z

Young Writers Society


The Gate of Glendon- Chapters 1 & 2



User avatar
516 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 890
Reviews: 516
Fri Mar 21, 2008 12:45 am
chocoholic says...



Because my chapters are so short, I'm going to post two at a time, unless people think I should do otherwise. The actual story is set 320 years after the prologue, and you can read the story without reading the prologue, if you wish.


CHAPTER ONE

Carrie sat on a log in the field. It had fallen during the storm the previous night, and was still damp. Despite her status, she was dressed plainly, in loose cotton pants and a white top.

Her Husky, Caleb, was running a little away from her, and her mouse Paula sat in the bag she had strung around her shoulder.

The mansion in which Carrie lived was out of sight, despite how big it was. Caleb disappeared from Carrie’s sight for a few moments, but then came running back.

“Silly dog,” Carrie giggled, scratching behind the Husky’s ears. Caleb licked Carrie’s hand affectionately, and she took a piece of meat out of her bag and threw it in the air, laughing as the dog bounded off to get it.

Paula crawled onto Carrie’s shoulder, digging her claws into the skin. Carrie flinched and eased Paula’s claws out. There wasn’t any blood, just a scratch. Carrie put Paula on her knee and stroked her fur.

“Carrie, come inside!” Carrie turned her head. Her mother’s maid was standing on the top of the hill, beckoning to Carrie with her hands. Sighing, Carrie whistled for Caleb to come back and stood up, putting Paula on her shoulder gently.

Caleb came running back with the meat in his mouth. He padded softly next to Carrie as they headed up the hill and to the mansion. It was massive, with three stories. There was also a tennis court and a pool. And why could Carrie’s parents afford to live in such a grand dwelling? Because her father was an Earl and mother a Countess.

“Why do you have to spend so much time getting dirty?” Mrs. Beoux asked Carrie as the girl wandered into the large hallway where her mother was waiting. “You’re a terrible influence on your sister. Did you know she asked me for a sheepdog yesterday?”

Carrie smiled broadly. She was four years older than her sister, now ten, and was adored by the younger girl. They also had a baby brother who spent most f his time eating, crying and sleeping.

“Go and get changed,” Mrs. Beoux said. “And take your time. We are going to the palace tonight.”

Carrie rolled her eyes.

“Do I have to go? William will just be trying to impress me again. He doesn’t understand the meaning of go away!”

Carrie was supposed to marry Prince William, somebody she hated with a passion, but somebody she would be forced to spend the rest of her life with.

“Yes you have to go,” Mrs. Beoux snapped. “How would it look if we showed up without you? Now march young lady!”

Reluctantly, Carrie turned and walked p two flights of stairs to her bedroom where a selection of dresses had been laid out. Not wanting to think about it, Carrie grabbed the first dress, a dark green one that had thin straps and stuck close to her body, and slipped it on. Mechanically, she walked over to her dresser and put on makeup and brushed her hair before turning on her curling iron at the switch.

“Carrie, can I play with Caleb?” a small voice asked. Carrie turned around and saw her younger sister in the doorway. She was wearing a light blue dress and her blonde hair was dead straight.

“Mother would butcher me if I let you,” Carrie said. “You can play with him afterwards.”

Kaya nodded and sat on Carrie’s bed, dangling her long legs.

“Is this another of Father’s meetings?” she asked. “Or is it actually going to be fun?”

Carrie laughed and finished curling her hair. It now cascaded down her back in waves.

“We’re going back to the palace, Kaya,” she said. “Of course it won’t be fun. Going to the palace is never fun.”

Kaya’s face dropped. Their mother was right, Carrie was a big influence of Kaya, but whether she was a good or a bad influence was in the eyes of the beholder.

“Come on. The sooner we get there the sooner we can leave.”

CHAPTER TWO

“Do you have a moment, Prince William?”

“Is everything ready?” I asked the servant. “Everything needs to be perfect.”

“Yes Prince William, everything is ready. You can go and inspect it for yourself, if you wish.”

I nodded and turned, heading to the dining hall where my family and the Beoux family would be dining tonight. It was a very important night. The night I would propose to Caroline Beoux.

