Stop The Scrolling Header | Enable the Scrolling Header

Young Writers Society
News:  

Must Read: No Chat-Speak

Happy Thanksgiving!
Username:    Password:      Log me on automatically each visit    
Secrets of the Unfaithful {2}
Secrets of the Unfaithful {2}

by Angel of Death in Romantic Fiction
Young Writers Society Forum Index » Other Fiction

This thread was created on July 30, 2008
Post new topic   Reply to topic
Digg It Del.icio.us


The Watchers

Topic ID: 33755
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
Conrad Rice   View This User's Portfolio
Clo's Girlfriend...You're Jealous.
Novelist

133
Gender: Gender:Male
Age: 18
Joined: 13 Apr 2008
Posts: 413
Reviews: 133
Country: The Ocean
483 Points

PostPosted: Wed Jul 30, 2008 6:08 pm    Post subject: The Watchers Reply with quote

Daniel walked up the lighted path towards the front door. ‘It’s a beautiful night,’ he thought to himself. Then again, prom night was supposed to be beautiful, was it not?

Daniel went inside. He walked down the hallway towards the Hall of Roses. He passed a few couples on the way. Some glanced in his general direction as he walked on by. But they didn’t say hi, or wave, or acknowledge him in any way. They simply stared through him like he wasn’t even there.

Daniel entered the Hall of Roses. It had been lavishly decorated, with no detail left out. The lights had been shaded so that they cast a deep, rose-colored hue out into the hall. Strips of white gossamer ribbon hung from the ceiling like a gaudy, Victorian spider web. Gold-painted spheres hung amidst the strips like glowing stars among pallid nebulae.

Daniel walked over to the table where he was to sit. The other three were already there. Daniel sat down and Jack reached across the table for his hand.

“Hey Danny,” he said. “Glad you could make it.”

Daniel shook Jack’s hand. “You know me,” he said. “I wouldn’t miss this for the world.”

Benny reached out and shook Daniel’s hand too. Then Mina did the same.

“So, the gang’s all here,” Jack said.

“As it should be,” Mina said.

The other tables began to get up one by one and get their food. But Daniel’s table did not. They were not hungry. They were only here to watch.

“Look at all the people,” Jack said. “They’re like one big ol’ train.”

“Let’s not talk about trains,” Benny said. “I don’t like trains.”

“But Benny, that was back in junior high,” Daniel said. “Didn’t you beat that?”

“I did, I beat the thing,” Benny said. “But I still don’t like trains.”

“Okay man, sorry to bring it up,” Jack said. “But, however you want to say it, that is a lot of people.”

“They won’t talk to us,” Mina said. “But they still talk of us, as though we are not still here.”

“You get used to it,” Jack said, but there was a pang in his voice when he said it. No one had ever talked to him anyway.

They stopped talking for a while after that. Daniel looked at all the people. The boys in tuxes, just like him, sitting around, cracking jokes with each other. The girls in their beautiful dresses, chatting about who looked the nicest and who didn’t. It all painted a very surreal picture.

Then Daniel saw a familiar face in the crowd. “Hey Jack,” he said, nudging his friend. “Isn’t that Ms. Howe?”

Jack looked over. “Hey, it is!” he said. He stood up and waved to get her attention. She noticed them and walked over.

“Hi, Ms. Howe,” Daniel said. “Kind of surprised to see you here. I thought you left.”

“I had,” Ms. Howe said. “I decided to come back to see how everyone was doing. But I’m afraid I’ll be moving on again after this. You four really should too.”

“We cannot,” Mina said. “We still have things to do.”

“Besides,” Jack said. “We’ve got all the time in the world.”

Ms. Howe nodded. “Yes, I suppose you do,” she said. “Well, I hope you enjoy tonight. I must be going now.” She turned and walked away, fading into the crowd.

“Man, I miss her,” Benny said, “She taught us a lot.”

Jack nodded. “That she did,” he said.

They went back to watching. “Hey, Jack,” Benny said. “You had Mrs. Regent. Was what they said about her being easy true?”

“How do you mean?” Jack asked.

“Some of the guys always said somebody got lucky with her once,” Benny said.

“I heard that too,” Daniel said.

Jack shook his head. “Listen,” he said. “If she did, she had a reason. Lord knows she had one, with her husband and all.”

