z

Young Writers Society


(Title pending) - English assignment needs feedback



User avatar
5 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 2743
Reviews: 5
Sat May 21, 2011 2:55 am
Camulaeus says...



So guys, I kinda have to write a really godo Shorty Story for English, and this is what I have so far. I would really appreciate any feedback you guys have for me.

(Title pending)

Sometimes we can sense when something’s about to go south, and we can work to avoid it. Others just turn right before your eyes, and you just have to cut your losses and run. Yet, there are the ones that sneak up on you, mistakes that don’t become apparent until your neck deep into it. It’s with these merry thoughts that I start my first day of school.

The class is silent as I walk up to my desk, briefcase in hand. The ocean of emotionless faces is damn right menacing, but I’m not going to let a bunch of 11h graders scare me from my first decent pay job in a while. I take a deep breath, calm my nerve and call the class’ attention.

“Good morning class, I’m Mr. Tuan. I’m looking forward to spending the year with you. Let’s just see if everyone’s here Ok?’ No one answers. Not that I expected them to, this is real life, not some Disney Sitcom. “Sorry if any of these come out wrong…um..is there an Kagami Loroso here?”

An ebony skinned girl raises her hand, a single bracelet with an elephant charm dangling from her wrist. Something about her…. seems off.

“Good…now how about Rance Smith?”

“Here” A lanky boy with shoulder length black hair nodded at me. His uniform was impeccable, everything about him was neat, even his pencils were perfectly lined up. I just hoped he had some brains in that bleached head of his.

“Nice to meet you, Rance. Next up…” Oh Lord, “Zbigniew Polaski?” What were mother’s smoking now days? A blonde girl smiled at me. “The “B” is silent” She seemed completely at ease, relaxing in her seat. She reminded me vaguely of a relationship counselor.

“Oh…is it ok if I call you Zig?” she shrugged and smiled some more. “Alright then. Moving on,” Finally, something normal, “Nolan Summers?”

There was no answer, and then I saw Kagami kick the chair in front of her. A boy with brown super-cut and combat boots was startled. “Uh..here?” he said, and then threw dagger eyes at Kagami. She mirrored him perfectly.

“Hello Nolan. Whoa, last one already. Pretty small class, eh?” Again, no answer, even Zig didn’t offer any support. “Right then, let’s see. Morgan Jackson?” A girl with purple hair and a black jacket over her uniform stuck her finger up. Geez…. one in every class.

“Right… well It’s nice to meet you Morgan”

“Totes thanks bro”

What? I mentally note to learn the lingo of the classroom before the year is out.


“Ok…um. So who here remembers what we learnt last year in Literature Study?”

The class simply turned to their laptops. One or two put headphones in. I turn to my own laptop, and pull up Morgan's screen.

Skype

Mørgån: Damn, Twan’s a noob

Kagami Loroso <3: He doesn’t seem that bad… he feels like he’s new at this, but he want’s it really badly. I can relate.

Mørgån: Is thar nythin u don’t relat 2?

Kagami Loroso <3: Eh. Sometimes I feel… like I relate too much.

Mørgån: That’s deep.

Kagami Loroso <3: lol. I know, I’m just deep like that :P

Mørgån: Oo

Kagami Loroso <3: EEW! You’re disgusting. Time out for you missy.

Mørgån has been blocked.


After a painful recap of their sub-standard knowledge, I glumly resign to my desk, watching the screens of my class’s laptops on my own. It was standard school monitoring, and I felt a bit bad for the naivety of the kids. Then I saw Nolan’s copy of the Literature Recap paper hit the floor. I pulled up his screen on the system.

Oovoo Chat

Nølåñ O¬ : I just don’t understand why your so prissy all the time.

Råñçé™: C’mon man. That’s low. & it applies to you 2 (obviously)

Nølåñ O¬: Dude, I’m BI.

Råñçé™: It’s because of Zig, isn’t it? 6 months of us and you still can’t get over her.

Nølåñ O¬: Bro, I’m over her.

Råñçé™: Then why do you keep your “Bi” shield?

Nølåñ O¬: WTH It’s not a shield. It’s the freakin’ truth. So don’t get so snappy at me about being homophobic if you don’t freakin believe in Bis!

I close the screen immediately. I’ve had my full share of teen drama…but this…this was just too much. I look pitifully at Nolan, who has an impassive face on. For the first time I notice the necklace he and Rance both have: a simple chain with two parallel lines on it: never intersecting, but standing side by side.

I decide not to pry any more, getting up to try and get the class to participate.

The Next day.

All five of my students are in class by the time I arrive from lunch. As I expected, none but Zig had done their homework. It looks like I’ll have to go a little unorthodox to get them to engage.

Three difficult lectures later, I settle into my chair as the kids tackle their Shakespearian language pamphlets, or at least try to keep them on their desks.

I’m seriously annoyed by the lack of effort they’ve put in so far. Ok, Ok, it’s the 2nd day of school, but still, they should’ve expected that one class would have a first week absent of “getting to know each other” games and pointless creative writing exercises.

The indicator on my laptop blinks, and I curiously open Zig’s Screen.

