Stop The Scrolling Header | Enable the Scrolling Header

Young Writers Society
News:  

Must Read: No Chat-Speak

Happy Thanksgiving!
Username:    Password:      Log me on automatically each visit    
To Swallow a Swallow
To Swallow a Swallow

by Suzanne in Other Poetry
Young Writers Society Forum Index » Romantic Fiction

This thread was created on June 22, 2008
Post new topic   Reply to topic
Digg It Del.icio.us

Related Items
Possible Related Items Follow:
God Still Loves You (1)
God Still Loves You (2)
God Still Loves You (3)
God Still Loves You (4)

God Still Loves You (5)

Topic ID: 31977
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
Suzanne   View This User's Portfolio
won NaNoWriMo!
Writer of Legend

1754
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 18
Joined: 21 Sep 2006
Posts: 7088
Reviews: 1754
Country: Riverbluff, MO
1160 Points

PostPosted: Sun Jun 22, 2008 6:44 pm    Post subject: God Still Loves You (5) Reply with quote

(This isn't as good as I wish it was, but I'm going on vacation Monday, and I didn't want to leave my "fans" without an ending. Please keep in mind, though I edited thoroughly, it was not given as much treatment as the other section. Do slay it, though.)

011. What The Bible Knows

The ice crashed around us like the sky was falling. I stood and waited while she tried to get her key into the lock. Nina’s fingers shook. I could have heard the key strike against metal as she continued to miss, if it hadn’t been for the ice beating the windows, the ground, my face.

The ice hit like it came from a machine gun. With each hit, my face lost more and more sensation, but despite that, I could still feel the cold searing my skin. I wrapped my hands around hers and pushed the key in the lock.

She turned it without my help.

“The cold’s gunna kill me!” Nina shouted once we were inside.

I pealed my coat off. “Only if it kills me first.”

She giggled. “Ice like that kills everyone.”

I watched her take off her coat, her scarf, her gloves, her sweater. Underneath it all was a long sleeve shirt; it was the only way to survive walking a mile in this kind of weather. Nina curled up on her couch.

“I’m so cold, Josie. Even my bones are frozen.”

I sat by her feet. “You’re bones are fine.”

She lied with her head towards the cushions, arms wrapped around herself.

“I’m so, so cold.”

I was, too. I was so cold I couldn’t feel my heart beat. I wasn’t sure I had one anymore.

Her jeans were rolled up to her ankles, and her tennis shoes were digging into my leg. She hadn’t taken them off at the door. I pulled on the laces, then the shoes, until they slipped off. Nina didn’t notice. “Do you know what today is?” I asked, setting them on the floor.

She looked up from her pillow-arm fort. “No?”

“It’s been three months since I got lost and found you.”

Nina giggled and threw a pillow at me. “If you aren’t going to let this cold kill me, then you should help me warm up.”

I hid my blush with the pillow. What I wouldn’t tell her: it was two weeks and four days since I kissed her. Since she sinned.

“Would you really want me to do that?” I asked, throwing the pillow back after I had regained myself.

“I’m cold, Josie! We ain’t got a good heater so you might as well do me some use if you ain’t going to teach me math.” Her hand grabbed mine and pulled me to her.

The way she hungered for my touch scared me, but I couldn’t tell her no. Nina kept her head to the cushions and I wrapped myself around her. It was a Josie-Couch sandwich, and Nina was the innards.

She kept my hand tightly in hers. She squeezed it with so much love, I thought my fingers would pop on the ends and spray blood. I ignored how close I was to her. Instead, I counted the dots in the couch fabric. One, two, three…

Nina pulled on my fingers. “I want to tell you a secret,” she whispered.

Her voice tickled the hairs inside my ear, and I felt a small fire light in the back of my brain. My stomach felt like it was in a washing machine: left, right, left right, churn churn stop. I wanted to throw up.

“Okay.” I stopped counting the couch dots and forty two.

“It’s about my momma,” she started. “What I told you. That’s not why she left.” Nina let go of my fingers. She took a breath, but didn’t look at me. She kept to herself. “You can’t tell nobody, but I saw Momma kiss someone, kiss a woman, and she told me she didn’t love Father anymore. That’s why she went to Arkansas.”