“But did it ever happen?” Benny asked.

Jack did not answer. Daniel looked at him. Jack was gazing at the table where Mrs. Regent was sitting. She wasn’t saying much at all, and she barely had a smile on her face. Her husband seemed to overpower her with his presence. Daniel thought he saw Jack’s eyes begin to tear up. He shook his head at Benny, an unsaid command. Benny nodded in understanding.

Just then somebody walked past. Daniel turned and looked after her. It was Shana Murphy. He’d been something with her once, about a year ago. Daniel made as if to get up and follow her.

“That will do you no good now,” Mina said to him. “She’s moved on. You are only something for her to remember.”

Daniel stopped. He knew that Mina was right, however much he hated to admit it when that happened. So he sat back down, but he watched her as she left. And so the hour passed and all the while the table watched. Then, just before the dancing started, a girl got up and stood at the front of the Hall of Roses. She took a microphone and began to speak.

“Ladies and gentlemen,” she said. “We hope you are enjoying your evening. We’ll start the dance in a moment, but we have a little something to show you first.”

A black screen was projected above her head. One by one pictures of Mina, Jack, Benny, and Daniel. Daniel looked around the room. Most of the girls were crying, a few were outright bawling. The guys shifted around uncomfortably, a few of them began to get moist-eyed. Then the pictures faded away and four words appeared in their place: Gone but Never Forgotten.

“This is how it must be,” Mina said. “We must be here to remind them. We must always be reminding them. They will never forget because we will not let them.”

Daniel stood. Benny had already left. Though he had stared death in the face once before, he still wasn’t used to the whole thing. Jack stood near Mrs. Regent. It almost seemed as though they made eye contact. Daniel felt a cold hand take his.

“Won’t you remind her?” Mina asked, her appearance now every bit that of the fourth-grader she had been when last she lived.

Daniel shook his head. Mina frowned, her lower lip jutting out in the pout so characteristic of young children. “You must remind her,” she said, “It is why you are here. It is your purpose.”

“That’s not true,” Daniel said, pulling away from Mina’s icy grip. “It’s not true at all, and you know it.”

“They must always remember us,” Mina said. “They must never forget the things that they did to us. Who will remind her if you will not? Who will never let her forget?”

Daniel looked around. He saw Shana sitting at her table. She wasn’t crying, but she was not doing much else either. For a moment Daniel considered going over to her, letting her catch just a glimpse. But he saw her smile, and he knew better.

“She’s doing a good job of that herself,” he said to Mina.

“There is no sorrow,” Mina said. “It is not good.”

“You’re still a kid,” Daniel said. “You still haven’t grown up. Let them go away and try to forget us. They won’t, even if we fade away, they’ll still remember us. But they’ll remember a lot more than just the horrible things they did to us. They’ll remember things worth remembering. And that’s how it should be.”

Daniel walked away from Mina, who now pouted alone. He looked at Shana and smiled. Then he turned back to the dance floor. After this he was going after Ms. Howe. She would be better company than those who could not forgive. But for now, there were memories to think about and dances to watch. For beauty is something even the dead appreciate.


_________________
It'll all be k, everybody. It'll all be k.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Sam   View This User's Portfolio
starface
Epic Novelist

1251
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 15
Joined: 12 Dec 2004
Posts: 4920
Reviews: 1251
Country: 'mreeka
446 Points

PostPosted: Sun Aug 03, 2008 1:43 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Hey, Conrad!

I've got to say, that was the most original plot I've seen in a long while. It was really crisply executed--it wrapped itself up, strings and all, in a really short space. Instant gratification at its best, if I do say so myself.

This story is very polished, but still a few things to think about:

- Many of your dialogue bits go like: "This is fantastic," Sam said. "It's like you're really at prom." It's good to create a shift in rhythm, but if it's all you use, it's a rhythm on its own. Break it up with "normal" pieces of dialogue, without the pause, to make it interesting for the reader.

- You never quite resolved what happened to the kids. They died, yes, but if people were grieving, doesn't that mean that they miss the dearly departed? If it was a murder, suicide, etc., then that's something we need to know in order to understand things.

- This made it hard to comprehend Mrs. Howe. She just kind of shows up, but we don't know for sure if she's living or dead because we don't know what happened to her. If you made things a little more final by the end, it'll be easier to understand why your "guest" characters show up.