“They’re here,” a voice giggled as I inspected the dinging hall. My little sister Lynette, or Lynn, was standing in the doorway, filing her nails. She looked up and smiled.

“What is she wearing?” I asked. Lynn was two years younger than me, and got on with Carrie a little better than I did, to my disappointment.

Lynn rolled her eyes.

“Come on, they’re waiting for us.”

I nodded and wiped my forehead on my sleeve. I always got nervous seeing Carrie, but knowing that I had to propose made it even worse. The only consolidation was the knowledge that I couldn’t be rejected, her mother would skin her alive if Carrie did that.

The family was in the parlour. Mother was there, talking to Mrs. Beoux, who was holding her baby, Gabriel. Mr. Beoux was standing in the corner with father, whisky glasses in their hands, and Carrie’s sister Kaya was reading a book on a couch. Carrie was sitting casually on the arm of the chair, looking fed up. She didn’t smile when Lynn came in. They weren’t great friends, they just got on. In fact, Carrie didn’t seem to have any proper friends. She had her dog and a mouse, but didn’t like to interact with people much.

“Hello Carrie,” Lynn said, sitting down next to her. Carrie was beautiful! I couldn’t take my eyes off her, but she barely glanced at me.

“Hi Lynn,” Carrie muttered, and stuck her hand inside her purse. I guessed that her mouse was in there, but there wasn’t any movement.

I walked over to my sister and my to-be fiancé, clearing my throat.

“May I escort you to dinner, Carrie?” I asked, sticking out my arm. Carrie looked up at her mother and reluctantly nodded. She slipped off the couch in one graceful movement and took my arm. We walked into the dining hall and I pulled out her chair. She didn’t even look at me.

“So Caroline,” Father asked over dinner. “How are you? Have you thought about your future at all? Do you know who you want to marry?”

I exchanged glances with Lynn as Carrie opened her mouth.

“I’ve been much to concerned with my studies and magic lessons to think about my future, sir.”

Father nodded.

“Good, good. You must keep up with your lessons. And how is your magic coming along? You were always very talented, perhaps you could put on a show for us this evening.”

Carrie blushed.

“I’m not that good, sir,” she muttered.


Feedback questions:
1. What characters do you like/not like?
2. Do you think posting two chapters at once is a good idea, or should I just do one?
Last edited by chocoholic on Thu Apr 10, 2008 6:29 am, edited 1 time in total.
*Don't expect to see me around much in the next couple of weeks. School has started again, and it'll be a couple of weeks before I've settled in. If you've asked me for a critique, you will get it, but not for a little while. Sorry*
  





User avatar
38 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 890
Reviews: 38
Fri Mar 21, 2008 1:36 am
Memento Mori says...



1.) I don't really like Carrie all that much, mainly because she's not that realistic. William is more realistic, and I like him much better. However, this is your story, and maybe you have an explanation for Carrie's behavior. All I'm saying is that it's not normal for a teen to dislike a prince.

2.) Two chapters at once are all right, since your chapters aren't so long.

Also, you might want to proof read, I found some mistakes.

I think you meant or Lynn, not of Lynn.

Please don't get mad at me for this review. >.<

Yours truly,
Memento Mori
When life gives you lemons, make lemonade, pee in it, and serve it to the people who piss you off. Outdo yourself. ^^
  





User avatar
112 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 890
Reviews: 112
Fri Mar 21, 2008 1:44 am
oneeyedunicornhunter says...



i liked William, and the first person helped. it made it seem like he really likes Carrie and that Carrie could come to like him too, despite her apparent (would 'loathing' be too strong a word?) dislike of him.

as for posting two chapters at once, i think it's a good idea. you were right; the chapters are short o.0
Am I a one eyed hunter of unicorns or a hunter of one eyed unicorns? The world may never know.
  





Random avatar


Gender: Male
Points: 1990
Reviews: 254
Fri Mar 21, 2008 1:58 am
mikedb1492 says...



The mansion in which Carrie lived was out of sight here, despite how big it was.

Get rid of the word 'here' to increase the fluidity.
She was four years older than her sister, who was now ten, and was adored b the younger girl.

Put a 'y' after the 'b'.
“Is everything ready?” I asked one of the servants as I wondered the halls.