It was the first time I truly had nothing to say. I felt like my tongue had been cut off. She rolled over and looked into my eyes. “I haven’t seen my momma in a long time, and I miss her so much.” Her hands found their way around me and she hugged me, curling her head against my chest. “You remind me a lot of her, Josie. She was just like you, she was…”

I whispered to myself, “A sinner.”

Nina heard me. She wriggled and sat up and looked at me with flames in her eyes.

No,” she said, in a voice unfamiliar to me.

Nina put her hands around my face and stared into my eyes. I smiled out of impulse—her hands were so soft.

“Like that,” Nina whispered. “That’s what she was. She was happy.”

Without another word she crawled up next to me with her face towards the cushions again. I wrapped my arms around her but couldn’t find the words to speak. I felt her shuddering underneath me, and I thought she might be crying.

I didn’t want to know if she was. Wasn’t she the strong one…? Didn’t she have God…?

She stopped shuddering, and I held her tighter. I think Nina fell asleep for a while, or if she didn’t, she lied still enough to fool me. I continued counting the fabric dots, one after another, starting at forty three and going on.

I could see the sun slipping away from the windows, letting darkness creep over us. I stopped 204.

“Are you cold anymore?” I asked.

“I’ll never be cold with you next to me,” she said, but it wasn’t as joyful as I had hoped. Her voice was laced with tears. “What do you think Father would do if he saw us like this?”

“Kill me.”

“I’d not let him. God says not to kill.”

I stirred behind her, because the fire in the back of my brain was spreading to other parts and I couldn’t think and my eyes were burning now.

“God says a lot of things.”

“You make me worry.”

I felt dizzy. “You make me worry, too, Nina.”

Somewhere in the house a faucet was leaking, and a clock was ticking, and the cat was meowing, and every noise possible was being made, but the house was still silent to our existence.

“Josie,” she whispered. I felt my dizzy spirit slam into me. “Do you ever think about hell?”

“Don’t talk about that,” was all I could think to say. I didn’t want her to think about it. I didn’t want her to know what she already knew.

“But I want to know. Do you think about it?”

The blood was rushing to my face, so I sat up. Nina rolled over and looked at me. Her eyes were red around the edges, swollen; she was still beautiful.

“I’m not sure I believe in hell,” I replied.

“Do you believe in God?”

“I don’t know.” I bit my lip and stared out into her living room. Jesus was being born on the fireplace, and crucified above the mantel. There were no seasons in Nina’s house. “Maybe I do, now.”

“Then why?” I felt her small fingers grab my hands again, begging that I lay next to her again. “Why would God do this, Josie?” He voice scared me more than her touch. “Why would God make loving someone a sin?”

I thought she was crying again and I thought I might cry. “I don’t know, Nina. What does the bible say?”

She frowned again and I felt her shudder against me. Nina sat up and wrapped her arms around me. We hugged, and I felt something wet and warm smudge against my arm. I didn’t mind being her tissue, but I didn’t want her to cry. I didn’t want to drown in her flood.

“I think you should go soon,” she whispered, after she had stopped crying.

“I want to stay.”

Nina shook her head.

“Father will be home soon and he’ll kill you and if he doesn’t then the ice will.” She was staring down into my lap, looking at my hand. Nina’s fingers traced the lines in my palm. “I worry about you walking home in that horrible weather.”

“God will protect me.” I ran my fingers through her hair and pulled her too me again. She struggled out of the hug and got up from the couch.

“I want you to have something.” Then she left the room. I watched her wander down the hall and into a doorway. She stayed hidden for a moment, then came back out with a book in her hand.

Nina held it out to me; it was a King James Bible. I took it, though it made me feel sick.

“What’s this for?” I asked.

“It’s a gift.”

She stared at her feet. Nina made eye contact like it was part of breathing; I didn’t want to know why she stared at floor now.

“Josie,” she cooed, and sat down next to me. “Josie, can I ask you something’? I know I’m asking you lots of questions but I want to ask you somethin’”

“Sure.” My stomach was in the dryer now; a constant tumult.

Nina leaned close to me, so close her breath stroked my throat and my chin and swirled with my own breath until our breath was one. “Will you kiss me again, before you go?”