__

Thanks for the read! Let me know if you have any questions. ^_^

_________________
You can build a throne with bayonets, but you can't sit on it for very long.

- Boris Yeltsin
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address MSN Messenger
Kyte   View This User's Portfolio
Fantasy guru
Master of the Forum

410
Gender: Gender:Male
Age: 17
Joined: 13 Aug 2007
Posts: 1062
Reviews: 410
Country: Somewhere in Florida
73 Points

PostPosted: Sun Aug 03, 2008 1:47 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I must be plot blind... didn't realize they were dead till the end. I just assumed the "pretending they weren't there" part was normal.

Anyway. The review. You started the first three paragraphs with "Daniel," which I think isn't a good idea.
Also, I think a lot of the friends' dialog was a bit formal for teenagers... even dead ones. It's your call of course. Otherwise, this was a great piece.

_________________
Oh, the humanity!
Black Cat Sachiko
We are the Folk, and tonight we speak in one voice of the deeds of all.
Tailchaser's Song
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
JFW1415   View This User's Portfolio
Team SPEW
Master of the Forum

367
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 14
Joined: 07 Jun 2007
Posts: 1287
Reviews: 367
Country: USA
1002 Points

PostPosted: Thu Aug 14, 2008 5:50 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

The promised critique:

Overall Comments

Hmm… it's not your best work, Con. And you made the same mistakes over and over again, so I think an overall would benefit you more than a nit-pick would.

Sentence Structure

In many places, your sentence structure is exactly the same, which becomes repetitive and boring very quickly. Like this:

Quote:
Daniel went inside. He walked down the hallway towards the Hall of Roses. He passed a few couples on the way. Some glanced in his general direction as he walked on by.

I'd combine some of those, or expand on them, or something. It's boring as is, and will make people stop reading.

And you also start with a proper noun or pronoun way too often.

Quote:
Jack did not answer. Daniel looked at him. Jack was gazing at the table where Mrs. Regent was sitting. She wasn’t saying much at all, and she barely had a smile on her face. Her husband seemed to overpower her with his presence. Daniel thought he saw Jack’s eyes begin to tear up. He shook his head at Benny, an unsaid command. Benny nodded in understanding.

See how many of those were like that? This was the paragraph with the most, but you did it in many other places, too.

((Note: I was looking through your stories, trying to find what was similar, and saw something I'd like to comment on for Dandelion Season. You start nearly every paragraph with 'he'!))

Just A Glimpse

We have a lot of side characters in here. The four main ones where Mina, Benny, Danny, and Jack, right? So other than that, we have Ms. Howe, Mrs. Regent, and Shana Murphy. But what do we know about them?

Ms. Howe is definitely the most developed character out of the three. We know that she was an awesome teacher, that she's forgiven, that she's moved on. But what else? If she's a Ms., I'm assuming that she's a little young – she acts like a new teacher, at least. So how'd she die? And where did she go? Why'd she stick around so long just to leave on prom night?

Mrs. Regent confused me the most. She… is abused by her husband? Had an affair? With… Jack? What's her importance? How do they make eye contact… is she dead…?

Shana was probably the worst. Sure, she's not that hard to understand – they dated at some point – but… she just popped in and out. That's it – I felt so rushed reading about her.

Slow down a bit, Con. Let us get to know these characters. They ALL need to be developed.

Character Personalities and Distinctions

Your four main characters were rather lacking as well. I couldn't tell them apart, which is why you had to continually resort to repeating names for us.

While these people all had pretty much the same experience, they reacted to it differently, guaranteed. They had different ways of living before they died. They react to things – hate people – in different ways and for different reasons. Every character is unique – show us this. Don't just stick them all into one mold and act like Danny is the only one with his own mind. He's not – he's just the only one whose mind we can get into.

Character Histories

Eh, I kind of mentioned this in the last one… I really shouldn't make the titles up before I write them, huh? XD

Anyway, I just want some clue to what their lives were like before we meet them.

You kind of do this for Mrs. Regent and her husband, but with these two you're a little over-the-top. SHOW us their history. Let her pull away from his touch when he reaches over to her suddenly, apologize to anyone when she makes a little mistake – stuff showing what happened. (I'm not much help as I don't even know what happened. XD) For her husband, don't be so obvious. Let him have an air about him, let him expect to get his way, but be careful – most men who do bad things put on an act, so you can't go right out and show everything.

