Stop The Scrolling Header | Enable the Scrolling Header

Young Writers Society
News:  

Must Read: No Chat-Speak

Happy Thanksgiving!
Username:    Password:      Log me on automatically each visit    
Railroad Crossing Photograph
Railroad Crossing Photograph

by BigBadBear in Art & Photography
Young Writers Society Forum Index » Romantic Fiction

This thread was created on July 25, 2008
Post new topic   Reply to topic
Digg It Del.icio.us

Related Items
Possible Related Items Follow:
Who Would've Thought? 2
Who Would've Thought? 3
Who Would've Thought? 4

Who Would've Thought? 1

Topic ID: 33532
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
salsashanno   View This User's Portfolio
Senior Writer

42
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 15
Joined: 24 Apr 2008
Posts: 110
Reviews: 42
Country: here, not there
300 Points

PostPosted: Fri Jul 25, 2008 4:41 am    Post subject: Who Would've Thought? 1 Reply with quote

Done a lot of tweeking here, it's pretty different from when I first posted it. As always, I'd love some reviews!

As my favorite song danced out of the stereo, I bobbed my head along and made my way from the living room back into the kitchen. It was Saint Patrick’s Day—an event that calls for great celebration in my family. The kitchen smelled of nearly burnt nachos, and my mother's home made spaghetti and meatballs. What better Saint Patrick's Day food could one ask for? It was typical of my family to throw a St. Patrick's Day party, only invite Italian people, and then not cook any food remotely Irish. Not the mention the room was packed, because, as usual, my father had invited far too many people. There were a few aunts and uncles in attendance, several of my Dad’s friends from work, along with their daughters, plus two of my friends, Kate and Sam.

I gave the obligatory greeting of a hug or a “nice to see you,” along the way, and most of them responded with the standard "You too! It's so good to see you again, Marie." After that brief exchange, I quickly moved onto the next person, eager to avoid quizzes about my love life or my favorite subject in school.

It was then that I came across some of our oldest family friends, the Starks. Mr. and Mrs. Stark were very good friends with my parents; they had met way back when, and had kept in touch ever since. Next, there was their daughter, Jackie, who was a few years younger than I. And she had grown a lot in the year since I had seen her last. Next, I reached their son, Kyle, who was a few months older than I was. I noticed Sam gesturing for me to escape with her; I threw him a quick “hey”, and quickly made my way up to my room with the girls, while the boys went into the den for some video games.

The party was going along great. I had fun gossiping with Kate and Sam, along with Jackie, while the younger girls listened and giggled. When we made our way downstairs for dessert later that night, we were welcomed by a feast of sweets neatly arranged on the kitchen counter. I carefully selected the ones that looked worst for my health, and sat down in the front room with the rest of the kids. Everyone was gathered around the old, oak, oval table, snacking on the newly baked cupcakes as they pretended to be amused at my youngest brother's latest storytelling creation. He was so excited at his little tale that he was nearly bursting out of his chair as he described the jaws of a crocodile he had supposedly met in his travels. He was midway through a not-so entertaining story when Kate invited me to escape with her for a few moments to get a refill on our Cokes. I happily agreed.

All of the adults were gathered around the kitchen table, listening to a story my father was telling them about the time he was reprimanded by a midget:

"And then she turned to me and said, what, did you forget the jell-o, now, too?"

I couldn't stop myself from rolling my eyes as everyone gathered around the table roared with laughter. Somehow, the story managed to change a little bit each time.

The soda seemed to sizzle as I poured it over the ice cubes. I was pouring some Cola into Kate’s cup when she leaned forward, and whispered something into my ear:

"Wow, Kyle’s pretty cute. He plays hockey, right? Marie, my buddy, my pal, you want to--"

I looked at her, gave her the evil eye, and said, “No! I don't want to put in a good word for you, and yes, I can read your mind. Yes, he does play hockey, but don’t you dare say anything to him! I’ve known him since forever, so, number one, no, he’s not cute! And, number two, he’s off limits, because I know I would have to endure hours of you going on and on about how dreamy he is if anything ever went down...and that would be repulsive.”

Kate replied with laugh, and said:

"Come on, Marie. We both know that the only reason you went on that little rant is because you like him, and you want to keep him all to yourself."