I tried to say, “You never need to ask that,” but the words slurred as our lips met. Not in the failed way they mingled before, but as though they danced together, caressing her top with my bottom, until they split apart with the energy of nuclear fission.

Her face was pale for a moment, then bright red. Nina continued to stare at her feet.

“Please be safe walkin’ home,” she said.

“I will.”

Nina walked me to the door and I put my layers of warmth back on and I left. There was nothing else.

The ice had stopped, and only the bitter wind nibbled my face. Nothing on the walk home was significant; I spent it trying to ignore the biblical weight in my pocket.

I opened it as soon as I was home and in my room. On the front cover was written Leviticus 18:22. My fingers hadn’t flipped the pages of a Bible since my school project on creation myths, but a note tucked into the pages made it easy to find.

Underlined in shaky red pen:

Thou shalt not lie with mankind, as with woman kind: it is an abomination.

The folded note had my name written on it. I hesitated for just a second, wondering what would be inside it. It was from Nina. It was her writing. Her tiny scrawl, perfect cursive, so that the J was looped and the E curved farther out than normal. I opened it with shaking hands.

I know it says mankind but it’s the same thing as womankind. Thou shalt not lie with womankind as with mankind. It doesn’t say why. It just is.

I don’t need you tutoring me anymore. I’m sorry. Please don’t come over again.

It’s an abomination but God still loves you.

(I could see the hesitation in the next line. The ink shot to the right and shuddered for a moment until the words were written, firm and meaningful. Each letter was scratched into the paper; I could feel the indentations on the other side.)

I love you, too.

Nina

I didn’t cry then, but I did later. I cried when I slept, I cried when I thought of her, I cried when I saw an apple, or a Bible, or an aged math book. I kept the bible on my shelf, unread, because I was scared of what I would find. I kept the note with me, always, folded several times and tearing on the edges.

I walked to her house once, wondering if she would be outside, cleaning apples again, waiting for me. No one sat on the porch, and the apple trees had been cut down. The house looked more dilapidated than it had the first time I saw it.

I memorized the words of her note. I didn’t need the note anymore; I knew it by heart. I still kept it with me. I repeated sections to myself, and they became my mantra.

It didn’t matter that I was an abomination. Somewhere deep, too, I knew it didn’t matter that she loved me, because I’d never see her again.

It mattered because God still loved me.

THE END

There you go! Now that you've gotten to the end of God Still Loves You, I would like to thank everyone who has read the whole series, and has given me many amazing critiques. I am unsure of whether or not I will rewrite this. It ultimately depends on my effort and time. I do appreciate everything you have said, and this story meant a lot to me, so I hope it meant the same to you. Keep your eyes open; you may find a rewrite of this, or perhaps, in a year or so, a whole novel. Again, thank you!


_________________
I demand
you put my heart back in my hand,
and wipe it clean from the mess you made of me.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website AIM Address MSN Messenger
BigBadBear   View This User's Portfolio
Pokémon! Gotta catch 'em all!
Master of the Forum

615
Gender: Gender:Male
Age: 15
Joined: 07 Oct 2007
Posts: 1720
Reviews: 615
Country: USA
937 Points

PostPosted: Sun Jun 22, 2008 6:54 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

This is a perfect ending for a perfect story.

Ugh. I really wish I had time to do a proper critique. I have to get going to church right now, but when I get home, I'll come back and edit this. But while I'm here, I'll give you my two cents.

This was an extremely emotional piece. Very, very well written, as everything you write is, Suz. This wasn't my favorite part out of all of them, but it was up there. Well done. Smile

Nina seemed a bit out of character, but I'll talk more about that when I edit this post.

Amazing.

-Jared

EDIT: I'm back!

The grammar was (as always) very good. No mistakes that I could find. I'm so glad that your writing is improving.

CHARACTERS:

Josie is a very shy character. We can tell that throughout the story, she is building up confidence with Nina. In the end she is freely expressing her emotions, which is a fantastic change of character. Josie was a very well developed character, and I have little to complain about.

