Raspberry Paradise," was waiting for them.
The first sentence is very wordy and I think it could be condensed simply to be "Nathan was caught of by the gesture and couldn't help but picture her perfectly moist lips pressed against his own as they made their way to the kitchen."
Baby steps, stick to the plan.
His inner thoughts, italics.
Make sure you call me. He mimicked her voice inside his head as he laughed.
I would italicize the "make sure you call me" as it's a memory.
And he was going to remember everything for the first time in quite a while.
This is a cool idea but it seemed a little out of place here. He hasn't been thinking or talking about memory or not being able to remember any time before this.
The drive home was exciting and captivating. He hadn't been on these roads in a long time and wasn't quite sure he was on the right road, but it didn't matter. There was a winding road ahead of him and he was driving aggressively.
This paragraph felt redundant from the paragraph before it and I think you could take it out.
A dead raccoon had been in the road all day.All of the other vehicles on the road were able to successfully navigate their cars around it, but that was because they were going the speed limit.Nathan sped up a short hill and saw the object in the road. Unsure of what it was, he swerved into the opposite lane. He overreacted.The swerve was one of driving inexperience. At those speeds, he had no idea how the car would handle and the avoidance maneuver spelled out his fate.(new paragraph here) The car's rear tires horizontally slid across the pavement at more than 80 miles per hour, trying to catch up to the direction he was steering. The attempts to steer the car straight were futile. A small dip in the road caused the driver side of the car to float over the pavement and when the tires made contact with the street again, it sent the car rolling ferociously down the road. (new paragraph here) When the top of the car bounced off the pavement it caused Nathan's head to smash into the roof knocking him unconscious. The second roll caved in the driver side of the car, shattering his left knee completely. After a third complete roll, the car slowed enough that it finally came to a pause standing on its passenger side it then gently rolled back onto its roof.
A lot of information was relayed in this paragraph so I marked some spots where I thought you could easily break it up. The lines I slashed out, I did that way because they didn't feel necessary to me. All of the information is still relayed well without them and it feels a lot less clunky to me.
The night was quiet and black clouds covered the stars. The force from the crash ignited memories in Nathan's unconscious mind.Random electrical signals in his brain triggered a dream-like memory inside.(new paragraph here) The night of Thanksgiving dinner when he was five years old grew ablaze. It was the moment when the Dansen family sat down for dinner. The house of four was quiet, all the food was placed on the table and a chandelier served as the main source of light hanging from the center of the dining room. Nathan's parents, Jerry and Claire, sat at the heads of the table while he sat across from his brother, Will.
Same as the previous paragraph.
"Hey Mom, how come people sometimes hold hands before they eat?" Nathan asked while looking at her towards the far end of the table.
This entire memory should be in italics to clarify that this is not the present.
and before every meal they pray to God thanking him for what he (He) gave them.
He chose to give up his faith when his career turned around due to his hard work and dedication which was something he did with encouragement from Claire.
This sentence felt very clunky to me and I'm not sure if I follow what happened exactly.
A breeze crept through the surrounding trees and made its way to the remains of the wrecked cars. The smoke from both of the cars connected with each other and disappeared upwards into the sky. Hissing from the vehicles scared away any odd creatures who might curiously approach the vehicles. Slowly, but surely, the dying sounds of the cars were absorbed by the surrounding forest. A single owl, perched in one of the trees, hooted as death’s silence filled the night.
Why are there suddenly two cars? I thought it was just Nathan's car in the ditch...
"Call 9-1-1!!" Claire yelled at her neighbor.
The rest of the memory, when you are showing us what happened, should be in italics. Prior to that it wouldn't be because you're telling us what happened. Personally, it would be more powerful if you showed us the entire memory from Nathan's five-year-old perspective. (Then the whole thing would be in italics).
The blood coming out of his mouth couldn’t resist the tantalizing charm of death’s song.
This sounds really awkward too. I would take it out.
He didn't look at anyone or anything in particular. The grey sky reflection was turning black in his eyes.
New paragraph at "the grey sky"
I'm alive.
I would put this in italics because it's his inner-thoughts.
The seat-belt was all that held Nathan in place and he needed to get out of there (the car).
His mind went black and filled with a dream.
Again, the whole dream should be in italics.
"Well, you have to believe in God and live your life according to his (His) plan."
He has Ten Commandments he (He) wants us to live by. They're sort of rules that he (He)wants us to follow throughout our lives."
"What rules?" Nathan asked, wondering if he had broken any already.
I loved this. I thought it really reflected a child's real inner thoughts.
"He wants us to believe in only him (Him) as our God, and worship only him (Him). Don't use his (His) name in vain, which means don't say anything bad about him (Him) or use his (His) name in a bad way.
"Oh! And when you get older and get married, he (He) wants you to stay true to your wife."
"I always thought that believing in God and knowing he (He) was with you at all times was good enough to get you up to Heaven.
She tried to cover up what she just said by saying it quickly and ending with a wink.
What is she trying to cover up?
Each individual droplet falling with purpose,
New paragraph starting with this line.
Why am I alone?
Where is my father?
What happens when we die?
All in italics.
It came to a stop a few feet in front of him with the palms still facing him,
New paragraph starting with this line.
I want to go over some of the big things I noticed throughout your story.
First, you have a lot of really great descriptions and use some very beautiful language. However, there are times when this goes overboard. You need to strike a balance and make sure that the beautiful language and descriptions make sense and aren't distracting from the overall message and story. I marked some of the places where I felt you could do this, and it's obviously all up to you, but I would tone it down at times.
Second, I don't feel anything for Nathan. Obviously this is a short story so it is hard to really develop the characters and make readers feel something for them in such a short time, but it's not impossible. I should have felt some emotion when he died and I felt nothing. I know his back story and all of that was sad, but I think it would have been more sad if you had done more showing rather than telling. Show the reader what happened, make us active in the story rather than telling us what happened.
Third, your spelling and grammar are very sound which is great. The one thing I would look out for is to break up those longer paragraphs to help the reader out a little. Also, always capitalize any reference to God (even the He's and Him's)
Overall, I think you have a really nice start to your story here. I think there is a powerful message and it has the potential to be a very moving story. One thing I would think about adding would be Nathan's feelings about God at his current stage in life. Did he grow to accept his mother's beliefs or had he began to develop his own feelings later in life?
Please let me know if you have any questions or if something doesn't make sense!
-Carly
Points: 32055
Reviews: 1162
Donate