Instead of 'wondered' you're supposed to say 'wandered'.
She didn’t smile when Lynn came in, they weren’t great friends, they just got on, was all.

Put a period after 'in', and rephrase the last part as 'they just got along.'
Carrie was wearing a silk dress that hung closely to her body and her hair was in soft curls.

You don't need to mention this since you already did in the previous chapter. You could, however, say he found her beautiful.
I walked over to my sister and m to-be fiancé, clearing my throat.

Put a 'y' after 'm'.
“I’ve been much to concerned with my studies and magic lessons to think about my future, sir.”

Wow. You just kind of dropped that on us didn't you, the whole magic thing. I hadn't known she'd been learning magic. If I were you, I would have integregrated this in the previous chapter in a different way.

Overall this was pretty good. I thought the first chapter was really boring, but I think its because your not that great in that third person style. You skills lie in the first person style of chapter 2, where you executed it all quite well.
Also, I think its a bad idea for you to switch between those two points of view. It could confuse the reader, and besides, like I said earlier, your skills lie in first person. The only problem with this, however, is that your kind of limited. The main character must always be there for the reader since its the character telling the story. Although, Charles Dickens, at the beginning of his book David Copperfield, wrote in first person even though he was talking about something that happened before he was born/not there.
Anyway, I'm officially interested. Keep it up.
Trying to get to heaven without Jesus is like climbing to the summit of Mount Everest naked. You die before it happens.
  





User avatar
110 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 1844
Reviews: 110
Mon Mar 24, 2008 1:08 am
TNCowgirl says...



Now I'm confussed, your switching between tenses is weird and if I remebered correctly the person that "I" refered to was a girl in the prologe. MAybe clear that up a little.


Other then that it was good. I liked it. Keep going.
"And you wonder why we don't like you!" -Trumpkin
.
.
Vist my world and make it bigger!
Want a Readers crit???
  





User avatar
863 Reviews

Supporter


Gender: Male
Points: 2090
Reviews: 863
Wed Apr 09, 2008 5:27 am
Griffinkeeper says...



Her husky Caleb was running a little away from her, and her mouse Paula sat in the bag she had strung around her shoulder.


Should be "Her Husky, Caleb, was running... since Husky in this context is referring to the dog breed, not the appearance.

Carrie was expected to marry Prince William as soon as she turned 18. He was already 17, three years older than her. He was heir to a vast fortune, but that alone failed to grab Carrie’s interest. Money meant nothing to her; it was life that she cared about.


Aside from being very cliche and unconvincing, it is also an info dump. Delete it all.

CHAPTER TWO

“Is everything ready?” I asked one of the servants as I wondered the halls. “Everything needs to be perfect.”

“Yes Prince William, everything is ready. You can go and inspect it for yourself, if you wish.”

I nodded and turned, heading to the dining hall where my family and the Beoux family would be dinging tonight. It was a very important night, as I was to propose to Carrie Beoux. I was eighteen tomorrow, and traditionally the Prince would propose at the strike of midnight.


EEEK!!!!!

NEVER EVER switch characters without a transition! Ever! Put in a sentence that transitions to the Prince.

"The Prince was a young man with ghastly bad teeth and a sense of humor that would try a jester. He saw the servant in the mirror."

A sentence like the above would be a perfect way to start off the second chapter because it introduces us to the Prince.

That being said, I don't know what advantage there is to actually seeing things from the Prince's point of view. Nothing new is brought up, it only tells us what is going to happen before it does. This makes it predictable, which is BAD! You want plot twists to electrify the reader, not to be inevitable.

This requires a little elaboration. It is okay for the reader to have an idea of what will happen. What you can't have is your reader to know when it happens. If I were to write in a story "They'll attack tomorrow for sure," then I wouldn't have the enemy attack tomorrow, I'd have them attack that very night.

So when you say that the prince will propose at midnight, then I just do a mental yawn.
Moderator Emeritus (frozen in carbonite.)
  





User avatar
12 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 1790
Reviews: 12
Wed Apr 09, 2008 11:35 pm
Linden Dante says...



Feedback questions:
1. What characters do you like/not like?

I like the characters so far but I would like to point out that naming the prince "Prince William" is a little cliche. Other than that the characters seem to be developing fairly well.