Nina, however, came across as a little bit of a hypocrite, which she was. It's not like we, the reader, didn't care about Nina. She was amazing to begin with--the Bible quotes and Jesus cookies--but in the end she kind of fell apart. I'm not sure if this is what you wanted to happen. She sudden seems to forget about all of her religious stuff and let her sexuality take over. Nina is a very strong character, and I think that (if you rewrote this, you should take more time describing the process which Nina goes through. You know. The process of going from perfect religious child to a sinner. I would like to see more of this.

Okay. That took a while to type. XD

I love this piece for obvious reason.

1) The characters play an important part, and you pulled everything off smoothly, except for the Nina part, up there. ^

2) The Jesus cookies were hilarious.

3) The religious stuff really packed a punch in here, and I loved it.

Anyway, another fantastic story. I can't wait to see your first published story. I'm gonna be the nerdy one in the booksigning.

-Jared

_________________
Read The Novel House here!!

Enter the YWS Fanfic Contest Today!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website AIM Address MSN Messenger
XxxDo   View This User's Portfolio
Oh, life..
Novelist

88
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 16
Joined: 29 Mar 2008
Posts: 385
Reviews: 88
Country: Switzerland and The Netherlands
424 Points

PostPosted: Mon Jun 23, 2008 7:15 am    Post subject: Heya Reply with quote

Oh my God Suzanne, yet another piece of incredible work! It's really nice, and I love it. Really, try to get it published someday, for it is definetly of good enough quality for that! Wink

It is such a heartbreaking, though fitting, ending of the series. You really allow the reader to feel for both Nina and Josie, and we learn to pity both at some moments. I hope Nina ends up alright, too.

Keep writing! Very Happy

Happy editing, and have a nice holiday!
XxxDo


Reviewed by XxxDo for Suzanne 5.doc
 Description:
Here it is :D

Download
 Filename:  Reviewed by XxxDo for Suzanne 5.doc
 Filesize:  40 KB
 Downloaded:  24 Time(s)


_________________
I love NaNoWriMo ^^ it is the absolute awesomeness.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website MSN Messenger
Squall   View This User's Portfolio
Roll of Thunder, Hear My Cry
Speaker of the Forum

452
Gender: Gender:Male
Age: 17
Joined: 01 Feb 2007
Posts: 650
Reviews: 452
Country: New Zealand
3913 Points

PostPosted: Mon Jun 23, 2008 11:27 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Hehe, you ask, I deliver.

Quote:
The ice crashed around us like the sky was falling. I stood and waited while she tried to get her key into the lock. Nina’s fingers shook. I could have heard the key strike against metal as she continued to miss, if it hadn’t been for the ice beating the windows, the ground, my face.

The ice hit like it came from a machine gun. With each hit, my face lost more and more sensation, but despite that, I could still feel the cold searing my skin. I wrapped my hands around hers and pushed the key in the lock.


Just something minor, but when I was reading this, it seemed kinda disrupted due to the repetition of several words.

Quote:
I hid my blush with the pillow. What I wouldn’t tell her: it was two weeks and four days since I kissed her. Since she sinned.


This is why I want this to be a novel, not a novella. I want to know what happened to them during that big time gap.

Quote:
I stirred behind her, because the fire in the back of my brain was spreading to other parts and I couldn’t think and my eyes were burning now.


I was thinking. If you omit the "and" and start a new sentence from "my", it adds some effect of emphasis on Josie's eyes burning.

Quote:
Jesus was being born on the fireplace, and crucified above the mantel. There were no seasons in Nina’s house.


I kind of get what you mean, but the metaphor is somewhat convoluted because you haven't strongly identified as to what the "Jesus" could be.

Quote:
I didn’t mind being her tissue, but I didn’t want her to cry. I didn’t want to drown in her flood.


Nice use of bringing back up the flood metaphor again.

Quote:
“God will protect me.” I ran my fingers through her hair and pulled her too me again.


"To".

Overall impressions:

Firstly, I want to counter one of BBB's points about Nina letting her sexuality taking over. In my opinion, it's a good thing actually as Nina is slowly being aware of who she is as a person. She gains the experience from a different viewpoint or perspective and hence she acts a bit differently here. Nina is still quite a strong character and still holds on to her religious values, she is just simply made more aware of who she is with her experiences with Josie.