I stood there, shocked. Kate just shot me a sly smile, and proceeded back into the other room. She knew she was disturbing me. Her remarks had put a pit into my stomach. I have to remind her not to ever tell me again when she was attracted to someone. Ever. Was she seriously going to do this to me? I knew she would, she loves to vocalize her attraction. I secretly wondered if Kyle was thinking the same thing about her. But, he couldn’t, of course he couldn’t…that would be…incredibly disgusting. If she dated him, I don’t know what I would do. I’ve known him my entire life. I knew a hell of a lot about him, too. I know that when he gets tired, he itches his nose. Did Kate know that? I didn’t think so. My mom even has a picture of the two of us playing from when I was no older than two.

And me liking Kyle? THAT was the craziest thing of all. I took a deep breath, chuckled to myself about Kate's lunacy, and then walked back into the dining room.


_________________
"A wild thing may say wild things."


Last edited by salsashanno on Sat Aug 23, 2008 10:38 pm; edited 7 times in total
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
scasha   View This User's Portfolio
What would Keynes do?
Novelist

148
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 17
Joined: 03 May 2008
Posts: 272
Reviews: 148
Country: Under the stars of another sun
436 Points

PostPosted: Fri Jul 25, 2008 9:05 pm    Post subject: Re: Who Would've Thought? Reply with quote

Hey Salsashanno!
I'm scasha!
Here's my crit key:Red = Comments
Bold = Words I've inserted that I think work better.
salsashanno wrote:
Reviews are greatly appreciated.

What do you think, too long? Should I cut it in half for the next part?



As my favorite song danced out of the stereo, I bobbed my head along I making my way from the living room back into the kitchen; which was overflowing with people, my family, and friends Wow! Really really long sentence. After I read the next couple lines, I decided you didn't need the end of that sentence. It was Saint Patrick’s Day—an event that calls for great celebration in my family, so my father had invited far too many people, as usual. There were a few aunts and uncles in attendance, several of my Dad’s friends from work, along with their daughters, plus two of my friends, Kate and Sam.
I was making my way through the kitchen, giving you're repeating yourself gave the obligatory greeting of a hug or a “nice to see you,” along the way, and most of them responded with the standard "You too! It's so good to see you again, Marie." After that brief exchange insert comma I quickly moved onto the next person, eager to avoid quizzes about my love life or my favorite subject in school. Make a new paragraph It was then that I came across some of our oldest family friends, the Starks. Mr. and Mrs. Stark were very good friends with my parents, they had met way back when, and kept in touch ever since. Next, there was their daughter, Jackie, a few years younger than I. She had grown a lot in the year since I had seen her last. Soon, I reached their son, Kyle, who was a few months older than I was. I threw him a quick “hey,” and quickly made my way up to my room with the girls, while the boys went into the den for some video games.
The party was going along great. I had fun gossiping with my two best friends You established this in the paragraph above , Kate and Sam, along with Jackie, while the younger girls listened and giggled. When we made our way downstairs for dessert later than night, we were welcomed by a feast of sweets neatly arranged on the kitchen counter. I carefully selected the ones that looked worst for my health, and sat down in the front room with the rest of the kids. Everyone was gathered around the old, oak, oval table, snacking on the newly baked cupcakes as they pretended to be amused at my youngest brother's latest storytelling creation. He was so excited at his little tale that he was nearly bursting out of his chair as he as who? Be careful with pronouns. I wasn't sure who was talking? described the jaws of a crocodile he had supposedly met in his travels. He was midway through a not-so entertaining story about a crocodile when Kate invited me to escape with her for a few moments to get a refill on our Cokes. I happily agreed.
All of the adults were gathered around the kitchen table, listening to a story my father was telling them about the time he was reprimanded by a midget. The soda seemed to sizzle sizzled as I poured it over the ice cubes. I was pouring some Cola into Kate’s cup when she leaned forward, and whispered something into my ear:

"Wow, Kyle’s pretty cute. He plays hockey, right? Marie, my buddy, my pal, you want to--"