2. Do you think posting two chapters at once is a good idea, or should I just do one?

I think posting two at a time is a good idea, as you mentioned before the chapters are short.

Overall I thought this was pritty well writen, although there were a few typos. There are a few things that bother me though like:

I was eighteen tomorrow, and traditionally the Prince would propose at the strike of midnight.


So for one saying "I was eighteen tomorrow" doesn't really make sense, so you might want to change that. And when you say "the Prince would propose at the strike of midnight" Not only should you say "stroke of midnight" but that is cliche as well.

As was stated before you did seem to throw the whole magic thing out there rather quickly, I agree that it would be a good idea if you had mentioned it in the first chapter.

Other than those few things I think that the story is developing well, I can't wait to read more. Keep up the great work! :D
  





User avatar
514 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 890
Reviews: 514
Thu Apr 10, 2008 7:52 pm
JC says...



Chapter One- (I'm a tad short on time, so I'll come back for chapter two)

and her mouse Paula

Comma before Paula.

Caleb licked Carrie’s hand affectionately, and she took a piece of meat out of her bag and threw it in the air, laughing as the dog bounded off to get it.

This should probably be two sentences, seeing as I had to re-read it to figure out what you meant.

I would say that this chapter was way to short to even introduce characters. I like the relationship between Carrie and the dog, an Carrie and the little sister, but I think there should be more here. Short chapters are fun and all, but this is almost too short to have any significance or meaning.

Other than that, good job on chapter one, I'll be back for two later on today.

Keep up the good work!
-JC
But that is not the question. Why we are here, that is the question. And we are blessed in this, that we happen to know the answer. Yes, in this immense confusion one thing alone is clear. We are waiting for Godot to come. -Beckett
  





User avatar
410 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 5890
Reviews: 410
Thu Apr 17, 2008 4:58 pm
Alainna says...



Hey Rosie! These two chapters were a lot better than the prologue and I found the story a little more enticing.

The mansion in which Carrie lived was out of sight, despite how big it was.

You could expand on this by saying why it is out of sight. For instance, 'The large rolling hills hid the mansion in which Carrie lived, despite the size of the grand house.' That way we also get some description. Yay!

Caleb licked Carrie’s hand affectionately, and she took a piece of meat out of her bag and threw it in the air, laughing as the dog bounded off to get it.

Ok, so this is me being a bit picky but..... She took a piece of meat out of her bag? As in the same bag with her mouse in it and her other possession's?
I think you need to change this so she pulls out a plastic bag from her bag and in that is the meat. That also gives more detail which equals more description.

It was massive, with three stories. There was also a tennis court and a pool.

MORE!!!! We can have so much more description here, the immaculate paintwork, the large courtyard with fountains and statues, the beautiful stained glass windows etc.

Reluctantly, Carrie turned and walked p two flights of stairs to her bedroom where a selection of dresses had been laid out.

*up

“Is everything ready?” I asked the servant. “Everything needs to be perfect.”

AH!!!!!!! What happened here? Ok, my suggestion is to put the character whose POV it is or who it is following at the top of the chapter e.g. :
CHAPTER TWO
WILLIAM
You should also consider choosing one type of narrative for the main chapters and sticking to it. It's hard to swap from 3rd person to 1st and back again all the time - for the reader and the writer.

We walked into the dining hall and I pulled out her chair.

If this guy is besotted by Carrie he would be in touch with his feelings so much more. He'd notice the feel of her skin, her perfume, her hair, everything. Yes, I'm saying I want more description!

1) I prefer William to Carrie but to be honest I don't like either. They just aren't the type of characters that you can empathise with.
2) When they are this short it is fine to post two at a time but I suggest that you do make them a bit longer.

Overall, this was better than the prologue but still needs some perfecting. More description, more feeling, more structure. I like where this is heading a bit more now.

Keep writing, my dear.

Alainna
xxx
Sanity is for the unimaginative.

Got YWS?
  





User avatar
721 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 7241
Reviews: 721
Thu Apr 17, 2008 9:02 pm
Azila says...



Again, I just skimmed the other reviews, so please pardon me if I repeat something.