Now go do the rest of the characters. XD Remember, yesterday shapes how we act today.

Death

This one's simple: how did they die???

You did mention that they wanted to make everyone remember how terribly they were treated – so was it suicide? You need to be more clear, and then make the class react appropriately. If it's suicide, some people will be mad – same with drunk driving. A murder? They'll be scared.

Then again, everyone reacts differently, so make sure you show it all – don't be so general.

Rules

Same as with fantasy – we need to know what's normal and what's not.

So, a few questions:

- Who can see them?

- Can they interact with the living?

- Why did they stay?

- How do you leave when your done?

- Can you change? (I'm assuming they didn't die in tuxes for the prom?)

- Do they have the wounds of their death on them?

- Do they experience things the way we do? (Feel the beat of the music, the people pressing by, hear the loud chatter…)

Atmosphere

You've done a good job setting up the basic atmosphere, showing where they are. But you neglected the other senses.

(Though first consider the last question in the 'Rules' section.)

Finish the atmosphere: Is it hot? Are bodies pressed close to one another, or is it so spacious there's enough room? Noise level? Is it awkward? Where's the majority of people – on the dance floor or at the tables?

Just bring it a step closer, Con.

Why Are They There?

Through the whole thing, I had the feeling that this wasn't quite right – which is good! I knew it wasn't the normal prom – they were too 'all business' and tense. But maybe a little too much?

Figure out why they're there, and let that show. Is it to remind them how awful they were? Then show anger! Is it to get a last glimpse at the people they used to know? Then show remorse, them trying to soak up every moment. Whatever the reason, they'll act a certain way. Their personalities, at the moment, tell us next to nothing.

Some Random Scenes I Had To Point Out

I just can't resist a good nit-pick. xD

Quote:
Daniel walked up the lighted path towards the front door. ‘It’s a beautiful night,’ he thought to himself. Then again, prom night was supposed to be beautiful, was it not?

This is your first paragraph, yet… I'm not drawn in. Not at all. Pick a point that will automatically hook us, and start there, whether that's before or after this paragraph.

Quote:
One by one pictures of Mina, Jack, Benny, and Daniel.

You're missing something on the end there. Wink

Quote:
“Look at all the people,” Jack said. “They’re like one big ol’ train.”

“Let’s not talk about trains,” Benny said. “I don’t like trains.”

“But Benny, that was back in junior high,” Daniel said. “Didn’t you beat that?”

“I did, I beat the thing,” Benny said. “But I still don’t like trains.”

One word: what??? Please explain, or ditch, 'cause this is just… odd. And I have no idea what they're talking about… how did you beat… the thing? O.o

Last Notes

I know you, Con, so I'm hoping that this critique is okay, even though it is longer than your actual story. XD You know I love you – I'm just trying to help out here, but I can be pretty harsh. But I know this isn't your best, and that's not good. So… I was harsh. XD

I hope this helps a little. Just remember to slow down, let US experience these things. Don't worry about writing something super long – just write until you're done.

PM/IM me for anything, okay?

Oh, and let me know what story this relates to, and I'll see if I can figure out how. I couldn't find the story you were talking about.

~JFW1415

_________________
Man is least himself when he talks in his own person. Give him a mask, and he will tell you the truth. -Oscar Wilde

Join the CIA.

In response to hearing my new story idea: "Aunt April": Oookaaay. You are one sick little puppy aren't you?
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address MSN Messenger
Display posts from previous:   
This thread was created on July 30, 2008
Post new topic   Reply to topic
   Young Writers Society Forum Index » Other Fiction All times are GMT
Page 1 of 1

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You can attach files in this forum
You can download files in this forum
This thread was created on July 30, 2008

Graphics By Bobo | YWS Sword & Shield Logo by Bobo
Bartemius says, Blessed is the man who, having nothing to say, abstains from giving us wordy evidence of the fact. - George Eliot
Contact | Memberlist | Copyright Policy | YWS Store | Site Map
Facebook |  Goodreads |  Live Journal |  MySpace |  Wikipedia

© 2004 - 2008 The Young Writers Society