What I can say however is that I think the change seemed rather rushed. We the reader don't really see her slowly changing as a character as she takes in her new experience. As we are not shown that, we have to assume that there was a process that Nina underwent internally in coming to terms with her experience. I think this could be one aspect you could improve on as you rewrite it.

Another thing (and you will probably hate me for repeating this) is Josie's background. Josie is more academically inclined than Nina (shown by her position as Math tutor and I can also assume that she also does science-related subjects due to the descriptions you use in her voice) whereas Nina is more religiously inclined.

However, it seemed to be that you only did that so that firstly, you can get them together and secondly to provide a reason as to why Josie is not that religiously inclined so that part of the plot involves her learning from Nina and hence making her character develop in order to fulfill the protagonist's desire for Nina.

I think it could have been more deeply explored as the ideas you've presented on those films are somewhat linear. One suggestion is that you consider the benefits and negatives on science/ knowledge and religion. From what I recall from the first part, Josie seems to be good at math, but doesn't seem to show much appreciation for her skills. This isn't elaborated on further, and I wanna know more about that aspect. If you are able to elaborate on it further and somehow utilize it in helping to tell the narrative as a whole, then I think it would add more depth to Josie. Another example: Why did Nina decided to seek Josie for math help? How does her religious background help contribute to this?

These are some of my suggestions though, so feel free to ignore them if you think I've gone mental lol Smile

Thirdly, I would also like to take this time to point out that I thought the 3rd part of this novella was the weakest. I disliked how the students in the cafe scene were portrayed. It seemed kinda shallow as it follows so closely to the stereotype of teenagers being associated with sex. I think you should had been able to explore and show further as to why they would behave that way. Maybe it's because they want to fit with the majority so that they don't experience the fear of isolation. Maybe it's because they want to find out who they are as a person. I just feel those minor characters weren't given enough justice since it is reliant on an old and worn stereotypical idea to make those characters work.

On the other hand, I can see why you didn't develop them as much as it is quite a good foreshadow of what Nina will experience at the climax of the novella.

I think that's all I have to say at the moment. Overall, I really like the series, particularly the style of the narrative, the characters and the themes you are portraying in the novella.

Good luck in trying to get this published and I'll give you a gold star as luck.

If I can think of something more that you can improve on, then I'll let you know.

Andy.

_________________
Dolphins for the win!

Originally known as Clockwerk Goblin. Back to my first username.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website MSN Messenger
Azila   View This User's Portfolio
Yes we did!
Speaker of the Forum

501
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 13
Joined: 23 Jul 2007
Posts: 968
Reviews: 501
Country: The Valley of the Wind
326 Points

PostPosted: Mon Jun 23, 2008 3:52 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Hey, Suz!

Quote:
The ice crashed around us like the sky was falling. I stood and waited while she tried to get her key into the lock. Nina’s fingers shook. I could have heard the key strike against metal as she continued to miss, if it hadn’t been for the ice beating the windows, the ground, my face.
The ice hit like it came from a machine gun. With each hit, my face lost more and more sensation, but despite that, I could still feel the cold searing my skin. I wrapped my hands around hers and pushed the key in the lock.
I agree with Andy -- you use the words "ice" and "hit" a lot here.

Quote:
Underneath it all was a long sleeve shirt; it was the only way to survive walking a mile in this kind of weather.
I'm pretty sure "long sleeve" is hyphenated. I also think it's "long-sleeved" but I may be wrong (and probably am ^_^).

Quote:
She lied with her head towards the cushions, arms wrapped around herself.
Unless you're trying to do some sort of dialect thing, "lied" should be "lay."

Quote:
I think Nina fell asleep for a while, or if she didn’t, she lied still enough to fool me.
Again, that "lied" thing! The fact that you do it twice makes me think it's intentional... but "lied" is the past-tense of "lie"... like to tell an untruth. And also, if you're trying to portray colloquials -- it isn't working because none of the other narrative has anything like this. So I think you should change this to "lay." ^_^

Quote:
“I’d not let him. God says not to kill.”
The first sentence seems unnatural -- especially for dialogue. Maybe try "I wouldn't let him."

Quote:
Her eyes were red around the edges, swollen; she was still beautiful.
Show us why she's beautiful to Josie -- don't tell us. ^_~

Quote:
He voice scared me more than her touch.
*her.