-Nitpicks-

The mansion in which Carrie lived was out of sight, despite how big it was.
I'm not exactly sure why, but this seems awkward. I think this is more natural: "The mansion in which Carrie lived could not be seen from here, despite how big it was."

He padded softly next to Carrie as they headed up the hill and to the mansion.
I think you should delete the "and" in between "hill" and "to."

It was massive, with three stories. There was also a tennis court and a pool.
I definitely agree with Alainna here: add more! Elaborate! Extend! I want to have a better picture that the minimalistic description you gave. :wink:

And why could Carrie’s parents afford to live in such a grand dwelling? Because her father was an Earl and mother a Countess.
This is telling rather than showing -- and unnecessary to boot. You can show us that they are Earl and Countess later on, by having someone address them as "Earl _______" or "Countess ________" Ya?

Mrs. Beoux asked Carrie as the girl wandered into the large hallway where her mother was waiting.
At first, I didn't realize that Mrs. Beoux was her mother... maybe you should specify that? Also, you should say before the dialogue starts that the mother was waiting for Carrie in the room that she was walking into, so that you don't have to do so now. ^_~

They also had a baby brother who spent most f his time eating, crying and sleeping.
I think you mean "...most OF his time..."

“How would it look if we showed up without you? Now march young lady!”
There should be a comma after "march."

Not wanting to think about it, Carrie grabbed the first dress, a dark green one that had thin straps and stuck close to her body, and slipped it on.
I think the bold part should either be inside parenthesis (or rounded brackets, depending on where your from) or inside dashes.

Mechanically, she walked over to her dresser and put on makeup and brushed her hair before turning on her curling iron at the switch.
You can delete the bold part.

“They’re here,” a voice giggled as I inspected the dinging hall.
I think you mean to say "dining hall." ^_~

Mr. Beoux was standing in the corner with father, whisky glasses in their hands, and Carrie’s sister Kaya was reading a book on a couch.
"father" should be capitalized, because you're using it like a proper noun, or name. Also, "whisky" should be "whiskey."
________________________

1. What characters do you like/not like? I'm very sorry to say this, but i don't think I like any of them. :oops: I just don't feel connected with them at all. I can relate with Carrie, but only because I'm a little like her (love animals, being alone, etc) but you really don't let us inside their heads or hearts to let us know what they're thinking and feeling. Try to use the first person more to your advantage, to let us feel like the character -- know his faults and charms, his weaknesses and awkwardnesses. make us pity him, love him, hate him all at once. Frankly, we need to BE your character when we're reading about the. :wink:

2. Do you think posting two chapters at once is a good idea, or should I just do one? It's fine, because they're short. But if they get longer, you should post them once at a time. This is actually a good length, though, because it's just enough so that we can grasp enough to have an opinion, but not too long that our eyes begin to hurt. XD


Something that I noticed is that you seem to repeat the characters' names a bit too much. Most of the time, a simple "he/she/the Prince/etc" will do.

Also, so far the plot seems kind of cliché: beautiful girl of royal blood is betrothed to a prince that she doesn't want to marry, but has to... blah blah blah.

But my main problem with this piece (other than the one mentioned in my answer to your first question) is the fact that there isn't really any description. Actually, this goes hand-in-hand with the other main issue; they're both matters of wanting to be inside the story, not just reading it. And the solution goes hand-in-hand as well; if you fix one you will fix the other. Try giving us biased descriptions. Descriptions that aren't necessarily true, but are how your MC/narrator sees it. For example, when William sees Carrie and thinks that she's beautiful just point out the beautiful things about her. When he's looking around at the dining hall, what kind of details does he notice? The negatives or the positives? That could say a lot about his character and mood. This goes for Carrie, too, of course.

PM me with questions/comments concerning my critique!

Oh, and please don't take this too harshly; I usually have an easier time pointing out the negatives of a piece of writing than the positives. I'm just here to help. :D

~Azila~
  





User avatar
103 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 4119
Reviews: 103
Thu Apr 17, 2008 9:22 pm
Dynamo says...