I looked at her, giving her the evil eye, and said “No! I don't want to put in a good word for you, and yes, I can read your mind. Yes, he does play hockey, but don’t you dare say anything to him! I’ve known him since forever, so, number one, no, he’s not cute! And, number two, he’s off limits, because I know I would have to endure hours of you going on and on about how dreamy he was if anything ever went down...and that would be repulsive.”
Kate replied with a sly smile, and proceeded back into the other room. She knew she was disturbing me. Her remarks had put a pit into my stomach. Was she seriously going to do this to me? I knew she would, she loves to vocalize her attraction. I secretly wondered if Kyle was thinking the same thing about her. But, he couldn’t, of course he couldn’t…that would be…incredibly disgusting. If she dated him, I don’t know what I would do. I’ve known him my entire life. I knew a hell of a lot about him, too. I know that when he gets tired, he itches his nose. Did Kate know that? I didn’t think so. My mom even has a picture of the two of us playing from when I was no older than two.
Feeling sick to my stomach, I walked back into the front room.
Whoa, whoa, whoa, my head was telling me, rewind…sick to your stomach? What is this?

Could I possibly have feelings for Kyle?


Interesting story! I really liked it! here are some additional suggestions:

Let me tell you a story: Watch out for telling. You do too much of what I call fast-forwarding. You don't show us what's going on. You tell us that her dad's telling everyone a story but instead have them walk in and have her dad say: "so this one time i was talking to this midget..." and then have your MC roll her eyes and say there's that story again, or something. Just describe more, show us how they feel, show us what they're saying. instead of saying they gossiped, show us how they gossiped.

Too Fast!: It was really abrupt (The ending). I was a bit confused because the part that Kate and your MC are talking about Kyle, your MC goes ballistic. We don't know enough about her to understand what she's feeling. You say she's Kyle's friend and when she sees him, she doesn't feel anything, but then all of a sudden she's like omg I like him. Just smooth over the transition a bit more. Show us more of her thoughts.

Other than that, good job! Keep up the good work! If you have any questions, feel free to PM me!

_________________
"Nous sommes tout deux victime. De ce doux jeu d'amants." -- Ce Jeu par Yelle
Want to enter a spiffy contest run by yours truly? Enter Here or how about This One?
Want a truly amazing critique? PM me!!

Got YWS?
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Clo   View This User's Portfolio
electronica dance queen
Master of the Forum

265
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 19
Joined: 13 Jun 2008
Posts: 1079
Reviews: 265
Country: in an Octopus's Garden
1047 Points

PostPosted: Tue Aug 05, 2008 8:07 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Hey Salsa! I will be your reviewer for today. *waves* =D
Quote: Mr. and Mrs. Stark were very good friends with my parents, they had met way back when, and kept in touch ever since
You have two separate ideas here, so that comma makes this a comma splice, or a run-on sentence. To fix this, there are a few things you can do – I would recommend a “semi-colon” or making them two separate sentences. A semi-colon is generally used in place of an and, but you already have one in the last part of the sentence, which is why I recommend a semi-colon.
“…with my parents; they had met way back when, and kept in touch ever since.”
Also, it should be “had kept in touch ever since.”

Quote: Next, there was their daughter, Jackie, a few years younger than I, she had grown a lot in the year since I had seen her last
“a few years younger than me”
You have another comma splice/run-on here. Easy fix! Here, because there are no other “ands”, you can make this into another sentence, add an “and”, or a semi-colon. I think a new sentence would look best.

Quote: Soon, I reached their son, Kyle, who was a few months older than I was.
If a family were coming to a party, at first they would probably all be together. Because of this, I don’t think the “soon” is the best choice of word. It makes it sound like Kyle is a distance away from his family. I think it would sound best to say that her eyes drifted over to him, or that she spotted him, or something along those lines, to imply that she hasn’t had to move much to see him.

Quote: I noticed Sam gesturing for me to escape with her; so I threw him a quick “hey,” and quickly made my way up to my room with the girls.
The comma and quotation thing appears again here. Your “hey” here is a phrase, not dialogue, so the comma goes outside of it: “hey”, and quickly. Also, I’m not sure if the “so” after a semi-colon is technically incorrect, but it sounds bad. So nix the so.

Quote: When we made our way downstairs for dessert later than night
Small typo. That.

Quote: He was midway through a not-so entertaining story about the crocodile
You already mentioned that his story was about a crocodile, so you don’t need to repeat that. You can just say “not so entertaining story.”

Quote: And then she turned to me and said, what, did you forget the jell-o, now, too?
Since this is dialogue, it should be in quotation marks.

Quote: Wow, Kyle’s pretty cute. He plays hockey, right? Marie, my buddy, my pal, you want to—
Same goes for here. Dialogue goes in quotations.

