Stop The Scrolling Header | Enable the Scrolling Header

Young Writers Society
News:  

The Top 25!

Favorite part of writing?
Username:    Password:      Log me on automatically each visit    
The Wrath of the Createspace Guy: A YWS Fanfic
The Wrath of the Createspace Guy: A YWS Fanfic

by Clo in Scripts
Young Writers Society Forum Index » Other Fiction

This thread was created on September 2, 2008
Post new topic   Reply to topic
Digg It Del.icio.us


Thoughts about pianos

Topic ID: 35483
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
mtempleton   View This User's Portfolio
Junior Writer

25
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 17
Joined: 11 Aug 2008
Posts: 48
Reviews: 25
Country: Scotland
322 Points

PostPosted: Tue Sep 02, 2008 2:38 pm    Post subject: Thoughts about pianos Reply with quote

A piano is a cheat instrument. That’s not to say that it isn’t difficult to get right, it’s just a hell of a lot safer than the string section of your average orchestra.

If life could be a piano, life would somehow be easier to handle. It could be clear cut, so you knew the rules, you knew where you stood. After all, with these guidelines set out for us centuries ago, suddenly the most imposing of instruments can be mastered. The smug look on the face of the musician only confirms as much.

Life as a piano… Each situation could be a sharp a flat or a natural. Black or white. High or low. Even enveloped in the deepest melancholy of a minor key there could be rules to adhere to.

Life is not a piano. There are no steps to be guided along, no easy jumps to make from one note to the next to the next to the next. In life, there is no get out. In pianos, even if your fingers snap off the right notes and your hands won’t stretch far enough to make a chord with middle c and the e above it there is no disaster. If all else fails, you call it jazz.

Life is no guitar either. Think of guitars. Think of frets. Frets are dependable. Frets are handy. Frets are unavoidable. There isn’t a fret in the world which is out to get you. Frets tell you where to put your soft beginner’s fingers in no uncertain terms. A chord on a guitar begs to be played. Even if you can’t quite tell that to the busker with the cold blue fingers, the one who’s voice doesn’t carry in the sad songs and whose tone is not true enough for the happy ones, guitars are easy.

Life is hard.

If you put a finger wrong, a hand slid a fraction too far then all is ruined, and the sound you make is suddenly meaningless.

Life then, is a cello.

Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
bisquit   View This User's Portfolio
Senior Writer

64
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 15
Joined: 29 Jun 2008
Posts: 107
Reviews: 64

300 Points

PostPosted: Wed Sep 03, 2008 10:25 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

WOW! i really enjoyed reading this. Firstly, its original and i have not come across anything like it before! The title immediately brought me in because i am keen on music too!
You have done some great thing in this text and i especially liked the start!

'A piano is a cheat instrument. That’s not to say that it isn’t difficult to get right, it’s just a hell of a lot safer than the string section of your average orchestra.'

The first sentence is powerful, and is also very encouraging for the rest of the piece. the reader is instantly curious to find out further what the point is that you're making! Smile

there was one bit i wasn't sure about but it might just be me. the line...' In life, there is no get out.' I just think that the tone of your piece changed a little with this line. But maybe it IS just me.

Anyhow, this is really awesome! Smile i very much enjoyed it and hope i have been of some help
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
scasha   View This User's Portfolio
What would Keynes do?
Novelist

148
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 17
Joined: 03 May 2008
Posts: 272
Reviews: 148
Country: Under the stars of another sun
436 Points

PostPosted: Wed Sep 03, 2008 1:38 pm    Post subject: Re: Thoughts about pianos Reply with quote

Hey mtempleton!
Here's my review guide:
red = comments
bold = words I've inserted
blue = comments that don't have to do with critiquing the story
Let's do this thing
mtempleton wrote:
A piano is a cheat instrument. That’s not to say that it isn’t difficult to get right, it’s just a hell of a lot safer than the string section of your average orchestra. The transition from this paragraph to the next is a little abrupt.

If life could be a piano, it life would somehow be easier to handle. It could be clear cut, so you knew the rules, you knew where you stood. After all, with these guidelines set out for us Just a note, if you are using second person and then you switch to first person plural, you confuse the readers. Either say you throughout the whole thing or I and us. centuries ago, suddenly the most imposing of instruments can be mastered. The smug look on the face of the musician only confirms as much.

Life as a piano… Each situation could be a sharp Comma a flat Comma or a natural. Black or white. High or low. Even enveloped in the deepest melancholy of a minor key there could be rules to adhere to.