I like the first character, Carrie. She has a mind of her own and doesn't like being bossed around. When you have at least one female character like that in your story it becomes a little more interesting. If this is just your first draft of the story, I'd say you're doing alright and posting two chapters at once is fine. But, if you're planning on trying to get this published I suggest you go back and put more thought into each and every one of your chapters, more descriptions, dialog, the works. I'm currently writing the third draft of my own story which is going to be around 500 pages by the time I'm finally finished. Each chapter is about 5 to 15 pages long double spaced. If you're planning on getting this published you need lengthier chapters.

A few little things, when writing for your characters you can only use 3rd person or 1st person. You can't switch between these views, it's either one or the other for the whole book. Also, when using the word 'to' there's two ways to spell it, 'to' and 'too'. The only way I know how to explain their uses is through an example:

"He went to the store and bought some food. When he got home he ate too much and got sick."

Just something for you to remember.
Chicken <-- Egg <-- Rocket Powered Fist
Take that, science!
  





User avatar
497 Reviews

Supporter


Gender: Female
Points: 6400
Reviews: 497
Mon Apr 21, 2008 2:46 am
Teague says...



Hey Choco! Sorry about the delay, I had to go for a while. ^^

Anyway. Keeping in mind what I said on your prologue...

Her Husky, Caleb, was running a little away from her, and her mouse Paula sat in the bag she had strung around her shoulder.

This should really be part of another paragraph -- it doesn't do well on its own.

Whoa there. Learn to love your pronouns. Seriously. You use their names too much. O_O

was standing on the top of the hill, beckoning to Carrie with her hands.

As opposed to beckoning her with her feet? ;)

Caleb came running back with the meat in his mouth.

What meat? Or did I miss something?

It was massive, with three stories. There was also a tennis court and a pool. And why could Carrie’s parents afford to live in such a grand dwelling? Because her father was an Earl and mother a Countess.

Some of this might be unnecessary info -- do the tennis court and pool play a part? If not, get rid of them. This paragraph lingers on the side of teling rather than showing -- and the question in there is just patronising.

They also had a baby brother who spent most f his time eating, crying and sleeping.

Disregarding the typo, again, is this necessary? If the brother does not play a part, delete this. If he does, include this information when his part comes in.

Carrie was supposed to marry Prince William, somebody she hated with a passion, but somebody she would be forced to spend the rest of her life with.

Again, don't lecture your audience. You have to assume that your reader will figure this out on their own. Don't throw it in their face. It's boring and kills the action.

Reluctantly, Carrie turned and walked p two flights of

walked up*

before turning on her curling iron at the switch.

As opposed to the part that gets hot? ;)
Don't point out the obvious. Also patronising your reader.

Carrie laughed and finished curling her hair. It now cascaded down her back in waves.

I have never curled my hair, but I always thought it took longer than how you've portrayed it here.

Whoa. The change in POV is a little grating, but nothing too horrible once you read a few paragraphs in. Personally, I think it would be better to juxtapose these chapters. Readers tend to take the first POV for the "official" one. And going from third person to first person is a little jarring.

The only consolidation was the knowledge

Consolation*
(although you might want to check the spelling of that)

I’ve been much to concerned

much too*

Feedback questions:
1. What characters do you like/not like?
2. Do you think posting two chapters at once is a good idea, or should I just do one?

1. Well, I can't really say at the moment. There's not been enough development.
2. You're fine with two, but you cut off your chapters at some weird points. It just feels like you cut them randomly. I like to cut chapters when there's a plot twist or development, no matter how little or much that takes.

Just a suggestion, though. ^^

Again, sory I was such a slowpoke! But yeah, work on trimming the fat and loving pronouns. And try and cut your chapters off in a slightly better place. ;)

-Saint Razorblade
The Official YWS Pirate :pirate3:
"2-4-6-8! I like to delegate!" -Meshugenah
"Teague: Stomping on your dreams since 1992." -Sachiko
"So I'm looking at FLT and am reminded of a sandwich." -Jabber
  





User avatar
685 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 890
Reviews: 685
Sat Apr 26, 2008 5:17 pm
Rei says...



I can't really say if I like or dislike any of the characters at the moment. We're in show-don't-tell territory here. You breeze through everything so quickly, and don't give very much descrition of the setting and characters. For this kind of fanatsy, we really need to be immersed in their world, who they are, and their culture. I noticed that you have other chapters posted, and probably have a bunch written that isn't posted, so what I'll suggest is, if you decide to do a rewrite on this, before you start over, do some world building exercises. Write up character profiles, draw some pictures of the setting, think up details about the culture. Stuff like that.