Quote:
I ran my fingers through her hair and pulled her too me again.
*to.

Quote:
I watched her wander down the hall and into a doorway.
"wander" strikes me as an odd word choice. I'm sure you're using it intentionally, and you have a good reason... but I don't like it. It implies meandering without reason or purpose. It implies (despite the saying "all who wander are not lost") being lost. I suggest you change it.

Quote:
“Josie, can I ask you something’? I know I’m asking you lots of questions but I want to ask you somethin’”
There should be a period/comma at the end there, no?

Quote:
My stomach was in the dryer now; a constant tumult.
Didn't you say it was in the dryer before? Maybe you should replace "now" with "again."

Quote:
My fingers hadn’t flipped the pages of a Bible since my school project on creation myths, but a note tucked into the pages made it easy to find.
Made what easy to find?! The quote? *confused*

Quote:
(I could see the hesitation in the next line. The ink shot to the right and shuddered for a moment until the words were written, firm and meaningful. Each letter was scratched into the paper; I could feel the indentations on the other side.)
This doesn't need to be parenthetical, methinks.

Quote:
It didn’t matter that I was an abomination. Somewhere deep, too, I knew it didn’t matter that she loved me, because I’d never see her again.
It mattered because God still loved me.
Wait?! So does she think it DOES matter or it DOESN'T? I don't really like the fact that you leave on an unsure note like that; I don't know what feeling to walk away with.
_____________

Overall, I can definitely tell that this hasn't had as much love as other sections. There are some great lines, but mostly they seem out of place -- like you didn't have time for normal narrative/description, so you just decided to jam in all the strong lines anyway. But those lines are so flavorful that we need more in-between, if you know what I mean. We need more normal, every-day type narrative to help us digest the really powerful, pithy, poetic lines.

I'm also disappointed by the fact that there isn't an extended metaphor. There aren't even that many or your gorgeous religious metaphors in this section. And (like I said before in PM) the plot of GSLY isn't particularly stellar; it's the metaphors that make it for me (and, of course, your way with words). Without the metaphors it's still beautifully written, and the emotion is masterful, but -- somehow -- it feels like it's "just a story," whereas before it was sooo much more.

The ending feels a little rushed... I mean the very end; the part where she talks about the note. It feels like you were in a hurry to finish it up and didn't take the time to make the flow better.

I would also like a little more description. I know this section is more about the emotion/dialogue, but I would still like some of your beautiful imagery. ^_~

I am actually quite content with the characters, though I do agree with the others that you should show Nina's transition more. I actually think that (even if you don't lengthen this into a novel(la)) you should add just one more section in the time between the kiss and the last section. That section would just be for Nina's development in that sense.

But I'm getting really nitpicky -- I'm sure this is better that I could do in a pinch. The emotion is done so well, and even though there are a few glitches, the flow and all is just wonderful. So three cheers to you, my dear, for an amazing series! I have had so much fun (for lack of a better word) reading and reviewing this piece.

As always, please PM me with questions/comments about my critique, or if you just want to talk about this piece... or anything else for that matter. Also, please tell me if you do decide to lengthen this or if you edit it majorly.

Hope this helps.
~Azila~

_________________
Want a critique?

"Never bolt your door with a boiled carrot." -Irish proverb. (sounds best if you read it with an Irish brogue)
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Kylan   View This User's Portfolio
how superior.
Master of the Forum

268
Gender: Gender:Male
Age: 16
Joined: 21 Apr 2007
Posts: 1089
Reviews: 268
Country: USA
372 Points

PostPosted: Wed Jul 09, 2008 12:02 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Wonderful. A very satisfying conclusion.

Some things I liked about the chapter:

-- The washing/drying machine metaphor
-- The note at the end. Very unexpected.
-- How you managed to weave the title into the end in a incredibly satisfying and poignant fashion.
-- The symbolism of the Father

Some things I didn't fancy:

-- If Nina truly loved Josie, then she wouldn't have broken the relationship, especially in the way she did (the note seems to me to be the equivalent of breaking up with someone via text message).
-- The fact that for a moment, it seemed like the two of them had run off to an icy retreat to live together alone. I don't know how I came up with that impression, but it's there.
-- A couple of other people mentioned that they felt that Nina seemed slightly hypocritical. I didn't see it at the time, but now that they mention it, she does seem that she was talking out of both sides of her mouth.
-- The dialogue seemed a little like twinkie filler. Some lines just didn't seem necessary, like the discussion of hell. Consider going back over it and doing a little trimming. This aspect isn't too important, but it was nagging at me for a little while there.