Quote: I looked at her, gave her the evil eye, and said “No! I don't want to put in a good word for you, and yes, I can read your mind.
Dialogue grammar: “and said, ‘No!” You need a comma after said.

Quote: and on about how dreamy he was if anything ever went down...
Was? Does something happen to him? ^_^ “how dreamy he is if anything ever went down…”

ATMOSPHERE
There’s a party going on, and that’s fun – it would be fun to describe too. You need to put more detail in the setting. Think of the five senses around Marie: what would she smell, taste, see, touch, hear? Her senses would be overwhelming her at party that has a lot of people, crowding her in – so let us feel that, too, as we read. There could be constant music coming from a stereo, she could smell nacho dip and pizza sauce, people could be brushing up against her. When you add more description to the setting, this party will just unfold around the reader and put them there. That should be your goal.

Also, you could slow down you pace a little… let us absorb more of the setting and character interaction.

OVERALL
This is a good intro – I think it’s interesting, starting at a party. A lot of things can happen with everyone together. It’s also a good way to get to know the main character, because we get to see how Marie acts in company. All you need to do is add a little more description and detail to the characters and the world around them. Really place us into the setting. But I love a good romance story, so I look forward to reading the next parts. Very Happy

Thanks for the read! Feel free to PM me if you have questions.

~ Clo

_________________
I need someone to toss the confetti at the ticker tape parade.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address Yahoo Messenger
Merry_Haven   View This User's Portfolio
Take a step into eternity
Novelist

162
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 18
Joined: 25 Jul 2008
Posts: 347
Reviews: 162
Country: ~Where the home is~
1870 Points

PostPosted: Sat Aug 23, 2008 4:29 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

salsashanno-
When I saw that you had St. Patricks Day, I freaked. I just love that holiday. All that green. *smiles*
The title: Who Would've Thought? didn't make sense, but then it hit me when I read the ending.
It was an abrupt ending but it makes me want to read the next chapter. Which I'll totally do.
I think all you need is character description of the people Marie sees through her eyes. I like to know who her dad's friends are besides the Starks. Like who else came besides her friends? And what about Kyle? What does he look like and besides the fact that he plays hockey? I like to know more about him, Marie and Kate.
Otherwise I'm off to read more...oh, and great job! Keep it up.
-Merry
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Yahoo Messenger MSN Messenger
sokool15   View This User's Portfolio
"Good God, you're a woman!"
Speaker of the Forum

368
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 17
Joined: 11 Dec 2006
Posts: 698
Reviews: 368
Country: Wunderbar!
404 Points

PostPosted: Sat Aug 23, 2008 6:17 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Quote:
It was typical of my family to throw a St. Patrick's Day party, only invite Italian people, and then not cook any food remotely Irish.


Hee hee... that made me laugh literally out loud. Nicely constructed sentence.

Overall, I really really liked this beginning! I was happy to see you'd posted more, because I didn't want to stop reading just yet. I'll toodle off to check out the other ones, too.

A couple of minor things:

first paragraph, you said "Not the mention the room was packed," when it should have been "not TO mention..." if you see what I mean.

Also, in two paragraphs you say that Kate invited her to escape somewhere. I would use the phrase once, and then the next time just say, "Kate was gesturing me towards the kitchen" or something like that.

Also, i thought it was a little abrupt that she's just casually tossing Kyle a "hey" one minute and then the next she thinks she might have feelings for him.

Note: "have feelings" is a really weak phrase - it reeks of eighteenth century prudishness, if you know what I mean. Anyway.

So besides those little things, an excellent read. I really can't wait to see the others.

Au revoir,
MademoiselleKool Cool

_________________
"Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the universe."
~Albert Einstein
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Display posts from previous:   
This thread was created on July 25, 2008
Post new topic   Reply to topic
   Young Writers Society Forum Index » Romantic Fiction All times are GMT
Page 1 of 1

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You can attach files in this forum
You can download files in this forum
This thread was created on July 25, 2008

Graphics By Bobo | YWS Sword & Shield Logo by Bobo
Bartemius says, All right pie, I'm just going to do this (munch munch). And if you get eaten, it's your own fault. (munch munch, bang) Ow! Oww!! - Homer Simpson
Contact | Memberlist | Copyright Policy | YWS Store | Site Map
Facebook |  Goodreads |  Live Journal |  MySpace |  Wikipedia

© 2004 - 2008 The Young Writers Society