Life is not a piano. There are no steps to be guided along, no easy jumps to make from one note to the next to the next to the next. In life, there is no way to escape get out. In pianos, even if your fingers snap off the right notes and your hands won’t stretch far enough to make a chord with middle c and the e above it comma there is no disaster. If all else fails, you call it jazz.

Life is no guitar either. Think of guitars. Think of frets. Frets are dependable. Frets are handy. Frets are unavoidable. There isn’t a fret in the world which is out to get you. Frets tell you where to put your soft beginner’s fingers in no uncertain terms. A chord on a guitar begs to be played. Even if you can’t quite tell that to the busker with the cold blue fingers, the one who’s voice doesn’t carry in the sad songs and whose tone is not true enough for the happy ones, guitars are easy. This entire paragraph felt out of place. One second, you're talking about the piano. Then you jump to a guitar. Have a smoother transition.

Life is hard.

If you put a finger wrong, a hand slid a fraction too far then all is ruined, and the sound you make is suddenly meaningless. Love this line!

Life then, is a cello. Great way to end it


Onto my overal.

Frankly, my favorite part of the entire piece was the last two sentences. The rest of the piece just felt a bit flat. I know you were going for metaphorical and stuff, but it came across as a little boring and repetitive. Be more descriptive. Use the word "you" more. Have your audience experiencing everything with you and understanding the comparisons you are making with music and life. Weave a story using the stuff you have here. It's a good outline for an even better second person narrative story. Also, watch out for your transitions. It felt as though you hopped around a bit from paragrapah to paragraph. For example, the line at the end of the paragraph that say "...you call it jazz". YOu should either show us an example of what you mean, but don't jump right into another paragraph that says something about a guitar.

Other than that, good job! Keep up the good work. If you have any questions, PM me!

_________________
"Nous sommes tout deux victime. De ce doux jeu d'amants." -- Ce Jeu par Yelle
Want to enter a spiffy contest run by yours truly? Enter Here or how about This One?
Want a truly amazing critique? PM me!!

Got YWS?
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
mtempleton   View This User's Portfolio
Junior Writer

25
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 17
Joined: 11 Aug 2008
Posts: 48
Reviews: 25
Country: Scotland
322 Points

PostPosted: Sun Oct 05, 2008 2:32 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Thank you for your comments! I was quite pleased considering this is really just a musing which my cello playing friend inspired me to write down. There is now a marginally updated version. I hope to make this into a short story soon (or maybe a poem??) so I guess watch this space. If there are any more suggestions as to how to develop this, please let me hear them!

_________________
those who trust in the Lord for strength will find their strength renewed
they will rise on wings like eagles
they will run and not get weary
they will walk and not grow weak
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
olivia1987uk   View This User's Portfolio
Novelist

164
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 21
Joined: 22 Jun 2008
Posts: 257
Reviews: 164

392 Points

PostPosted: Sun Oct 05, 2008 4:06 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Good one! Kudos to you my dear! Must be a UK thing, lol! But anyway, just when I was getting bored of the monotony of reading teenage romance after teenage romance, you come up with something so different, thought provoking and scarily accurate!

Really enjoyed readig this...if you have anything similar I might just have to have a look at that as well!

_________________
Olivia
xxx
http://www.youngwriterssociety.com/topic36697.html
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address MSN Messenger
olivia1987uk   View This User's Portfolio
Novelist

164
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 21
Joined: 22 Jun 2008
Posts: 257
Reviews: 164

392 Points

PostPosted: Sun Oct 05, 2008 4:07 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Good one! Kudos to you my dear! Must be a UK thing, lol! But anyway, just when I was getting bored of the monotony of reading teenage romance after teenage romance, you come up with something so different, thought provoking and scarily accurate!

Really enjoyed reading this...if you have anything similar I might just have to have a look at that as well!

_________________
Olivia
xxx
http://www.youngwriterssociety.com/topic36697.html
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address MSN Messenger
Display posts from previous:   
This thread was created on September 2, 2008
Post new topic   Reply to topic
   Young Writers Society Forum Index » Other Fiction All times are GMT
Page 1 of 1

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You can attach files in this forum
You can download files in this forum
This thread was created on September 2, 2008

Graphics By Bobo | YWS Sword & Shield Logo by Bobo
Bartemius says, You must believe in free will; there is no choice. - Isaac Bashevis Singer
Contact | Memberlist | Copyright Policy | YWS Store | Site Map
Facebook |  Goodreads |  Live Journal |  MySpace |  Wikipedia

© 2004 - 2008 The Young Writers Society