Anyway, this was a very philosophical piece. It made me think. And I can tell that you put a lot of thought and emotion into it as well. Maybe the subject matter is something that's bothering you in your personal life right now. Regardless of whether it is or not, I really think that this story has become a Suzanne classic and should definately be persued further. The characters deserve it.

A Smattering Of Nitpicks:

Quote:
I didn’t want to know if she was. Wasn’t she the strong one…? Didn’t she have God…?


The ellipses are unnecessary.

Quote:
“I’ll never be cold with you next to me,”


This line screams cliche to me. Especially since I found it in something of yours. It reads like a passage out of a country or teen-pop song. Please, for the love of everything sacred in this world, remove it.

Quote:
I felt my dizzy spirit slam into me.


I don't understand this. Perhaps a typo?

Anyway, I loved it. And I think you ended it professionaly and satisfactorily. Keep up the good work.

-Kylan

_________________
"'At's the shtuff! Give the friggin' world back to the friggin' people!"

~ Kurt Vonnegut

Got YWS?
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
JFW1415   View This User's Portfolio
Team SPEW
Master of the Forum

367
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 14
Joined: 07 Jun 2007
Posts: 1287
Reviews: 367
Country: USA
1002 Points

PostPosted: Sun Jul 13, 2008 8:17 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Well, my contest is finally over, so I can critique this! You did an excellent job – I haven't read these in ages, yet I remembered it all right away. Smile

Nit-Picks

Quote:
The ice crashed around us like the sky was falling. I stood and waited while she tried to get her key into the lock. Nina’s fingers shook.

These sentences are way too similar in structure, which makes them boring.

Quote:
“I’m cold, Josie! We ain’t got a good heater so you might as well do me some use if you ain’t going to teach me math.” Her hand grabbed mine and pulled me to her.

Oh, I had forgotten about her accent/poor grammar. Make sure you keep it consistent – this is the first time it was used in this part.

Quote:
She squeezed it with so much love, I thought my fingers would pop on the ends and spray blood.

I'd ditch this comma.

Quote:
left, right, left right,

Keep the commas there consistent, or they look ugly.

Quote:
I stopped counting the couch dots and forty two.

Do you mean 'at?'

Quote:
Nina heard me. She wriggled and sat up and looked at me with flames in her eyes.

“No,” she said, in a voice unfamiliar to me.

The repetition of 'me' bothers me here.

Quote:
“You make me worry, too, Nina.”

I'd ditch this comma – it slows us down too much.

Quote:
It mattered because God still loved me.

…What mattered? The parts before this ('it didn't matter...') made sense, but not this one.

Overall Comments

This was *amazing.* Seriously – I found nearly no fault. You left me close to tears. I loved it.

The characters were amazing – I could see their struggles perfectly.

The only thing I would like to see would be a bit of atmosphere, as previously mentioned.

Sorry for the unhelpful-ness.

PM me for anything.
~JFW1415

_________________
Man is least himself when he talks in his own person. Give him a mask, and he will tell you the truth. -Oscar Wilde

Join the CIA.

In response to hearing my new story idea: "Aunt April": Oookaaay. You are one sick little puppy aren't you?
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address MSN Messenger
Display posts from previous:   
This thread was created on June 22, 2008
Post new topic   Reply to topic
   Young Writers Society Forum Index » Romantic Fiction All times are GMT
Page 1 of 1

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You can attach files in this forum
You can download files in this forum
This thread was created on June 22, 2008

Graphics By Bobo | YWS Sword & Shield Logo by Bobo
Bartemius says, If a million people say a foolish thing, it is still a foolish thing. - Anatole France
Contact | Memberlist | Copyright Policy | YWS Store | Site Map
Facebook |  Goodreads |  Live Journal |  MySpace |  Wikipedia

© 2004 - 2008 The Young Writers Society