z

Young Writers Society


Mama's Smile



User avatar
516 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 890
Reviews: 516
Mon Apr 07, 2008 8:01 am
chocoholic says...



Just so you know, lyrics have never been my thing, and I think this it horrid, but it's the best song I've ever written. It was inspired by Dance With My Father Again by Luther Vandross
Mama's Smile

When I was a little girl
I would cry when I fell down
And my mother
She would come and pick me up
She would hug me, brush me knees
And then she’d tell me its okay
‘Cause mama, she would be there everyday

And I would, I would
Smile

I would smile at my mother
And attack her with my hug
She was the light I wanted
In the world of darkness
And when I felt like cryin’
I would hug my mother more
And I knew that I was safe
When mama’s smile’s what I saw

When I was sixteen
And my heart had just been broke
I cried for my mother
And I knew it’d be alright
When I saw that smile
I knew just what I had to do
I picked myself up from the ground

And I would, I would
Smile

I would smile at my mother
And attack her with my hug
She was the light I wanted
In the world of darkness
And when I felt like cryin’
I would hug my mother more
And I knew that I was safe
When mama’s smile’s what I saw

And then,
Just as I reached twenty
Mum was taken ill
Daddy told our family
That mummy’s with us still
But I cried that night
Because she wasn’t coming back
And thought to when I knew she’d be there

I would smile at my mother
And attack her with my hug
She was the light I wanted
In the world of darkness
And when I felt like cryin’
I would hug my mother more
And I knew that I was safe
When mama’s smile’s what I saw

I knew that I was safe
When mama’s smile’s what I saw
*Don't expect to see me around much in the next couple of weeks. School has started again, and it'll be a couple of weeks before I've settled in. If you've asked me for a critique, you will get it, but not for a little while. Sorry*
  





User avatar
896 Reviews

Supporter


Gender: Female
Points: 240
Reviews: 896
Mon Apr 07, 2008 11:21 pm
PenguinAttack says...



Hi Choco!

So, I'm not fabulous at critiquing lyrics, mainly because I can't usually put them to music, so I don't know how they'd work that way. But! I could for yours.

It took a little while, but by the end I had a rhythm and a feeling to it, and I like it! - That's not me sounding surprised, that's me sounding excited. I think it's sweet and sad, and it touched me a little, which is just amazing. ^^It's nice work, and I'm worry I'm not able to critique this to a suitable standard, I think you must have worked hard to make it so nice, and I applaud that kind of dedication.

I will say that I'm not sure the chorus isn't a little... typical? In it's imagery, with the darkness, but I don't see that it detracts from the poem so much.

Nice work, Choco!

*Hearts* Le Penguin.
I like you as an enemy, but I love you as a friend.
  





User avatar
558 Reviews

Supporter


Gender: Female
Points: 22481
Reviews: 558
Wed Apr 09, 2008 9:11 pm
Matt Bellamy says...



I have never critiqued lyrics before. I used to write them, when I was all teen angsty at fourteen, and they were very, very bad! But I'll do my best to give a good review.

I really like this. I like the idea, and the continuous mentions of smiling, smiling, then the mother smiling, and everyone is smiling! :) I liked how you used the kind of timeline throughout the song-when I was little, a teenager, and then an adult. Only criticism I have is that this line: "And thought to when I knew she’d be there" doesn't seem to make sense, and I don't know what you mean there at all. Apart from that, loved the idea, not at all angsty like my previous attempts :P Let me know if you want any more lyrics reviewed, as it's good for me to try to tone these critting skills.
Matt.

Got Tumblr? Me too! http://www.writersam.co.uk

Peeking Cat Poetry Magazine is accepting submissions! http://peekingcatpoetrymagazine.blogspot.co.uk
  





User avatar
150 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 5214
Reviews: 150
Sat Apr 12, 2008 3:41 am
Ross says...



Oh my gosh! This almost made me cry...and I'm a guy. I loved the subject. I could imagine the music (heavy on acoustic guitar, a light drum background) and I like how you put all the meat in the verses and made the chorus light and simple.
And we'll be a dream...

"Dee Dubbleyou." - BigBadBear
  





User avatar
1464 Reviews

Supporter


Gender: Female
Points: 83957
Reviews: 1464
Mon Apr 14, 2008 11:38 am
JabberHut says...



Hello there, Choco!

Must I repeat what everyone said about critting lyrics? Lol, I don't critique them much.

But! I really liked this! Great imagery, and by the end, I had a rhythm. Your wording is really good, considering I don't know the music that will accompany the lyrics. I really like songs that, as Matt said before me, have that timeline. This was very touching, and I wish I could give it the critique it deserves.

I really liked the refrain/chorus, by the way. It's truly lovely!

And my heart had just been broke


Alliteration! Even lyrics get poetic devices. Nice job! :wink:

I knew that I was safe
When mama’s smile’s what I saw


Great choice of ending! It touched me right here *hand/chest* Right there, girl. Bravo!

Kay, did it look like I critiqued it? Sweet... Great job! I truly liked this! You have a knack for lyrics! :wink:

Keep writing!

Jabber, the One and Only!
I make my own policies.
  





User avatar
140 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 890
Reviews: 140
Tue Apr 15, 2008 2:33 pm
Kalliope says...



Hey Choco,

I haven't critiqued or written any lyrics in a while, so I'm a bit out of practise, but I thought I'd get back into this business ;)

I really like the way you built this up. The whole story line is very touching and everybody should have a mom like that.

And then she’d tell me its okay
‘Cause mama, she would be there everyday


These are two really neat lines, since they express what every little girl wishes for and in these lyrics you show the truth to them.

And attack her with my hug


Aww, always mama's little girl.

She was the light I wanted
In the world of darkness


Light in a world full of darkness has been done a lot, but I suppose it's fitting here. Maybe you can search for an alternative that's more original? Or just leav it ;)

When mama’s smile’s what I saw


This seems a bit akwardly worded. Maybe try When I saw mama's smile or When I saw mama smile?

Hmm... the whole teenage verse doesn't seem to flow quite as well as the rest, but other than that I really enjoyed these lyrics!

Very nicely done.

~Kalliope
If you don't know where you are going, any road will take you there. - Lewis Carol (1832-98 )


Got YWS?
  





User avatar
20 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 890
Reviews: 20
Fri May 23, 2008 3:37 am
This_is_history says...



Hey! Just let me say, I LOVE Dance with my father, and I think this poem is basically it's equivelant. So yeah, this is great.

One thing I saw was your wording. It got a little awkward in places. And it would probably fit with music really well, but when you're reading it straight it sounds a bit forced. (They should really have a way you could upload a music file with your lyrics. That would make everything so much easier!)

Your first verse is really strong, and I really like it, but like I said, your wording tends to be a bit skewed after that.

Everything else is really great. I love the idea. You hardly ever see any songs about moms, so kudos to you!

I think the whole thing is very sweet. It's a lovely song, and I really like it.

Well, I hope I could help!
-Elise
"I move the stars for no one."
-Jareth

"You say this Labyrinth's a peice of cake? Well let's see how you deal with this little slice."
-Jareth
  








Proud people breed sad sorrows for themselves.
— Emily Bronte, Wuthering Heights