PTSG

Advice and tips for premature moth-


The Internet screen closes, as Zig clicks the red “X” at the top. I close the system and let my head sink into my hands. Dear lord. Zig must have forgotten to close the screen when she came to school, and now I knew more about her than I would’ve liked.

Shakily I get up and move over to Nolan, asking him how his worksheet was coming.

45 minutes later, Nolan seems to be able to understand what an “iamb” is. The whole conversation is burdened with an awkward sense of Nolan’s predicament, and how he seemed to sort off know that I knew. I kept glancing over at Zig, hoping I was a bit subtler than I appeared.
With friends and courage one can stand against all foes, for neither man nor God can conquer those who are not alone

"109 in the sky but the pigs won't quit"

GLBT it doesn't matterone thing doesn't change who we are
  





User avatar
13 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 1018
Reviews: 13
Sat May 21, 2011 3:39 am
ashjoy7 says...



Overall I liked this piece. I thought the characters were clear and they had interesting personalities. I get what you're trying to do, and writing with a purpose is probably one of the most important things, especially to English teachers.

The thing that struck me in the first paragraph was the second sentence:

Others just turn right before your eyes, and you just have to cut your losses and run.


The word "just" is used twice. I would suggest either deleting one of them or coming up with a different way to say what you're trying to say. Also the words around the first "just" don't make sense.

Others just turn right before your eyes,


Turn? As in, turn in circles? I would add the word "up" right after the word "turn".

Others just turn up right before your eyes,


Makes more sense.

Next,

The class is silent as I walk up to my desk, briefcase in hand. The ocean of emotionless faces is damn right menacing, but I’m not going to let a bunch of 11h graders scare me from my first decent pay job in a while. I take a deep breath, calm my nerve and call the class’ attention.


Is it Nolan's desk yet? He just got the job, right, so I wouldn't say that it was necessarily his desk yet. I love the way you describe the kids faces as an "ocean of emotionless faces", your teacher will eat that up. There's a slight typo on "11th graders", missing the "h". I might be wrong, I'm not sure, but I think the proper way to say "classes attenion" is to place the apostophe at the end of "classes" like this:

I take a deep breath, clam my nerves and call the classes' attention.


Next,

“Here” A lanky boy with shoulder length black hair nodded at me. His uniform was impeccable, everything about him was neat, even his pencils were perfectly lined up. I just hoped he had some brains in that bleached head of his.


I only have one confusion here. First you say that Lance has "shoulder length black hair", then you say that the teacher hopes he has "some brains in that bleached head of his". Does he have black or bleached hair?

Next,

“Nice to meet you, Rance. Next up…” Oh Lord, “Zbigniew Polaski?” What were mother’s smoking now days? A blonde girl smiled at me. “The “B” is silent” She seemed completely at ease, relaxing in her seat. She reminded me vaguely of a relationship counselor.


You've got a slight tense issue with the sentence "What were mother's smoking now days". The word "were" implies that you are talking about a past event, but the word "now days" (I'd make it "nowadays"), implies that you are talking about an event in the present.

I like how you add some complexity in the formatting structure of this piece by having the characters converse through computers. It adds a different feel to the piece and gives you a lot of power when manipulating how the audience feels about certain characters and their reltaionships with each other.

I hope my nit-picking will help. Good luck!
  





User avatar
191 Reviews



Gender: None specified
Points: 8890
Reviews: 191
Sun Jun 05, 2011 1:04 am
carbonCore says...



Sorry for the late review, my notifications didn't really let me know that someone posted on my thread. Odd, that.

First of all, you characterize so many individuals, but you only use four of them. Why is that?

Second: what is "PTSG"? What is "premature moth--"? Premature "mother"? I have no clue. Perhaps you should clear this up a little bit. Nothing else in this story hints at Zig being a mother.

Third: why did Kagami block Morgan?

Fourth: why does Kagami have a Japanese name, yet she's described as "ebony-skinned"? The Japanese are pretty pale. While we're on the subject of names, Zbigniew is a masculine name, not feminine. I am Eastern European myself, and this caught my eye.

Fifth: What, exactly, is the point of this story? I mean: there are paragraphs and words, periods, and all that good stuff. But there's no conflict, there's no real ending, there's no... real beginning either. What did you try to say with this story? I didn't see anything. All I saw is a scene that doesn't really fit anywhere, for any reason.

Yours,
cC
_
  





User avatar
5 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 2743
Reviews: 5
Mon Jun 06, 2011 7:42 pm
Camulaeus says...



Yeah, this is definitely not my best work. It might even be one of my worst. I had no direction, no idea and no research, it was just the time of the moment, and it resulted in something I regret posting.
With friends and courage one can stand against all foes, for neither man nor God can conquer those who are not alone

"109 in the sky but the pigs won't quit"

GLBT it doesn't matterone thing doesn't change who we are
  





User avatar
136 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 2952
Reviews: 136
Fri Oct 07, 2011 4:42 am
Leahweird says...



Hey! I can see you posted this a while back, but I just wanted to say that I thought this was a really interesting piece. Yes it lacks purpose as of yet, and it has a few problems, but I really like the premis. I think with some expanded information on the various character it could have become something really cool. Don't regret sharing, because I really enjoyed reading it.
  








The real voyage of discovery consists not in seeking new landscapes, but in having new eyes.
— Marcel Proust