Here are a few nitpicks I noticed that I don't think have been mentioned yet:

She was four years older than her sister, now ten, and was adored by the younger girl.


This reads very awkwardly. It’s heard to tell who you’re referring to. I’d suggest breaking it up into at least three sentences. Also, try expanding other paragraphs in the same way, whether they read smoothly or not. That will help you get more detail that this sort of novel really needs.

“So Caroline,” Father asked over dinner. “How are you? Have you thought about your future at all? Do you know who you want to marry?”


This sounds really wooden to have it all at once. There should be some real dialogue and have the character answer each question separately, rather than her father bombarding her with them all at once.
Please, sit down before you fall down.
Belloq, "Raiders of the Lost Ark"
  





Random avatar


Gender: Male
Points: 1823
Reviews: 665
Mon Apr 28, 2008 6:01 pm
deleted6 says...



I really don't like Carrie, I felt the Prince more realistic and you don't give us detail of world. It's got magic but it's got tennis courts. Modern or Fantasy. Without the telling of magic I'd never realized this was in an earlier time. You don't show us any other reason to think different. A lot of this is boring as ya tell so much .The use of names at the start to tell us all with the pets slows it down. You get a better idea of William character but not much else. As Rei said that Father asking everything at once is unrealistic. A lot of this is unrealistic.

Overall: You need to rewrite and edit this as it's all telling not enough showing.

Hope this helps

Good luck
VSN
We get off to the rhythm of the trigger and destruction. Fallujah to New Orleans with impunity to kill. We are the hidden fist of the free market.
We are the ink, we are the quill.
[The Ink And The Quill (Be Afraid) - Anti-Flag]
  





User avatar
438 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 2999
Reviews: 438
Fri May 02, 2008 7:55 pm
JFW1415 says...



Just a quick review, as I am short on time and promised these ages ago. :wink:

Chapter One

They also had a baby brother who spent most of his time eating, crying and sleeping.


Reluctantly, Carrie turned and walked up two flights of stairs to her bedroom where a selection of dresses had been laid out.


Honestly, this wasn’t the best, but can be fixed easily. ;P

- Stop using names. Yes, it is needed sometimes, but it’s annoying having names this often. You need to develop the characters so well that we don’t need names. Even in the first chapter, we shouldn’t need them often.
- Describe where they are. Set the atmosphere! How’s it feel to be there? Are there people around her? How do they treat her? How’s she feel to be there? Is it quiet? Does it feel large? Don’t just tell us that it’s three stories; let us learn this through action, and how huge it feels.
- Slow down. You have a whole story to tell us this! Don’t tell us that her sister looks up to her – show it. Does she suddenly change her perception on something when her sister shares her thoughts? Don’t just tell us that she’s about to be married – show it. What’s it like between them? And didn’t you say she was ten? Or was that her little sister?

Chapter Two

“Do you have a moment, Prince William?”


You completely switched topic after this sentence. It felt like it was thrown in there.

“I’ve been much too concerned with my studies and magic lessons to think about my future, sir.”


“I’m not that good, sir,” she muttered.


This seemed to end rather abruptly.

Feedback Questions

1. What characters do you like/not like?

Right now, I don’t like any of them. You listed a bunch of characters, but who’s who? I have no clue. You need to expand on them, develop them, so I know the difference. Why should I care about them at this point?

2. Do you think posting two chapters at once is a good idea, or should I just do one?

I’m the pathetic reader who thinks 500 words is too long (yet posts up to 2,000,) so I would say just do one. ;P

-----

Sorry about the short review, but there’s not much to improve. Just two major things: the lack of character depth, and the lack of feeling like I’m there.

PM me for anything.

~JFW1415
  








For a short space of time I remained at the window watching the pallid lightnings that played above Mont Blanc and listening to the rushing of the Arve, which pursued its noise way beneath. The same lulling sounds acted as a lullaby to my too keen sensations; when I placed my head upon my pillow, sleep crept over me; I felt it as it came and blessed the giver of oblivion.
— Mary Shelley, Frankenstein